Disciplined reasoning: Styles of reasoning and the mainstream-heterodoxy divide in Swedish economics
Citations
15 citations
13 citations
Cites background or result from "Disciplined reasoning: Styles of re..."
...Some studies only cover one field (Hamann 2019; Hylmö 2018), while others only distinguish between social and natural science and neglect to disentangle specific disciplinary differences (e.g., Herschberg et al....
[...]
...…on hiring processes have hitherto focused on a single country, and comparative studies are lacking; therefore, the question of whether fields apply similar or different evaluative criteria when evaluating candidates for academic positions has gone unanswered (e.g., Hylmö 2018; Levander et al....
[...]
...…special status in the social sciences; recruiters place considerable value on candidates’ publications in top journals, and there is a high level of internal consensus on mainstream or neoclassical economics, which is sustained by a highly international knowledge community (Hylmö 2018; Lee et al....
[...]
...Furthermore, such indicators seem to be primarily preferred in fields such as 1 3 economics, which is often characterized as exhibiting a rather deviant and extreme behavior compared with other disciplines (Hammarfelt and Rushforth 2017; Hylmö 2018)....
[...]
...These results aligned with prior studies on academic recruitment processes, which have shown that economists emphasize publications in top journals (Hylmö 2018)....
[...]
12 citations
Cites background from "Disciplined reasoning: Styles of re..."
...Accordingly, several studies have analyzed how judgment devices are used when making evaluative decisions in academic hiring processes (see e.g., Hammarfelt and Rushforth 2017; Hylmö 2018; Musselin 2010)....
[...]
11 citations
10 citations
References
34,393 citations
23,806 citations
6,401 citations
6,044 citations
5,884 citations