scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Controlling crippled aircraft-with throttles

TL;DR: In this paper, a study was conducted of the capability and techniques for emergency flight control of a multi-engine crippled aircraft, with most or all of the flight control system inoperative, may use engine thrust for control.
Abstract: A multiengine crippled aircraft, with most or all of the flight control system inoperative, may use engine thrust for control. A study was conducted of the capability and techniques for emergency flight control. Included were light twin engine piston powered airplanes, an executive jet transport, commercial jet transports, and a high performance fighter. Piloted simulations of the B-720, B-747, B-727, MD-11, C-402, and F-15 airplanes were studied, and the Lear 24, PA-30, and F-15 airplanes were flight tested. All aircraft showed some control capability with throttles and could be kept under control in up-and-away flight for an extended period of time. Using piloted simulators, landings with manual throttles-only control were extremely difficult. However, there are techniques that improve the chances of making a survivable landing. In addition, augmented control systems provide major improvements in control capability and make repeatable landings possible. Control capabilities and techniques are discussed.

Content maybe subject to copyright    Report

Citations
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, a neural network hybrid direct-indirect adaptive flight control is developed for the stability augmentation control of the damaged aircraft. But, this approach is limited to a single aircraft.
Abstract: This paper presents a recent study to investigate flight dynamics and adaptive control methods for stability and control recovery of a damaged generic transport aircraft. Aerodynamic modeling of damage effects is performed using an aerodynamic code to assess changes in the stability and control derivatives of the damaged aircraft. Flight dynamics for a general aircraft are developed to account for changes in aerodynamics, mass properties, and the center of gravity that can compromise the stability of the damaged aircraft An iterative trim analysis is developed to compute incremental trim states. A neural network hybrid direct-indirect adaptive flight control is developed for the stability augmentation control of the damaged aircraft. The proposed method performs an online estimation of damaged plant dynamics to improve the command tracking performance in conjunction with a direct adaptive controller. The plant estimation is based on two approaches: 1) an indirect adaptive law derived from the Lyapunov stability theory to ensure that the tracking error is bounded, and 2) a recursive least-squares method that minimizes the modeling error. Simulations show that the hybrid adaptive controller can provide a significant improvement in the tracking performance over a direct adaptive controller working alone.

168 citations


Cites background from "Controlling crippled aircraft-with ..."

  • ...This accident gave an impetus to the propulsion controlled aircraft (PCA) research at NASA [4]....

    [...]

Proceedings ArticleDOI
01 Nov 2009
TL;DR: In this paper, a sensitivity analysis revealed a complex interaction of the limits and the difficulty in predicting the way to achieve the fastest response, and demonstrated that significantly faster engine response can be achieved compared to standard Bill of Material control.
Abstract: Damaged aircraft have occasionally had to rely solely on thrust to maneuver as a consequence of losing hydraulic power needed to operate flight control surfaces. The lack of successful landings in these cases inspired research into more effective methods of utilizing propulsion-only control. That research demonstrated that one of the major contributors to the difficulty in landing is the slow response of the engines as compared to using traditional flight control. To address this, research is being conducted into ways of making the engine more responsive under emergency conditions. This can be achieved by relaxing controller limits, adjusting schedules, and/or redesigning the regulators to increase bandwidth. Any of these methods can enable faster response at the potential expense of engine life and increased likelihood of stall. However, an example sensitivity analysis revealed a complex interaction of the limits and the difficulty in predicting the way to achieve the fastest response. The sensitivity analysis was performed on a realistic engine model, and demonstrated that significantly faster engine response can be achieved compared to standard Bill of Material control. However, the example indicates the need for an intelligent approach to controller limit adjustment in order for the potential to be fulfilled.

47 citations

01 May 1998
TL;DR: In this paper, the NASA Dryden Flight Research Center has developed a propulsion-controlled aircraft (PCA) system in which computer-controlled engine thrust provides emergency flight control, which can operate without modifications to engine control systems.
Abstract: With modern digital control systems, using engine thrust for emergency flight control to supplement or replace failed aircraft normal flight controls has become a practical consideration. The NASA Dryden Flight Research Center has developed a propulsion-controlled aircraft (PCA) system in which computer-controlled engine thrust provides emergency flight control. An F-15 and an MD-11 airplane have been landed without using any flight control surfaces. Preliminary studies have also been conducted that show that engines on only one wing can provide some flight control capability if the lateral center of gravity can be shifted toward the side of the airplane that has the operating engine(s). Simulator tests of several airplanes with no flight control surfaces operating and all engines out on the left wing have all shown positive control capability within the available range of lateral center-of-gravity offset. Propulsion-controlled aircraft systems that can operate without modifications to engine control systems, thus allowing PCA technology to be installed on less capable airplanes or at low cost, are also desirable. Further studies have examined simplified 'PCA Lite' and 'PCA Ultralite' concepts in which thrust control is provided by existing systems such as auto-throttles or a combination of existing systems and manual pilot control.

46 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, a large, civilian, multi-engine transport MD-11 airplane control system was recently modie ed to perform as an emergency backup controller using engine thrust only.
Abstract: A large, civilian, multiengine transport MD-11 airplane control system was recently modie ed to perform as an emergency backup controller using engine thrust only. The emergency backup system, referred to as the propulsion-controlled aircraft (PCA)system, would be used if a majorprimary e ight control system fails. To allow for longitudinal- and lateral-directional control, the PCA system requires at least two engines and is implemented through software modie cations. A e ight-test program was conducted to evaluate the PCA system high-altitude e ying characteristics and to demonstrate its capacity to perform safe landings. The cruise e ight conditions, several low approaches, and four landings without any aerodynamic e ight control surface movement were demonstrated; however, only one landing is presented. Results that show satisfactory performance of the PCA system in the longitudinal axis are presented. Test results indicate that the lateral-directional axis of the system performed well at high altitude but was sluggish and prone to thermal upsets during landing approaches. Flight-test experiences and test techniques are also discussed, with emphasis on the lateral-directional axis because of the dife culties encountered in e ight test.

40 citations

Book
02 Aug 2013
TL;DR: In this paper, a history of accidents or incidents in which some or all flight controls were lost, manual TOC results for a wide range of airplanes from simulation and flight, and suggested techniques for flying with throttles only and making a survivable landing.
Abstract: If normal aircraft flight controls are lost, emergency flight control may be attempted using only engines thrust. Collective thrust is used to control flightpath, and differential thrust is used to control bank angle. Flight test and simulation results on many airplanes have shown that pilot manipulation of throttles is usually adequate to maintain up-and-away flight, but is most often not capable of providing safe landings. There are techniques that will improve control and increase the chances of a survivable landing. This paper reviews the principles of throttles-only control (TOC), a history of accidents or incidents in which some or all flight controls were lost, manual TOC results for a wide range of airplanes from simulation and flight, and suggested techniques for flying with throttles only and making a survivable landing.

39 citations

References
More filters
Proceedings ArticleDOI
01 Jun 1991
TL;DR: The use of throttle control laws to provide adequate flying qualities for flight path control in the event of a total loss of conventional flight control surface use was evaluated in this paper, where the results were based on a simulation evaluation by transport research pilots of a B-720 transport with visual display.
Abstract: The use of throttle control laws to provide adequate flying qualities for flight path control in the event of a total loss of conventional flight control surface use was evaluated. The results are based on a simulation evaluation by transport research pilots of a B-720 transport with visual display. Throttle augmentation control laws can provide flight path control capable of landing a transport-type aircraft with up to moderate levels of turbulence. The throttle augmentation mode dramatically improves the pilots' ability to control flight path for the approach and landing flight condition using only throttle modulation. For light turbulence, the average Cooper-Harper pilot rating improved from unacceptable to acceptable (a pilot rating improvement of 4.5) in going from manual to augmented control. The low frequency response characteristics of the engines require a considerably different piloting technique. The various techniques used by the pilot resulted in considerable scatter in data. Many pilots readily adapted to a good piloting technique while some had difficulty. A new viable approach is shown to provide independent means of redundancy of transport aircraft flight path control.

45 citations

Proceedings ArticleDOI
01 Sep 1991
TL;DR: In this paper, a preliminary investigation was conducted regarding the use of throttles for emergency flight control of a multiengine aircraft, including a light twin-engine piston-powered airplane, jet transports, and a high performance fighter.
Abstract: A preliminary investigation was conducted regarding the use of throttles for emergency flight control of a multiengine aircraft. Several airplanes including a light twin-engine piston-powered airplane, jet transports, and a high performance fighter were studied during flight and piloted simulations. Simulation studies used the B-720, B-727, MD-11, and F-15 aircraft. Flight studies used the Lear 24, Piper PA-30, and F-15 airplanes. Based on simulator and flight results, all the airplanes exhibited some control capability with throttles. With piloted simulators, landings using manual throttles-only control were extremely difficult. An augmented control system was developed that converts conventional pilot stick inputs into appropriate throttle commands. With the augmented system, the B-720 and F-15 simulations were evaluated and could be landed successfully. Flight and simulation data were compared for the F-15 airplane.

16 citations