Demonstrating the Value of an Organization's Learning Culture: The Dimensions of the Learning Organization Questionnaire
Citations
10,294 citations
2,004 citations
Cites background from "Demonstrating the Value of an Organ..."
...Readiness for change Conceptualizations, definitions, and measures of organizational readiness to change vary widely and range from organizations that are poised to change and innovate (Marsick and Watkins 2003) to organizations with high levels of inertia that may stifle innovation....
[...]
711 citations
Cites methods from "Demonstrating the Value of an Organ..."
...Half of the original items were deleted from the scale using the MG process and the remaining half constituted the academic version of the DLOQ (Marsick & Watkins, 2003)....
[...]
...The DLOQ will provide a useful tool for researchers to assess dimensions of the learning organization....
[...]
...Reliability Estimates for the Measures in the DLOQ Initial Measurement Refined Measurement Coefficient Reliability Coefficient Reliability Scale Alpha Under CFA Alpha Under CFA Continuous learning .81 .90 .71 .84 Dialogue and inquiry .87 .91 .78 .87 Team learning .86 .93 .79 .87 Embedded system .81 .89 .75 .85 System connection .84 .90 .75 .84 Empowerment .80 .88 .68 .83 Provide leadership .87 .94 .83 .93 Financial performance .74 .84 .70 .79 Knowledge performance .77 .86 .64 .78 more than 90 percent of the joint amount of variance and covariance of the data could be accounted for by the model being tested....
[...]
...Phase 3 was used to assess the nomological validity of the DLOQ with SEM technique....
[...]
...Finally, an important use of an instrument such as the DLOQ is to measure change over time in order to determine whether and how an active intervention to create a learning organization affects responses....
[...]
633 citations
Cites background from "Demonstrating the Value of an Organ..."
...Dimensions of the Learning Organization Questionnaire [115] X O: Continuous learning, inquiry and dialogue collaboration and team learning, systems to c ture learning, empower people, connect the orga ation, provide strategic leadership for learning, finan al performance, knowledge performance [115] None Healthcare...
[...]
...%) of the measures located in our search neither assessed criterion validity in Table 1 Coded measures (N = 62) Scale name and original source Structural (S) Organizational (O) Individual: Provider (PR) Individual: Patient (PA) Innovation (I) Construct information Search article/s Criterion validity Implementation context Alberta Context Tool (ACT) [86] X O: culture, leadership, evaluation, social capital, informal interactions, formal interactions, structural and electronic resources, organizational slack [86] Adoption* Healthcare [87] Adoption* [88] None [89] None [90] None Appraisal of Guidelines, Research, and Evaluation in Europe (AGREE) scale [91] X I: Scope and purpose, stakeholder involvement, rigor of development, clarity and presentation, applicability, editorial independence [91] None EBP government support organizations[92] None Attitudes, Perceived Demand, and Perceived Support (ARTAS) [93] X X X X S: Funding and policy support [93] Adoption* Healthcare O: Management support PA: Patient benefit I: Adaptability and feasibility Barriers and Facilitators Assessment Instrument [47] X X X X X S: Social, political, societal context [47] Adoption* Healthcare [94] NoneO: Organizational context PR: Care provider characteristics PA: Patient characteristics I: Innovation characteristics Barriers to Implementation of Behavioral Therapy (BIBT) [95] X X X O: Institutional constraints, insufficient collegial support [95] None Mental Health/ Substance Abuse [96] None PR: Philosophical opposition to evidence-based practice [97] None PA: Client dissatisfaction Barriers to Research Utilization Scale (BARRIERS) [56] X X X O: Setting barriers and limitations [56] None Healthcare PR: Research skills, values, and awareness of EBP [77] Adoption* I: Quality and presentation of research [98] None [99] None [100] None [101] None [102] None [103] None [78] Adoption [79] None C haudoir et al.Im plem entation Science 2013,8:22 Page 8 of 20 http://w w w .im plem entationscience.com /content/8/1/22 Table 1 Coded measures (N = 62) (Continued) [80] Adoption* [104] None [105] None Big 5 Personality (e.g., NEOFFI) [46] X PR: Personality attributes (openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeablenes neuroticism) [46] None Education [66] Fidelity* California Critical Thinking Dispositions Inventory [106] X PR: Inquisitiveness, systematicity, analyticity, tr hseeking, open-mindedness, self-confidence, m urity [106] None Healthcare [107] Adoption* [108] None Clinical Practice Guidelines Implementation Instrument [64] X X O: Context features [64] None Healthcare I: Evidence Community-Level Predictors [109] X S: Poverty and population [109] Adoption* Healthcare Competing Values Framework [62] Adapted from [110,111] X O: Organizational culture (hierarchical, entrep eurial, team, and rational) [62] None Healthcare Context Assessment Index [112] X O: Collaborative practice, evidence-informed ctice, respect for persons, practice boundaries, eval tion [112] None Healthcare Coping Style: Supervisory Working Alliance Inventory [113] X PR: Coping style [113] None Education [66] Fidelity* Decision-Maker Information Needs and Preferences Survey [114] X X X X S: Financial resources, impact of regulations a legislation [114] None Healthcare O: Support for EBP PR: Preferences for EBP information I: Quality, relevance of EBP Dimensions of the Learning Organization Questionnaire [115] X O: Continuous learning, inquiry and dialogue collaboration and team learning, systems to c ture learning, empower people, connect the orga ation, provide strategic leadership for learning, finan al performance, knowledge performance [115] None Healthcare [116] Adoption* Edmonton Research Orientation Survey (EROS) [58] X PR: Valuing research, research involvement, b g at the leading edge [58] None Healthcare [79] None [104] None Electronic Health Record Nurse Satisfaction Survey (EHRNS) [117] X I: Satisfaction with innovation [117] None Healthcare C haudoir et al.Im plem entation Science 2013,8:22 Page 9 of 20 http://w w w .im plem entationscience.com /content/8/1/22 s, ut at ren pra ua nd , ap niz ci ein Table 1 Coded measures (N = 62) (Continued) EPC [52,118] X PR: Cognitive response style [52] None Healthcare [118] Adoption* [119] None Evidence Based Practice Attitude Scale [24] X PR: Intuitive appeal of EBP, openness to new practices [24] None Mental Health/ Substance Abuse [120] Adoption* [121] None [122] Adoption [123] None ‡ Evidence-Based Practice Beliefs Scale [57] X PR: Attitudes about EBP [57] Adoption* Healthcare [124] None [122] None [125] None Evidence-Based Practice Questionnaire [126] X PR: EBP attitudes, knowledge, and skills [126] Adoption* Healthcare [80] Adoption* [77] Adoption* Facilitators Scale [105] X X X O: Support for research [105] None Healthcare PR: Education [98] None I: Improving utility of research [101] None Four As Research Utilization Survey [127] X O: Organizational barriers to access, assess, adapt, and apply EBP [127] Adoption Mental Health/ Substance Abuse General Practitioners’ Perceptions of the Route of Evidence-Based Medicine [128] X X X O: Organization support for EBP [128] None Healthcare PR: Attitudes toward EBP [129] None I: Quality of evidence Group Cohesion Scale [130] X O: Perceived group attractiveness and cohesiveness [130] None Healthcare [131] None GuideLine Implementability Appraisal (GLIA) [132] X I: Implementability [132] None Healthcare [133] None Healthy Heart Kit Questionnaire [26] X X X O: Type of practice [26] Adoption* Healthcare PR: Perceived confidence and control I: Relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, observability Information System Evaluation Tool [134] X I: Usability and usefulness of innovation [134] None Healthcare Intention to Leave Scale [135] X X O: Work rewards, people at work, work load [135] None Healthcare C haudoir et al.Im plem entation Science 2013,8:22 Page 10 of 20 http://w w w .im plem entationscience.com /content/8/1/22 Table 1 Coded measures (N = 62) (Continued) PR: Intention to leave nursing profession [131] None Job Satisfaction [136] X X O: Communication and decision-making [136] None Healthcare PR: Pay, fringe benefits, and promotion, close friends at work [131] None Knowledge, Attitudes, and Expectations of WebAssisted Tobacco Interventions [137] X I: Knowledge, expectations, actions, networking, information seeking related to innovation [137] None Healthcare Knowledge Transfer Inventory (Personal Knowledge Transfer subscale) [138] X PR: Knowledge acquisition and sharing [138] None Healthcare [139] None Knowledge Transfer and Exchange Correlates [140] X X X S: Policymakers use of EBP, and funding support [140] Adoption Healthcare O: Communication and decision-making PR: Research skills, and research activities Leader Member Exchange Scale [141] X O: Leadership style, work environment [141] None Healthcare [139] None Nurses Retention Index [142] X PR: Intention to stay in nursing profession [142] None Healthcare [131] None Nursing Research Utilization Survey [143] X PR: Attitudes towards nursing research [143] Adoption* Healthcare Nursing Work Index [144] X O: hospital characteristics [144] None Healthcare [83] None [145] None Organization Readiness to Change Assessment (ORCA) [27] X X X O: culture, leadership, measurement, readiness for change, resources, characteristics, role [27] None Healthcare PA: Evidence: Patient preferences [146] Adoption* I: Evidence: Disagreement, evidence, clinical experience Organizational Culture and Readiness for System-Wide Implementation of EBP (OCRSIEP) [147] X O: organizational culture, readiness for system-wide integration of EBP [147] None Healthcare [148] Adoption* [131] None Organizational Culture Survey [60,149] X O: Constructive Culture (motivation, individualism, support), Passive Defensive Culture (consensus, conformity, subservience) [149] None Education [60] None [66] Fidelity* Healthcare Organizational Learning Survey (OLS) [150] X O: Clarity of purpose, leadership, experimentation and rewards, transfer of knowledge, teamwork [150] None Workplace [145] None C haudoir et al.Im plem entation Science 2013,8:22 Page 11 of 20 http://w w w .im plem entationscience.com /content/8/1/22 Table 1 Coded measures (N = 62) (Continued) Organizational Readiness for Change [45] X X O: Institutional resources, Organizational climate, motivational readiness [45] None Mental Health/ Substance Abuse [78] Adoption PR: Staff personality attributes [151] Adoption* Organizational Social Context† [152] X X O: Climate, culture [152] None Mental Health/ Substance Abuse PR: Work attitudes [121] None Organizational/Psychological Climate [60,153] X PR: Job satisfaction, depersonalization, emotional exhaustion, role conflict [60] None Education [153] None [66] Fidelity* Mental Health/ Substance Abuse [151] Adoption* Ottawa Acceptability of Decision Rules Instrument (OADRI) [154] X I: Acceptability of clinical practice guidelines [154] Adoption* Healthcare Perceived Importance of Dissemination Activities [155] X PR: Perceived importance of dissemination activities [155] None University Health Researchers Pre-Implementation Expectancies [59] X X X O: Teacher morale, leadership encouragement [59] Adoption* Education Fidelity* PR: Enthusiasm for Implementation, preparedness to implement, implementation self-efficacy [66] Fidelity* I: Compatibility, beliefs about the program Quality Improvement Implementation Survey [156] X O: Culture, leadership, information and analysis, strategic planning quality, human resource utilization, quality management, quality results, customer satisfaction [156] None Healthcare [157] None Rational Experiential Inventory [158] X PR: Rational and experiential thinking styles [158] None Healthcare [159] Adoption* Research Conduct and Research Utilization by Nurses Questionnaire [160] X PR: Knowledge base for research, attitude towards research utilization [160] None Healthcare Research Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices of Research Survey [161] X PR: Research knowledge, attitudes, practice [161] None Healthcare [79] None [104] Adoption* Research Utilization Questionnaire (RUQ) [162] X PR: perceived difficulty of research utilization activities, attitudes regarding utilization [162] None Healthcare Research Utilization Questionnaire (RUQ) [65] X X O: availability and support [65] None Healthcare PR: attitude [163] None [108] Adoption* C haudoir et al.Im plem entation Science 2013,8:22 Page 12 of 20 http://w w w .im plem entationscience.com /content/8/1/22 Table 1 Coded measures (N = 62) (Continued) [164] None San Francisco Treatment Research Center Course Evaluation [165] X X O: Organizational barriers to adopting EBP, agency [165] None Mental Health/ Substance Abuse [166] NoneManagement, strategies to support EBP PR: Stage of change for using EBPs, attitudes regarding EBP, past experience with EBP Team Check-Up Tool [167] X O: Leadership, shared decision-making, shared vision [167] None Healthcare [83] Adoption* ‡ Team Climate Inventory [168] X O: Shared vision, shared decision-making, support, information sharing [168] Adoption* Healthcare [123] None ‡ Team Functioning Survey [169] X O: Team skill, support, and work environment [169] Adoption* Healthcare [83] None Team Organization and Support Conditions Questionnaire [61] X O: organizational support, team organization, external change agent support [61] None Healthcare Theoretical-Domains Framework [170] X X X O: Management support, organizational support and resources [170] None Healthcare PR: Perceived knowledge, skills, and abilities, motivation PA: patient interest in treatment Theory of Planned Behavior Constructs (i.e., attitudes, norms, perceived behavioral control) [25] X PR: Attitudes, norms, perceived behavioral control [25] None Healthcare [171] Adoption* [38] Adoption* [172] Adoption [173] Adoption* Therapist Characteristics and Barriers to Implementation [174] X X O: clinic type, location, organizational support [174] None Mental Health/ Substance Abuse PR: Perceived skills and ability, counseling discipline, level of education, workload, motivation Worksite Health Promotion Capacity Instrument (WHPCI) - Health Promotion Willingness subscale [67] X O: Health promotion willingness [67] Adoption* Workplace Notes....
[...]
520 citations
References
16,386 citations
12,403 citations
10,294 citations