scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Is UN successful in promoting pEACE AND SECURITY? 

Best insight from top research papers

The United Nations (UN) faces challenges in promoting peace and security despite some successes. The UN's peace operations are increasingly involved in countries affected by terrorism, necessitating adaptation without compromising doctrine . While the UN has made progress in integrating human security priorities, challenges persist in effectively implementing peacekeeping operations due to political, economic, and societal factors . Critics argue that the UN has failed in promoting security and stability, attributing this to the inherent violence in the international system and states pursuing their national interests . The success of UN peacekeeping operations hinges on the commitment of superpowers to resolving conflicts without self-interest, as seen in the case of the Democratic Republic of Congo . Ultimately, the UN's effectiveness in promoting peace and security depends on addressing these challenges and fostering genuine commitment from key stakeholders.

Answers from top 5 papers

More filters
Papers (5)Insight
UN peacekeeping missions have been successful in promoting peace in conflict regions, but face challenges hindering full effectiveness due to political, economic, and societal factors.
The United Nations has failed in promoting security and stability, as highlighted in the paper. It discusses the organization's shortcomings in maintaining peace and fostering international security.
The UN has made progress in promoting peace and security through initiatives like the protection of civilians agenda, as seen in missions in Haiti, reflecting human security priorities.
The UN aims to enhance peace operations by integrating counterterrorism and violent extremism measures, focusing on analysis, dialogue, early warning, partnerships, and staff training to address security challenges effectively.
The success of UN peacekeeping missions depends on superpowers' genuine commitment without self-interest, potentially ensuring peace and security in conflict zones like the Democratic Republic of Congo.

Related Questions

4. To what extent has the United Nations been effective as a peace guardian?5 answersThe effectiveness of the United Nations (UN) as a peace guardian has been a subject of scrutiny. While the UN was founded to promote global peace, its peace operations have faced challenges in adapting to the evolving international security landscape. The UN Security Council's (UN SC) performance in safeguarding international peace post-Cold War has been questioned due to inconsistent responses to threats. Research suggests that UN peacekeeping missions deployed with larger armed troops are more successful in reducing violence in civil wars, highlighting the importance of appropriate composition. Criticisms of the UN's structure, particularly the Security Council's permanent membership and veto rights, have raised concerns about decision-making processes and effectiveness in maintaining peace. Overall, while the UN plays a crucial role in peacekeeping, there are ongoing challenges that impact its effectiveness as a peace guardian.
How effective are peace operations in reducing armed conflict and fostering peace?10 answersPeace operations have emerged as a resilient and multifaceted international institution for managing armed conflict, demonstrating a capacity to adapt and respond to the complexities of modern warfare and peacebuilding efforts. Their effectiveness, however, varies across different dimensions and contexts. For instance, the AU-EU cooperation in the Central African Republic in 2013 exemplifies how inter-organizational peace operations can be effective through resource exchange, convergence of organizational goals, and acting within a supportive conflict setting. Despite these successes, the direct impact of UN peacekeeping troops on fostering negotiations during civil wars has been questioned, with findings suggesting that their presence alone, without considering the tactics of rebels, may not be sufficient to induce non-violent engagements. The deployment of peacekeepers to areas of violence within missions has shown potential in preventing bloodshed, although this evidence is contingent and calls for a nuanced understanding of peacekeeping operations and their components. The historical role of UN peace operations since 1948 highlights their significant contribution to international peace and security, despite ongoing debates about their geopolitical purposes and effectiveness. Civilian components of peacekeeping have been shown to play a crucial role in reducing battle-related deaths by strengthening local livelihoods and state institutions, and peace operations have also been found to mitigate the adverse effects of conflict on malnutrition and food insecurity. However, the effectiveness of peace operations in mediating national peace agreements in contexts with incohesive belligerents has been challenged, suggesting a need for more inclusive and decentralized negotiation processes. The evolving concepts and practices of peace operations reflect broader debates about their ability to protect civilians and transform the global system. Lastly, the involvement of UN peace operations in the political economy of conflict-affected states underscores the complex challenges they face in addressing the root causes of conflict. Overall, while peace operations have demonstrated effectiveness in certain areas, their success is highly dependent on the specific conflict context, the strategies employed, and the integration of both military and civilian efforts.
How effective are UN organisations such as WHO?4 answersUN organizations such as the World Health Organization (WHO) have been subject to analysis regarding their effectiveness. Criticisms and strengths of the WHO have been weighed in various aspects, including structure, composition, funding, and response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The WHO's authority based on international law has been effective in mitigating the spread of COVID-19. The WHO's power and influence have been compared to that of the United Nations (UN) Security Council, with the WHO being seen as more influential in issuing health advisories. However, the WHO is no longer the sole major player in international health, with other UN organizations such as UNICEF, the World Bank, UNFPA, and UNDP also playing active roles. The effectiveness of UN organizations, including the WHO, can be improved by defining clear mandates and considering comparative advantages.
How effective is UN Peacekeeping?4 answersUN peacekeeping has been historically effective, but currently suffers from a trust deficit. The absence of a viable political or peace process in contemporary peacekeeping operations creates a stabilization dilemma, prolonging conflicts and embedding peacekeeping in the local political economy. The process leading to the deployment of peacekeeping operations can increase violence levels in a pre-operation environment, as conflict actors seek to improve their relative positions through violence. The UN engages in combat fairly frequently, and the challenge lies in calibrating force and politics to ensure combat power is harnessed to viable political strategies for peace. Peacekeepers increase individuals' willingness to cooperate and reduce violence, particularly among those who hold low esteem for other groups and institutions and have frequent contact with peacekeepers. Increasing UN military personnel deployed to a conflict significantly reduces violence against civilians and mitigates battle-related violence, while smaller missions and observer missions are not associated with reduced violence.
How has the UNSC failed to act on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?5 answersThe UNSC has failed to act on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict due to several factors. Firstly, the influence of superpowers such as the US has hindered the UN's ability to resolve the conflict. Additionally, there has been a lack of reference to international law and an emphasis on asymmetrical negotiations between the two parties, which has impeded progress. Furthermore, the parochial interests of the permanent members of the UNSC, combined with normative considerations and concerns for the Council's organizational mission, have constrained the agenda-setting speed and decision-making process. This has resulted in a failure to effectively address the conflict and find a just and lasting peace. The UNSC's inability to take decisive action on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has raised questions about its legitimacy and effectiveness in resolving conflicts.
How effective is the UN in achieving peace?5 answersThe effectiveness of the UN in achieving peace is a topic of debate. Some studies suggest that the UN plays a vital role in promoting global peace and maintaining health and safety. However, there are concerns about the effectiveness of international instruments for conflict resolution and the recurrence of violence in countries where the UN has intervened. The structure and operation of the UN, particularly the Security Council's permanent membership and veto power, have been criticized for hindering decision-making processes. While the UN's peacekeeping operations have been successful in managing conflicts and establishing peace in many parts of the world, there are issues and challenges that negatively impact their efficiency and effectiveness. Overall, the UN's efforts to achieve peace have had both successes and failures.

See what other people are reading

ESSENTIAL SECURITY INTERESTS IN INVESTMENT ARBITRATION Should ESI clauses in BITs be interpreted as per customary international law?
5 answers
ESSENTIAL SECURITY INTERESTS IN INVESTMENT ARBITRATION: ESI clauses in Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs) should be interpreted in alignment with customary international law. The interpretation of these clauses has been a contentious issue, especially in cases like those involving Argentina's emergency measures during financial crises. The indeterminate language in BIT provisions often leads to reliance on customary international law for clarity, sparking debates on the relationship between necessity defenses under customary law and specific treaty agreements. The evolving concept of security, encompassing economic and environmental aspects alongside traditional military concerns, further complicates the scope of security measures in investment law. Harmonizing ESI interpretations with customary law can provide a more predictable framework, ensuring the protection of essential security interests while balancing the rights of foreign investors.
Issues of security in rural areas in nig
5 answers
Security issues in rural areas, particularly in Nigeria, are multifaceted and have significant implications on regional integration and economic stability. Rural banditry in West Africa, including Nigeria, is a resource-based conflict exacerbated by factors like bad governance, poverty, and the disappearance of grazing lands. Financial stability in rural areas is crucial for economic security, necessitating the identification of key financial indicators to assess the economic well-being of these regions. Policing in rural, regional, and remote areas presents unique safety challenges, influenced by factors like distance, isolation, and community dynamics, requiring tailored strategies and policy changes to enhance officer safety and security. Addressing security concerns in rural areas involves not only law enforcement but also economic revitalization efforts to attract young professionals and improve the overall situation in these regions. Media representations of crime in rural Ireland highlight the importance of community engagement and state-led strategies to combat property and violent crimes against older individuals, emphasizing the need for adaptive responses to enhance security perceptions.
What is doctrine in project?
5 answers
A doctrine in a project refers to a set of principles or guidelines that govern the decision-making process and overall framework of the project. In the context of Islamic perspectives, the incorporation of the concepts of maslahah and Maqasid al-Shari’ah into project evaluation frameworks establishes a detailed order of priorities among competing projects, rationalizes choices based on Islamic principles, and ensures alignment with the Islamic system as a whole. Additionally, in urban planning, projects like 'Skopje 2014' can lead to the formation of planning doctrines driven by political ideologies, influencing the spatial and legal aspects of urban renewal initiatives. Understanding and adhering to specific doctrines can guide project development, decision-making, and resource allocation processes in various contexts.
What is the theoretical background of Syrian conflict?
5 answers
The theoretical background of the Syrian conflict encompasses a complex interplay of factors. Neoliberal reforms in Syria, coupled with economic dependence on hydrocarbon resources, exacerbated socio-economic tensions, making the country vulnerable to external influences and leading to a political crisis and civil war. Additionally, the Syrian conflict was influenced by a combination of factors such as climate change, unsustainable government policies, and economic structures that deepened inequality and poverty, ultimately contributing to widespread human insecurity. The pre-conflict Syrian economy struggled with a "low-level equilibrium trap," characterized by insufficient savings, investments, and high demographic growth rates, hindering sustainable development and contributing to the conflict's roots. These various elements highlight the multidimensional nature of the theoretical underpinnings of the Syrian conflict.
What is individual financial security?
5 answers
Individual financial security refers to the ability of a person to maintain a stable and sufficient level of income and assets to cover their expenses and withstand financial shocks. In modern times, the responsibility for financial security has shifted from governments and employers to individuals, emphasizing the importance of personal financial planning and literacy. Factors such as loss of income sources, ineffective financial planning, and health-related disabilities pose significant threats to individual financial security. Enhancing financial literacy and actively working to improve one's understanding of financial matters are crucial steps towards achieving and maintaining individual financial security. Additionally, considering both current and future risks at macro and micro levels is essential for ensuring comprehensive individual security in the face of evolving social and economic landscapes.
What is financial security of people?
5 answers
Financial security refers to a person's confidence in affording present and future needs. It plays a crucial role in psychological well-being and perceptions of meaning in life. Financial security is influenced by factors such as income, debt obligations, and the ability to provide for oneself in case of income loss. Enhancing financial literacy is essential, especially for individuals with mental illness who are less likely to have savings. The concept of financial security extends beyond mere financial stability to include effective money management, asset accumulation, and resilience against economic uncertainties. Research emphasizes the importance of addressing financial security through community and economic development activities to promote overall welfare. Ultimately, financial security ensures a stable standard of living and contributes significantly to individual and collective well-being.
What is the defenition of financial security?
5 answers
Financial security refers to the protection of financial resources from threats and risks, ensuring stability and efficiency in economic activities. It is a crucial component of overall security systems, including military, banking, and enterprise security. Financial security involves strategies to mitigate internal and external risks, such as unbalanced asset-liability structures, competition, and market instability. This protection encompasses the rational use of financial resources, cost reduction, and improvement of financial indicators to maintain stability and prevent bankruptcy. Implementing a systematic approach and management mechanisms are essential for creating and maintaining financial security in various sectors, including businesses, banks, and the state.
What is financial security?
5 answers
Financial security encompasses the ability of a country or an enterprise to effectively manage, preserve, and utilize financial resources to ensure stability, development, and protection against threats. It is a vital component of economic security, influencing the overall socio-economic progress and defense capability of a nation. Financial security involves a complex network of interconnected elements aimed at stabilizing socio-economic development, maintaining stability, and upholding financial obligations. Threats to financial security include deficits in state budgets, economic crime, low financial culture, and insufficient development of financial markets. Effective management of financial security involves strategies to mitigate threats, such as forming comprehensive enterprise management strategies that include financial security management. Ultimately, financial security plays a crucial role in ensuring the resilience and prosperity of both nations and businesses.
To what extent has the UN been effective as a peace guardian?
5 answers
The effectiveness of the United Nations (UN) as a peace guardian has been a topic of debate. While the UN was founded to promote global peace, its peace operations have faced challenges in adapting to the changing international security landscape. The UN Security Council's (UNSC) performance in safeguarding international peace post-Cold War has been questioned due to inconsistent responses to threats. UN peacekeeping missions have evolved from solely peacekeeping to managing ongoing violence in active conflicts, with armed troops being more effective in reducing combat hostilities. To enhance its role as a peace guardian, the UN must address issues such as politicization within the UNSC and ensure that peace operations are appropriately composed to effectively reduce human suffering.
What is meant by Retrived from?
5 answers
"Retrieved from" typically refers to the action of obtaining or accessing information, files, or web pages from a specific source or location. In the context of the provided abstracts, "retrieved from" is mentioned in the context of accessing information from databases like Revenant for resurrected proteins, analyzing the performance of coated hip implants in humans after retrieval from failed cases, and refinding information based on previous access context using a system called Regainer. The term "retrieved from" signifies the process of obtaining specific data or materials from a known or specified origin, which is crucial in various fields like protein research, medical device analysis, and information retrieval systems.
How does innovation leads to decrease in cost?
4 answers
Innovation plays a crucial role in reducing costs across various sectors. By implementing innovative approaches, organizations can achieve significant cost reductions while maintaining or even improving product quality and competitiveness. For instance, a study in a metal mechanical industry demonstrated a 68% reduction in production costs and a 32% decrease in logistics costs through innovative product design. Similarly, in the food industry, embracing resource-saving technologies and lean manufacturing can lead to cost reductions and increased profitability. Moreover, firms with higher levels of innovation output tend to enjoy lower costs of funds, as innovation attracts investors and reduces the cost of equity and debt, especially in countries with developed financial markets and effective legal systems. Overall, innovation drives efficiency, enhances productivity, and ultimately leads to cost savings in various aspects of business operations.