Null energy condition and superluminal propagation
TL;DR: In this paper, the null energy condition is violated in a large class of situations, including isotropic solids and fluids relevant for cosmology, and the existence of superluminal modes is shown to imply the presence of instabilities.
Abstract: We study whether a violation of the null energy condition necessarily implies the presence of instabilities. We prove that this is the case in a large class of situations, including isotropic solids and fluids relevant for cosmology. On the other hand we present several counter-examples of consistent effective field theories possessing a stable background where the null energy condition is violated. Two necessary features of these counter-examples are the lack of isotropy of the background and the presence of superluminal modes. We argue that many of the properties of massive gravity can be understood by associating it to a solid at the edge of violating the null energy condition. We briefly analyze the difficulties of mimicking u H > 0 in scalar tensor theories of gravity.
Citations
More filters
TL;DR: In this article, the authors study the connection between self-acceleration and the presence of ghosts for a quite generic class of theories that modify gravity in the infrared, defined as those that at distances shorter than cosmological, reduce to a certain generalization of the Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati (DGP) effective theory.
Abstract: In the Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati (DGP) model, the "self-accelerating" solution is plagued by a ghost instability, which makes the solution untenable. This fact, as well as all interesting departures from general relativity (GR), are fully captured by a four-dimensional effective Lagrangian, valid at distances smaller than the present Hubble scale. The 4D effective theory involves a relativistic scalar pi, universally coupled to matter and with peculiar derivative self-interactions. In this paper, we study the connection between self-acceleration and the presence of ghosts for a quite generic class of theories that modify gravity in the infrared. These theories are defined as those that at distances shorter than cosmological, reduce to a certain generalization of the DGP 4D effective theory. We argue that for infrared modifications of GR locally due to a universally coupled scalar, our generalization is the only one that allows for a robust implementation of the Vainshtein effect-the decoupling of the scalar from matter in gravitationally bound systems-necessary to recover agreement with solar-system tests. Our generalization involves an internal Galilean invariance, under which pi's gradient shifts by a constant. This symmetry constrains the structure of the pi Lagrangian so much so that in 4D there exist only five terms that can yield sizable nonlinearities without introducing ghosts. We show that for such theories in fact there are "self-accelerating" de Sitter solutions with no ghostlike instabilities. In the presence of compact sources, these solutions can support spherically symmetric, Vainshtein-like nonlinear perturbations that are also stable against small fluctuations. We investigate a possible infrared completion of these theories at scales of order of the Hubble horizon, and larger. There are however some features of our theories that may constitute a problem at the theoretical or phenomenological level: the presence of superluminal excitations; the extreme subluminality of other excitations, which makes the quasistatic approximation for certain solar-system observables unreliable due to Cherenkov emission; the very low strong-interaction scale for pi pi scatterings.
2,086 citations
Cites background from "Null energy condition and superlumi..."
...In a broad technical sense we may define a modification of gravity as a field theory possessing solutions over which new degrees of freedom affect the propagation of gravity while the background is not producing any sizable energy momentum tensor [7]....
[...]
Heidelberg University1, Korea Institute for Advanced Study2, University of Nottingham3, Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth4, University of Oxford5, INAF6, Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare7, University of Bologna8, University of Padua9, University of Toulouse10, University of Geneva11, University of Trieste12, Roma Tre University13, University of Milan14, University of Oslo15, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte16, University College London17, Imperial College London18, Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich19, Autonomous University of Madrid20, ETH Zurich21, University of Edinburgh22, Leiden University23, Sun Yat-sen University24, Max Planck Society25, Royal Institute of Technology26, University of Milano-Bicocca27, University of California, Berkeley28, University of Pennsylvania29, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo30, University of Porto31, University of Portsmouth32, King's College London33, Durham University34, Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris35, Helsinki Institute of Physics36, University of Lisbon37, Université Paris-Saclay38, Paris Diderot University39, University of Surrey40, University of Trento41, University of Chile42, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic43, University of Cyprus44, University of Barcelona45, California Institute of Technology46, Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics47
TL;DR: Euclid is a European Space Agency medium-class mission selected for launch in 2020 within the cosmic vision 2015-2025 program as discussed by the authors, which will explore the expansion history of the universe and the evolution of cosmic structures by measuring shapes and red-shift of galaxies as well as the distribution of clusters of galaxies over a large fraction of the sky.
Abstract: Euclid is a European Space Agency medium-class mission selected for launch in 2020 within the cosmic vision 2015–2025 program. The main goal of Euclid is to understand the origin of the accelerated expansion of the universe. Euclid will explore the expansion history of the universe and the evolution of cosmic structures by measuring shapes and red-shifts of galaxies as well as the distribution of clusters of galaxies over a large fraction of the sky. Although the main driver for Euclid is the nature of dark energy, Euclid science covers a vast range of topics, from cosmology to galaxy evolution to planetary research. In this review we focus on cosmology and fundamental physics, with a strong emphasis on science beyond the current standard models. We discuss five broad topics: dark energy and modified gravity, dark matter, initial conditions, basic assumptions and questions of methodology in the data analysis. This review has been planned and carried out within Euclid’s Theory Working Group and is meant to provide a guide to the scientific themes that will underlie the activity of the group during the preparation of the Euclid mission.
1,211 citations
TL;DR: The effective field theory of inflation as discussed by the authors is the most general theory describing the fluctuations around a quasi de Sitter background, in the case of single field models, in which the scalar mode can be eaten by the metric by going to unitary gauge.
Abstract: We study the effective field theory of inflation, i.e. the most general theory describing the fluctuations around a quasi de Sitter background, in the case of single field models. The scalar mode can be eaten by the metric by going to unitary gauge. In this gauge, the most general theory is built with the lowest dimension operators invariant under spatial diffeomorphisms, like g00 and Kμν, the extrinsic curvature of constant time surfaces. This approach allows us to characterize all the possible high energy corrections to simple slow-roll inflation, whose sizes are constrained by experiments. Also, it describes in a common language all single field models, including those with a small speed of sound and Ghost Inflation, and it makes explicit the implications of having a quasi de Sitter background. The non-linear realization of time diffeomorphisms forces correlation among different observables, like a reduced speed of sound and an enhanced level of non-Gaussianity.
1,183 citations
Cites background or methods from "Null energy condition and superlumi..."
...It would also be interesting to use our approach for the study of fluctuations in fluids like in radiation or matter dominance [8]....
[...]
...In appendix A we prove (1)Indeed, as shown for example in [8], non-vorticous excitations of a perfect fluid may be described by a derivatively coupled scalar....
[...]
...This is an example of the well studied relationship between violation of the null energy condition, which in a FRW Universe is equivalent to Ḣ < 0, and the presence of instabilities in the system [17, 8]....
[...]
TL;DR: In this paper, it was shown that low-energy effective field theories described by local, Lorentz invariant Lagrangians, secretly exhibit macroscopic non-locality and cannot be embedded in any UV theory whose S-matrix satisfies canonical analyticity constraints.
Abstract: We argue that certain apparently consistent low-energy effective field theories described by local, Lorentzinvariant Lagrangians, secretly exhibit macroscopic non-locality and cannot be embedded in any UV theory whose S-matrix satisfies canonical analyticity constraints. The obstruction involves the signs of a set of leading irrelevant operators, which must be strictly positive to ensure UV analyticity. An IR manifestation of this restriction is that the “wrong” signs lead to superluminal fluctuations around non-trivial backgrounds, making it impossible to define local, causal evolution, and implying a surprising IR breakdown of the effective theory. Such effective theories can not arise in quantum field theories or weakly coupled string theories, whose S-matrices satisfy the usual analyticity properties. This conclusion applies to the DGP brane-world model modifying gravity in the IR, giving a simple explanation for the difficulty of embedding this model into controlled stringy backgrounds, and to models of electroweak symmetry breaking that predict negative anomalous quartic couplings for the W and Z. Conversely, any experimental support for the DGP model, or measured negative signs for anomalous quartic gauge boson couplings at future accelerators, would constitute direct evidence for the existence of superluminality and macroscopic non-locality unlike anything previously seen in physics, and almost incidentally falsify both local quantum field theory and perturbative string theory.
1,127 citations
Cites background from "Null energy condition and superlumi..."
...Conversely, as soon as superluminal modes are allowed, the null energy condition is lost, even in the absence of instabilities within the matter dynamics [12], and CTC’s can in principle appear with respect to the gravitational metric gμν as well....
[...]
...While our arguments do not directly apply to theories in which the vacuum spontaneously breaks Lorentz invariance, such as Higgs phases of gravity [6, 7, 8] or the models studied in [12], it would be interesting to ask whether there are any analogous constraints to those we have discussed....
[...]
...Notice that a violation of the Null Energy Condition under very broad assumptions leads either to instabilities at arbitrarily short time-scales or to superluminal propagation in the matter sector [12]....
[...]
...It is a remarkable fact that if the matter dynamics do not feature either instabilities or superluminal modes then the energy momentum tensor corresponding to the effective metric satisfies the null energy condition [12]....
[...]
TL;DR: The effective field theory of inflation as mentioned in this paper is the most general theory describing the fluctuations around a quasi de Sitter background, in the case of single field models, in which the scalar mode can be eaten by the metric by going to unitary gauge.
Abstract: We study the effective field theory of inflation, i.e. the most general theory describing the fluctuations around a quasi de Sitter background, in the case of single field models. The scalar mode can be eaten by the metric by going to unitary gauge. In this gauge, the most general theory is built with the lowest dimension operators invariant under spatial diffeomorphisms, like g^{00} and K_{mu nu}, the extrinsic curvature of constant time surfaces. This approach allows us to characterize all the possible high energy corrections to simple slow-roll inflation, whose sizes are constrained by experiments. Also, it describes in a common language all single field models, including those with a small speed of sound and Ghost Inflation, and it makes explicit the implications of having a quasi de Sitter background. The non-linear realization of time diffeomorphisms forces correlation among different observables, like a reduced speed of sound and an enhanced level of non-Gaussianity.
1,103 citations
References
More filters
TL;DR: In this paper, it was shown that low-energy effective field theories described by local, Lorentz invariant Lagrangians, secretly exhibit macroscopic non-locality and cannot be embedded in any UV theory whose S-matrix satisfies canonical analyticity constraints.
Abstract: We argue that certain apparently consistent low-energy effective field theories described by local, Lorentzinvariant Lagrangians, secretly exhibit macroscopic non-locality and cannot be embedded in any UV theory whose S-matrix satisfies canonical analyticity constraints. The obstruction involves the signs of a set of leading irrelevant operators, which must be strictly positive to ensure UV analyticity. An IR manifestation of this restriction is that the “wrong” signs lead to superluminal fluctuations around non-trivial backgrounds, making it impossible to define local, causal evolution, and implying a surprising IR breakdown of the effective theory. Such effective theories can not arise in quantum field theories or weakly coupled string theories, whose S-matrices satisfy the usual analyticity properties. This conclusion applies to the DGP brane-world model modifying gravity in the IR, giving a simple explanation for the difficulty of embedding this model into controlled stringy backgrounds, and to models of electroweak symmetry breaking that predict negative anomalous quartic couplings for the W and Z. Conversely, any experimental support for the DGP model, or measured negative signs for anomalous quartic gauge boson couplings at future accelerators, would constitute direct evidence for the existence of superluminality and macroscopic non-locality unlike anything previously seen in physics, and almost incidentally falsify both local quantum field theory and perturbative string theory.
1,127 citations
TL;DR: In this article, the authors proposed a theoretically consistent modification of gravity in the infrared, which is compatible with all current experimental observations and opens up a number of new avenues for attacking cosmological problems, including inflation, dark matter and dark energy.
Abstract: We propose a theoretically consistent modification of gravity in the infrared, which is compatible with all current experimental observations. This is an analog of the Higgs mechanism in general relativity, and can be thought of as arising from ghost condensation — a background where a scalar field has a constant velocity, = M2. The ghost condensate is a new kind of fluid that can fill the universe, which has the same equation of state, ρ = −p, as a cosmological constant, and can hence drive de Sitter expansion of the universe. However, unlike a cosmological constant, it is a physical fluid with a physical scalar excitation, which can be described by a systematic effective field theory at low energies. The excitation has an unusual low-energy dispersion relation ω2 ~ 4/M2. If coupled to matter directly, it gives rise to small Lorentz-violating effects and a new long-range 1/r2 spin dependent force. In the ghost condensate, the energy that gravitates is not the same as the particle physics energy, leading to the possibility of both sources that can gravitate and anti-gravitate. The newtonian potential is modified with an oscillatory behavior starting at the distance scale MPl/M2 and the time scale MPl2/M3. This theory opens up a number of new avenues for attacking cosmological problems, including inflation, dark matter and dark energy.
1,104 citations
TL;DR: The present acceleration of the Universe strongly indicated by recent observational data can be modeled in the scope of a scalar-tensor theory of gravity by determining the structure of this theory along with the present density of dustlike matter from two observable cosmological functions.
Abstract: The present acceleration of the Universe strongly indicated by recent observational data can be modeled in the scope of a scalar-tensor theory of gravity. We show that it is possible to determine the structure of this theory along with the present density of dustlike matter from two observable cosmological functions: the luminosity distance and the linear density perturbation in the dustlike matter component as functions of redshift. Explicit results are presented in the first order in the small inverse Brans-Dicke parameter ${\ensuremath{\omega}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$.
912 citations
TL;DR: In this article, the authors introduce a technique for restoring general coordinate invariance into theories where it is explicitly broken, which is the analog for gravity of the Callan-Coleman-Wess-Zumino formalism for gauge theories.
874 citations
TL;DR: In this article, the scalar curvature of the brane metric contributes to brane action and the curvature term arises generically on account of one-loop effects induced by matter fields residing on a brane.
Abstract: We explore a new class of braneworld models in which the scalar curvature of the (induced) brane metric contributes to the brane action. The scalar curvature term arises generically on account of one-loop effects induced by matter fields residing on the brane. Spatially flat braneworld models can enter into a regime of accelerated expansion at late times. This is true even if the brane tension and the bulk cosmological constant are tuned to satisfy the Randall–Sundrum constraint on the brane. Braneworld models admit a wider range of possibilities for dark energy than standard LCDM. In these models the luminosity distance can be both smaller and larger than the luminosity distance in LCDM. Whereas models with dL ≤ dL(LCDM) imply w = p/ρ ≥ −1 and have frequently been discussed in the literature, models with dL > dL(LCDM) have traditionally been ignored, perhaps because, within the general-relativistic framework, the luminosity distance has this property only if the equation of state of matter is strongly negative (w > t0, where t0 is the present epoch. Such models could help reconcile an accelerating universe with the requirements of string/M-theory.
769 citations