Effect of the trap crop Solanum sisymbriifolium and two biocontrol fungi on reproduction of the potato cyst nematode, Globodera pallida

TLDR: Results suggest that S. sisymbriifolium has potential to significantly reduce G. pallida populations, and also that the cropping system (i.e. the sequence of non-host and host plants) may play a significant role in the efficacy of fungal biological control agents.

Abstract: The potato cyst nematode, Globodera pallida, is one of the most important pests of potato worldwide. Owing to regulatory considerations and potential environmental impact, control options for this nematode are becoming increasingly limited. Solanum sisymbriifolium and biological control agents offer viable alternative options for controlling G. pallida. Therefore, experiments were conducted to determine the effect of the nematode trap crop S. sisymbriifolium, alone or in combination with the biocontrol agents Trichoderma harzianum or Plectosphaerella cucumerina, on population decline of G. pallida. Experiments were conducted for three different ‘cropping systems’: potato (Solanum tuberosum), S. sisymbriifolium, or soil only (fallow), each followed by a potato crop. Soil was amended with P. cucumerina, T. harzianum or left unamended, and then infested with nematodes at a rate of five eggs g−1 of soil. After 16 weeks in the greenhouse, plants were removed and the soil containing cysts was refrigerated at 4°C for 8 weeks, and then planted to potato. Cysts of G. pallida were counted after an additional 16-week period. The Pf/Pi of G. pallida was significantly reduced by 99% in potato following S. sisymbriifolium compared to both the potato-following-fallow and the potato-following-potato treatments. Amendment of soil with T. harzianum significantly reduced Pf/Pi of G. pallida by 42–47% in the potato-following-potato but not in either the potato-after-fallow nor in the potato-after-S. sisymbriifolium cycles which supports evidence that the plant species may play a role in the biocontrol activity of this fungus. Addition of the fungus P. cucumerina resulted in a 64% decrease in Pf/Pi in the potato-following-fallow in one experiment, and an 88% decrease in Pf/Pi in potato-following-potato but the decrease in Pf/Pi was not consistent over all experiments. However, both biocontrol fungi resulted in lower numbers of progeny cysts after an initial 16-week incubation with potato. To look at the effect of varied population density of the nematode on efficacy of S. sisymbriifolium to reduce G. pallida populations, potato, S. sisymbriifolium, or barley were planted into soil infested with G. pallida at rates of 5, 20 or 40 eggs g−1 soil applied as cysts (20, 80 or 160 cysts pot−1). After 16 weeks, numbers of cysts produced in each treatment were determined for each infestation rate. No new cysts were recovered from either S. sisymbriifolium or barley treatments, confirming that neither plant is a host for G. pallida. High numbers of cysts were recovered with potato. Soil from each treatment (containing original cysts and newly-formed cysts when present) were then planted with potato. After an additional 16 weeks, few cysts were found in the potato-after- S. sisymbriifolium treatments regardless of initial infestation rate. When potato followed barley, numbers of cysts were similar to those found after a single cycle of potato, indicating that the barley crop had no effect on the survival of initial inoculum. Overall, these results suggest that S. sisymbriifolium has potential to significantly reduce G. pallida populations, and also that the cropping system (i.e. the sequence of non-host and host plants) may play a significant role in the efficacy of fungal biological control agents.