Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archaeology: Problems with Difference and Collaboration
Citations
155 citations
14 citations
13 citations
Cites background from "Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archae..."
...…Accepted 3 Feb 2021; Revised 31 Dec 2020 Yet, as one of the reviewers of this article pointed out, the term ‘subaltern’ has become in a certain way an abstract academic cul-de-sac, a rather elusive and rarely theorized concept in archaeological literature (see also González-Ruibal 2019b, 104–6)....
[...]
...…groups, disregarding the heterogeneity encompassed by the term (cf. Cañete Jiménez & Vives-Ferrándiz Sánchez 2011; Cuozzo & Pellegrino 2016; Dietler 2010; Ferris et al. 2014; Gnecco & Ayala 2011; Kistler & Mohr 2016; but see González-Ruibal 2019a; Liebmann & Murphy 2010; Spencer-Wood 2010)....
[...]
References
[...]
18,201 citations
"Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archae..." refers background in this paper
...Discussion: towards an ethics of difference Homi Bhabha [41], referring to the problem with the disturbing colonial copy, the hybrid, uses the famous phrase “almost the same but not quite”....
[...]
...Homi Bhabha [41], referring to the problem with the disturbing colonial copy, the hybrid, uses the famous phrase “almost the same but not quite”....
[...]
...If in the case described by Bhabha the irruption of difference within the copy is the subversive, uncanny element, in the case of postcolonial and indigenous archaeologies what we find all too often is a tamed difference with a limited capacity for true subversion....
[...]
3,940 citations
"Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archae..." refers background in this paper
...This is the difference that is incorporated by Dipesh Chakrabarty [34], for example, in his studies of Indian modernity, in which spirits play a role alongside bourgeois institutions or industrial economy....
[...]
1,156 citations
"Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archae..." refers background in this paper
...We do not live in the age of empire, but this does not mean that we are not living under a regime of coloniality [48]....
[...]
714 citations
"Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archae..." refers background in this paper
...This is the difference that is incorporated by Dipesh Chakrabarty [34], for example, in his studies of Indian modernity, in which spirits play a role alongside bourgeois institutions or industrial economy....
[...]
...For this we have to look among the Adivasis, the indigenous minorities of India [35], not among the urban dwellers that are the object of Chakrabarty’s research....
[...]
...The Other (Indian, Native American, Asiatic or African) was imagined in negative terms and excluded from the realm of true humanity, represented by European civilization – indeed, the only civilization worth the name [43]....
[...]
...The Benga, who eagerly participated with the Europeans in the slave trade, are a good case in point, but one can think also of the French and Indian War (1754-1763)....
[...]
...Consider a recent case in California: The Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria did not have any trouble allowing a sacred ancestral site on their territory that was several thousand years old to be completely destroyed in order to build luxury houses that were selling at one million dollars each....
[...]
586 citations
"Ethical Issues in Indigenous Archae..." refers background in this paper
...Thus, although it is true that non-Western communities have had a more sustainable relation with nature than capitalism, which knows no limits to the devastation of societies and ecosystems for profit [21], we cannot depict non-capitalist attitudes towards nature as always inherently harmonious: it is important to identify different attitudes among a diversity of groups....
[...]