scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Does allowing undocumented immigrants into the US hurt the economy? 


Best insight from top research papers

Allowing undocumented immigrants into the US does not necessarily hurt the economy. While opponents argue that undocumented immigrants are a burden, research shows that they contribute to the economy through taxes and can stimulate job growth . Undocumented immigrants pay billions of dollars in state, local, and federal taxes, and their contributions are expected to increase under proposed immigration reform . Additionally, including undocumented immigrants in healthcare programs like the Affordable Care Act (ACA) can have economic benefits, as they are generally young, healthy, and use relatively little healthcare. This would provide them with greater access to preventive services and reduce delays in seeking needed care, resulting in long-term cost savings to health plans and taxpayers . Overall, the economic impact of allowing undocumented immigrants into the US is complex and depends on various factors, including their contributions to taxes and the healthcare system.

Answers from top 4 papers

More filters
Papers (4)Insight
The answer to the query is not explicitly mentioned in the paper. The word "undocumented" is not used in the paper. The paper analyzes the economic impacts of immigration in the United States, but it does not specifically address the question of whether allowing undocumented immigrants hurts the economy.
The paper states that undocumented immigrants contribute to the economies of federal, state, and local governments through taxes and can stimulate job growth. However, the net economic costs or benefits to state and local governments vary throughout the U.S. Therefore, the impact of allowing undocumented immigrants into the US on the economy is not explicitly stated in the paper.
The paper discusses the economic implications of an amnesty for unauthorized immigrants, but it does not explicitly state whether allowing undocumented immigrants into the US hurts the economy.
Open accessPosted Content
Pia M. Orrenius, Madeline Zavodny 
01 Jan 2012-Cato Journal
19 Citations
The paper discusses the economic implications of an amnesty for unauthorized immigrants, but it does not explicitly state whether allowing undocumented immigrants into the US hurts the economy.

Related Questions

How does migration impact the economy of a country?5 answersMigration significantly impacts the economy of a country in various ways. It affects the labor market, population size, age structure, and social dynamics, leading to changes in wages, inflation, and economic activity. Migration can boost economic growth by expanding the workforce and increasing consumer demand, benefiting both newcomers and native residents. However, it can also create challenges such as brain-drain, dependency on developed countries, and potential wage disparities between native and immigrant workers. The economic effects of migration are complex, with implications for tax incomes, government expenses, and regional competitiveness. Overall, understanding and managing migration is crucial for maximizing its positive impacts on national development while minimizing negative consequences.
What are immigrants doing to the US economy?5 answersImmigrants in the US are making significant contributions to the economy. They are more likely to start businesses and engage in entrepreneurship compared to native-born individuals. Immigrant entrepreneurs play a major role in industries such as transportation, food-related, and building services, contributing to job growth and increasing demand for ethnic foods. Studies show that immigration expands the economy's productive capacity by stimulating investment and promoting specialization, leading to efficiency gains and higher income per worker. Additionally, immigration has positive effects on educational attainment and wages, while its impact on native employment is ambiguous. The economic impacts of migration also extend to migrant-sending countries, as remittances from migrants in rich countries contribute to increased familial spending on education and child care. Overall, immigrants are playing a vital role in driving economic growth, innovation, and job creation in the US.
Is piracy bad for the economy?5 answersPiracy can have both positive and negative impacts on the economy. In certain situations, a moderate level of piracy can actually benefit the supply chain of information goods, leading to increased profits for manufacturers and retailers, as well as enhanced consumer welfare. However, piracy can also be detrimental to economic growth. For example, in the case of software piracy, studies have shown that it has a negative impact on economic growth, with a non-linear relationship. Additionally, piracy can act as a substitute for trade and affect the terms of trade of the pirate country, leading to changes in investment in defense and attack strategies. Therefore, the overall impact of piracy on the economy depends on various factors and contexts.
How does immigration effect economy?5 answersImmigration has various economic impacts on both migrant-receiving and -sending countries. It expands the population and economy, benefiting newcomers and most native residents in terms of higher incomes and faster economic growth. However, there are distributional consequences, as wages may rise slower for native workers compared to newcomers. Nevertheless, it is difficult to detect wage depression and high unemployment among native workers in areas with high immigration rates. In the case of the United States, the closure of borders in the 1920s resulted in a decline in earnings for existing US-born workers, despite the loss of immigrant labor supply. Skilled US-born workers and unrestricted immigrants from Mexico and Canada replaced European immigrants in affected urban areas. The labor market performance of immigrants is a key factor in determining whether immigration is a net benefit or cost for a nation's economy. If immigrants quickly obtain high-paying jobs, the receiving nation is likely to benefit. Additionally, research shows that immigration has positive or neutral impacts on educational attainment and wages, and potentially ambiguous effects on native employment. Restricting immigration can have a depressing effect on job creation and native labor markets, while substituting family-based entry with employment-based entry can stimulate job creation and native earnings.
What are the main economic reasons for immigrants to move to the United States?5 answersMost immigrants move to the United States for economic reasons, seeking stable jobs and better wages to support their families. Economic factors play a significant role in migration, alongside other motivations such as political and economic freedom. Research shows that immigrants, both documented and undocumented, contribute positively to the US economy by working hard, paying taxes, and stimulating economic growth. However, it is important to consider that immigrants, particularly low-skilled ones, often face low wages and have an adverse fiscal impact, receiving more in public services than they pay in taxes. Additionally, the economic gains from immigration are not evenly distributed among native-born workers, as competing low-skilled workers may experience wage losses, and the benefits of lower prices for immigrant-produced goods and services may not reach poor households as much as wealthier ones.
Is there any paper which estimate the effect of immigrants on GDP?5 answersSeveral papers estimate the effect of immigrants on GDP. Charles evaluates the impact of immigration on GDP per worker for ten European countries. Kang and Kim find that immigration from developed economies positively affects the economic growth of host countries, with a larger effect when immigration flows from developed to developing economies. Hamza and Sihaloho study the impacts of immigrants from different home countries on the GDP of Malaysia, finding significant effects in manufacturing, services, and agriculture sectors. McIntosh's estimation reveals positive effects of immigration on educational attainment and wages, and an ambiguous effect on native employment. Boubtane, Dumont, and Rault find a positive impact of migrants' human capital on GDP per capita and a positive effect of permanent increase in migration flows on productivity growth.

See what other people are reading

Why euthanasia should not be legalized?
5 answers
Euthanasia should not be legalized due to various ethical, societal, and practical concerns highlighted in the provided contexts. The sanctity of human life, emphasized in religious and secular perspectives, opposes the direct taking of innocent lives, making euthanasia ethically problematic. Legalizing euthanasia could lead to a devaluation of certain lives, contradicting the principles of a just social order. Additionally, concerns about vulnerable individuals feeling pressured to opt for early death and the potential lack of true voluntariness in such decisions further argue against legalization. Moreover, the advancements in medical care allow for better management of terminal illnesses, reducing the necessity for euthanasia. Ultimately, the complexity of the euthanasia debate transcends mere empirical data, requiring a careful consideration of ethical, societal, and practical implications before contemplating legalization.
How does critical discourse analysis approach the study of power dynamics in language and discourse?
5 answers
Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) delves into power dynamics in language and discourse by uncovering covert forms of power and domination underlying discourse. It aims to unveil asymmetrical power relations hidden in texts through text analysis. CDA examines how individuals acquire and sustain power in society through language, emphasizing the interconnectedness between language, power, and ideology. By utilizing a descriptive qualitative method, CDA analyzes verbal elements, participants, circumstances, context, and discursive practices to understand how power relationships are constructed and challenged by teachers and students through language. Additionally, CDA's theoretical and methodological framework, as outlined by Norman Fairclough, provides a unique and valuable approach to exploring power dynamics in contemporary social and political communication.
How same sex marriage could lead to positive health benefits?
5 answers
Legalizing same-sex marriage has been linked to positive health outcomes for sexual minorities. Studies show that the legalization of same-sex marriage leads to improved mental health among sexual minorities, reducing the mental health gap between sexual minorities and heterosexual individuals. Additionally, access to legalized same-sex marriage is associated with positive psychological and physical health outcomes, particularly among sexual minority adults, by reducing structural stigma and improving social acceptance. Research also indicates that Californians in legal same-sex marriages reported lower levels of psychological distress and higher self-related health compared to other adults, highlighting the positive impact of same-sex marriage on overall well-being and prosperity. Overall, the evidence suggests that legalizing same-sex marriage plays a crucial role in promoting the health and well-being of sexual minorities.
What contributes to the spread of studs and stis?
5 answers
Migration plays a significant role in the spread of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and diseases. Historically, migration has been linked to the transmission of diseases like smallpox, impacting indigenous populations [. Workers in remote areas, including migrants, are particularly vulnerable to STIs due to factors like loneliness, isolation, and engaging in risky sexual practices while away from regular partners [. Changes in social behavior, migration, and international travel have contributed to the rise in STI cases in Europe, with molecular diagnostic techniques aiding in better detection and characterization of infections [. Additionally, the spread of infectious diseases, including STIs, is influenced by the rate of contact between susceptible and infectious individuals, with migration facilitating such interactions [. Preventative measures are crucial to mitigate the impact of STIs on individuals, families, healthcare systems, and employers [.
In what ways do anti-French sentiments arise in the region as a result of these intertwined dynamics?
4 answers
Anti-French sentiments in the region arise due to a combination of factors. Firstly, frustrations with the growing jihadist threat and perceptions of French neocolonial influence contribute to resentment and conspiracy theories against France. Additionally, the lack of consideration for the aspirations of the youth fuels rejection of France, whose model is no longer seen as attractive. Furthermore, discontent over social exclusion in France, particularly among the Muslim population with ties to former French colonies, has led to identification with causes like the Palestinians, resulting in an upsurge in anti-Semitism and alignment with Middle East-based jihadist groups. These intertwined dynamics create a complex environment where anti-French sentiments manifest through various lenses, from political frustrations to social exclusion and historical legacies.
Issues and Challenges of Forced-Seasonal Labour Migrants: A study in Bolangir District of Odisha
4 answers
Forced-Seasonal Labour Migration in Bolangir District of Odisha presents significant challenges. The migration patterns in Odisha, driven by poverty and lack of opportunities, lead to adverse working conditions and exploitation. Children of migrant families face neglect, educational barriers, and health hazards, both at the origin and destination. The study highlights that distress seasonal migration is a survival strategy but does not significantly improve income or living standards. Moreover, the influx of seasonal workers in tourism destinations is met with stereotypical and prejudicial attitudes from locals, leading to vulnerability and exploitation of migrant employees. Addressing these issues requires comprehensive policies focusing on improving working conditions, protecting migrant rights, and combating stereotypes to ensure the well-being of forced-seasonal labour migrants in Bolangir District.
Should same sex marriage legalized in philippines? GIVE ME REASON?
4 answers
Legalizing same-sex marriage in the Philippines is a contentious issue with varying perspectives. Research indicates that there are differing opinions among Filipinos regarding the acceptance of homosexuals and the legalization of same-sex marriage. While some are open-minded and supportive of legalizing same-sex marriage, others, particularly those with strong religious beliefs, may oppose it. The country's stance on gender equality has been recognized positively on a broader scale, with the Philippines being commended for its gender outcomes within the ASEAN region. However, the debate intertwines legal, theological, and cultural contexts, reflecting the complex nature of the issue. Advocates emphasize the importance of social change, empowerment, and community collaboration to support the rights and well-being of LGBTQ+ individuals. Ultimately, the decision to legalize same-sex marriage in the Philippines involves navigating through these multifaceted perspectives and considerations.
Why should same sex marriage legalized in philippines?
4 answers
Legalizing same-sex marriage in the Philippines is crucial due to various reasons highlighted in the research contexts. The Filipino society exhibits diverse views on homosexuality and same-sex marriage. Advocates emphasize the importance of equal rights for the LGBTQ+ community, aiming to combat discrimination and promote acceptance. However, conservative Christian entities often oppose such initiatives, invoking religious freedom to uphold traditional values. The Communist Party of the Philippines has even facilitated same-sex marriages, reflecting a push for cultural revolution and ideological changes within the LGBT community. Legalization would not only promote inclusivity and equality but also align with global trends and human rights principles, fostering a more progressive and accepting society in the Philippines.
What is the purpose of Law 483?
4 answers
Law 488 aims to promote selective investments, particularly favoring innovative projects, small enterprises, and the identification of deprived areas. On the other hand, a security warning device for wire entanglement structures utilizing an RS 485 system is designed to enhance construction efficiency and reduce costs. Additionally, the emergence of Covid-19 has led to discussions on governmental responses, including economic measures like Perppu implementation. Furthermore, the study of British immigration law highlights regulations aimed at restricting entry for young individuals from the Indian subcontinent, impacting Asian families in the UK and influencing immigration policies. Law 488 focuses on fostering growth in specific sectors, while the security device and immigration laws serve distinct purposes in construction safety and immigration control, respectively.
How is the implementation of maternity rights in Indonesia in the context of women workers?
5 answers
The implementation of maternity rights in Indonesia for women workers involves various aspects such as social protection policies, maternity leave, and the challenges faced in ensuring these rights. Companies like PT. X in South Tangerang City provide special health services for pregnant women, scholarships for workers' children, and financial assistance. However, there are still vulnerabilities among young women workers in garment factories regarding maternity protection, with breastfeeding being neglected, leading to significant economic costs. The transition from a three-month to a six-month maternity leave in Indonesia faces challenges due to controversies and the need for meaningful participation of all stakeholders in policy formation. Additionally, the omnibus law in Indonesia has negative implications for female workers, highlighting the importance of better protecting vulnerable groups like women in future regulations.
What is the migration pattern of workers in brickkilns in India?
5 answers
Workers in brick kilns in India follow a circular migration pattern, moving between their home villages and the kiln worksites. This migration is distress-driven, with underprivileged households flocking to brick kilns for livelihood due to agricultural failures. The brick kiln industry heavily relies on seasonal migrant workers, including women and children, who face poor living and working conditions that impact their health status. These workers are exposed to various health hazards, including respiratory problems, allergies, and malnutrition, due to inadequate care and occupational hazards. Additionally, the mobility of marginalized migrant workers between peri-urban brick kilns and urban spaces contributes to the production of the urban periphery, highlighting the tenuous ties between brick kiln workers and urban areas.