A comparative study using liquid scintillation counting to determine 63Ni in low and intermediate level radioactive waste
Summary (3 min read)
Introduction
- In France, the National Radioactive Waste Management Agency is in charge of the long-term management of all radioactive waste.
- Several repository sites have been built in order to accommodate nuclear waste packages.
- Elimination of the interfering elements is mainly achieved with ammonium citrate during the rinsing step.
Reagents and equipments
- All chemicals (nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, hydrofluoric acid, hydroiodic acid, ammonium hydroxide, hydrogen peroxide, citrate ammonium, sodium citrate, tartaric acid, 2-nitroso-1-naphthol, dimethylglyoxime) were of analytical grade.
- Ultra-pure water (resistivity 18.2 M cm) was obtained from a Milli-Q purification system (Millipore, France).
- Anion-exchange resin AG1-X4 (50-100 mesh) was supplied by Bio-Rad Laboratories .
- All measurements of gamma emitting radionuclides were completed using a high purity germanium detector (Canberra, ) which was calibrated with a multi gamma standard (9ML01ELME20) supplied by CERCA LEA .
- The uncertainties of the 63 Ni activities concentrations were calculated according to the standard NF M60-317 [21] by combining the uncertainties associated with the quantities of digested samples, the standards, the recovery yields and the LSC measurements.
Sample preparation and digestion
- The different radioactive samples were collected in several French nuclear facilities and laboratories.
- They consisted of the following types of materials: evaporate concentrates, steels, muds embedded in concretes, effluents, ion exchange resins embedded or not in polymers and graphites (denoted from S1 to S8 in this work).
- All samples were digested using a microwave acid digestion system (Speed Wave, Berghof, Germany), except graphites.
- The resulting solutions were transferred to 100 mL volumetric flasks and diluted with ultra-pure water.
- As examples, the chemical and radiochemical compositions of two studied samples (S1 and S2) are detailed in Table 1 .
Method 1 based on the organic extraction of the Ni(DMG) 2 complex
- Aliquots of the digested samples were first weighed in a beaker.
- As the reaction between Co and 2-nitroso-1-naphthol proceeds rather slowly [34] , the solutions were allowed to stand for about 30 min.
- 3x10 mL of chloroform were then added to extract the Co-nitrosonaphtol complex in the organic phases whereas Ni remained in the aqueous phases.
Method 2 based on the precipitation of the Ni(DMG) 2 complex
- As the total activity concentrations of the other radionuclides are not 10 times higher in comparison to 63 Ni in the studied samples, only one precipitation step was implemented from the specifications of this standard [21] .
- Aliquots of the digested samples were first weighed in a beaker.
- The precipitates were collected by filtration and washed with water.
- Afterwards, the solutions were evaporated near to dryness (otherwise insoluble black residues were obtained as indicated in Ref. [26] ).
- DMG was then decomposed with hydrogen peroxide.
Method 3 based on the precipitation of the Ni(DMG) 2 complex on Ni resin
- Eichrom Technologies recommend to eliminate Given the Fe compositions of the studied samples, an additional purification step was introduced only for the steel sample.
- From the works of Hou et al. and Rajkovich et al. [6, 23] , it was decided to implement a separation on the anion exchange AG1-X4 resin before the purification step on the Ni resin.
- The AG1-X4 resin has indeed a higher loading capacity towards Fe (around 15 mg/g resin) in comparison to TRU resin (5 mg/g resin).
- The resulting solutions were then evaporated to dryness and the residues were treated as described above in the protocol dedicated to the Ni columns.
Speciation studies
- A previous work of their group demonstrated the importance of speciation studies in order to achieve a better understanding of the behaviours of the analytes during the different separation steps and to optimize the radiochemical procedures [25] .
- This approach was also investigated by Rosskopfova et al.
- Ni which was not complexed by 2-nitroso-1-naphthol remained in the aqueous phase.
- From the speciation studies, it can be inferred that the behaviours of Ni, Co and Fe strongly depend on the considered purification methods.
Applications of the three DMG-based radiochemical methods to real nuclear waste samples
- From the literature, it is not obvious to choose the best selective radiochemical procedure based on DMG (solvent extraction, precipitation and extraction chromatography) and to determine if a single separation step can be implemented for nuclear waste samples.
- To answer this question, the three radiochemical methods based on the use of DMG complexing agent were applied to different types of radioactive waste samples (evaporate concentrates, steels, muds embedded in concretes, effluents, ion exchange resins embedded or not in polymers and graphites).
- The Ni recovery yields were satisfactory whatever the analysed samples and the radiochemical methods.
Where
- For method 2 based on DMG precipitation, the E n values were higher than 1 for the majority of the studied samples (up to 17), which indicated that the performances of method 2 were unsatisfactory.
- The E n value related to the S2 steel was prescribes that one DMG-based precipitation step should be sufficient when the total activity concentrations of the other radionuclides are not 10 times higher in comparison in comparison to 63 Ni [21] , which is not in agreement with their experimental results.
- This standard published in 2001 [21] might be no more adapted to the nuclear waste produced in the past decade from decommissioning operations of various radioactive facilities.
- For method 3 based on Ni column, the E n values were lower than 1 whatever the studied samples, which demonstrated that the performances of method 3 were satisfactory.
- To check this assumption, the S3 sample (corresponding to muds embedded in concrete) was analysed with and without performing the AG1-X4 separation before the purification of the Ni column.
Did you find this useful? Give us your feedback
Citations
42 citations
12 citations
6 citations
5 citations
3 citations
References
12 citations
"A comparative study using liquid sc..." refers background or methods in this paper
...In recent years, many radiochemical procedures based on Ni resin have been applied on many nuclear materials [5, 6, 12, 13, 15, 17, 27]....
[...]
...It corresponds to the radiochemical method described by Eichrom Technologies [26] and applied in many reported works [6, 12, 13, 15, 17, 27]....
[...]
...Some authors also prepared in-house Ni resins which relies on the same principle [15, 27]....
[...]
9 citations
"A comparative study using liquid sc..." refers background or methods in this paper
...Aliquots were prepared for the determination of stable metal elements and gamma emitting radionuclides by ICP-AES and gamma spectrometers respectively....
[...]
...In recent years, many radiochemical procedures based on Ni resin have been applied on many nuclear materials [5, 6, 12, 13, 15, 17, 27]....
[...]
...This hypothesis was confirmed by gamma and ICP-AES measurements....
[...]
...The recovery yield of the overall radiochemical procedure is generally determined from the measurement of stable Ni by atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) [12] or inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES) [5, 13, 15, 17]....
[...]
...Organic complexing agents, such as citric acid [6, 12, 21], tartaric acid [9, 21] or oxalic acid [5] are generally introduced to prevent the precipitation of Fe and the other metal elements at basic pH....
[...]
8 citations
8 citations
"A comparative study using liquid sc..." refers background in this paper
...Ni is then back-extracted in aqueous solution, mostly with hydrochloric acid [11, 16, 18]....
[...]
...The Ni(DMG)2 complex is first extracted in an organic solvent [20], commonly chloroform [8, 10, 11, 18, 20] which has a higher Ni extraction capacity [20]....
[...]
7 citations
"A comparative study using liquid sc..." refers background or methods in this paper
...Aliquots were prepared for the determination of stable metal elements and gamma emitting radionuclides by ICP-AES and gamma spectrometers respectively....
[...]
...In recent years, many radiochemical procedures based on Ni resin have been applied on many nuclear materials [5, 6, 12, 13, 15, 17, 27]....
[...]
...This hypothesis was confirmed by gamma and ICP-AES measurements....
[...]
...The recovery yield of the overall radiochemical procedure is generally determined from the measurement of stable Ni by atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) [12] or inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES) [5, 13, 15, 17]....
[...]
...Stable Fe, Co and Ni concentrations were measured using an ICP-AES (Inductively Coupled Plasma-Atomic Emission Spectroscopy) Activa M spectrometer (HORIBA Jobin– Yvon, Longjumeau, France)....
[...]