Outdoor adventure in Australian outdoor education: is it a case of roast for Christmas dinner?
Citations
94 citations
Cites background from "Outdoor adventure in Australian out..."
...While it is right that such foundations be questioned (Nicol, 2002; Lugg, 2004, this issue), any alternatives require just as careful scrutiny and evaluation....
[...]
...That skill learning through adventure impinges on environmental outcomes is in agreement with much recent writing which questions the use of traditional adventure activities in outdoor education (see, e.g., Payne 2002; Lugg, 2004, this issue)....
[...]
90 citations
77 citations
Cites background from "Outdoor adventure in Australian out..."
...While I find it encouraging that within outdoor education some attention has been given to developing place sensitive education (see for example Brookes, 2002a; Lugg, 2004; Preston, 2004), I believe there is still considerable work to be done....
[...]
72 citations
Cites background from "Outdoor adventure in Australian out..."
...In particular, the acknowledgement of the historical and cultural milieu in which these activities arose along with the critique of these practices given the changing social, geographic, economic and ecological conditions that have emerged, and continue to emerge (Lugg, 2004 )....
[...]
72 citations
References
153 citations
"Outdoor adventure in Australian out..." refers background in this paper
...…issues have been recognised by outdoor educators and some suggestions for more environmentally empathetic teaching and practice via alternative epistemological frameworks have been offered (Brookes, 1998, 2002; Martin, 1999; Nicol, 2002b; Nicol & Higgins, 1998; Payne, 2002; Slattery, 2001)....
[...]
...Perhaps some or all of the above influences on Australian outdoor education curricula have contributed to programs that Brookes (2002) suggests are based on flimsy educational rationales: A persistent search for universals in outdoor-education discourse has drawn attention from the particulars of…...
[...]
...As Humberstone and Pederson (2000), Nicol (2002a, 2002b), Payne (2002), and Brookes (2002, 2003) explain, outdoor education philosophy and practice is a social and cultural construct, shaped by particular concepts of knowledge, experience and human interaction with landscapes....
[...]
...These failings have been attended by an uncritical acceptance of imported outdoor-education theory, and point to some widespread inadequacies in outdoor-education internationally (Brookes, 2002, p. 406)....
[...]
...Specific Australian influences on outdoor education philosophy and practice are often political (relating to funding sources, curriculum development, organisation/association control, etc.) as well as ideological (Brookes, 2002; Martin, 1998; Pickett & Polley, 2001)....
[...]
129 citations
"Outdoor adventure in Australian out..." refers background in this paper
...…issues have been recognised by outdoor educators and some suggestions for more environmentally empathetic teaching and practice via alternative epistemological frameworks have been offered (Brookes, 1998, 2002; Martin, 1999; Nicol, 2002b; Nicol & Higgins, 1998; Payne, 2002; Slattery, 2001)....
[...]
...Nicol believes that in outdoor education, "practical knowing" (Reason, 1998, in Nicol, 2002b), should not merely take the form of skill acquisition, but should be socially transformative action based on the deep ecology principle that humans are “part of, not apart from, the natural world” (Nicol,…...
[...]
...As Humberstone and Pederson (2000), Nicol (2002a, 2002b), Payne (2002), and Brookes (2002, 2003) explain, outdoor education philosophy and practice is a social and cultural construct, shaped by particular concepts of knowledge, experience and human interaction with landscapes....
[...]
...While clearly allowing people to access and, perhaps, to appreciate outdoor environments, the very nature of adventure activities is problematic in relation to deeper environmental education objectives (HaluzaDelay, 1999; Nicol, 2002b, Payne, 2002)....
[...]
...…that in outdoor education, "practical knowing" (Reason, 1998, in Nicol, 2002b), should not merely take the form of skill acquisition, but should be socially transformative action based on the deep ecology principle that humans are “part of, not apart from, the natural world” (Nicol, 2002b, p. 219)....
[...]
111 citations
"Outdoor adventure in Australian out..." refers background in this paper
...There is considerable evidence from outdoor education research to suggest that this is often the case in the UK and Australia (Allin, 2000; Humberstone, 2000; Kiewa, 2001; Preston, 2001)....
[...]
...8 research to suggest that this is often the case in the UK and Australia (Allin, 2000; Humberstone, 2000; Kiewa, 2001; Preston, 2001)....
[...]
...It may also illustrate a manifestation of the hegemonic view of masculinity discussed by Humberstone (2000), thus highlighting a potential discrepancy between between historical values embedded in outdoor education practice and current social imperatives....
[...]
...Humberstone (2000) argues that outdoor adventure education activities in the UK often perpetuate hegemonic views of masculinity associated with rugged individualism, competitiveness and physical strength....
[...]
67 citations
"Outdoor adventure in Australian out..." refers background in this paper
...Clearly, significant environmental education issues have been recognised by outdoor educators and some suggestions for more environmentally empathetic teaching and practice via alternative epistemological frameworks have been offered (Brookes, 1998, 2002; Martin, 1999; Nicol, 2002b; Nicol & Higgins, 1998; Payne, 2002; Slattery, 2001)....
[...]
...…issues have been recognised by outdoor educators and some suggestions for more environmentally empathetic teaching and practice via alternative epistemological frameworks have been offered (Brookes, 1998, 2002; Martin, 1999; Nicol, 2002b; Nicol & Higgins, 1998; Payne, 2002; Slattery, 2001)....
[...]
...As Humberstone and Pederson (2000), Nicol (2002a, 2002b), Payne (2002), and Brookes (2002, 2003) explain, outdoor education philosophy and practice is a social and cultural construct, shaped by particular concepts of knowledge, experience and human interaction with landscapes....
[...]
...Critique of outdoor education philosophy and practice does not aim to be destructive but to expose underlying values and principles, often accepted as common sense, which may need to be reexamined in relation to current educational imperatives (Brookes, 1993, 2002, 2003; Nicol, 2002a, 2002b; Payne, 2002; Slattery, 2002)....
[...]
...While clearly allowing people to access and, perhaps, to appreciate outdoor environments, the very nature of adventure activities is problematic in relation to deeper environmental education objectives (HaluzaDelay, 1999; Nicol, 2002b, Payne, 2002)....
[...]