Preference of Experience in Image Tone-Mapping: Dataset and Framework for Objective Measures Comparison
TL;DR: A subjective experiment attempting to determine users’ preference with respect to these two types of content in two different viewing scenarios—with and without the HDR reference shows that the absence of the reference can significantly influence the subjects' preferences for the natural images, while no significant impact has been found in the case of the synthetic images.
Abstract: The popularity of high dynamic range (HDR) imaging has grown in both academic and private research sectors. Since the native visualization of HDR content still has its limitations, the importance of dynamic range compression (i.e., tone-mapping) is very high. This paper evaluates observers’ preference of experience in context of image tone-mapping. Given the different nature of natural and computer-generated content, the way observers perceive the quality of tone-mapped images can be fundamentally different. In this paper, we describe a subjective experiment attempting to determine users’ preference with respect to these two types of content in two different viewing scenarios—with and without the HDR reference. The results show that the absence of the reference can significantly influence the subjects’ preferences for the natural images, while no significant impact has been found in the case of the synthetic images. Moreover, we introduce a benchmarking framework and compare the performance of selected objective metrics. The resulting dataset and framework are made publicly available to provide a common test bed and methodology for evaluating metrics in the considered scenario.
...read more
Citations
50 citations
Additional excerpts
...[43]–[45] can not be employed to perform statistical significance test in this work....
[...]
30 citations
Cites background from "Preference of Experience in Image T..."
...[70]–[73], which evaluates classification abilities of IQA models to distinguish which of the two images is better or of the...
[...]
13 citations
13 citations
Additional excerpts
...Preference of Experience (PoE) [15] and employed beyond 3DTV in context such as HDR QoE assessment [16]....
[...]
11 citations
References
13,555 citations
2,222 citations
"Preference of Experience in Image T..." refers methods in this paper
...Publicly available datasets of HDR images processed by different TMOs including respective subjective scores are mainly restricted to the experiments performed by Čadı́k et al. [5] and Yeganeh and Wang [10]....
[...]
1,871 citations
1,597 citations
"Preference of Experience in Image T..." refers methods in this paper
...For displaying the HDR images, SIM2 HDR47E S 4K display was used, which is a 16-bit, 47-inch, 1080p LCD TV with maximum and minimum displayable luminance of 4000 and 0.03 cd/m2 , respectively....
[...]
1,593 citations
"Preference of Experience in Image T..." refers result in this paper
...Hence, our studies provide valuable insights towards this goal....
[...]