Impact of the tumor microenvironment on prognosis in follicular lymphoma is dependent on specific treatment protocols
TL;DR: It is suggestive that a dense infiltrate of FoxP3-positive T cells, dense and interfollicular infiltrate of CD68-positive macrophages and complete follicular dendritic meshworks were associated with a favorable time to progression in CVP-treated patients, while being poor prognostic sign in fludarabine- treated patients.
Abstract: Background The clinical behavior of follicular lymphoma is largely determined by properties of the non-malignant tumor microenvironment. The precise nature of the cell populations is still unclear and published data on their prognostic significance are highly conflicting. This may be partly due to heterogeneous composition and tr eatments. Design and Methods Pre-treatment biopsy samples of patients with follicular lymphoma treated in an EORTC/BNLI trial comparing fludarabine to cyclophosphamide, vincristine and prednisone (CVP) chemotherapy could be retrieved for 61 patients in five Eur opean countries. Immunohistochemical investigations were performed to evaluate tumor cell characteristics, T-cell subsets, follicular dendritic cells and macrophages and associations with clinical outcome were studied. Results Some markers showed a homogeneous prognostic impact, while others had a different and sometimes opposite effect in the treatment arms. CD69 expression on tumor cells was a poor prognostic sign and an interfollicular infiltrate of FoxP3-positive T cells was a good prognostic sign irrespective of the treatment arm. It is suggestive that a dense infiltrate of FoxP3-positive T cells, a dense and interfollicular infiltrate of CD68-positive macr ophages and complete follicular dendritic meshworks were associated with a favorable time to progression in CVP-treated patients, while being a poor prognostic sign in fludarabine-treated patients. Conclusions Our results suggest that characteristic properties of the microenvironment in follicular lymphoma determines the responses to essentially different chemotherapeutic approaches. These data may provide an explanation for the highly conflicting r esults on immunohistochemical markers and the prognostic role of the microenvironment in follicular lymphoma reported thus far and lay the basis for the development of predictive assays to tailor treatment in patients with follicular lymphoma.
Citations
More filters
TL;DR: Younger, poor-prognosis DLBCL patients display different biological risk factors compared with an elderly population, with BCL2 translocations emerging as a powerful negative prognostic marker.
Abstract: Prognostically relevant risk factors in patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) have predominantly been evaluated in elderly populations. We tested whether previously described risk factors are also valid in younger, poor-prognosis DLBCL patients. Paraffin-embedded samples from 112 patients with de novo DLBCL, enrolled in the R-MegaCHOEP trial of the German High Grade Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma Study Group (DSHNHL) were investigated using immunohistochemistry (MYC, FOXP1, LMO2, GCET1, CD5, CD10, BCL2, BCL6, IRF4/MUM1) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (MYC, BCL2, BCL6). MYC, BCL2 and BCL6 breaks occurred in 14, 21 and 31%, respectively. In the majority of cases, MYC was simultaneously rearranged with BCL2 and/or BCL6. The adverse impact of MYC rearrangements was confirmed, but the sole presence of BCL2 breaks emerged as a novel prognostic marker associated with inferior overall survival (OS) (P=0.002). Combined overexpression of MYC and BCL2 showed only limited association with inferior OS. All immunohistochemical cell of origin classifiers applied failed to predict survival time. DLBCL tumors with significant proportion of immunoblastic and/or immunoblastic-plasmacytoid cells had inferior OS, independently from from BCL2 break. Younger, poor-prognosis DLBCL patients, therefore, display different biological risk factors compared with an elderly population, with BCL2 translocations emerging as a powerful negative prognostic marker.
62 citations
TL;DR: Classes of CD4+ T-cell populations including follicular helper T cells and regulatory T cells are now identified as major players to regulate the delicate balance of effector populations into a supportive microenvironment.
61 citations
TL;DR: Inhibition of TIGIT signaling may be an additional mechanism to prevent T-cell suppression and exhaustion in B-cell lymphoma.
Abstract: Purpose: T-cell immunoglobulin and ITIM domain (TIGIT), a member of the immune checkpoint family, is important in normal T-cell biology. However, the phenotypical profile and clinical relevance of TIGIT in follicular lymphoma is largely unknown. Experimental Design: Biopsy specimens from a cohort of 82 patients with follicular lymphoma were analyzed using mass cytometry to explore the phenotype and biological and clinical significance of TIGIT+ T cells. Results: TIGIT is highly expressed on intratumoral T cells and its expression alters T-cell phenotype in follicular lymphoma. TIGIT is abundantly expressed on Treg cells, resulting in an enhanced suppressive property. TIGIT expression on non-Treg/TFH T cells defines a population that exhibits an exhausted phenotype. Clinically, increased numbers of TIGIT+ T cells are associated with inferior patient outcomes and poor survival. We observe that anti–PD-1 therapy with pembrolizumab alters the phenotype of TIGIT+ T subsets and identifies a role for CD28 expression on TIGIT+ T cells in treatment response. Conclusions: The current study provides a comprehensive analysis of the phenotypic profile of intratumoral TIGIT+ T subsets and their prognostic relevance in follicular lymphoma. Inhibition of TIGIT signaling may be an additional mechanism to prevent T-cell suppression and exhaustion in B-cell lymphoma.
58 citations
TL;DR: Better developed CD21+ follicular dendritic cell (FDC) meshworks at diagnosis was a negative prognostic factor for overall survival, progression‐free survival (PFS) and time to transformation (TTT) in patients with subsequently transformed FL.
Abstract: The tumour microenvironment influences outcome in patients with follicular lymphoma (FL), but its impact on transformation is less studied. We investigated the prognostic significance of the tumour microenvironment on transformation and survival in FL patients treated in the rituximab era. We examined diagnostic and transformed biopsies from 52 FL patients using antibodies against CD3, CD4, CD8, CD21 (CR2), CD57 (B3GAT1), CD68, FOXP3, TIA1, PD-1 (PDCD1), PD-L1 (CD274) and PAX5. Results were compared with a second cohort of 40 FL patients without signs of transformation during a minimum of five years observation time. Cell numbers and localization were semi-quantitatively assessed. Better developed CD21+ follicular dendritic cell (FDC) meshworks at diagnosis was a negative prognostic factor for overall survival (OS), progression-free survival (PFS) and time to transformation (TTT) in patients with subsequently transformed FL. Remnants of FDC meshworks at transformation were associated with shorter OS and PFS from transformation. High degrees of intrafollicular CD68+ and PD-L1+ macrophage infiltration, high total area scores and an extrafollicular/diffuse pattern of FOXP3+ T cells and high intrafollicular scores of CD4+ T cells at diagnosis were associated with shorter TTT. Scores of several T-cell subset markers from the combined patient cohorts were predictive for transformation, especially CD4 and CD57.
56 citations
Cites background from "Impact of the tumor microenvironmen..."
...One study has suggested that different chemotherapy regimens may alter the prognostic impact of some markers in the tumour microenvironment (de Jong et al, 2009) and, as previously discussed, rituximab may modulate the impact of macrophages in FL (Taskinen et al, 2007; Canioni et al, 2008;…...
[...]
Netherlands Cancer Institute1, University of Würzburg2, Harvard University3, Queen Mary University of London4, University of Barcelona5, Paris 12 Val de Marne University6, Paris Descartes University7, Bosch8, Radboud University Nijmegen9, Claude Bernard University Lyon 110, University of British Columbia11, Karolinska Institutet12
TL;DR: In this paper, the reproducibility of manual scoring and automated microscopy based on a tissue microarray of 25 follicular lymphomas as compared to flow cytometry is evaluated.
Abstract: The cellular microenvironment in follicular lymphoma is of biological and clinical importance. Studies on the clinical significance of non-malignant cell populations have generated conflicting results, which may partly be influenced by poor reproducibility in immunohistochemical marker quantification. In this study, the reproducibility of manual scoring and automated microscopy based on a tissue microarray of 25 follicular lymphomas as compared to flow cytometry is evaluated. The agreement between manual scoring and flow cytometry was moderate for CD3, low for CD4, and moderate to high for CD8, with some laboratories scoring closer to the flow cytometry results. Agreement in manual quantification across the 7 laboratories was low to moderate for CD3, CD4, CD8 and FOXP3 frequencies, moderate for CD21, low for MIB1 and CD68, and high for CD10. Manual scoring of the architectural distribution resulted in moderate agreement for CD3, CD4 and CD8, and low agreement for FOXP3 and CD68. Comparing manual scoring to automated microscopy demonstrated that manual scoring increased the variability in the low and high frequency interval with some laboratories showing a better agreement with automated scores. Manual scoring reliably identified rare architectural patterns of T-cell infiltrates. Automated microscopy analyses for T-cell markers by two different instruments were highly reproducible and provided acceptable agreement with flow cytometry. These validation results provide explanations for the heterogeneous findings on the prognostic value of the microenvironment in follicular lymphoma. We recommend a more objective measurement, such as computer-assisted scoring, in future studies of the prognostic impact of microenvironment in follicular lymphoma patients.
53 citations
Additional excerpts
...manual Median percent of cores across labs (range) Image=manual 38 (32-43) 61 (43-73) 65 (17-78)*** Among missclassified: Image<manual 23 (8-67) 67 (10-100) 0 (0-80) Image>manual 77 (33-92) 33 (0-80) 100 (20-100)...
[...]
...Manual score distribution Median percent of cores in each category across labs (range) 0-5% 0 (0-13)* 0 (0-21)* 17 (0-63) 6-25% 25 (13-38) 33 (25-63) 75 (29-88) 26-50% 46 (17-63) 46 (38-63) 0 (0-33)** >50% 17 (13-67) 13 (8-21) 4 (4-4)...
[...]
...manual Median percent of cores across labs (range) Flow=manual 50 (30-68) 38 (30-58) 71 (39-87) Among misclassified: Flow<manual 70 (38-100) 87 (50-90) 100 (10-100) Flow>manual 30 (0-54) 13 (10-50) 0 (0-90)...
[...]
References
More filters
TL;DR: The Follicular Lymphoma International Prognostic Index was designed from the data recorded over 8 years of nearly 5000 patients registered worldwide to help provide an optimal treatment option for patients with follicular lymphoma.
1,459 citations
National Institutes of Health1, University of Würzburg2, University of British Columbia3, University of Nebraska Medical Center4, University of Rochester5, Oregon Health & Science University6, University of Arizona7, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center8, University of Oslo9, St Bartholomew's Hospital10, University of Barcelona11
TL;DR: The length of survival among patients with follicular lymphoma correlates with the molecular features of nonmalignant immune cells present in the tumor at diagnosis.
Abstract: background Patients with follicular lymphoma may survive for periods of less than 1 year to more than 20 years after diagnosis. We used gene-expression profiles of tumor-biopsy specimens obtained at diagnosis to develop a molecular predictor of the length of survival. methods Gene-expression profiling was performed on 191 biopsy specimens obtained from patients with untreated follicular lymphoma. Supervised methods were used to discover expression patterns associated with the length of survival in a training set of 95 specimens. A molecular predictor of survival was constructed from these genes and validated in an independent test set of 96 specimens. results Individual genes that predicted the length of survival were grouped into gene-expression signatures on the basis of their expression in the training set, and two such signatures were used to construct a survival predictor. The two signatures allowed patients with specimens in the test set to be divided into four quartiles with widely disparate median lengths of survival (13.6, 11.1, 10.8, and 3.9 years), independently of clinical prognostic variables. Flow cytometry showed that these signatures reflected gene expression by nonmalignant tumor-infiltrating immune cells. conclusions The length of survival among patients with follicular lymphoma correlates with the molecular features of nonmalignant immune cells present in the tumor at diagnosis.
1,336 citations
"Impact of the tumor microenvironmen..." refers background in this paper
...From a biological point of view, the clinical behavior of FL is determined principally by the tumor microenvironment rather than by inherent properties of the tumor cells themselves.(5-7) Specific T-cell and accessory cell populations, including macrophages and follicular dendritic cells, have been reported to have an influence on overall and/or progression-free survival, either as a poor or a good prognostic parameter....
[...]
...haematologica | 2009; 94(1) | 75 | tance of the microenvironment in the clinical behavior of FL.(5-7) The precise nature of the relevant cell populations is still unclear, and published data on the prognostic significance of cell populations, including T-cell subsets, macrophages and follicular dendritic cells, are conflicting....
[...]
Journal Article•
TL;DR: The population of CD4+CD25+ immunoregulatory cells is characterized and it is demonstrated that they can suppress not only the induction of disease post-thymectomy, but can also efficiently suppress disease induced by cloned autoantigen-specific effector cells.
Abstract: Thymectomy of susceptible strains of mice on day 3 of life results in a spectrum of organ-specific autoimmunity that can be prevented by reconstitution of the thymectomized animals early in life with normal adult lymphocytes. The effectors and suppressors of autoimmunity in this model have been convincingly shown to be CD4+ T cells. It has been demonstrated recently that the regulatory CD4+ T cells that prevent disease coexpress CD25. We have further characterized the population of CD4+CD25+ immunoregulatory cells and demonstrated that they can suppress not only the induction of disease post-thymectomy, but can also efficiently suppress disease induced by cloned autoantigen-specific effector cells. Furthermore, the CD4+CD25+ T cells appear to be members of a unique lineage of regulatory T cells, as the induction of CD25 expression on a monospecific population of T cells derived from TCR transgenic SCID mice did not result in suppression of post-thymectomy autoimmunity. In addition, the TCR transgenic SCID mice were highly susceptible to autoimmune disease induced by the cloned line of autoantigen-specific effectors, while normal mice were relatively resistant. The capacity of the cloned line to transfer disease to nu/nu recipients could be inhibited by normal spleen cell populations containing CD4+CD25+ cells and by purified CD4+CD25+ cells. Although the target Ag(s) and mechanism of action of the CD4+CD25+ T cells remain to be determined, it is likely that they also play an important role in modulating other autoimmune diseases that are mediated by activation of "ignorant" self-reactive T cells present in the normal peripheral lymphocyte pool.
927 citations
"Impact of the tumor microenvironmen..." refers background in this paper
...It has been shown that fludarabine has a rather specific effect on FoxP3-positive regulatory T cells in patients with B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia, in that both the frequency and the inhibitory functions of these cells are reduced after treatment.(23-25) Very likely, interference with the tumor microenvironment may result in different responses depending on the specific role of the microenvironment in a specific class of FL....
[...]
TL;DR: This is the first report demonstrating that CY, in addition to decreasing cell number, inhibits the suppressive capability of T(REGs), and the relevance of the loss of suppressor functionality and the changes in gene expression are discussed.
889 citations
"Impact of the tumor microenvironmen..." refers background in this paper
...Similar effects of cyclophosphamide have been shown on regulatory T cells too.(26)...
[...]
TL;DR: The Follicular Lymphoma International Prognostic Index was designed from the data recorded over 8 years of nearly 5000 patients registered worldwide to help provide an optimal treatment option for patients with follicular lymphoma.
Abstract: Although numerous treatment approaches are proposed for patients with follicular lymphoma, criteria to help in choosing a treatment for a given patient and for comparing trial results are lacking. Several retrospective studies have analyzed prognostic factors, but their conclusions rely on limited numbers of patients treated during long periods, and their results are discordant. The Follicular Lymphoma International Prognostic Index was designed from the data recorded over 8 years of nearly 5000 patients registered worldwide. Five factors are used (age, Ann Arbor stage, number of nodal sites, serum lactate dehydrogenase level, and hemoglobin level) to build a three-category index. This index, together with new biologic markers such as gene profiling and proteomics, could help provide an optimal treatment option for patients with follicular lymphoma.
863 citations