scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Does open access papers have citation advantage? 


Best insight from top research papers

Open access papers have been a topic of discussion in the literature for many years. Several studies have examined the citation advantage of open access papers. One study found that hybrid gold open access articles in clinical medicine had a citation advantage over subscription articles. Another study compared the citation impact of fully open access journals to a control group of non-open access publications and found no citation advantage for fully open access journals. However, the same study found that there is a citation advantage for open access publications in hybrid journals, suggesting that better accessibility improves the visibility of publications. In dermatology, a study found that open access articles in hybrid journals had higher citation counts compared to subscription articles. Additionally, a study focused on journals that "reverse flipped" from open access to subscription and found that this switch did not affect the visibility or citation impact of the journals' articles. Overall, the evidence suggests that open access papers can have a citation advantage, particularly in hybrid journals.

Answers from top 5 papers

More filters
Papers (5)Insight
The paper states that there is no Open Access Citation Advantage (OACA) for publications in fully OA journals, and that there is rather a disadvantage. However, the OACA seems to be a reality in hybrid journals, suggesting that better accessibility in this context tends to improve the visibility of publications. Therefore, the answer to the query is that open access papers do not always have a citation advantage.
The paper discusses the "open access citation advantage" (OACA) but does not provide a clear answer to whether open access papers have a citation advantage.
Yes, the paper states that hybrid Gold open access articles have a citation advantage compared to subscription articles.
The paper states that there is no citation advantage for publications in fully open access journals, but there is a citation advantage for publications in hybrid journals.
Yes, open-access papers have a citation advantage compared to subscription-based access papers in dermatology.

Related Questions

How is related Open Access and Open Science?5 answersOpen Access and Open Science are closely related concepts that aim to transform the dissemination and accessibility of scientific research. Open Access focuses on providing free access to publications and data, while Open Science encompasses transparent and collaborative practices in sharing research, data, and software with society at large. Open Science Sensemaking (OSSm) proposes an interoperable network for researchers to record, share, and own sensemaking data, enhancing collective decision-making and content discovery. Open Science initiatives, such as open data, pre-registration of studies, and open peer review, not only increase research credibility but also promote trust and accessibility in scientific findings. The integration of Open Access principles within the broader framework of Open Science is essential for fostering a culture of transparency, collaboration, and innovation in scientific endeavors.
Does open access papers have higher citations?4 answersOpen access papers do not consistently have higher citations compared to non-open access papers. In the field of Biological and Physical Sciences, toll-access (TA) articles have garnered a greater number of citations than open access (OA) articles in different impact factor zones. Similarly, in the discipline of library and information science (LIS), non-OA journals have a significant citation advantage over OA journals. However, there is evidence of an open access citation advantage in hybrid journals, where better accessibility improves the visibility of publications. Additionally, the effect of funding on citation rates is also observed, with funded articles generally obtaining more citations than unfunded ones, regardless of publication modality. Overall, the relationship between open access and citation counts is complex and varies depending on the discipline, publication modality, and funding status.
What are the benefits of open access information in libraries?5 answersOpen access information in libraries provides the widest possible access to information for the public, meeting the diverse needs of information users and optimizing services through collaboration between libraries. It allows for the dissemination and exchange of information between institutions, facilitating library collaboration. Open access also benefits libraries by shifting their role from gatekeepers of licensed content to facilitators and supporters of the publishing process, requiring a fundamental shift in structures, tasks, and skills. Libraries can curate and make publicly available the content created by their own users, fostering a collection that reflects the research, staff, and student output. Open access enhances research, teaching, and learning in higher education by providing increased and easier access to scholarly research output, amplifying citation rates, and offering barrier-free information to teachers and learners.
What are the benefits of open digital resources?3 answersOpen digital resources have several benefits. They provide expanded access to knowledge, supporting lifelong learning, and enhancing students' learning outcomes. Additionally, they can help decrease college students' textbook spending without undermining student learning effectiveness. Open educational resources (OER) have been found to improve course outcomes and save students money on textbooks. Furthermore, open access to information resources and technology can have a profound impact on economic development and innovation. Overall, open digital resources offer opportunities for cost savings, increased access to knowledge, and improved learning outcomes.
What are the benefits of open science?5 answersOpen science has several benefits. It removes barriers to sharing science, increases reproducibility and transparency, and maximizes its benefits when incorporated throughout the research process. Open science skills enhance outcomes for individual researchers and the broader community, and help develop networks of support. It enables the tracking of datasets and code versions, facilitates collaborative research and learning, and promotes reproducible research. Open science creates a more nurturing, diverse, inclusive, and equitable science ecosystem, increasing participation of historically underrepresented groups and empowering communities. It also improves the quality of science, enhances career prospects, and can have positive effects on individual scientific careers. Overall, open science fosters collaboration, accessibility, and the co-production of knowledge, leading to a more impactful and inclusive scientific community.
What publications from the year 2018 address an open access citation advantage?5 answersPublications from the year 2018 that address an open access citation advantage include the study by Saravudecha et al., which compares the citation counts of hybrid Gold open access articles to subscription articles in the field of Clinical Medicine. Another study by Colavizza et al.analyzes the citation advantage of data availability statements that contain links to data in a repository. Hubbardexamines the open access citation advantage of gold open access journal articles published at a large U.S. research university, focusing on different disciplines. Additionally, Young and Brandesquantify the impact of different open access implementations on the number and subject diversity of citations to articles. Finally, Alkhawtani et al.investigate the difference in citation rate between open access and subscription access articles in the field of radiology.

See what other people are reading

Can the implementation of green technology in marine engines lead to a reduction in fuel consumption and environmental impact?
4 answers
The implementation of green technology in marine engines can indeed lead to a reduction in fuel consumption and environmental impact. Green fuels like green hydrogen, green ammonia, and green methanol are being considered for maritime use, with production methods involving renewable energy sources. Additionally, the use of dual-fuel engines operating on natural gas has shown promising results in reducing CO2 emissions in the maritime sector. Furthermore, advancements in energy-saving and emission reduction technologies for marine diesel engines have been highlighted to improve efficiency, reduce pollution, and enhance environmental protection objectives. Overall, the adoption of green technology in marine engines not only contributes to fuel efficiency but also helps in mitigating the environmental impact caused by traditional hydrocarbon fuel combustion, aligning with the industry's decarbonization goals.
How do cultural and socio-economic factors influence students' engagement with energy-saving practices in school?
5 answers
Cultural and socio-economic factors significantly impact students' engagement with energy-saving practices in school. Environmental values, including biospheric, altruistic, and egoistic values, play a crucial role in shaping energy-saving behavior among students. Additionally, students' intention to save energy is influenced by psychological, social, sociodemographic, and economic factors. Factors such as feeling morally obliged to consider the environment, believing in the power to avoid unnecessary power consumption, and positive influences from teachers and peers enhance students' willingness to engage in energy-saving practices. Moreover, students' awareness levels and attitudes towards energy conservation are influenced by their socio-demographic profiles. Therefore, understanding and addressing these cultural and socio-economic factors are essential for promoting sustainable energy consumption behaviors among students in educational settings.
What is the proportion of pregnancy malaria tested for in pregnancy in ghana?
5 answers
The proportion of pregnancy malaria tested for in Ghana varies across different studies and regions. A study in an urban setting in Ghana found that 66.5% of pregnant women had taken at least 2 doses of Sulfadoxine-Pyrimethamine (SP) for malaria prevention. Another study in an area with perennial malaria transmission reported that 20.4% of pregnant women attending their first antenatal clinic visit had Plasmodium falciparum infection. Additionally, a review of studies conducted over 1994-2019 showed a decline in asymptomatic parasite prevalence in pregnancy, ranging from 5-26% depending on the transmission zone. These findings highlight the importance of continuous monitoring and improvement of malaria testing and prevention strategies during pregnancy in Ghana.
Why does using AR in teaching Chemistry in high schools increase students' chemical awareness and interest in learning?
5 answers
Using Augmented Reality (AR) in teaching Chemistry in high schools increases students' chemical awareness and interest in learning due to its ability to bridge the gap between theoretical concepts and practical applications. AR technologies provide a platform where students can visualize chemical reactions and phenomena that are otherwise abstract or invisible, making learning more engaging and interactive. By incorporating AR into the curriculum, students can better understand complex concepts by observing virtual chemical interactions in a simulated laboratory setting. This hands-on approach enhances students' comprehension of the material and fosters a deeper interest in Chemistry, as it offers a more immersive and dynamic learning experience. Overall, the use of AR in Chemistry education not only enhances students' understanding but also stimulates their curiosity and engagement in the subject.
How does competitive rivalry affect academic performance among students?
5 answers
Competitive rivalry among students can have varying effects on academic performance based on different contexts. Research suggests that in competitive environments, the sense of being envied can stimulate motivation to increase one's competitive position, especially for those in lower or medium positions. Additionally, competition can lead to negative peer effects, discouraging help and inducing unfriendly behaviors among peers, ultimately impacting academic performance. Gender and ethnic differences also play a role, with competition affecting groups differently; for example, competition may widen performance gaps between genders and ethnicities, influencing academic outcomes. Furthermore, while rivalry in competitive settings is linked to increased motivation and positive outcomes, in collaborative settings, team rivalry may negatively impact team performance due to its effect on team learning behaviors.
What is workload on teachers?
5 answers
Teacher workload refers to the demands and tasks that teachers are required to fulfill in their professional roles. Research indicates that high workloads can have significant implications on teachers' efficiency, effectiveness, and ultimately on student academic achievement. Teachers with heavy workloads may experience stress, burnout, and decreased engagement, negatively impacting student learning outcomes. However, effectively managing workload can lead to improved support and guidance for students, resulting in enhanced academic achievement. Workload levels can vary among teachers, with some feeling overworked while others effectively manage their tasks. It is crucial for schools to monitor and balance workloads, provide support for workload management, and focus on professional development to ensure optimal teacher performance and student outcomes. Contradictory discourses on teacher work, as seen in policy and professional practice, can also impact teachers' professional identities.
How does professional learning relate to teacher agency?
5 answers
Professional learning plays a crucial role in shaping teacher agency, which is essential for the development of a strong professional teacher identity. Studies emphasize that professional learning interventions can promote agency by encouraging critical reflection on pedagogic practices and broader social concerns, leading to changes in classroom practices. Teacher agency is seen as a key element in the consolidation of a professional identity, with subjective learning experiences and positional changes contributing to this process. Furthermore, the ability to justify classroom practices based on conceptual knowledge and transformative reflection is highlighted as a significant aspect of professional agency, as seen in the experiences of student teachers in Norway. Effective professional development programs, such as the Cambridge English Teacher (CET) initiative, have been shown to significantly enhance teacher agency by providing opportunities for curriculum input, teaching method autonomy, and freedom in material selection.
What are the common challenges faced by third-grade students in learning and practicing cursive writing?
5 answers
Third-grade students commonly face challenges in learning and practicing cursive writing, including issues with neatness, legibility, fluency in writing capital letters, and alignment with writing lines. Research indicates that difficulties in reading and writing are prevalent among students, with a significant percentage performing below the 5th percentile in standardized tests. The decline in cursive writing instruction is noted due to technological advancements, state-mandated tests, and limited classroom time, impacting students' ability to learn and practice cursive effectively. Additionally, students' engagement in writing is crucial for their academic success, with student engagement being a critical factor in achieving proficiency in writing skills. Challenges in writing Arabic sentences are also observed, with factors such as letter distinctions and external influences affecting students' writing difficulties and academic performance.
What are the current advancements in the diagnosis and treatment of lung cancer?
5 answers
Current advancements in the diagnosis and treatment of lung cancer encompass a multidisciplinary approach, integrating histological subtype classification, molecular testing for targeted therapy, and biomarker detection for immunotherapy. Surgical treatment has evolved towards minimally invasive techniques, enhancing individualized strategies for different stages of lung cancer. Recent updates from the American Society of Clinical Oncology 2022 meeting highlight significant progress in managing non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and small cell lung cancer (SCLC), emphasizing early-stage NSCLC, mutated and non-mutated advanced NSCLC, and SCLC. Pathological assessments play a crucial role in guiding treatment decisions, especially for NSCLC patients requiring immunotherapy or targeted therapy based on predictive biomarker testing. These advancements aim to standardize diagnostic and treatment protocols, ultimately improving patient outcomes in the era of precision medicine.
What is legal and illegal crime?
5 answers
Legal and illegal crime represent a continuum of activities involving legal and illegal income generation, influenced by various factors such as punishment costs, job opportunities, and personal preferences. Illegal markets, unlike legal ones, involve the exchange of goods or services that violate established legal provisions, accumulating significant financial assets and playing a crucial role in organized crime. The interplay between legal and illegal activities is evident in the overlap where individuals engage in both legal work and crime, driven by factors like low wages and harsh conditions in legal employment. The relationship between legal business, politics, and eco crime highlights the complex intertwining of legal and illegal spheres, emphasizing the need for understanding and addressing the impact of illegal activities on society and the environment.
What are some successful case studies of modular integrated construction projects in the public sector of Hong Kong?
9 answers
Hong Kong has witnessed several successful case studies of Modular Integrated Construction (MiC) projects in the public sector, showcasing the innovative approach's effectiveness in addressing housing shortages, enhancing construction efficiency, and responding to emergency healthcare needs. One notable example is the integration of 'wet' markets into the infrastructure of public housing estates through modularization, reflecting a significant shift in addressing food hygiene, health, and social order within the colonial context of Hong Kong. This project highlighted the adaptability of modular construction to meet specific community needs while incorporating cultural practices. Another significant project involved the construction of high-rise living quarters for firefighters, utilizing 3726 factory-made concrete modules. This development not only marked the first high-rise concrete building project to adopt MiC in the region but also demonstrated the method's efficiency and sustainability. The rapid construction of a temporary 1000-bed hospital and a 10,000-bed isolation and treatment facility during the Covid-19 pandemic in February 2022 further exemplifies MiC's potential. Achieved in just 51 days on an island site, this project utilized factory-made modules and introduced new modular construction technologies, showcasing MiC's capability in emergency response and healthcare facility delivery. Additionally, the use of MiC for delivering healthcare facilities during the pandemic demonstrated significant improvements in time and cost efficiency compared to conventional construction practices, highlighting the method's effectiveness in emergency healthcare building project delivery. These case studies underscore the versatility, efficiency, and sustainability of MiC in the public sector of Hong Kong, addressing a range of needs from housing and infrastructure to emergency healthcare facilities, and setting a precedent for future modular construction projects.