scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

What are the arguments for and against the existence of market efficiency? 


Best insight from top research papers

The arguments for and against the existence of market efficiency are debated in the literature. Some argue that markets are inherently efficient, meaning that stock prices accurately reflect all available information . This efficient market hypothesis (EMH) has been extensively tested and is one of the most widely studied theories in financial economics . On the other hand, there are researchers who assert that markets are inherently inefficient and do not support the EMH theory . They argue that it is possible to consistently outperform the market and that established trends can be used to predict future market performance . Additionally, studies have shown that shocks to funding liquidity, hedge fund assets under management, and algorithmic trading can significantly impact market efficiency . Overall, the debate on market efficiency continues, with ongoing research exploring and clarifying the relationship between markets and information .

Answers from top 3 papers

More filters
Papers (3)Insight
The paper discusses arguments for and against market efficiency, but does not provide a clear conclusion.
Open accessJournal ArticleDOI
David Peterson, Aaron Panofsky 
4 Citations
The provided paper is about arguments against efficiency in science, not market efficiency. Therefore, the paper does not provide any information about the arguments for or against the existence of market efficiency.
The provided paper does not explicitly discuss the arguments for and against the existence of market efficiency.

Related Questions

What is market efficiency?5 answersMarket efficiency refers to the degree to which prices in financial markets reflect all available information. It is a measure of how quickly and accurately prices adjust to new information. Efficient markets are characterized by random price movements and the absence of predictable patterns that can be exploited for consistent profits. However, studies have shown that markets may not always be efficient, leading to price anomalies. The efficiency of markets is important for companies to develop effective market policies and optimize resources. The concept of market efficiency is closely related to risk and risk aversion. While there is evidence of market efficiency, its dynamics and collective aspects are not well understood. Overall, market efficiency is a key concept in finance that influences trading strategies, the behavior of stock prices, and the effectiveness of market policies.
How can we measure market efficiency?3 answersMarket efficiency can be measured using various tools and approaches. One proposed tool is the Financial Market Efficiency Index (FMEI), which assesses and compares market efficiency based on qualitative growth and market efficiency. Another approach is to use the Shannon entropy, a tool from information theory, applied to a symbolic representation of price returns in a time series. This allows for the determination of the amount of information contained in the series and the development of a statistical test of market efficiency. The approximate entropy approach is also used to measure stock market efficiency, taking into account global, regional, and domestic economic factors. A new market efficiency measure has been developed to analyze efficiency dynamics over quantile levels, revealing differences in efficiency across different market conditions and regions. Additionally, a simple measure has been constructed to quantify market efficiency, allowing for easy comparisons across assets, time, regions, and data frequencies.
How the empirical evidence support the market efficiency?4 answersEmpirical evidence from the provided abstracts supports the market efficiency in different contexts. The study by Ahmad et al.analyzes the financial effectiveness of listed companies in the Indian stock market and concludes that efficiency is an indicator of support for investment decision-making. Elangovan et al.find that the Indian stock market is weak-form inefficient, suggesting that abnormal returns can be achieved by beating the market. Yi et al.examine the Bitcoin market and find that it satisfies the weak-form efficient market hypothesis, implying that speculators may face difficulty in exploiting profitable trading strategies. Khurram et al.conclude that there is mixed evidence regarding the market efficiency of D-8 equity markets, indicating the presence of arbitrage opportunities. Ahmed and Hossainfind that the weekly returns of selected Asian markets do not follow a random walk, suggesting the possibility of gaining arbitrage profit.
What are the main arguments against the theory of adaptive efficiency of markets?5 answersThe main arguments against the theory of adaptive efficiency of markets are that the efficient markets hypothesis (EMH) states that market prices incorporate all information rationally and instantaneously. However, proponents of behavioral finance argue that markets are not rational, but are driven by fear and greed. They believe that market efficiency is challenged by behavioral biases such as loss aversion, overconfidence, overreaction, and mental accounting. The adaptive markets hypothesis (AMH) reconciles market efficiency with behavioral alternatives by applying the principles of evolution to financial interactions. It suggests that market efficiency is related to environmental factors such as the number of competitors, profit opportunities, and adaptability of market participants. The AMH argues that these behavioral biases are consistent with an evolutionary model of individuals adapting to a changing environment via simple heuristics.
What are the criticisms of Fama and French's concept of market efficiency?5 answersFama and French's concept of market efficiency has faced criticisms in the literature. One criticism is that the assumption of constant equilibrium expected excess returns is rejected for both the French and German stock markets. Another criticism is that the French stock market exhibits periods of both efficiency and inefficiency, which coincide with major macroeconomic events. Additionally, the relationship between stock returns and Fama-French risk factors in the French stock market depends significantly on the considered time horizon. Furthermore, there is evidence that sentiment measures, such as the implied volatility index and investment advisor sentiment, have weak impacts on risk premia, but there are strong feedback effects where these sentiments are led by risk premia. Finally, factor premia have strong dynamic effects on sentiment measures, while the reverse effect is weak and only contemporaneous.
What are the implications of the Bitcoin market efficiency?5 answersThe efficiency of the Bitcoin market has several implications. Firstly, the market is found to be more inefficient compared to gold, stock, and currency markets, as it exhibits stronger long-memory features and multifractality. Secondly, Bitcoin has become more efficient over time in relation to its own events, but it is not affected by monetary policy news, indicating the absence of control on Bitcoin. Additionally, the efficiency of the Bitcoin market changes over time, with the market being more efficient during downward periods. The market also exhibits a persistent long memory phenomenon in its short-term components, suggesting possible speculation by investors. These findings are important for investors and policymakers, as they highlight the unique characteristics and behavior of the Bitcoin market, which is not influenced by traditional monetary policies and exhibits time-varying efficiency levels.

See what other people are reading

How does learning delivery affect financial problem towards learning?
5 answers
Learning delivery can have an impact on financial problems in education. For example, the full-time MBA program at Ohio University uses a problem-based learning approach to deliver accounting competencies, which is also applied in the undergraduate program. In the context of an artificial financial market, the relationship between liquidity and prices is studied, showing that the parameters defining the learning process affect price dynamics through their impact on market liquidity variability. Additionally, a deep learning-based solution is used to minimize the cost of restaurant dispatching, resulting in savings of up to 43.8%. Furthermore, a learning content delivery system is designed to provide customized learning content to users based on their device attributes, enhancing the learning experience. These examples demonstrate how different learning delivery approaches can influence financial aspects in education.
When will fully autonomus cars be available for public sale?
5 answers
Fully autonomous cars are expected to be available for public sale in the next few years, with some models potentially hitting the market as early as 2018. The industry consensus is that autonomous driving will be widely available by 2020. By 2035, sales of autonomous vehicles are projected to reach 95.4 million annually, representing 75% of all light-duty vehicle sales.
Informed Trading in Stock and Option Markets?
4 answers
Informed trading occurs in both the stock and options markets. Options trading contributes to price discovery in the underlying stock market, indicating an important informational role for options. Informed traders are attracted to out-of-the-money options due to higher liquidity, lower premiums, and higher delta-to-premium ratios. Activist investors trade in both stocks and options, with stock trading being more prevalent. When activists accumulate shares, option implied volatility decreases and volatility skew increases, suggesting that informed trading in the stock market contributes to the flow of volatility information into option prices. The return predictability of options volume is concentrated in stocks with steep volatility smirks.
Option theory derivatives markets?
5 answers
Options theory in derivative markets is studied by Robert A. Jarrow. He examines the impact of derivative security markets on market manipulation in a large trader economy. Jarrow shows that the introduction of derivative securities can generate market manipulation trading strategies that would not exist otherwise. However, he provides a condition on the price process that prevents additional market manipulation trading strategies from being introduced. Under this condition, Jarrow demonstrates that the standard binomial option model still applies, but with random volatilities.
What are the best practices for selling chocolate online?
3 answers
Online markets for chocolate are growing rapidly, and pricing strategies play a major role in the competitive strategies of multichannel suppliers and pure online traders in this sector. However, there is no evidence of price homogeneity or frequent price adjustments in the German online chocolate market. Psychographic segmentation has been found to be effective in designing marketing strategies for indulgence products like chocolate. The design of e-commerce applications, such as an electronic sales information system, can help improve turnover and expand product marketing in the chocolate sales industry. Overall, the best practices for selling chocolate online involve implementing effective pricing strategies, utilizing psychographic segmentation, and utilizing e-commerce applications to enhance sales and marketing efforts.
Do stock market prices exhibit long-range dependence?
5 answers
Stock market prices exhibit long-range dependence. Empirical investigations in the Indian stock market show significant long-range dependence in both major indices and individual stocks, rejecting the notion of weak form efficiency. The Indian stock market has a high degree of persistence, indicating long memory. Studies on European stock markets also find time-varying long-range dependence, particularly during major financial disruptions. Analysis of the Indian stock market prices using long-range dependence techniques supports the existence of nonstationarity and high persistence, with a mean shift in the data. Additionally, the performance of stock price predictions is influenced by the long-range correlation, with better predictions observed for strongly anti-persistent time series. Overall, the evidence suggests that stock market prices do exhibit long-range dependence.
What are the different debt instruments in debt capital markets?
5 answers
Debt capital markets consist of various debt instruments. These include money market instruments such as Treasury bills, federal agency notes, certificates of deposit, commercial papers, and repurchase agreements. Coupon bonds and their derivatives are also important debt instruments. Governments borrow from a range of creditors, including commercial banks, sovereign bondholders, official bilateral creditors, and multilateral financial institutions. European capital markets include a wide variety of debt instruments issued by institutions and corporations, such as asset-backed securities. Debt financial instruments are also used in public-private partnership projects, including bank credit resources, syndicated lending, and debt securities like infrastructure bonds.
How can liquidity be measured?
3 answers
Liquidity can be measured using a variety of measures and proxies. These measures capture different aspects and dimensions of liquidity. Some commonly used measures include transaction cost, volume, price impact, and multidimension-based measures. Researchers have developed new measures and adapted existing ones to different markets using high frequency databases. Liquidity can also be measured using low-frequency measures, which are divided into categories such as transaction cost, volume, price impact, and multidimension-based measures. Intraday data allows for more comprehensive measurements of liquidity and is used to describe the characteristics and performance of a capital market. Liquidity is important for market development and can be measured using trade-based or order-based approaches. Different measures of liquidity have been compared against liquidity benchmarks, such as effective spread, realized spread, and price impact, with new effective/realized spread measures performing well.
What is a Market?
3 answers
A market can be described as a forum of exchange where buyers and sellers meet physically or through interconnected exchange networks. It requires a legal-institutional framework that respects property rights. The traditional focus of economics on markets as abstract price-making mechanisms has neglected the influence of the legal-institutional framework. However, the field of New Institutional Economics seeks to address this issue by studying the interrelation between markets and the law. Despite the different perspectives and experiences of various actors, a market can be understood as the internal environment of the economic system, where communication of exchange and observation of competitors blend into each other and crystallize in prices. Michel Callon distinguishes between a market and a marketplace, with the former referring to the abstract mechanism of supply and demand, and the latter representing the place where exchange occurs. Market definition is a tool for identifying market power, but it cannot resolve the ambiguity in what analysts mean by market power.
What is joint hypothesis deal with market efficiency?
4 answers
The joint hypothesis in the context of market efficiency refers to the idea that testing for market efficiency requires the use of asset pricing models. Market efficiency cannot be directly tested, so we need to compare real returns with expected returns predicted by a specific pricing model. The efficient markets hypothesis has been traditionally tested using the joint-hypothesis problem, which has limitations. However, a mathematical theory called market connectivity provides new methods for testing market efficiency without suffering from the joint-hypothesis problem. Different interpretations of market efficiency include rational expectations, constant expected returns, and similarity to prices in the absence of frictions. The weak form of the Market Efficiency Hypothesis (MEH) assumes that stock prices already reflect all available past information, making it impossible to achieve abnormal long-term returns.
What are the best practices for commercializing new technologies?
4 answers
The best practices for commercializing new technologies involve several factors. Firstly, having a team with different personalities and characteristics, such as inventor/innovator, investor, technology, and entrepreneur, is crucial for success in technology development and commercialization. Secondly, the application of lean/agile methodology can be beneficial in commercialization activities, as it focuses on eliminating waste and improving production and organization strategies. Additionally, conducting pre-test market surveys using appropriate methodologies, such as SWOT analysis and 2-stage surveys, can help in determining the market readiness and potential improvements for new products with new technology. Finally, research-industry collaboration and continuous production of superior products to meet customer needs are essential for successful commercialization.