Normal form theory and nonlinear normal modes: Theoretical settings and applications
Summary (7 min read)
1 Introduction and notations
- These lecture notes are related to the CISM1 course on ”Modal Analysis of nonlinear Mechanical systems”, held at Udine, Italy, from June 25 to 29, 2012.
- After a brief introduction reviewingthe main concepts for deriving the normal form for a given dynamical system, the relationship between normal form theory and nonlinear normal modes (NNMs) will be the core of the developments.
- For generic dynamical systems,X will denote the state vector,X ∈ E , whereE is the phase space, of dimensionn.
- For the particular case of vibratory system, geometric nonli earity is considered, so that only quadratic and cubic type nonlinearities are present in the equations of motions.
- NNMs and normal form are used to derive theROMs, and examples on different shells are shown: a doubly-curved (hyperbolic paraboloid) panel illustrates a case without internal resonance, while a closed circular cylindrical shell allows illustrating a more complicated case with a 1:1 internal resonance.
2 Normal form theory
- Normal form theory is a classical tool in the analysis of dynamical systems, and general introductions can be found in many textbooks, see.g. [20, 21, 57, 29].
- Here however, the general theory will be usedfor another purpose: defining a nonlinear change of coordinates allowing one to express the dynamics in an invariant-based span of the phase space, where the generating axis are the invariantm ifolds arising from the linear eigenspaces, i.e. the NNMs of the system.
- Normal form theory is based on two major theorems, due to Poincaré and Poincaré-Dulac, which have been demonstrated in the beginning of the XXth century [39, 13].
- The presentation will begin with a reverse problematic, in order to understand better the main issue: starting from a simple, linear problem, the authors will show how a nonlinear change of coordinate can make it appear as complicated.
- The ”reverse” illustrative problematic is borrowed from [30], and the presentation of normal form used follows closely that shown in [30, 29].
2.1 Problematic
- Before entering the complicated calculations for tacklingthe general case, let us first introduce an illustrative example, allowing us to properly define the goal pursued, which is defined as trying tosimplify as far as possible, in the vicinity of a particular solution (e.g. fixed point or periodic orbit), a given dynamical system.
- Maybe that with a great intuition and a bit of luck, one could have find the solution which, in their case, is known by construction, and is simply given by: X(t) = exp(Y0 cos t)−.
- Without inspired intuition, one could at least try an asymptotic, power series expansion, in order to get an idea of the sought nonlinear change of coordinates.
- The common sense would state that this problem withp= 6 is ”more nonlinear” than the same withp=2.
2.2 Example study
- 2.1 HereY is the new variable, and the goal of the transformation is to obtain a dynamical system for the new unknownY that is simpler than the original one.
- In any case the authors can conclude that: The objective is fulfilled: nonlinearities have been repelled up to fourth order.
- The first two conditions have already been encoutered in the precedent subsection in dimensionn = 1: once again, they are the consequence of the assumption ofhyperbolicityof the fixed point, stating that the authors are not at a bifurcation point.
- In the analysis,the resulting normal form keeps the monom and the dynamics is different from a linearizable case.
- When no resonance condition exist between the eigenvalues, then the system isquivalent to a linear one (Poincaré).
2.4 Application to vibratory systems, undamped case
- The case of vibratory systems displaying quadratic and cubic nonlinearities, is now examined, following the general notation stated in the introduction, Eq. (2).
- A second family of resonance relationships may arise frominternal resonancesbetween the eigenfrequencies of the system.
- The following comments are worth mentionable: Even though the last Eq. (40) appears longer on the page than the original one (2), the reader must be convinced that it is simpler.
2.5 NNMs and Normal form
- Nonlinear Normal Modes (NNMs) is the core of this CISM courseon Modal analysis of nonlinear systems.
- As expressed with the modal coordinates, he equations of motion are written in a phase space which is spanned by the linear eigenspaces (two-dimensional planes parameterized by (Xp, Yp)).
- The nonlinear transform cancels the invariant-breaking terms.
- Once the system expressed in its normal form, the truncations can be realized as one is ascertained of an accurate and meaningful result thanks to the invariance property.
2.6 Single-mode motion
- In order to restrict the dynamics to a single NNM, one has justto proceed as usual with thenormal coordinates.
- Detailed comparisons with other computations led by different authors, have been realized.
- In particular the invariant manifold procedur proposed by S. Shaw and C. Pierre in [42] and its asymptotic development for solving out the Partial Differential Equation defining the geometry resolved in [37, 38] gives exactly the same expressions.
- This point will be key for the remainder of the presentation.
- Note that the normal form theory provides the most complete picture for expr ssing the NNMs of a system, as the nonlinear change of coordinate (39) is a complete change, from the phase space into itself.
2.7 Classification of nonlinear terms, case of internal resonance
- From all the results obtained in the previous subsection, one is now able to draw out a classification of the nonlinear coupling terms appearing in the equations of motion, in order to get a clear physical understanding of their meaning on the dynamics.
- The following classification can be derived from the precedent results: .
- Note that when no internal resonance of order two are present,all the quadratic terms can be cancelled by the normal transform. .
- This example shows that the treatment of internal resonanceis not made too difficult with the formalism of normal form, contrary to the huge complexities involved in other methods (invariant manifold, multiple scales) to adapt their treatments to the case of internal resonance.
2.8 Damped systems
- All the developments presented in the previous section havebeen obtained under the assumption of a conservative system.
- When modal damping is added to each linear contribution, the decay rate of all the linear modes that are gathered to create the selected NNM are somehow added, so that the decay rate onto the manifold is not as simple as the initial decay rate postulated for the linear modal coordinates.
- Hence all the calculations are led with the extra condition that when a coefficient in the normal form transform scales as1/ξp, then it must be cancelled, and the corresponding monom stayin the normal form.
- By doing so, only the trivially resonant terms are kept, and a continuity from undamped to damped real normal forms, is obtained.
- In Fig. 9(a), the two damping coefficients have the same values, so thatξ1=ξ2=ξ, andξ is increased from 0 to 0.4, so that a system that is more and more damped is studied.
2.9 Closing remarks
- The main theoretical results for deriving a normal form approach for nonlinear normal modes, has been shown in this section.
- In particular, the special case of structural system with quadratic and cubic nonlinearities, Eqs. (48), has been here assumed as it contains the great majority of applications to thin structures like beams, plates and shells, vibrating at large amplitudes.
- Another limitation could appear through the asymptotic develoments, systematically stopped at third order.
- Moreover, the legitimate question is to know if the game is worth the candle.
- Asymptotic expansions up to order five realized for computing the NNMs with the center manifold technique in [43] show that the gain in accuracy brought by the fifth-order is not significative, and in some cases can be poorest than the third-order.
3 Hardening/softening behaviour
- This section is entirely devoted to the correct prediction of the type of nonlinearity (hardening/softening behaviour) for the modes of an assembly ofN nonlinear oscillator equations as in Eq. (2).
- NNMs and normal form are used to derive a proper, easy-to-use and almost analytical method.
- The presentation in subsections 3.1 and 3.2 recalls the main results obtained in[55].
- The next subsection 3.3 with applications to shells gives the main results published in [53, 47],while subsection 3.4 gathers important results published in [50] on the influence of the damping.
3.1 Definition
- This dependence can be of two different types.
- Either ahardening behaviour is at hand, which implies that the oscillation frequ ncyincreaseswith the amplitude, or a softeningtype nonlinearity is present, which means that the oscillation frequencydecreaseswith the amplitude.
- Hence reducing a system ofN linear oscillator as Eq. (2) to a single linear mode, in orderto predict the type of nonlinearity of the selected mode, may lead to erroneous results.
- Note that for applying these formulae, the implicit conventio used throughout the notes:gpij = 0 when i > j, must be applied.
- The expressions in Eqs (61) shows that in case of internal resonance, a small denominator effect appears, leading to a divergence in the expressions ofappp andb p pp, and thus on the predicted type of nonlinearityΓp.
3.2 A two dofs example
- The two dofs system composed of a masse connnected to two nonlinear springs, whose equations of motions are given in Eqs. (42), is once again considered.
- This can be easily understood by comparing the quadratic and cubic coefficients of the oscillator-equation (62).
- One can notice for example the upper-left region, which is predicted to exhibit a hardening behaviour by the linear approximation, whereas the real behaviour is soft.
- In order to have a better picture of the behaviour of the type of non linearity versus the two parameters (ω1, ω2) of the system, Figure 11 shows two cuts in this two-dimensional parameter plane, namely for fixed ω2=2 andω1 variable, then for fixedω1= √ 0.5 andω2 variable,i.e. along the two lines indicated in Fig. 10.
- As already underlined, in the vicinity of this internal resonance, theconcept of the type of nonlinearity loses its meaning because the dynamics is essentially two-dimensional and cannot be reduced to a single NNM.
3.3 Application to shells
- The method shown previously for predicting accurately the type of nonlinearity, is now applied to the case of spherical-cap thin shallow shells with a varying radius of curvatureR.
- Flat plates are known to exhibit a hardening behaviour,as it has been shown both theoretically and experimentally (see e.g. [48, 58, 35, 44, 54, 46]), which means that the leading cubic coefficienthpppp is positive.
- Introducing a radius of curvatureR, going to infinity (perfect plate) to finite values (spherical- p shells) introduces an asymmetry in the restoring force, due to the loss of symmetryof the neutral plane of the shell.
- The model is based on von Kármán kinematical assumptions on the strain-displacement relationship, in order to take into account moderately large vibration amplitudes.
- The governing equations are first recalled, then the Galerkin method is briefly reviewed in order to explain how to pass from the PDE of motion to oscillator-equations having the form of Eqs. (2),then finally the type of nonlinearity for some eigenmodes of the structure, are given.
3.3.2 Linear analysis
- All the analysis is here performed for a free-edge boundary condition.
- They are not recalled here for the sake of brevity, theinterested reader can found the complete expressions in [47, 53].
- The results will be presented as functions ofκ, in order to set apart the material property which appear through the Poisson ratioν in the expression ofχ.
- On the contrary, the eigenfrequencies dependence on the aspect ratioκ, represented on Fig. 15, shows a different behaviour, which leads to classify the modes into two families.
3.3.3 Modal expansion
- The complete non-linear equations of motion (70) are projected onto the natural basis of the transverse eigenmodes.
- Now that the PDE has been reduced to nonlinear oscillator equations, the formalism of NNMs and normal form can be applied to derive the type of nonlinearityfor each mode of the shell.
- The nonlinear coefficientsgpij andh p ijk shows a very slight dependence on the curvature of the shell.
- This is the consequence of the slight dependence of the mode shapes with the aspect ratio, as the non-linear coefficients are computed from integrals involving the mode shape functions (Eqs (76-77)).
- The conditions for these quadratic coefficients to be non-zero are expressed in terms of the number of nodal diameterskl andkp of the l andp modes.
3.3.4 From circular plates to spherical-cap shells
- The type of nonlinearity is now computed for three differentmodes of the shell, representing each of the three families.
- Secondly, hardening behaviour is observed until the 2:1 resonance with mode (0,1), where softening behaviour settles down.
- The type of non-linearity tends to zero asκ tends to infinity.
- The case of an axisymmetric mode is now considered with mode (0,1).
3.5 Closing remarks
- A general strategy has been proposed for deriving the type ofnonlinearity of an assembly of nonlinear oscillator equations, based on normal form theory and reduction to a single NNM.
- The reason is the non invariance of the linear eigenspace, as shown in the previous section.
- The effect of the other modes on the type of nonlinearity, has been underlined, i particular the presence of 2:1 internal resonance.
- For the last section of this lecture, the focus is on the derivation of ROMs for structural systems in forced vibration.
4 Reduced-order models for resonantly forced response
- The goal of this section is to use the reduced-order modelling strategy based on NNMs and normal form theory, in order to compute the harmonically forced response of thin structures, vibrating at large amplitudes and excited in the vicinity of one of its eigenfrequency.
- Applications to shells will be specifically shown, and a comparison with the Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) method will highlight the benefit of using NNMs in this case.
- In the first subsection, thederivation of the ROM is briefly reviewed and the advantage of using the normal form method including the damping is shown on a two-dofs example.
- The presentation in subsection 4.1 recalls some of the results published in [50].
- Subsection 4.2 selects one of the examples shown in [51] for illustration.
4.1 Derivation of the reduced-order model
- The previous developments have clearly highlighted the general method for deriving the ROM, shown schematically in Fig.
- 1 internal resonance is present and two NNMs must bere ained in the truncation, also known as Hence a 1.
- Secondly, the perturbation brought by the external force onto the normal form is at least a second-order effect [21].
- The second ROM, following the ”conservative NNM” method, isfound by subsituting in Eqs. (45) and (61) the coefficients by their expressions.
- The ROM constructed with the ”conservative NNM” method underestimates the damping in the system, and gives a maximum amplitude which is slightly larger that the reference solution.
4.2 Application : the case of a doubly-curved panel with in-plane inertia
- Frequency response curves, in the vicinity of its fundamental mode, will be computed for different ROMs.
- As a single NNM ROM is awaited to give good results, it is decidedto compare two ROMs having the same complexity (a single nonlinear oscillator equation).
- Fig. 26 shows the six main coordinates,i.e. the first four coordinates in transverse direction,w1,1, w3,1, w1,3 andw3,3, as well as the first two longitudinal coordinatesu1,1 andv1,1.
- Once again, the reference solution is compared to the two reduced models composed of a single linear and non-linear mode.
4.3 Application : the case of a closed circular cylindrical shell
- A water-filled perfect circular cylindrical shell, simply supported, and harmonically excited in the neighbourhood of the fundamental frequency, is selected in orderto derive a NNM-based ROM for a continuous structure.
- Mathematical expressions of boundary conditions are given in [6, 7].
- The case considered here (a perfect shell) does not produce new terms because of the perfect symmetry of the initial problem.
- One can see that all the dynamical features of the original system are recovered: the two branches are found as well as the nature of the bifurcations and the stability.
- For comparison, the sixth most important modal amplitudes are represented in Fig. 31, for the full-order model, and the“damped NNM” ROM.
4.4 Comparison with the Proper Orthogonal Decomposition method
- This last section is devoted to a comparison between reduced-order modeling as proposed with NNM via normal form theory, and the more popular Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) method.
- Eq. (106) is used to solve the equations of motion of the shell, given in the beginning of the previous subsection, Eqs. (94) and (96), with the Galerkin method to find the equations of motion of the ROM.
- The coefficientsαm,n,i andβm,n,i are also meaningful in order to get a physical interpretation of the POMs in phase space.
- On the other hand, The NNM-based ROM is accurate with two NNMs only, as thebending of the phase space is taken into account in the nonlinear change of coordinates.
Did you find this useful? Give us your feedback
Citations
54 citations
48 citations
Cites background or methods or result from "Normal form theory and nonlinear no..."
...The physical consequence is that in vibration theory, backbone curves are bent to create either hardening or softening behaviour [15,28]....
[...]
...5 Internal resonance When deriving the theory of normal form, as already stated in the previous sections and fully detailed in [15,27, 28], one has to take care of the occurrence of internal resonance....
[...]
...These terms come from the denominators of the modal normal form and vanish in case of internal resonance, see [15, 28] and section 2....
[...]
...The theory is detailed in [15,27,28], and further comments will be provided in the next sections....
[...]
...For the external forcing, the strategy had already been proposed in [27,28]....
[...]
44 citations
39 citations
35 citations
Cites background or methods from "Normal form theory and nonlinear no..."
...The frequency-response curves of the thick beam in the vicinity of its first eigenfrequency is investigated in order to illustrate how the static condensation and the NNM approach are able to retrieve the correct nonlinear behaviour....
[...]
...Considering only the NNM label p, the reduced-order model reads: q̈p + ω 2 pqp + ( N∑ s=NB+1 − αppsα s pp ω2s ( ω2s − 2ω2p ω2s − 4ω2p ) + βpppp ) q3p + ( N∑ s=NB+1 αppsα s pp ω2s ( 2 ω2s − 4ω2p )) qpq̇p 2 = 0 ....
[...]
...On the other hand, the NNM solution with all the modes taken into account show also a direct convergence to the frequency-response curve....
[...]
...They are also key in the formulation of invariant manifolds in order to define NNMs in phase space [46,33]....
[...]
...[46,42]), in the sense that as soon as energy is given to the master mode p, all s modes having these important invariant-breaking terms will no longer be vanishing....
[...]
References
12,669 citations
12,485 citations
5,220 citations
3,721 citations
1,532 citations