Engaging divided society in the nation-building process : the case of government communication in Malaysia
16 Jul 2020-
TL;DR: Thematic analysis on all eleven national action plan (NAP) documents known as Malaysia Plan (1965-2016) was conducted to enable the pattern of similarities and differences in nation-building and government communication strategies to be identified over time as discussed by the authors.
Abstract: This thesis explores how government engages with a divided society in the context of nation-building. The widely used yet loosely understood concept of ‘engagement’ in the context of government communication is the focus of this thesis. By using Malaysia as the case study, this research investigates how citizens are communicatively constructed in the context of Malaysia’s post-independence nation-building process. This study is significant because research on citizen engagement in Malaysia’s nation-building is limited and studies focusing on the concept of engagement in deeply divided societies are also scarce.Thematic analysis on all eleven national action plan (NAP) documents known as Malaysia Plan (1965-2016) was conducted to enable the pattern of similarities and differences in nation-building and government communication strategies to be identified over time. Semi-structured elite interviews with the elite actors in Malaysia’s federal government were conducted to understand the government’s articulation and operationalisation of engagement in the context of nation-building process.The key findings from the NAPs reveal that the nation-building in Malaysia takes in a form of national identity project. Adopting an elite instrumentalist approach, national unity becomes the focal communicative strategy in the construction of the national identity. The elite interviews on the other hand demonstrate that government actors tend to describe engagement using the notion of dialogic communication. While acknowledging the advancement in communication technologies, government actors emphasise that the face-to-face engagement initiatives with the citizens are of central importance in the nation-building process.This thesis contributes to the studies of government strategic communication in the context of a deeply divided society that has been characterised as "plural society" that is in a state of “stable tension” (Shamsul, 2009). It helps to develop a richer understanding and knowledge of Malaysia’s nation-building process and approach as a modern postcolonial nation.
References
More filters
01 Jan 2009
TL;DR: A comparison of the Anglo-American methodological debate in the social sciences with its counterpart in the German-speaking world reveals that scientists in the latter have now regarded expert interviews as a distinct interview form for some years as mentioned in this paper.
Abstract: A comparison of the Anglo-American methodological debate in the social sciences with its counterpart in the German-speaking world reveals that scientists in the latter have now regarded expert interviews as a distinct interview form for some years (Flick and others, 2003, Bogner and others, 2005, Glaser and Laudel, 2004, Mieg and Naf, 2006). With few exceptions, for example (Brandl and Klinger, 2006), the notion of the elite interview is rarely, if ever, encountered in German-speaking countries. Yet the reverse is the case in the Anglo-American and (given the dominance of English as the language of scientific publication) international social sciences debate see, for example (Gubrium and Holstein, 2002 or Denzin and Lincoln, 2000), where the concept of the expert interview appears largely unknown. However, closer study reveals that in many respects the content of publications on these two interview forms does not really differ fundamentally. In fact, quite the opposite applies: central themes in both methodological traditions include the problems of gaining access to the elite or to experts (particularly at a high level) as well as the specifics of interaction and the actual interview process itself. Although not identical, even the respective target group definitions (experts and the elite) for such interviews overlap. The focus of interest in both generally lies on the professional (functional) elite and on professional experts. Indeed, it would seem that the differences between interviews with the elite and interviews with experts lie primarily in differing social and political sciences research traditions and interests.
109 citations
TL;DR: This article argued that the resurgence of minority nationalism is also a response to the needs for collective action in a world of weakened nation-states. But this project is difficult to translate into constitutional terms or to reconcile with the model of the state prevailing in the respective majority communities.
Abstract: . The reconfiguration of political space is bringing about new forms of territorial politics. The meanings of nationalism and the state are being transformed and new types of autonomist movement are emerging. These are often seen as a resurgence of ethnicity, or as attempts to recreate mini nation-states fragmented from the existing ones. Mainstream political science tends to regard them negatively. It is argued that the resurgence of minority nationalism is also a response to the needs for collective action in a world of weakened nation-states. New forms of collective identity and action are emerging which recognise the limitations of traditional sovereignty and the necessary interdependence of the contemporary world. There is much that is new here, but also much that has always been present but has been lost in the state-centred perspective of political science. The argument is illustrated by an examination of three of the most electorally successful nationalist movements in the Western world, in Quebec, Catalonia and Scotland. These are seen not as classic nationalist movements but as nation-building projects which recognise the limitations of the nation-state formula and are engaged in ‘stateless nation-building’. This project is difficult to translate into constitutional terms or to reconcile with the model of the state prevailing in the respective majority communities.
108 citations
TL;DR: In this paper, the normative principles for managing ethnocultural diversity in a liberal democracy are discussed, and whether they have any applicability to ethnic conflict in Eastern and Central Europe.
Abstract: Until quite recently, the area of ethnocultural relations has been surprisingly neglected by Western political theorists. For most of this century, ethnicity was viewed by political theorists as a marginal phenomenon that would gradually disappear with modernisation, and hence was not an important topic for forward-looking political theorists. As a result, even into the mid-1980s, there were very few political philosophers working in the area. The question of the rights of ethnocultural groups, however, has moved to the forefront of Western political theory in the last few years. The aim in this article is to describe this emerging literature on the normative principles for managing ethnocultural diversity in a liberal democracy, and to consider whether it has any applicability to ethnic conflict in Eastern and Central Europe. The goal is not to propose the unrealistic transplanting of institutions and policies from the West to the East, but rather to outline some of the interesting recent work done by We...
107 citations
TL;DR: In this article, the authors examine the effectiveness and the value of digital government as a strategic tool for public management reform and discuss the digital divide and its impact on the success of digital governments.
Abstract: Today, access to information and communication technologies (ICTs) plays an essential role in economic and social development. Accelerated change in the introduction of ICT-enabled solutions can potentially transform all aspects of society, work, business and government. E-technologies and ICT-enabled solutions bring about new forms of governance in the public sector. It is evident that the Internet and Web-based technologies have both had a profound effect on the ways in which the public sector functions. This article examines the effectiveness and the value of digital government as a strategic tool for public management reform. It addresses differing views and perceptions of the implications of digital government; elaborates on the ‘digital divide’ and its impact on the success of digital government; and outlines the results of a preliminary study of the effectiveness of a digital local government initiative.
106 citations
TL;DR: The Rohingya people are one of the most ill-treated and persecuted refugee groups in the world, having lived in a realm of statelessness for over six generations, and who are still doing so.
Abstract: The Rohingya people are one of the most ill-treated and persecuted refugee groups in the world, having lived in a realm of statelessness for over six generations, and who are still doing so. In recent years, more than 500,000 Rohingyas fled from Myanmar (Burma) to neighboring countries. This article addresses the Rohingya refugee crisis in Bangladesh, with special emphasis on the living conditions of this vulnerable population. We reviewed several documents on Rohingya refugees, visited a registered refugee camp (Teknaf), collected case reports, and conducted a series of meetings with stakeholders in the Cox's Bazar district of Bangladesh. A total of 33,131 registered Rohingya refugees are living in two registered camps in Cox's Bazar, and up to 80,000 additional refugees are housed in nearby makeshift camps. Overall, the living conditions of Rohingya refugees inside the overcrowded camps remain dismal. Mental health is poor, proper hygiene conditions are lacking, malnutrition is endemic, and physical/sexual abuse is high. A concerted diplomatic effort involving Bangladesh and Myanmar, and international mediators such as the Organization of Islamic Countries and the United Nations, is urgently required to effectively address this complex situation.
101 citations