Clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of collaborative care for depression in UK primary care (CADET): a cluster randomised controlled trial.
David Richards,Peter Bower,Carolyn Chew-Graham,Linda Gask,Karina Lovell,John Cape,Stephen Pilling,Ricardo Araya,David Kessler,Michael Barkham,Martin Bland,Simon Gilbody,Colin Green,Glyn Lewis,Chris Manning,Evangelos Kontopantelis,Jacqueline J Hill,Adwoa Hughes-Morley,Abigail Emma Russell +18 more
Reads0
Chats0
TLDR
Collaborative care improves depression up to 12 months after initiation of the intervention, is preferred by patients over usual care, offers health gains at a relatively low cost, is cost-effective compared with usual care and is mediated by patient activation.Abstract:
BACKGROUND: Collaborative care is effective for depression management in the USA. There is little UK evidence on its clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of collaborative care compared with usual care in the management of patients with moderate to severe depression. DESIGN: Cluster randomised controlled trial. SETTING: UK primary care practices (n = 51) in three UK primary care districts. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 581 adults aged ≥ 18 years in general practice with a current International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Edition depressive episode, excluding acutely suicidal people, those with psychosis, bipolar disorder or low mood associated with bereavement, those whose primary presentation was substance abuse and those receiving psychological treatment. INTERVENTIONS: Collaborative care: 14 weeks of 6-12 telephone contacts by care managers; mental health specialist supervision, including depression education, medication management, behavioural activation, relapse prevention and primary care liaison. Usual care was general practitioner standard practice. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Blinded researchers collected depression [Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9)], anxiety (General Anxiety Disorder-7) and quality of life (European Quality of Life-5 Dimensions three-level version), Short Form questionnaire-36 items) outcomes at 4, 12 and 36 months, satisfaction (Client Satisfaction Questionnaire-8) outcomes at 4 months and treatment and service use costs at 12 months. RESULTS: In total, 276 and 305 participants were randomised to collaborative care and usual care respectively. Collaborative care participants had a mean depression score that was 1.33 PHQ-9 points lower [n = 230; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.35 to 2.31; p = 0.009] than that of participants in usual care at 4 months and 1.36 PHQ-9 points lower (n = 275; 95% CI 0.07 to 2.64; p = 0.04) at 12 months after adjustment for baseline depression (effect size 0.28, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.52; odds ratio for recovery 1.88, 95% CI 1.28 to 2.75; number needed to treat 6.5). Quality of mental health but not physical health was significantly better for collaborative care at 4 months but not at 12 months. There was no difference for anxiety. Participants receiving collaborative care were significantly more satisfied with treatment. Differences between groups had disappeared at 36 months. Collaborative care had a mean cost of £272.50 per participant with similar health and social care service use between collaborative care and usual care. Collaborative care offered a mean incremental gain of 0.02 (95% CI -0.02 to 0.06) quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) over 12 months at a mean incremental cost of £270.72 (95% CI -£202.98 to £886.04) and had an estimated mean cost per QALY of £14,248, which is below current UK willingness-to-pay thresholds. Sensitivity analyses including informal care costs indicated that collaborative care is expected to be less costly and more effective. The amount of participant behavioural activation was the only effect mediator. CONCLUSIONS: Collaborative care improves depression up to 12 months after initiation of the intervention, is preferred by patients over usual care, offers health gains at a relatively low cost, is cost-effective compared with usual care and is mediated by patient activation. Supervision was by expert clinicians and of short duration and more intensive therapy may have improved outcomes. In addition, one participant requiring inpatient treatment incurred very significant costs and substantially inflated our cost per QALY estimate. Future work should test enhanced intervention content not collaborative care per se. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN32829227. FUNDING: This project was funded by the Medical Research Council (MRC) (G0701013) and managed by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) on behalf of the MRC-NIHR partnership.read more
Citations
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
Traumatic brain injury: integrated approaches to improve prevention, clinical care, and research
Andrew I R Maas,David K. Menon,P. David Adelson,Nada Andelic,Michael J. Bell,Antonio Belli,Peter Bragge,Alexandra Brazinova,Andras Buki,Randall M. Chesnut,Giuseppe Citerio,Mark Coburn,D. Jamie Cooper,A Tamara Crowder,Endre Czeiter,Marek Czosnyka,Ramon Diaz-Arrastia,Jens P. Dreier,Ann-Christine Duhaime,Ari Ercole,Thomas A. van Essen,Valery L. Feigin,Guoyi Gao,Joseph T. Giacino,Laura E. Gonzalez-Lara,Russell L. Gruen,Russell L. Gruen,Deepak Gupta,Jed A. Hartings,Sean Hill,Jiyao Jiang,Naomi Ketharanathan,Erwin J. O. Kompanje,Linda Lanyon,Steven Laureys,Fiona Lecky,Harvey S. Levin,Hester F. Lingsma,Marc Maegele,Marek Majdan,Geoffrey T. Manley,Jill A. Marsteller,Luciana Mascia,Charles McFadyen,Stefania Mondello,Virginia F. J. Newcombe,Aarno Palotie,Aarno Palotie,Aarno Palotie,Paul M. Parizel,Wilco C. Peul,James Piercy,Suzanne Polinder,Louis Puybasset,Todd E. Rasmussen,Rolf Rossaint,Peter Smielewski,Jeannette Söderberg,Simon J. Stanworth,Murray B. Stein,Nicole von Steinbüchel,William Stewart,Ewout W. Steyerberg,Ewout W. Steyerberg,Nino Stocchetti,Anneliese Synnot,Anneliese Synnot,Braden Te Ao,Olli Tenovuo,Alice Theadom,Dick Tibboel,Walter Videtta,Kevin K.W. Wang,W. Huw Williams,Lindsay Wilson,Kristine Yaffe,Hadie Adams,Vanni Agnoletti,Judith Allanson,Krisztina Amrein,Norberto Andaluz,Audny Anke,Anna Antoni,Arjan Bastiaan van As,Gérard Audibert,Antun Azaševac,Philippe Azouvi,Maria Luisa Azzolini,Camelia Baciu,Rafael Badenes,Karen M. Barlow,Ronald H. M. A. Bartels,Ursula Bauerfeind,Miriam H. Beauchamp,Darcy Beer,Ronny Beer,Francisco Javier Belda,Bo-Michael Bellander,Rémy Bellier,Habib Benali,Thierry Benard,Valzerda Beqiri,Luigi Beretta,Francis Bernard,Guido Bertolini,Federico Bilotta,Morten Blaabjerg,Hugo den Boogert,Kathy Boutis,Pierre Bouzat,Brian L. Brooks,Camilla Brorsson,Monika Bullinger,Emma Burns,Calappi E,Peter Cameron,Elsa Carise,Ana M. Castaño-Leon,Francesco Causin,Giorgio Chevallard,Arturo Chieregato,Brian R. Christie,Maryse C. Cnossen,Jonathan P. Coles,Johnny Collett,Francesco Della Corte,William Craig,Gábor Csató,Ákos Csomós,Nicola Curry,Claire Dahyot-Fizelier,Helen Dawes,Carol DeMatteo,Bart Depreitere,Deborah Dewey,Jeroen T. J. M. van Dijck,Đula Đilvesi,Diederik W.J. Dippel,Kemal Dizdarevic,Emma Donoghue,Or Duek,Guy-Loup Dulière,Adelaida Dzeko,George A. Eapen,Carolyn A. Emery,Shane W. English,Patrick Esser,Erzsébet Ezer,Martin Fabricius,Junfeng Feng,Dean Fergusson,Anthony Figaji,Joanne Fleming,Kelly A Foks,G. Francony,Stephen B. Freedman,Ulderico Freo,Shirin Frisvold,Isabelle Gagnon,Damien Galanaud,Dashiell Gantner,Benoit Giraud,Ben Glocker,Jagos Golubovic,Pedro A Gómez López,Wayne A. Gordon,Primoz Gradisek,Jocelyn Gravel,Donald E. G. Griesdale,Francesca Grossi,Juanita A. Haagsma,Asta Håberg,Iain K. Haitsma,Wim Van Hecke,Raimund Helbok,Eirik Helseth,Caroline M. van Heugten,Cornelia W. E. Hoedemaekers,Stefan Höfer,Lindsay Horton,Jiyuan Hui,Jilske A Huijben,Peter J. Hutchinson,Bram Jacobs,Mathieu van der Jagt,Stefan Jankowski,Koen Janssens,Bojan Jelaca,Kelly Jones,Konstantinos Kamnitsas,Rafael Kaps,Mladen Karan,Ari Katila,Kirsi-Maija Kaukonen,Véronique De Keyser,Riku Kivisaari,Angelos G. Kolias,Balint Kolumban,Ksenija Kolundžija,Daniel Kondziella,Lars-Owe D. Koskinen,Noémi Kovács,Andreas H. Kramer,Demitri Kutsogiannis,Theodoros Kyprianou,Alfonso Lagares,Francois Lamontagne,Roberto Latini,François Lauzier,Isaac Lazar,Christian Ledig,Rolf Lefering,Valerie Legrand,Leon Levi,Roger Lightfoot,Angels Lozano,Stephen MacDonald,Sebastian Major,Alex Manara,Pauline Manhes,Hugues Maréchal,Costanza Martino,Alessandro Masala,Serge Masson,Julia Mattern,Bradford J. McFadyen,Catherine McMahon,Maureen O. Meade,Béla Melegh,Tomas Menovsky,Lynne Moore,Marta M Correia,Maria Cristina Morganti-Kossmann,Holger Muehlan,Pratik Mukherjee,Lynnette Murray,Joukje van der Naalt,Ancuta Negru,David W. Nelson,Daan Nieboer,Quentin Noirhomme,József Nyirádi,Mauro Oddo,David O. Okonkwo,Annemarie W. Oldenbeuving,Fabrizio Ortolano,Martin H. Osmond,Jean-François Payen,Vincent Perlbarg,Paolo Persona,Nicolas Pichon,Anna Piippo-Karjalainen,Sebastien Pili-Floury,Matti Pirinen,Horia Ple,Maria A. Poca,Jussi P. Posti,Dominique Van Praag,Alain Ptito,Andreea Radoi,Arminas Ragauskas,Arminas Ragauskas,Rahul Raj,Ruben G. L. Real,Nick Reed,Jonathan Rhodes,Claudia S. Robertson,Saulius Rocka,Saulius Rocka,Cecilie Røe,Olav Røise,Gerwin Roks,Jonathan Rosand,Jeffrey V. Rosenfeld,Christina Rosenlund,Guy Rosenthal,Sandra Rossi,Daniel Rueckert,Godard C.W. de Ruiter,Marco Sacchi,Barbara J. Sahakian,Juan Sahuquillo,Oliver W. Sakowitz,Gerardo Salvato,Renán Sánchez-Porras,János Sándor,Grinder Sangha,Nadine Schäfer,Silke Schmidt,Kathryn J Schneider,David M. Schnyer,Herbert Schöhl,Guus G. Schoonman,Rico Frederik Schou,Özcan Sir,Toril Skandsen,Dirk Smeets,Abayomi Sorinola,Emmanuel Stamatakis,Ana Stevanovic,Robert Stevens,Nina Sundström,Fabio Silvio Taccone,Fabio Silvio Taccone,Riikka S.K. Takala,Päivi Tanskanen,Mark Taylor,Ralph Telgmann,Nancy R. Temkin,Guido Teodorani,Matthew Thomas,Christos M. Tolias,Tony Trapani,Alexis F. Turgeon,Peter Vajkoczy,Alex B. Valadka,Egils Valeinis,Shirley Vallance,Zoltan Vamos,Alessia Vargiolu,Emmanuel Vega,Jan Verheyden,Anne Vik,Rimantas Vilcinis,Carmen L.A. Vleggeert-Lankamp,Lidia Vogt,Victor Volovici,Daphne C. Voormolen,Peter Vulekovic,Thijs Vande Vyvere,Julia Van Waesberghe,Lars Wessels,Eno Wildschut,Guy B. Williams,Maren K.L. Winkler,Stefan Wolf,Gordon Wood,Nektaria Xirouchaki,Alexander Younsi,Menashe Zaaroor,Veronika Zelinkova,Roger Zemek,Fabrizio Zumbo +342 more
TL;DR: The InTBIR Participants and Investigators have provided informed consent for the study to take place in Poland.
Journal ArticleDOI
Traumatic brain injury in England and Wales: prospective audit of epidemiology, complications and standardised mortality
TL;DR: The first comprehensive report of the management of TBI in England and Wales, including data from all neurosurgical units, is provided, to provide transparency and suggests equity of access to high-quality TBI management provided.
Journal ArticleDOI
Tailored online cognitive behavioural therapy with or without therapist support calls to target psychological distress in adults receiving haemodialysis: a feasibility randomised controlled trial
Joanna L. Hudson,Rona Moss-Morris,Sam Norton,Federica Picariello,David Game,Amy Carroll,Jonathan Spencer,Paul McCrone,Matthew Hotopf,Lucy Yardley,Joseph Chilcot +10 more
TL;DR: Online CBT appears feasible but only for computer literate patients who identify with the label psychological distress, and a definitive trial using the current methods for psychological distress screening and online care delivery is unfeasible.
Journal ArticleDOI
Cognitive–behaviour therapy for health anxiety in medical patients (CHAMP): a randomised controlled trial with outcomes to 5 years
Peter Tyrer,Paul M. Salkovskis,Helen Tyrer,Duolao Wang,Mike J. Crawford,Simon Dupont,Sylvia Cooper,John Green,David Murphy,Geoffrey Smith,Sharandeep Bhogal,Shaeda Nourmand,Valentina Lazarevic,Gemma Loebenberg,Rachel Evered,Stephanie Kings,Antoinette McNulty,Yvonne Lisseman-Stones,Sharon McAllister,Kofi Kramo,Jessica Nagar,Steven Reid,Rahil Sanatinia,Katherine Whittamore,Gemma Walker,Aaron B. Philip,Hilary M. C. Warwick,Sarah Byford,Barbara Barrett +28 more
TL;DR: CBT-HA is a highly effective treatment for pathological health anxiety with lasting benefit over 5 years and may also be cost-effective, but the high costs of concurrent medical illnesses obscure potential savings.
Journal ArticleDOI
How much change is enough? Evidence from a longitudinal study on depression in UK primary care.
Daphne-Zacharenia Kounali,Katherine S. Button,Gemma Lewis,Simon Gilbody,David Kessler,Ricardo Araya,Larisa Duffy,Paul Lanham,Triinu Peters,Nicola J Wiles,Glyn Lewis +10 more
TL;DR: An MCID representing 20% reduction of scores in these scales, is a useful guide for patients with moderately severe symptoms, if treatment had the same effect on patients irrespective of baseline severity.
References
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
Using thematic analysis in psychology
Virginia Braun,Victoria Clarke +1 more
TL;DR: Thematic analysis is a poorly demarcated, rarely acknowledged, yet widely used qualitative analytic method within psychology as mentioned in this paper, and it offers an accessible and theoretically flexible approach to analysing qualitative data.
Book
Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research
TL;DR: The Discovery of Grounded Theory as mentioned in this paper is a book about the discovery of grounded theories from data, both substantive and formal, which is a major task confronting sociologists and is understandable to both experts and laymen.
Journal ArticleDOI
The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale.
A. S. Zigmond,R. P. Snaith +1 more
TL;DR: It is suggested that the introduction of the scales into general hospital practice would facilitate the large task of detection and management of emotional disorder in patients under investigation and treatment in medical and surgical departments.
Journal ArticleDOI
The PHQ-9: validity of a brief depression severity measure.
TL;DR: In addition to making criteria-based diagnoses of depressive disorders, the PHQ-9 is also a reliable and valid measure of depression severity, which makes it a useful clinical and research tool.
Journal ArticleDOI
A Brief Measure for Assessing Generalized Anxiety Disorder: The GAD-7
TL;DR: In this article, a 7-item anxiety scale (GAD-7) had good reliability, as well as criterion, construct, factorial, and procedural validity, and increasing scores on the scale were strongly associated with multiple domains of functional impairment.