Why is it important to evaluate a health promotion policy?
Answers from top 12 papers
More filters
| Papers (12) | Insight |
|---|---|
| These factors are potentially amenable to health promotion interventions. | |
| The author argues that health promotion models are being used by professionals purely to achieve targets and, as a consequence, important information on clients' socio-economic circumstances is being ignored. | |
21 Citations | It is argued that programmes, large-scale campaigns and public policy should be anchored more firmly in basic research, but that there are inevitable incompatibilities between maximal validity and ideal generality of behavioural research in health promotion. |
25 Citations | Advocacy is vital to ensure health promotion is better resourced and prioritized by policy makers. |
79 Citations | The direction of health promotion research and policy is, therefore, caught in the bureaucratic logic of "trapped administrators", and results in contradictory emphases on problems like the development of "health promotion indicators", which show little result in informing a broader but coherent conceptualization of health, let alone in effecting change in health policy and outcomes. |
| To illustrate this premise, available evidence is presented that suggests that the use of “health promotion” by the proprietary sector, as well as the commercialization of health promotion, is creating decision-making processes that are not accountable to those whom they affect. | |
| This approach is especially appropriate for the field of health promotion given emerging ideas and the congruency between the underlying values of responsive evaluation and health promotion. | |
42 Citations | For example, these findings explain why some organizations are more or less likely to adopt health promotion programs. |
19 Citations | RESULTS There have been a plethora of policy and strategy documents over the last decade relevant to PHC, and these suggest an intention to strengthen health promotion. |
20 Citations | Further, the study demonstrates the utility of comparing different data sources when assessing a population-wide change in health promotion policy. |
| It is useful as a framework for devising health promotion strategies and activities. | |
41 Citations | In conclusion, the paper encourages further research to investigate the effectiveness of health-promoting policy strategies within a multilevel health promotion framework. |
Related Questions
What are the positives and challenges of policy evaluation in developing countries?5 answersPolicy evaluation in developing countries presents both positives and challenges. Positives include the potential for quantitative assessment of impact on development investments, the aim to improve data efficiency while maintaining unbiasedness in Monte Carlo methods, and the focus on addressing societal problems through targeted interventions. Challenges involve the complexity of assessing program effectiveness and value for money, requiring adequate economic modeling tools and decision-making processes. Additionally, factors like non-linear information processing costs and political bias in program selection can distort evidence and policy choices during implementation at scale in less-developed countries. These challenges highlight the need for rigorous evaluation methods and evidence-based policy approaches in the context of developing countries.
What are the positives of policy evaluation in developing countries?4 answersPolicy evaluation in developing countries offers a valuable means to assess the effectiveness of interventions and support learning and adaptive management within research programs. It focuses on outcomes, causes, and impacts, aiding in understanding what works, for whom, and under which circumstances. By utilizing frameworks like principal-agent concepts, policy evaluation can enhance the responsiveness of policies to poverty reduction efforts, potentially benefiting the poor. Additionally, evaluation methods like discrete choice dynamic programming (DCDP) provide a robust framework for assessing policies relevant to developing countries, such as those aimed at reducing child labor, improving school attendance, and fostering small-business investment. Overall, policy evaluation in developing countries plays a crucial role in enhancing the quality, effectiveness, and societal impact of interventions, contributing to informed decision-making and sustainable development.
What is policy evaluation?4 answersPolicy evaluation is the process of assessing and analyzing governmental policies to determine their effectiveness, efficiency, and impact. It involves evaluating the goals of the policies and determining the best way to achieve them, as well as evaluating decisions before they are made and across different places and times. Policy evaluation is a strategy used in public governance to provide retrospective assessments of government measures and inform decision-making. It aims to distinguish between worthwhile and useless policies and to steer future actions in a better direction. Evaluation policies are rules or principles that guide organizations in conducting evaluations, and every entity engaged in evaluation has them. The field of policy evaluation examines various models and approaches, including internal and external evaluation, impact assessment, and process evaluation.
How can policy evaluation studies help policy makers?4 answersPolicy evaluation studies can help policy makers in several ways. Firstly, these studies provide information on the performance of policy programs, including both process and result, which is essential for assessing their effectiveness. Secondly, evaluation studies can emphasize learning from all studies rather than just identifying winners and losers, allowing policy makers to gain insights from a broader range of evidence. Thirdly, these studies can collect information on the conditions that shape the success or failure of interventions, helping policy makers understand the factors that influence program effectiveness. Additionally, policy evaluation studies can provide policy makers with a broader perspective on the impacts and effectiveness of policies, enabling them to make more informed decisions. By commissioning and coordinating groups of studies and sharing data, policy makers can benefit from larger, longer-term, and more holistic evaluations that address overarching themes. Overall, policy evaluation studies can provide policy makers with valuable information and insights to inform their decision-making processes.
How are policies evaluated?5 answersPolicies are evaluated using various methods. One approach is to learn a single value function that can evaluate and improve multiple policies represented by deep neural networks (NN). This method involves learning a small set of "probing states" and a mapping from actions produced in these states to the policy's return. By changing actions in these probing states, the policy can be improved following the gradient of the value function's predictions. Another method involves adaptively weighting observations to control the variance of doubly robust (DR) estimators used for policy evaluation. This improved estimator allows for the formation of confidence intervals and hypothesis testing. Additionally, a policy evaluation device can compare the control policy of a group to be evaluated with other control policies and generate evaluation information based on the comparison result.
How do democratic policy evaluation?2 answersDemocratic policy evaluation involves the use of evaluations in democratic processes to assess the impact of policies on governance and decision-making. Evaluations can be utilized beyond expert utilization, with parliamentarians showing familiarity with evaluations and their inclusion in policy arguments enhancing the deliberative quality of democratic campaigns. The interrelation between democracy and policy evaluation is well compatible, as evaluations can help manage threats to democracy, promote democratic renewal, and address the mediatisation of public policy and governance. Coherent and systematic evaluation is needed at all phases of the policy cycle, including formulation, implementation, and accountability. Policy evaluations can be conducted and subsequently utilized to inform political decision-making processes in various policy sectors, such as environment, health insurance, education, economic development, industrial relations, energy, child support, and housing.