Reconceiving the grain heap: Margins and movements on the market floor
22 Jan 2018-Contributions to Indian Sociology (SAGE PublicationsSage India: New Delhi, India)-Vol. 52, Iss: 1, pp 28-52
TL;DR: In this article, the post-harvest grain heap is reconceptualised as a critical entry point and analytic for the study of contemporary commodity markets, based on long-term ethnographic fieldwork in an agricultural market (mandi) in Madhya Pradesh.
Abstract: This article returns to what was once an ethnographic staple in the sociology of India: the post-harvest grain heap. Having long occupied centre stage in analyses of a moneyless, redistributive transactional order widely known as the jajmani system, it has also been the subject of influential critique, where it has been argued that the misconceived heap sustained a powerful anthropological fiction. Moving beyond these positions, which seem to have left the heap grounded in the past, the grain heap in this work is reconceptualised as a critical entry point and analytic for the study of contemporary commodity markets. Based on long-term ethnographic fieldwork in an agricultural market (mandi) in Madhya Pradesh, it finds that it is along the seams or internal margins of the market, at routine sites of physical transfer and exchange, assembly and dispersal, integration and disruption, that heaps of agricultural produce materialise. An analysis of critical aspects of the heap—its position, composition, measure...
Citations
More filters
01 Jan 2020
22 citations
01 Jan 2020
15 citations
01 Jan 2020
15 citations
01 Oct 2020
15 citations
References
More filters
TL;DR: In this paper, an analysis of the conflicts that arose when the propertied attempted to undermine the gleaning rights of the poor in the century after 1750, reassesses both the degree to which the courts could be used by the property against the poor and the specific model of a transition from custom to crime used by some historians of law and social relations in this period.
Abstract: Through an analysis of the conflicts that arose when the propertied attempted to undermine the gleaning rights of the poor in the century after 1750, this article reassesses both the degree to which the courts could be used by the propertied against the poor and the specific model of a ‘transition from custom to crime’ used by some historians of law and social relations in this period. Gleaning was an important source of income for labouring families. The uncut or fallen grain left in the fields after the harvest sometimes accounted for more than a tenth of their annual income. Gleaning was particularly important in the predominantly grain-growing region of East Anglia, the area which forms the primary focus of this study. In this region the loss of spinning and other by-employments and the decline of female wage-earning opportunities in agriculture meant that gleaning played an increasingly central part in early nineteenth-century descriptions of women's work. When the farmers began to use legal sanctions to attack the gleaners’ rights in the late eighteenth century, one of the few ways by which women could safeguard their households against the privations of winter was severely threatened, and although the resulting disturbances have received scant attention from historians of women's protest, the gleaners were not slow to act collectively in defence of their customary rights.
52 citations
TL;DR: This paper argued that global market prices are not set by the mere coming together of demand and supply, but are produced as mercantile tools by a multiplicity of actors, and instead of focusing narrowly on price setting, policy makers and researchers should attend to the conditions of price realization.
Abstract: What is a global price? Studying the making of prices in spot, options and futures markets, the article ethnographically addresses this question by using world cotton trade as its empirical context. It argues that global market prices are not set by the mere coming together of demand and supply, but are produced as mercantile tools. These tools or prosthetic prices are realized by a multiplicity of actors. The article shows that instead of focusing narrowly on price setting, policy makers and researchers should attend to the conditions of price realization. In world and regional markets, prices are realized in multiple forms. Drawing on contemporary economic anthropology and sociology, the article maps the rich world of prices in their multiple manifestations and processes of realization. Price realization in the world cotton market is performed and maintained by constant interventions in the making of the markets and their prices through different forms of perceptions, scientific assumptions, standardiza...
26 citations
TL;DR: The authors examines popular distrust of early refrigerated transport and storage in light of larger debates about how best to procure good food at a fair price, and shows that refrigeration proved controversial not simply because it helped de-localize and industrialize food supply, but also challenged norms that had previously governed trade in perishables.
Abstract: In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the spread of what we now know as the cold chain sparked controversy in both Europe and North America. This article examines popular distrust of early refrigerated transport and storage in light of larger debates about how best to procure good food at a fair price. Expanding on E. P. Thompson's concept of moral economy, the article shows that refrigeration proved controversial not simply because it helped de-localize and industrialize food supply. It also challenged norms that had previously governed trade in perishables, especially those concerning transparency, naturalness and freshness.
21 citations
18 citations
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors address the social effects of material exhibitions in Melanesia and suggest that people in Vanuatu perceive subjects and objects within a totalizing mode of production, in which the material object takes on the capacity of encompassing social relations.
Abstract: In this article, the author addresses the social effects of material exhibitions in Melanesia. He suggests that people in Vanuatu perceive subjects and objects within a totalizing mode of production, in which the material object takes on the capacity of encompassing social relations. He introduces the Vanuatu case as countering some of the analytical problems with materiality, especially efforts to dismantle the subject/object distinction or to understand the role of agency and will in objects.
13 citations