Multilevel analysis of ambidexterity and tagging of specialised projects in project-based information technology firms
22 Aug 2017-International Journal of Operations & Production Management (Emerald Publishing Limited)-Vol. 37, Iss: 9, pp 1185-1206
TL;DR: The study extends the concept of ambidexterity to the “within” project level and finds it relevant at the lowest level in the project-based structure.
Abstract: Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to understand the expression of ambidexterity at the “between” projects level as well as the “within” project level in project-based information technology firms (PBITF). The research also provides a framework for the classification of specialised projects. This classification is essential to clarify the level of attention the project will receive with respect to the appropriation of resources and the requisite management bandwidth.
Design/methodology/approach
This paper draws on a nine-month long field-based qualitative study and ensures a rigorous triangulation of the findings through an analysis of archival data and actual project artefacts.
Findings
The authors bring forth three critical implications for practice. First, strategizing ambidexterity at the level of “between” projects and “within” projects is heavily dependent on the interaction among distributed actors and partners. Second, routines and actions to deal with manpower constraints are completely different at these two levels. Lastly, the classification framework of specialised projects proposed here should enable firms to appropriately apportion resources to engagements that are strategic in nature.
Originality/value
The study extends the concept of ambidexterity to the “within” project level and finds it relevant at the lowest level in the project-based structure. Also, the framework for the classification of specialised projects that is provided will assist decision makers in PBIT firms to decide the organisational response to such projects.
Citations
More filters
TL;DR: In this article, the authors assess the ability of project portfolio management practices to support the pursuit of ambidexterity at the project level through engagement with specific dimensions and mechanisms.
Abstract: The aim of this study is to assess the ability of project portfolio management practices to support the pursuit of ambidexterity at the project level through engagement with specific dimensions and mechanisms. The focus is on examining the operating/business model and challenges that are imposed on the firms, but deemed resolvable through the simultaneous pursuit of multiple projects emphasizing contradictory strategic goals. Data are obtained from multiple exploratory interviews of senior executives involved in project-level activities who were drawn from 12 case organizations in the Middle East. The study finds evidence of four forms of ambidexterity dimensions and mechanisms. Analysis undertaken against operating/business model and challenges of these dimensions and mechanisms of ambidexterity suggests that they are not only inter-related, but do so at various organizational levels.
19 citations
Cites background or result from "Multilevel analysis of ambidexterit..."
...This point is reiterated in his later works (see Turner et al. 2013a; Turner et al. 2016a) and the works of Liu et al. (2012) and Sohani and Singh (2017) who assert that while there is substantial research is available on organisation-level ambidexterity, insight on project-level ambidexterity is…...
[...]
...From our understanding of the literature, PPM is critical to successfully achieving ambidexterity....
[...]
...2013a, 2013b, 2014, 2015, 2016a,b; 2018) and the wider operations management discipline (Kortmann et al. 2014; Sohani and Singh 2017)....
[...]
...Sohani and Singh (2017) examined the processes and routines utilised to operationalise ambidexterity finding amongst others that the nature of the interaction among various individual actors across different functional units (including at the level of the portfolio) of the organisation played a…...
[...]
...…of scholars in the field of project management (Aubry and Lièvre 2010; Leybourne and Sainter 2012; Eriksson 2013; Turner and Lee-Kelley 2013; Turner et al. 2013a, 2013b, 2014, 2015, 2016a,b; 2018) and the wider operations management discipline (Kortmann et al. 2014; Sohani and Singh 2017)....
[...]
TL;DR: In this article, the impact of exploitative and explorative QM practices on performance is investigated in a sample of German pharmaceutical firms and the results show that the impact is dependent on the competitive strategy pursued.
Abstract: This study aims to advance understanding about quality management (QM) practices by clarifying how competitive strategy conditions the impacts of exploitative and explorative QM practices on performance.,The authors apply partial least squares structural equation modeling to data from a sample of German pharmaceutical firms.,The results show that the impact of exploitative and explorative QM practices on firm performance is contingent on the competitive strategy pursued. Explorative QM practices are significantly more relevant for firms following a differentiation strategy, whereas exploitative QM practices are significantly more relevant for cost leaders. Furthermore, for strategically ambidextrous firms that follow simultaneously a cost and a differentiation focus, the interplay of the two QM practices matters.,This paper contributes to understanding which kind of management practices, exploitative and/or explorative, have greater performance impacts under certain competitive strategy conditions.
9 citations
TL;DR: In this paper, the antecedents that facilitate three prevalent types of ambidexterity in project-based organizations in China are identified through an exploratory multiple-case study.
Abstract: Through an exploratory multiple-case study in the context of project-based organizations in China, this study aims to identify the antecedents that facilitate three prevalent types of ambidexterity...
8 citations
Cites background from "Multilevel analysis of ambidexterit..."
...Sohani and Singh (2017) examine ambidexterity in the “within” project level and the “between” projects level; Lee- Kelley (2018) applies the ambidexterity theory in the development of project management staff....
[...]
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors investigate the labour supply chain of Indian technical immigrants in the United States and reveal a latent phenomenon of broker-induced precarity that results from the labor supply chain and explore how aspirational jobs are becoming precarious ones.
Abstract: The primary purpose of this article is to investigate the labour supply chain of Indian technical immigrants in the United States. The two important findings that emerge are as follows: First, the study unearths a latent phenomenon of broker‐induced precarity that results from the labour supply chain and explores how aspirational jobs are becoming precarious ones. Second, the study provides a foundation for devising policies and interventions to make the process of the labour supply chain less detrimental to the Indian technical immigrants. This article draws on a seven‐month‐long field‐based qualitative study and ensures a meticulous triangulation of the findings through an analysis of archival data and actual artefacts related to manpower movement across the labour supply chain.
7 citations
Cites background from "Multilevel analysis of ambidexterit..."
...Instead of starting with the existing constructs and their interlinkages, we began with an area of investigation and allowed constructs and their interrelationships to emerge there from (Sohani and Singh, 2017; Strauss and Juliet, 1990)....
[...]
TL;DR: Results show that technology has a dual nature where it enhances as well as diminish the engagement of drivers, and the identity of a professional and the flexibility offered by this app-based work fosters engagement for drivers aswell as customers.
Abstract: With the advent of mobile application-based aggregator models, engaging stakeholders has become more challenging as the lines separating external and internal customer are blurred. This study deciphers the points of engagement and points of disengagement for the major stakeholders viz. drivers and commuters for the cab aggregators in India. Through semi-structured interviews of cab drivers and triangulation through media reports, interviews of customers, bank officers and regional transport officers, the authors elicit what enhances customer and driver engagement and what reduces it. Results show that technology has a dual nature where it enhances as well as diminish the engagement of drivers. The identity of a professional and the flexibility offered by this app-based work fosters engagement for drivers as well as customers. Changes in organizational and government norms are a source of disengagement. The theoretical and practical implications are also discussed.
4 citations
References
More filters
TL;DR: In this article, the authors report a research study which tests the relationship between PM performance and project success, drawing from empirical data on PM professionals working in UAE project-based organizations.
523 citations
TL;DR: A systematic review of relevant literature is presented and an integrated framework for assessing the complexities of managing projects is synthesised, which comprises five dimensions of complexity – structural, uncertainty, dynamics, pace and socio‐political complexity.
Abstract: Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to contribute to operations management (OM) practice contingency research by describing the complexity of projects. Complexity is recognised as a key independent (contingent) variable that impacts on many subsequent decisions in the practice of managing projects.Design/methodology/approach – This paper presents a systematic review of relevant literature and synthesises an integrated framework for assessing the complexities of managing projects.Findings – This framework comprises five dimensions of complexity – structural, uncertainty, dynamics, pace and socio‐political complexity. These five dimensions present individuals and organisations with choices about how they respond to each type of complexity, in terms of business case, strategic choice, process choice, managerial capacity and competencies.Originality/value – The contribution of this paper is to provide a clarification to the epistemology of complexity, to demonstrate complexity as a lived experience for pro...
452 citations
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors use a systematic review to develop a research framework which integrates intellectual capital resources (organizational, social and human capital) across various levels of analysis (organization, group and individual).
Abstract: Ambidexterity is of central importance to the competitive advantage of the firm, yet to date there is limited understanding of how it is managed. The theorization of ambidexterity is inadequate for complex, practical realities and, in turn, this hinders the way in which it can aid the management of ambidexterity in practice. This paper asks: What are the mechanisms for achieving ambidexterity? The authors use a systematic review to develop a research framework which integrates intellectual capital resources (organizational, social and human capital) across various levels of analysis (organization, group and individual). This review extends understanding of the generic mechanisms (i.e. temporal, structural and contextual ambidexterity) that dominate the literature. This allows for a more fine-grained understanding of how ambidexterity is achieved and enables avenues for further research to be identified.
403 citations
TL;DR: In this article, a critical review of standard program management approaches is presented, pointing out that there is an excessive control focus, insufficient flexibility in the context of an evolving business strategy, and ineffective co-operation between projects within the programme.
354 citations
TL;DR: The top 12 people-related and project-related IT project risks, based on “early warning sign” data collected from a panel of 19 experts and a survey of 55 IT project managers, are described.
Abstract: The postmortem examination of failed IT projects reveals that long before the failure there were significant symptoms or “early warning signs.” This article describes the top 12 people-related and project-related IT project risks, based on “early warning sign” data collected from a panel of 19 experts and a survey of 55 IT project managers.
336 citations