Development of a training phantom for compression breast elastography-comparison of various elastography systems and numerical simulations.
TL;DR: A tissue-like agar-based phantom is developed, which mimics breast tissue with common abnormal lesions like fibroadenoma and invasive ductal carcinoma in a clinically perceived way and compares the sonographic and elastographic appearances using different commercially available systems.
Abstract: The elastic properties of tissue are related to tissue composition and pathological changes. It has been observed that many pathological processes increase the elastic modulus of soft tissue compared to normal. Ultrasound compression elastography is a method of characterization of elastic properties that has been the focus of many research efforts in the last two decades. In medical radiology, compression elastography is provided as an additional tool with ultrasound B-mode in the existing scanners, and the combined features of elastography and echography act as a promising diagnostic method in breast cancer detection. However, the full capability of the ultrasound elastography technique together with B-mode has not been utilized by novice radiologists due to the nonavailability of suitable, appropriately designed tissue-mimicking phantoms. Since different commercially available ultrasound elastographic scanners follow their own unique protocols, training novice radiologists is becoming cumbersome. The main focus of this work is to develop a tissue-like agar-based phantom, which mimics breast tissue with common abnormal lesions like fibroadenoma and invasive ductal carcinoma in a clinically perceived way and compares the sonographic and elastographic appearances using different commercially available systems. In addition, the developed phantoms are simulated using the finite-element method, and ideal strain images are generated. Strain images from experiment and simulation are compared based on image contrast parameters, namely contrast transfer efficiency (CTE) and observed strain, and they are in good agreement. The strain image contrast of malignant inclusions is significantly improved compared to benign inclusions, and the trend of CTE is similar for all elastographic scanners under investigation.
...read more
Citations
194 citations
7 citations
6 citations
5 citations
2 citations
References
3,476 citations
"Development of a training phantom f..." refers background or methods in this paper
...The elastic properties are imaged by giving a mechanical compression to tissues of interest and analyzing the response of the same, which is known as stiffness imaging or elastography.(5) The tissue response could be measured using either ultrasound,(5) MRI,(6) or optical methods....
[...]
...Here, we focus on ultrasound elastography imaging techniques in which tissue displacement is estimated by finding out the time delay between reflected echoes.(5) Based on the compression, there are two different approaches in ultrasound elastography, namely compression or strain elastography(5) and shear wave elastography (SWE)....
[...]
...In the literature, the promising features of compression elastography, namely strain and the area ratio between the ultrasound B-mode and elastogram, have been discussed toward improving the specificity of breast diagnosis.(5,11) The classification accuracy of the diagnostic system was significantly improved by including strain information as an additional input with ultrasound B-mode features....
[...]
...isotropic behavior and, therefore, characterized by its Young’s modulus.(4,5) Now, the model became a discrete deformation problem whose solution is approximated to the solution obtained at the nodes of the mesh, which approximates the tissue continuous domain using FEM....
[...]
...Since the applied compression is usually <5%, the tissue is assumed as a linear elastic material.(4,5,24) The results from the image analysis of developed phantoms indicate that malignant lesions (high-contrast lesions) have an improved conspicuity relative to low contrast, benign lesions using ultrasound compression elastography....
[...]
2,115 citations
1,906 citations
1,610 citations
"Development of a training phantom f..." refers background in this paper
...reaction around the lesion, calcifications, microlobulation, and significant vascularization.(29) Out of the above-men-...
[...]
1,609 citations
"Development of a training phantom f..." refers background in this paper
...However, the Young’s modulus values of the targets are within a limited range for determining the elasticity contrast study, which is far less than the full dynamic range encountered during clinical scanning of breast tissue (25 to 550 kPa).(3) Most of the studies reported in literature to explain commercial phantoms discuss the axial and lateral resolutions, and do not discuss clinical performance....
[...]
...Researchers have shown that the disease process in the human body alters the elastic properties of soft tissues.(3,4) The elastic properties are imaged by giving a mechanical compression to tissues of interest and analyzing the response of the same, which is known as stiffness imaging or elastography....
[...]
...2)—which covers the entire range of breast abnormalities.(3) Additionally, simple cysts of various diameters were also mimicked to understand their elastographic appearance....
[...]