Developments in Ethnographic Research in Education: From Interpretive to Critical Ethnography.
Citations
603 citations
Cites background from "Developments in Ethnographic Resear..."
...(For a more complete discussion of these issues than will be found in this review, see Angus, 1986a; Comstock, 1982; Lather, 1986a, 1986b; Masemann, 1982; Reynolds, 1980-1981; Simon & Dippo, 1986; Thomas, 1983; and West, 1984.)...
[...]
...Other studies that have explored the dynamics of race, gender, and class in student subcultures include those of Angus, 1986b; Aggleton, 1987; Aggleton and Whitty, 1985; Brah and Minhas, 1985; Corrigan, 1979; Humphries, 1981; Jenkins, 1983; and Macpherson, 1983....
[...]
...ethnographers who have taken care to build procedures for "objectivity" into their work (see the critique of Willis by Hammersley & Atkinson, 1983; the critique of Everhart by Cusick, 1985a, 1985b; and the critique of Anyon by Ramsey, 1983). Critical ethnography is, after all, what Lather (1986a) called "openly ideological research." The apparent contradiction of such value-based research with traditional definitions of validity has left critical ethnography open to criticism from both within and outside of the ethnographic tradition. Of course, critical ethnographers engage in standard practices associated with what Lincoln and Guba (1985) called the "trustworthiness" of ethnographic research, such as member checking and triangulation of data sources and methods....
[...]
...The result of the interpretivist movements in both disciplines was to highlight the importance of symbolic action and "to place human actors and their inteφretive and negotiating capacities at the centre of analysis" (Angus, 1986a, p. 61)....
[...]
...ethnographers who have taken care to build procedures for "objectivity" into their work (see the critique of Willis by Hammersley & Atkinson, 1983; the critique of Everhart by Cusick, 1985a, 1985b; and the critique of Anyon by Ramsey, 1983). Critical ethnography is, after all, what Lather (1986a) called "openly ideological research....
[...]
181 citations
155 citations
85 citations
67 citations