scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question
Journal ArticleDOI

El discurso psicológico en el campo educativo: una revisión crítica de su configuración histórica y su devenir actual

02 Jul 2020-Foro de Educación (FahrenHouse Ediciones)-Vol. 18, Iss: 2, pp 149-170
TL;DR: In this paper, a historical analysis of educational psychology is presented, showing how this discipline, conditioned by the situation that allowed its origin in the late nineteenth century, participated strategically in the emergence of knowledge that legitimized school practice and established new government circuits for childhood.
Abstract: From the beginning, Educational Psychology had the objective of procuring tools to enhance the development of the educational practice. In this way, it offered knowledge to improve the students’ learning but also to discriminate those who presented difficulties of accommodation to the rhythms established by the school institution. From a historical analysis, this work will demonstrate how this discipline, conditioned by the situation that allowed its origin in the late nineteenth century, participated strategically in the emergence of a knowledge that legitimized school practice and established new government circuits for childhood. Following this, the perspectives that began to criticize the original paradigm of the discipline from the middle of the 20th century will be examined, exposing a certain naturalized pattern of psychological knowledge production in the school environment and thus promoting a contextual model that will take into account the broad characteristics of the teaching and learning process. Finally, it will be concluded that, in spite of the theoretical strength that these orientations have managed to distribute, the proliferation of psychological diagnosis in the school classrooms during the last decades, although protected under the argument of smoothing the borders between normal education and special education, would seem not only to eclipse and diminish the possibilities of the contextual model, but also to shake the traditional school structure and bear consequences of extreme importance for the current configuration of educational practice.

Content maybe subject to copyright    Report

Citations
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
14 Dec 1911-Nature
TL;DR: Welton as discussed by the authors has drawn a map of life from infancy to manhood, not as the adult lives it, but as it develops in form and complexity, with great ability and clearness.
Abstract: WHATEVER criticism Prof. Welton's book may excite, it is undeniably interesting-the most interesting book dealing with its particular problems that has been produced in recent years. With great ability and clearness, the author has drawn a map of life, not as the adult lives it, but as it develops in form and complexity from infancy to manhood. The teacher and the situations with which he deals are in his mind all through. His book is therefore not a treatise on psychology, yet the psychologist's point of view is so dominant that neither does it set forth a theory of education. This Prof. Welton makes clear in his preface. His concern is with the connections between the two-psychology and education-and especially to give a psychological explanation of educational procedure. The Psychology of Education. By Prof. J. Welton. Pp. xxi + 507. (London: Macmillan and Co., Ltd., 1911.) Price 7s. 6d. net.

154 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Hirsch et al. as mentioned in this paper make a review of this discussion and particularly the antagonistic form in which it has been developed, from a materialist perspective, identifying that, although they seem antagonist, they coincide on one central point: the belief that capitalist social relations are imposed externally to the subject, to a supposal free subjectivity.
Abstract: The question of whether school is a place for social transformation or not is a central issue to modern educational thought, particularly in the last decades of the twentieth century. «Theories of resistance» of the 80’s and 90’s aimed to show the transformative potential of schooling through the development of a critical pedagogy, in clear response to the so called «theories of reproduction», which in the 70›had denounced the role played by school in capitalism. This article aims to make a review of this discussion and, particularly, the antagonistic form in which it has been developed, from a materialist perspective. To that end, main classics of both group of theories will be analyzed identifying that, although they seem antagonist, they coincide on one central point: the belief that capitalist social relations are imposed externally to the subject, to a supposal free subjectivity. While «theories of reproduction» argue that such domination can only be faced through class struggle, which can only be given outside school, «theories of resistance» argue that struggle may be developedin the ideological sphere within schooling. The premise of this article is that such external imposition is an appearance product of the alienated character of our consciousness, and does not allow to analyze that social relations, far from being imposed to our free will, are developed by us to organize social work. To transcend these appearances, a process of recognition of the general determinations of education in capitalism will be developed, in order to enable us to overcome a binary logic between reproduction and transformation, and think social transformation as part of the process of social organization itself. How to reference this article Hirsch, D., Rio, V. (2015). Teorias de la reproduccion y teorias de la resistencia: una revision del debate pedagogico desde la perspectiva materialista. Foro de Educacion , 13(18), pp. 69-91. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.14516/fde.2015.013.018.004

3 citations

01 Jan 2017
TL;DR: In this paper, a trabajo analiza the modos en which se han conceptualizado las relaciones entre the procesos de desarrollo y de aprendizaje and su relevancia for el campo de la Psicologia Educacional, considera the implicancias educativas, epistemicas, eticas and politicas that el modo de abordar dicha relacion supone.
Abstract: El presente trabajo analiza los modos en que se han conceptualizado las relaciones entre los procesos de desarrollo y de aprendizaje y su relevancia para el campo de la Psicologia Educacional. Considera las implicancias educativas, epistemicas, eticas y politicas que el modo de abordar dicha relacion supone. La Psicologia Educacional se organizo historicamente hacia principios de siglo XX, como resultado del intento de utilizar el conocimiento psicologico para fundamentar practicas educativas, particularmente, las vinculadas a los aprendizajes escolares. Las teorias psicologicas sobre el aprendizaje, el desarrollo y la medicion de las diferencias individuales parecieron particularmente interesantes para fundamentar la toma de decisiones en educacion. Los problemas que esto trajo aparejado han sido analizados en terminos de aplicacionismo y de reduccionismo. Las teorias psicologicas de Jean Piaget y Lev Vygostky van a constituirse en marcos teoricos que tendran derivaciones educativas, las que deben comprenderse en el contexto de los problemas y los interrogantes que dan origen a ambas perspectivas. Una tematica particularmente relevante en la agenda de la Psicologia Educacional, lo constituye el tema de la direccionalidad y la universalidad de los cambios en el desarrollo: ?sigue el desarrollo humano un curso unico y universal o son posibles caminos multiples y diversos? Categorias teoricas propuestas por James Wertsch (1933) posibilitan un analisis critico de las jerarquias geneticas y la comprension de diferentes perspectivas sobre la heterogeneidad. Este tema adquiere sentido en el cruce de fronteras entre psicologia y educacion por la carga valorativa, normativa y prescriptiva que las teorias del desarrollo y del aprendizaje conservan en relacion con las practicas educativas posibles. Se entrama directamente con discusiones en torno a la educabilidad de los sujetos, el fracaso escolar, las politicas de inclusion y la delimitacion de unidades de analisis de la intervencion psicoeducativa.

1 citations

01 Dec 2012
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors analyze relevant topics regarding the reconstruction of identity that the educational psychologist is facing in the context of psychoanalysis and genetic psychology in Argentina, which is a discipline that shares some characteristics with other Latin American and European countries but it has traits of it own due to a particular historical background.
Abstract: Educational Psychology developed in Argentina in different stages. This discipline shares some characteristics with other Latin American and European countries but it has traits of it’s own due to a particular historical background. In Argentina the positivist approach not only influenced psychology but had also an effect on education. This was followed by phenomenological and gestaltic reactions and in the 1950’s the rise of Psychoanalysis imposed a clinical and psychodynamic approach of the learning situation. At the same time Genetic Psychology started to develop. But one of the most radical changes that took place in pedagogy was caused by the neo-Marxist criticism that accused the state of using education as a mean of oppression which legitimized social inequality. In the 1990’s technocratic education policies aimed at a wider population and looked for efficient results. This paperanalyses relevant topics regarding the reconstruction of identity that the educational psychologist is facing.

1 citations

References
More filters
Book
13 Jul 1996

408 citations


"El discurso psicológico en el campo..." refers background in this paper

  • ...Sin soslayar que este «uso [crítico] de la historia es, a menudo, tan problemático como las versiones prestigiosas a las cuales se opone» (Rose, 1996, p. 3), se presentará el surgimiento de la disciplina psicológica sin perder de vista las condiciones políticas, institucionales y discursivas que…...

    [...]

  • ...Las normas del programa experimental se habían fusionado […] con la propia disciplina psicológica y, en ese proceso, el objeto mismo de la psicología quedó disciplinado, se volvió «dócil»; internalizó los medios técnicos para conocerlo en la forma misma en que se lo podía pensar (Rose, 1996, p. 15)....

    [...]

  • ...…en la elaboración de una gran variedad de técnicas y prácticas para disciplinar, vigilar y formar a las poblaciones, este autor sostiene que es posible detallar «cómo ciertas normas y valores de naturaleza técnica llegaron a definir la topografía de la verdad psicológica» (Rose, 1996, p. 13)....

    [...]

  • ...Como lo afirma Rose (1996), las técnicas de la estadística comenzaron siendo una condensación de lo empírico y luego se reestructuraron de forma tal que se convirtieron en una materialización de lo teórico […] A partir de ese momento, los medios de justificación comienzan a dar forma a lo que puede…...

    [...]

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the authors suggest future directions for research in educational psychology as we enter our second hundred years of psychology in America and suggest that there are both continuities and discontinuities in our development from the early days of Hall, Thorndike, James, and Dewey to the current multiplicity of perspectives represented by educational psychology.
Abstract: The purpose of this article is to suggest future directions for research in educational psychology as we enter our second hundred years of psychology in America. The basic theme is that there are both continuities and discontinuities in our development from the early days of Hall, Thorndike, James, and Dewey to the current multiplicity of perspectives represented in educational psychology. Eight issues are presented that will guide future research directions. They include. (a) specifying basic constructs; (b) developing integrative models and linkages between constructs; (c) returning to the problems of acquisition, learning, and transfer; (d) applying models from the sciences and mathematics; (e) dealing with the discontinuity of contextual and cultural models; (0 including content and disciplinary perspectives; (g) adapting to diversity; and (h) developing multiple perspectives an the unit of analysis issue. The article concludes with a call for the allowance of multiple perspectives and multiple possib...

185 citations


"El discurso psicológico en el campo..." refers background in this paper

  • ...Más aún, y según Pintrich (1994), la persistente búsqueda de unidades del conocimiento instalará aquellos temas generales que encontrarán continuidad en el campo de la disciplina durante todo su desarrollo....

    [...]

  • ...La agenda de la psicología actual revierte viejas premisas e instaura el denominado giro contextualista o situacional (Baquero, 2002; Pintrich, 1994) que cuestiona la adopción de una perspectiva sustancialista de la subjetividad, basada en la ilusión de que es posible describir atributos inherentes…...

    [...]

Journal ArticleDOI
14 Dec 1911-Nature
TL;DR: Welton as discussed by the authors has drawn a map of life from infancy to manhood, not as the adult lives it, but as it develops in form and complexity, with great ability and clearness.
Abstract: WHATEVER criticism Prof. Welton's book may excite, it is undeniably interesting-the most interesting book dealing with its particular problems that has been produced in recent years. With great ability and clearness, the author has drawn a map of life, not as the adult lives it, but as it develops in form and complexity from infancy to manhood. The teacher and the situations with which he deals are in his mind all through. His book is therefore not a treatise on psychology, yet the psychologist's point of view is so dominant that neither does it set forth a theory of education. This Prof. Welton makes clear in his preface. His concern is with the connections between the two-psychology and education-and especially to give a psychological explanation of educational procedure. The Psychology of Education. By Prof. J. Welton. Pp. xxi + 507. (London: Macmillan and Co., Ltd., 1911.) Price 7s. 6d. net.

154 citations


"El discurso psicológico en el campo..." refers background in this paper

  • ...…la Psicología Educacional, a los fines de asumir esta postura diligentemente, debe renunciar a su papel de «Queen of the Educational Sciences» (Wall, 1979) alcanzado con el primer modelo y reconocer en la complejidad de los fenómenos educativos la exigencia de una aproximación…...

    [...]

  • ...Con este propósito, y en cuanto a la función que le corresponde como disciplina educativa, la Psicología Educacional, a los fines de asumir esta postura diligentemente, debe renunciar a su papel de «Queen of the Educational Sciences» (Wall, 1979) alcanzado con el primer modelo y reconocer en la complejidad de los fenómenos educativos la exigencia de una aproximación interdisciplinar....

    [...]

Journal Article
TL;DR: The problem of the transmision of conocimientos or saberes dentro de concepciones constructivistas and situacionales is discussed in this paper.

57 citations

01 Jan 1989

28 citations


"El discurso psicológico en el campo..." refers background in this paper

  • ...Como lo sentencia Coll (1989), «el psicólogo escolar es un profesional ocupado en la administración de test de inteligencia y de rendimiento escolar» (p. 322)....

    [...]

  • ...…orígenes, con la historia de la psicología científica en el largo proceso de diferenciación de ésta última respecto a la filosofía y la metafísica» (Coll, 1989, p. 7), sino también proyectar un marco interpretativo a partir del cual analizar el fundamento y el desarrollo singular de la…...

    [...]

  • ...Por su parte, Coll (1989) plantea que es posible hallar tres tipos de modelos que los psicólogos de la educación han ofrecido como respuesta a estos problemas: la extrapolación, la independencia y la interdependencia-interacción....

    [...]

  • ...De acuerdo con lo propuesto por Coll (1989), este proceso se expresó mediante la conformación de los primeros departamentos universitarios dedicados a la materia e inscriptos con nombres propios y específicos como así también por el manifiesto interés en realizar investigaciones y publicaciones…...

    [...]

  • ...Coll (1989) relata que mediante una metodología de análisis de contenido de los manuales y de los programas de los cursos impartidos en algunos prestigiosos centros de formación universitaria, Feldhusen (1978) ha llevado a cabo un intento de perfilar la evolución de los contenidos abarcados por…...

    [...]