Noise emitted from road, rail and air traffic and their effects on sleep
TL;DR: The equivalent noise level seems to be a suitable predictor for subjectively evaluated sleep quality but not for physiological sleep disturbances, where physiological sleep parameters were most severely affected by rail noise.
Abstract: This study compared the effects of road, rail, and aircraft noise and tested the applicability of the equivalent noise level for the evaluation of sleep disturbances. Sixteen women and 16 men (19–28 years) slept during 3 consecutive weeks in the laboratory. Eight persons slept in quiet throughout. Twenty-four persons were exposed to road, rail, or aircraft noise with weekly permuted changes. Each week consisted of a random sequence of a quiet night (32 dBA) and 3 nights with equivalent noise levels of 39, 44, and 50 dBA and maximum levels of 50–62, 56–68, and 62–74 dBA, respectively. The polysomnogram was recorded during all nights, sleep quality was assessed and performance tests were completed in the morning. Subjectively evaluated sleep quality decreased and reaction time increased gradually with noise levels, whereas most physiological variables revealed the same reactions to both the lower and considerably stronger reactions to the highest noise load. Aircraft noise, rail and road traffic noise caused similar after-effects but physiological sleep parameters were most severely affected by rail noise. The equivalent noise level seems to be a suitable predictor for subjectively evaluated sleep quality but not for physiological sleep disturbances.
...read more
Citations
693 citations
402 citations
194 citations
Cites background from "Noise emitted from road, rail and a..."
...Typical for studies on the effects of noise on sleep (Basner & Samel 2005; Griefahn et al. 2006, 2008), amounts of wake and S1 were increased while amounts of SWS and REM were decreased....
[...]
169 citations
160 citations
Cites background from "Noise emitted from road, rail and a..."
...Laboratory studies have documented immediate effects of traffic noise, such as EEG (Electroencephalographic) arousals, awakenings and sleep stage shifts (Basner et al., 2008) and consequently on overall sleep architecture (Basner and Samel, 2005; Griefahn et al., 2006)....
[...]
..., 2008) and consequently on overall sleep architecture (Basner and Samel, 2005; Griefahn et al., 2006)....
[...]
...reduced subjective sleep quality, changed cortisol levels and reduced performance on reaction time tests (Griefahn et al., 2006; Maschke et al., 2002; Öhrström and Rylander, 1982)....
[...]
...Some of these effects are also observed in subjects after exposure to high levels of nighttime traffic noise, i.e. reduced subjective sleep quality, changed cortisol levels and reduced performance on reaction time tests (Griefahn et al., 2006; Maschke et al., 2002; Öhrström and Rylander, 1982)....
[...]
References
11,976 citations
7,774 citations
1,276 citations
728 citations
"Noise emitted from road, rail and a..." refers methods in this paper
...So, this study relied on the polysomnogram which was recorded and evaluated according to internationally accepted criteria [9]....
[...]
...Polysomnogram The polysomnogram (2 EEG, 2 EOG, 1 EMG) was continuously recorded throughout the nights and evaluated according to international recommendations [9]....
[...]
710 citations
"Noise emitted from road, rail and a..." refers background in this paper
...But the underlying concept of energy equivalence is debated, at least in view of a meta-analysis which, based on 55 social surveys with overall about 58 000 interviews, has clearly shown that aircraft annoys most and rail noise the least, whereas road traffic noise has an intermediate position [2,3]....
[...]
...This ‘bonus’ bases on extended social surveys whereafter aircraft noise annoys most and rail noise the least, which was most clearly shown by the meta-analysis performed by Miedema and co-workers [2,3]....
[...]
...Type of traffic noise The hypothesis adopted for this study bases firstly on the replicated observation that man responds more likely to meaningful than to neutral noises even during sleep [7,8] and secondly on a meta-analysis according to which aircraft noise annoys most and rail noise the least [2,3]....
[...]