The Potential for Upscaling Kelp(Saccharina latissima) Cultivation in Salmon-Driven Integrated Multi-Trophic Aquaculture (IMTA)
TL;DR: The aim of this study was to investigate the growth and composition of the kelp Saccharina latissima in salmon-driven IMTA, and to assess the spatial extent of the influence of salmon derived nitrogen in order to evaluate the upscaling potential for IMTA.
Abstract: Integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA) has the potential of reducing open-cage fish farming impacts on the environment while also introducing new value chains. The aim of this study was to investigate the growth and composition of the kelp Saccharina latissima in salmon-driven IMTA, and to assess the spatial extent of the influence of salmon derived nitrogen in order to evaluate the upscaling potential for IMTA. S. latissima was cultivated 100, 200 and 1,000 m east and 1,000 m west of a 5,000 tonnes salmon farm in Western Norway from February to September 2013. The proportion of salmon derived nitrogen available for the kelp showed a clear decline with distance from the farm. Accordingly, the kelp cultivated near the salmon cages grew faster during the spring season, and growth rate decreased with increasing distance from the farm. A spatially explicit numerical model system (SINMOD), including compartments for dissolved nutrients and kelp growth, was tuned to the field data and used to investigate the potential for upscaling IMTA production. The model was used to introduce a new metric – the impacted area IA - for the areal effects of IMTA in terms of the increase in production by IMTA. The model showed that a 25 hectare kelp farm in the vicinity of the studied salmon farm could take up 1.6 of the 13.5 tonnes of dissolved inorganic nitrogen released during kelp cultivation, amounting to almost 12 % of the ammonia released during the cultivation period from February to June. The 25 hectare kelp farm would have a production yield of 1,125 tonnes fresh weight (FW), being 60 % more than that of a non-IMTA kelp farm, while a 20 % increase of kelp FW could be obtained over a 110 hectar area in salmon-driven IMTA. To achieve an even mass balance, an area of approximately 220 ha-1 would be needed to cultivate enough kelp to fix an equivalent of the nitrogen released by the fish.
Citations
More filters
TL;DR: In this article, the authors evaluated the potential of sugar kelp (Saccharina latissima) as a function of latitude and position (near and offshore) along the Norwegian coast using a coupled 3D hydrodynamic-biogeochemical-kelp model system (SINMOD).
Abstract: We have evaluated the cultivation potential of sugar kelp (Saccharina latissima) as a function of latitude and position (near- and offshore) along the Norwegian coast using a coupled 3D hydrodynamic-biogeochemical-kelp model system (SINMOD) run for four growth seasons (2012-2016). The results are spatially explicit and may be used to compare the suitability of different regions for kelp cultivation, both inshore and offshore. The simulation results were compared with growth data from kelp cultivation experiments and in situ observations on coverage of naturally growing kelp. The model demonstrated a higher production potential offshore than in inshore regions, which is mainly due to the limitations in nutrient availability caused by the stratification found along the coast. However, suitable locationsareas for kelp cultivation were also identified in areas with high vertical mixing close to the shore. The results indicate a latitudinal effect on the timing of the optimal period of growth, with the prime growth period being up to 2 months earlier in the south (58 °N) than in the north (71 °N). Although the maximum cultivation potential was similar in the six marine ecoregions in Norway (150-200 tons per unit area per year) in the six marine ecoregions in Norway, the deployment time of the cultures seems to matter significantly in the south, but less so in the north. The relevance of the results is discussed with a view towards use in decision support tools and a management context. The results are discussed, focusing on their potential significance for optimized cultivation and to support decision making towards sustainable management.
57 citations
Cites background or methods from "The Potential for Upscaling Kelp(Sa..."
...The model has been further coupled with an individual based growth model for S. latissima (Broch et al., 2013; Fossberg et al., 2018)....
[...]
...An individual based growth model for sugar kelp has been developed and coupled with SINMOD (Broch and Slagstad, 2012; Broch et al., 2013; Fossberg et al., 2018)....
[...]
...…variables used to force kelp growth in the model are temperature, salinity, light intensity (PAR), nutrient (NO−3 , NO + 4 ) concentrations, water current speed and latitude (implicitly through the day length) (Broch and Slagstad, 2012; Broch et al., 2013; Fossberg et al., 2018) (Figure 1)....
[...]
...…Aquaculture (IMTA) in this study, though this is a practice that may increase biomass yields locally (Broch et al., 2013; Handå et al., 2013; Fossberg et al., 2018; Jansen et al., 2018) and Frontiers in Marine Science | www.frontiersin.org 12 January 2019 | Volume 5 | Article 529 may be…...
[...]
...In the present simulations the same set of numerical values for the kelp growth parameters were used (Broch and Slagstad, 2012; Broch et al., 2013; Fossberg et al., 2018) for the entire Norwegian coast....
[...]
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors compared the effects of cultivation depth and season on the increase in biomass (frond length and biomass yield), chemical composition (protein, tissue nitrogen, intracellular nitrate and ash content) and biofouling (total cover and species composition) of cultivated Saccharina latissima at nine locations along a latitudinal gradient from 58 to 69° N.
Abstract: The Norwegian coastline covers more than 10° in latitude and provides a range in abiotic and biotic conditions for seaweed farming. In this study, we compared the effects of cultivation depth and season on the increase in biomass (frond length and biomass yield), chemical composition (protein, tissue nitrogen, intracellular nitrate and ash content) and biofouling (total cover and species composition) of cultivated Saccharina latissima at nine locations along a latitudinal gradient from 58 to 69° N. The effects of light and temperature on frond length and biofouling were evaluated along with their relevance for selecting optimal cultivation sites. Growth was greater at 1–2 m than at 8–9 m depth and showed large differences among locations, mainly in relation to local salinity levels. Maximum frond lengths varied between 15 and 100 cm, and maximum biomass yields between 0.2 and 14 kg m−2. Timing of maximum frond length and biomass yield varied with latitude, peaking 5 and 8 weeks later in the northern location (69° N) than in the central (63° N) and southern (58° N) locations, respectively. The nitrogen-to-protein conversion factor (averaged across all locations and depths) was 3.8, while protein content varied from 22 to 109 mg g−1 DW, with seasonality and latitude having the largest effect. The onset of biofouling also followed a latitudinal pattern, with a delayed onset in northern locations and at freshwater-influenced sites. The dominant epibiont was the bryozoan Membranipora membranacea. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of S. latissima cultivation along a wide latitudinal gradient in North Atlantic waters and underscore the importance of careful site selection for seaweed aquaculture.
36 citations
TL;DR: In this paper , the authors examined the major GHG sources and carbon sinks associated with fed finfish, macroalgae and bivalve mariculture, and the factors influencing variability across sectors.
Abstract: Abstract Aquaculture is a critical food source for the world's growing population, producing 52% of the aquatic animal products consumed. Marine aquaculture (mariculture) generates 37.5% of this production and 97% of the world's seaweed harvest. Mariculture products may offer a climate-friendly, high-protein food source, because they often have lower greenhouse gas (GHG) emission footprints than do the equivalent products farmed on land. However, sustainable intensification of low-emissions mariculture is key to maintaining a low GHG footprint as production scales up to meet future demand. We examine the major GHG sources and carbon sinks associated with fed finfish, macroalgae and bivalve mariculture, and the factors influencing variability across sectors. We highlight knowledge gaps and provide recommendations for GHG emissions reductions and carbon storage, including accounting for interactions between mariculture operations and surrounding marine ecosystems. By linking the provision of maricultured products to GHG abatement opportunities, we can advance climate-friendly practices that generate sustainable environmental, social, and economic outcomes.
35 citations
TL;DR: In this article, a total of 11 different treatments for seeding twine or rope with meiospores, gametophytes or juvenile sporophytes from the kelp Saccharina latissima were measured for growth (frond length, frond area, biomass yield and density) and protein content after 80 and 120 days at sea.
Abstract: To reach the goal of an industrialised macroalgae industry in Norway and other high-cost countries in the near future, a standardised seedling production method to improve quality control and predictability of cultivated biomass is essential. A total of 11 different treatments for seeding twine or rope with meiospores, gametophytes or juvenile sporophytes from the kelp Saccharina latissima were measured for growth (frond length, frond area, biomass yield and density) and protein content after 80 and 120 days at sea. Meiospore- and gametophyte-seeded twines were pre-cultivated in the hatchery for 14–42 days prior to deployment, while juvenile sporophytes of different ages were seeded on ropes directly on the day of deployment using a commercial binder to attach the seedlings. The results showed that seeding with meiospores pre-cultivated in the hatchery for 42 days (S42) before deployment gave significantly longer fronds (77.0 ± 6.7 cm) and a higher biomass yield (7.2 ± 0.1 kg m−1) at sea compared to other treatments. The poorest growth was measured for the direct-seeded sporophytes pre-cultivated in free-floating cultures for 35 days prior to deployment (D35; 34.4 ± 2.4 cm frond length and 1.6 ± 0.4 kg m−1). Image analysis was used to measure the coverage of the twine substrate before deployment, and a correlation was found between substrate coverage and frond length at sea, indicating that this can be used as a tool for quantity and quality control during the hatchery phase and before deployment. The protein content did not reveal any large differences between the treatments after 120 days of cultivation.
26 citations
References
More filters
TL;DR: The isotopic composition of nitrogen was measured in marine and fresh-water animals from the East China Sea, The Bering Sea, Lake Ashinoko and Usujiri intertidal zone as mentioned in this paper.
4,020 citations
TL;DR: For both two- and three- source mixing models, formulas for calculat- ing variances, standard errors (SE), and confidence inter- vals for source proportion estimates that account for the observed variability in the isotopic signatures for the sources as well as the mixture are presented.
Abstract: Stable isotope analyses are often used to quan- tify the contribution of multiple sources to a mixture, such as proportions of food sources in an animal's diet, or C3 and C4 plant inputs to soil organic carbon. Linear mixing models can be used to partition two sources with a single isotopic signature (e.g., δ13C) or three sources with a second isotopic signature (e.g., δ 15 N). Although variability of source and mixture signatures is often re- ported, confidence interval calculations for source pro- portions typically use only the mixture variability. We provide examples showing that omission of source vari- ability can lead to underestimation of the variability of source proportion estimates. For both two- and three- source mixing models, we present formulas for calculat- ing variances, standard errors (SE), and confidence inter- vals for source proportion estimates that account for the observed variability in the isotopic signatures for the sources as well as the mixture. We then performed sensi- tivity analyses to assess the relative importance of: (1) the isotopic signature difference between the sources, (2) isotopic signature standard deviations (SD) in the source and mixture populations, (3) sample size, (4) analytical SD, and (5) the evenness of the source proportions, for determining the variability (SE) of source proportion es- timates. The proportion SEs varied inversely with the signature difference between sources, so doubling the source difference from 2‰ to 4‰ reduced the SEs by half. Source and mixture signature SDs had a substantial linear effect on source proportion SEs. However, the population variability of the sources and the mixture are fixed and the sampling error component can be changed only by increasing sample size. Source proportion SEs varied inversely with the square root of sample size, so an increase from 1 to 4 samples per population cut the SE in half. Analytical SD had little effect over the range examined since it was generally substantially smaller than the population SDs. Proportion SEs were minimized when sources were evenly divided, but increased only slightly as the proportions varied. The variance formulas provided will enable quantification of the precision of source proportion estimates. Graphs are provided to al- low rapid assessment of possible combinations of source differences and source and mixture population SDs that will allow source proportion estimates with desired pre- cision. In addition, an Excel spreadsheet to perform the calculations for the source proportions and their varianc- es, SEs, and 95% confidence intervals for the two-source and three-source mixing models can be accessed at http://www.epa.gov/wed/pages/models.htm.
1,066 citations
TL;DR: A mechanism of tissue 6'5N enrichment due to reduced nutrient intake is hypothesized and the implications of these results to ecosystem studies using stable-nitrogen isotope analysis are discussed.
Abstract: Studies using measurements of61'5N to delineate diet or trophic level in natural ecosystems are based on the premise that 6'5N values in consumer tissues can be reliably correlated with those in the diet. However, juvenile Japanese Quail (Coturnixjaponica) fed a rationed diet designed to maintain, but not increase, body mass showed significantly enriched tissue 6'5N values over a control group fed the same diet ad libitum. We tested the hypothesis that fasting or nutritional stress can also cause elevated 6'5N values in tissues of wild birds by examining tissues of Arctic-nesting female Ross' Geese (Chen rossii) before and after their period of fasting during egg laying and incubation. Significant declines in body, pectoral muscle, liver and abdominal fat mass occurred from arrival through incubation. Post-incubating geese showed significantly higher pectoral muscle and liver 6'5N values compared to geese taken before clutch initiation but 6a3C values in these tissues were unchanged. We hypothesize a mechanism of tissue 6'5N enrichment due to reduced nutrient intake and discuss the implications of these results to ecosystem studies using stable-nitrogen isotope analysis.
865 citations
"The Potential for Upscaling Kelp(Sa..." refers background in this paper
...…in starving organisms (e.g., Oelbermann and Scheu, 2002; Haubert et al., 2005; Aberle andMalzahn, 2007), and may therefore not reflect the nutrient sources anymore, hence violating one of the basic assumptions behind the use of stable isotopes as tracers for nutrient sources (Hobson et al., 1993)....
[...]
TL;DR: This work expects progress in SIA resulting from standardization of methods and models, calibration of model parameters through experimentation, andContinuing to be a useful tool in reconstructing diets, characterizing trophic relationships, elucidating patterns of resource allocation, and constructing food webs.
Abstract: Stable isotope analysis (SIA) has proven to be a useful tool in reconstructing diets, characterizing trophic relationships, elucidating patterns of resource allocation, and constructing food webs. Consequently, the number of studies using SIA in trophic ecology has increased exponentially over the past decade. Several subdisciplines have developed, including isotope mixing models, incorporation dynamics models, lipid-extraction and correction methods, isotopic routing models, and compound-specific isotopic analysis. As with all tools, there are limitations to SIA. Chief among these are multiple sources of variation in isotopic signatures, unequal taxonomic and ecosystem coverage, over-reliance on literature values for key parameters, lack of canonical models, untested or unrealistic assumptions, low predictive power, and a paucity of experimental studies. We anticipate progress in SIA resulting from standardization of methods and models, calibration of model parameters through experimentation, and continu...
784 citations
TL;DR: By adopting integrated polytrophic practices, the aquaculture industry should find increasing environmental, economic, and social acceptability and become a full and sustainable partner within the development of integrated coastal management frameworks.
Abstract: The rapid development of intensive fed aquaculture (e.g. finfish and shrimp) throughout the world is associated with concerns about the environmental impacts of such often monospecific practices, especially where activities are highly geographically concentrated or located in suboptimal sites whose assimilative capacity is poorly understood and, consequently, prone to being exceeded. One of the main environmental issues is the direct discharge of significant nutrient loads into coastal waters from open-water systems and with the effluents from land-based systems. In its search for best management practices, the aquaculture industry should develop innovative and responsible practices that optimize its efficiency and create diversification, while ensuring the remediation of the consequences of its activities to maintain the health of coastal waters. To avoid pronounced shifts in coastal processes, conversion, not dilution, is a common-sense solution, used for centuries in Asian countries. By integrating fed aquaculture (finfish, shrimp) with inorganic and organic extractive aquaculture (seaweed and shellfish), the wastes of one resource user become a resource (fertilizer or food) for the others. Such a balanced ecosystem approach provides nutrient bioremediation capability, mutual benefits to the cocultured organisms, economic diversification by producing other value-added marine crops, and increased profitability per cultivation unit for the aquaculture industry. Moreover, as guidelines and regulations on aquaculture effluents are forthcoming in several countries, using appropriately selected seaweeds as renewable biological nutrient scrubbers represents a cost-effective means for reaching compliance by reducing the internalization of the total environmental costs. By adopting integrated polytrophic practices, the aquaculture industry should find increasing environmental, economic, and social acceptability and become a full and sustainable partner within the development of integrated coastal management frameworks.
600 citations