Q2. What have the authors stated for future works in "Acoustic emission for in situ quality monitoring in additive manufacturing using spectral convolutional neural networks" ?
The possible transfer of the results presented to other technologies is the subject of the future investigations.
Q3. What are the main techniques used in additive manufacturing?
at present, additive manufacturing processes incorporate several independently developing techniques, such as stereo-lithography, laser sintering, multi-jet printing, powder-bed fusion and others.
Q4. What is the recent extent of conventional CNN?
Spectral convolutional neural networks (SCNN) are a recent extent of conventional CNN with improved efficiency in classification/regression tasks [27,28,29].
Q5. What is the advantage of using acoustic gratings for AE?
At present, Fiber Bragg gratings (FBG) are often used for detecting AE signals because of its high sensitivity in a wide acoustic spectral range [22].
Q6. What is the definition of the classification accuracies in the table?
Theclassification accuracies in the table are defined as the number of true positives divided by the total number of tests for each category.
Q7. What was the connection to the read out system?
Its connection to the read out system was provided via an optical feedthrough mounted on a plate that hermetically closed the working chamber.
Q8. Why were the signals not included in the training and tests data sets?
Those signals were used to evaluate the existence of changes in the AE content and noise parameters but they were not included into the training and tests data sets.
Q9. What is the spectrogram of the AE signal produced?
An example of a fragment of an AE signal that corresponds to a high quality layerproduced with the optimal process condition that is with an energy density (79 J/mm3, 500 mm/s) and b) a spectrogram corresponding to the relative energies of the narrow frequency bands, localized in time-frequency domain.
Q10. What is the classification error structure of the acoustic signal recorded by the FBG?
the authors can conclude that the acoustic signal recorded by the FBG and its processing with the SCNN could be a solution for in situ and real-time quality monitoring in AM.
Q11. How many narrow frequency bands were extracted?
Each RW was decomposed by WPT at ten decomposition levels, resulting in the extraction of 2,046 narrow frequency bands with their corresponding values of the relative energies (See Section 3.1).
Q12. How is the dimension of the feature space reduced?
The dimensions of the feature space are reduced via the principle component analysis (PCA) projection [41] into a lower 3D dimensional space.