scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Showing papers on "Shielding gas published in 2010"


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the effect of metal vapour on the distributions of temperature, current density and heat flux in arcs is examined in terms of these thermophysical properties, and different approaches to treat diffusion of metal vapor in plasmas, and the production of vapour from molten metal, are compared.
Abstract: Metal vapour is formed in arc welding processes by the evaporation of molten metal in the weld pool, and in the case of gas–metal arc welding, in the wire electrode and droplets. The presence of metal vapour can have a major influence on the properties of the arc and the size and shape of the weld pool. Previous experimental and computational works on the production and transport of metal vapour in welding arcs, in particular those relevant to gas–metal arc welding and gas–tungsten arc welding, are reviewed. The influence of metal vapour on the thermodynamic, transport and radiative properties of plasmas is discussed. The effect of metal vapour on the distributions of temperature, current density and heat flux in arcs is examined in terms of these thermophysical properties. Different approaches to treating diffusion of metal vapour in plasmas, and the production of vapour from molten metal, are compared. The production of welding fume by the nucleation and subsequent condensation of metal vapour is considered. Recommendations are presented about subjects requiring further investigation, and the requirements for accurate computational modelling of welding arcs.

230 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The behavior and effect of a plasma plume on the weld penetration are greatly different between CO2 laser welding and YAG, disk or fiber laser welding as discussed by the authors, and the effects of the power and the power density on the welding penetration are elucidated.

188 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, a computational model of the argon arc plasma in gas-metal arc welding (GMAW) that includes the influence of metal vapour from the electrode is presented, and the occurrence of a central minimum in the radial distributions of temperature and current density is demonstrated.
Abstract: A computational model of the argon arc plasma in gas‐metal arc welding (GMAW) that includes the influence of metal vapour from the electrode is presented. The occurrence of a central minimum in the radial distributions of temperature and current density is demonstrated. This is in agreement with some recent measurements of arc temperatures in GMAW, but contradicts other measurements and also the predictions of previous models, which do not take metal vapour into account. It is shown that the central minimum is a consequence of the strong radiative emission from the metal vapour. Other effects of the metal vapour, such as the flux of relatively cold vapour from the electrode and the increased electrical conductivity, are found to be less significant. The different effects of metal vapour in gas‐tungsten arc welding and GMAW are explained.

110 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, a gas tungsten arc (GTA) was modelled taking into account the contamination of the plasma by metal vapour from the molten anode, and a viscosity approximation was used to express the diffusion coefficient.
Abstract: A gas tungsten arc (GTA) was modelled taking into account the contamination of the plasma by metal vapour from the molten anode. The whole region of GTA atmosphere including the tungsten cathode, the arc plasma and the anode was treated using a unified numerical model. A viscosity approximation was used to express the diffusion coefficient in terms of viscosity of the shielding gas and metal vapour. The transient two-dimensional distributions of temperature, velocity of plasma flow and iron vapour concentration were predicted, together with the molten pool as a function of time for a 150 A arc current at atmospheric pressure, both for helium and argon gases. It was shown that the thermal plasma in the GTA was influenced by iron vapour from the molten pool surface and that the concentration of iron vapour in the plasma was dependent on the temperature of the molten pool.GTA on high sulfur stainless steel was calculated to discuss the differences between a low sulfur and a high sulfur stainless steel anode. Helium was selected as the shielding gas because a helium GTA produces more metal vapour than an argon GTA. In the GTA on a high sulfur stainless steel anode, iron vapour and current path were constricted. Radiative emission density in the GTA on high sulfur stainless steel was also concentrated in the centre area of the arc plasma together with the iron vapour although the temperature distributions were almost the same as that in the case of a low sulfur stainless steel anode.

105 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the effects of shielding gas compositions on transport phenomena in the metal are reported which include the transient processes of electrode melting; droplet formation, detachment, transfer and impingement onto the workpiece; weld pool dynamics and weld bead formation.

78 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the influence of metal vapour on the arc behavior during the arc-splitting process in the quenching chamber of a lowvoltage circuit breaker is investigated numerically.
Abstract: The influence of metal vapour on the arc behaviour during the arc-splitting process in the quenching chamber of a low-voltage circuit breaker is investigated numerically. A three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic model of air arc plasma, taking into account the production of metal vapour from erosion of an iron splitter plate, is developed. An equation describing conservation of the iron vapour mass is added to the standard mass, momentum and energy conservation equations. The influence of the iron vapour on the thermodynamic and transport properties of the gas mixture is considered. The arc voltage, distributions of temperature, gas flow and mass fraction of iron vapour in the arc chamber are calculated. The formation of new arc roots on the splitter plate is examined. The simulation results indicate that this is strongly influenced by the presence of iron vapour from the splitter plate, due to the increased electrical conductivity in the arc root formation region. The consequences of this are dramatic. The presence of metal vapour causes the arc to attach first to the cathode side of the splitter plate, and electromagnetic forces then cause the arc on this side to move more rapidly than the arc on the anode side. The opposite occurs if metal vapour is neglected. High-speed photography of arc motion is used to confirm the arc motion predicted in the presence of metal vapour. Further, the calculated arc voltage taking into account metal vapour is lower than that calculated neglecting metal vapour, because of the increased electrical conductivity, and agrees much better with the measured voltage.

75 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the effects of shielding gas, heat input and post-weld heat treatment on the microstructural evolution and wear resistance of a modified AISI H13 martensitic tool steel deposited by semi-automatic gas shielded arc welding process using a tubular metal-cored wire, were studied.

60 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, microstructural changes occur in ferritic and duplex stainless steels when heat input is controlled by welding parameters, and they were identified and examined using optical metallographic methods.

60 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the impact of tool material and geometry, tool tilt angle, cooling system and shielding gas effects on macrostructure, microstructure and mechanical properties of pure titanium weld joint were investigated.
Abstract: Friction stir welding (FSW) parameters, such as tool material, tool geometry, tilt angle, tool rotational speed, welding speed, and axial force play a major role in the weld quality of titanium alloys. Because of excessive erosion, tool material and geometry play the main roles in FSW of titanium alloys. Therefore, in the present work for the first time, tool material and geometry, tool tilt angle, cooling system and shielding gas effects on macrostructure, microstructure, and mechanical properties of pure titanium weld joint were investigated. Result of this research shows that Ti can be joined by the FSW, using a tool with a shoulder made of tungsten (W) and simple pin made of tungsten carbide (WC). The best conditions for welding were use of compressed air as a cooling system, tool tilt angle of 1°, and a stream of Argon as a shielding medium. Investigation on mechanical properties shows that the tensile strength and the yield strength of the welded joint in the best case could be similar to the corresponding strengths of the base metal.

60 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, numerical simulations for the dynamic effects of metal vapour in gas metal arc welding (GMAW) suggest that vapour from the welding droplet at the tip of the welding wire has a significant influence on the plasma properties.
Abstract: Numerical simulations for the dynamic effects of metal vapour in gas metal arc welding (GMAW) suggest that vapour from the welding droplet at the tip of the welding wire has a significant influence on the plasma properties. It is found that for the evaporation rates calculated for arcs in pure argon, the dynamic effects of metal vapour markedly cool down the plasma in the central region of the arc, leading to the formation of a low temperature zone centred on the arc axis, in agreement with experimental measurements in the literature. Radiation effects, omitted in this paper, may produce further cooling of the plasma gas. The results highlight major deficiencies in the common approach to modelling the GMAW process and suggest that accurate description of GMAW must include the influence of metal vapour on the plasma.

56 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: A numerical model of spot pulsed current GTA welding for partially and fully penetrated weld pools is presented in this article, where heat transfer and fluid flow in the weld pool driven by the combination of electromagnetic force, buoyancy force, surface tension gradient and latent heat are included in the model.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: An alternate cleaning process to chemical process of Ti-3Al-25V tube surface by a pulsed fiber laser and welding of the laser-cleaned tubes with end fittings by Pulsed Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW-P) technique is reported in this paper.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, a fume formation model consisting of a heterogeneous condensation model, a homogeneous nucleation model and a coagulation model has been developed and coupled with the GTA or GMA welding model.
Abstract: In order to clarify the fume formation mechanism in arc welding, a quantitative investigation based on the knowledge of interaction among the electrode, arc and weld pool is indispensable. A fume formation model consisting of a heterogeneous condensation model, a homogeneous nucleation model and a coagulation model has been developed and coupled with the GTA or GMA welding model. A series of processes from evaporation of metal vapour to fume formation from the metal vapour was totally investigated by employing this simulation model. The aim of this paper is to visualize the fume formation process and clarify the fume formation mechanism theoretically through a numerical analysis. Furthermore, the reliability of the simulation model was also evaluated through a comparison of the simulation result with the experimental result. As a result, it was found that the size of the secondary particles consisting of small particles with a size of several tens of nanometres reached 300 nm at maximum and the secondary particle was in a U-shaped chain form in helium GTA welding. Furthermore, it was also clarified that most part of the fume was produced in the downstream region of the arc originating from the metal vapour evaporated mainly from the droplet in argon GMA welding. The fume was constituted by particles with a size of several tens of nanometres and had similar characteristics to that of GTA welding. On the other hand, if the metal transfer becomes unstable and the metal vapour near the droplet diffuses directly towards the surroundings of the arc not getting into the plasma flow, the size of the particles reaches several hundred nanometres.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the effect of processing parameters including laser power, welding speed, focal point position, nozzle configuration and protection gas flow was investigated and reported using optical microscopy, morphological analysis and mechanical tests (tensile, hardness).

Journal ArticleDOI
09 Nov 2010-Vacuum
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors present results of computational simulations of tungsten-inert-gas and metal inert-gas welding and show that the shape of the wire electrode has a strong influence on flow velocities in the arc and the pressure and shear stress at the weld pool surface.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, double shielded gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) with pure inert argon as the inner layer shielding and the Ar-CO(2) or CO(2)-active gas as the out layer shielding was investigated.

Journal Article
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors present results of computational simulations of tungsten-inert-gas and metal inert gas welding and show that the geometry and depth of the weld pool depend strongly on the properties of the arc.
Abstract: We present results of computational simulations of tungsten-inert-gas and metal-inert-gas welding. The arc plasma and the electrodes (including the molten weld pool when necessary) are included self-consistently in the computational domain. It is shown, using three examples, that it would be impossible to accurately estimate the boundary conditions on the weld-pool surface without including the arc plasma in the computational domain. First, we show that the shielding gas composition strongly affects the properties of the arc that influence the weld pool: heat flux density, current density, shear stress and arc pressure at the weld-pool surface. Demixing is found to be important in some cases. Second, the vaporization of the weld-pool metal and the diffusion of the metal vapour into the arc plasma are found to decrease the heat flux density and current density to the weld pool. Finally, we show that the shape of the wire electrode in metal-inert-gas welding has a strong influence on flow velocities in the arc and the pressure and shear stress at the weld-pool surface. In each case, we present evidence that the geometry and depth of the weld pool depend strongly on the properties of the arc.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Exposure to welding fumes include multiple Mn species, both soluble and insoluble, and that exposures to Mn species vary with specific processes and shield gases, are concluded.
Abstract: Fumes from a group of gas metal arc welding (GMAW) processes used on stainless steel were generated using three different metal transfer modes and four different shield gases. The objective was to identify and measure manganese (Mn) species in the fumes, and identify processes that are minimal generators of Mn species. The robotic welding system was operated in short-circuit (SC) mode (Ar/CO2 and He/Ar), axial spray (AXS) mode (Ar/O2 and Ar/CO2), and pulsed axial-spray (PAXS) mode (Ar/O2). The fumes were analyzed for Mn by a sequential extraction process followed by inductively coupled plasma–atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES) analysis, and by X-ray diffraction (XRD). Total elemental Mn, iron (Fe), chromium (Cr) and nickel (Ni) were separately measured after aqua regia digestion and ICP-AES analysis. Soluble Mn2+, Fe2+, Fe3+, and Ni2+ in a simple biological buffer (phosphate-buffered saline) were determined at pH 7.2 and 5.0 after 2 h incubation at 37 °C by ion chromatography. Results indicate that Mn was present in soluble form, acid-soluble form, and acid-soluble form after reduction by hydroxylamine, which represents soluble Mn0 and Mn2+ compounds, other Mn2+ compounds, and (Mn3+ and Mn4+) compounds, respectively. The dominant fraction was the acid-soluble Mn2+ fraction, but results varied with the process and shield gas. Soluble Mn mass percent in the fume ranged from 0.2 to 0.9%, acid-soluble Mn2+ compounds ranged from 2.6 to 9.3%, and acid plus reducing agent-soluble (Mn3+ and Mn4+) compounds ranged from 0.6 to 5.1%. Total Mn composition ranged from 7 to 15%. XRD results showed fumes had a crystalline content of 90–99% Fe3O4, and showed evidence of multiple Mn oxides, but overlaps and weak signals limited identification. Small amounts of the Mn2+ in the fume (<0.01 to ∼1% or <0.1 to ∼10 μg ml−1) and Ni2+ (<0.01 to ∼0.2% or <0.1 to ∼2 μg ml−1) ions were found in biological buffer media, but amounts were highly dependent on pH and the welding process. Mn generation rates for the fractions were tabulated, and the influence of ozone is discussed. The conclusions are that exposures to welding fumes include multiple Mn species, both soluble and insoluble, and that exposures to Mn species vary with specific processes and shield gases.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the effects of shielding gas compositions on the transient transport phenomena, including the distributions of temperature, flow velocity, current density, and electromagnetic force in the arc and the metal, and arc pressure in gas metal arc welding of mild steel at a constant current input.
Abstract: This article presents the effects of shielding gas compositions on the transient transport phenomena, including the distributions of temperature, flow velocity, current density, and electromagnetic force in the arc and the metal, and arc pressure in gas metal arc welding of mild steel at a constant current input. The shielding gas considered includes pure argon, 75% Ar, 50% Ar, and 25% Ar with the balance of helium. It is found that the shielding gas composition has significant influences on the arc characteristics; droplet formation, detachment, transfer, and impingement onto the workpiece; and weld pool dynamics and weld bead profile. As helium increases in the shielding gas, the droplet size increases but the droplet detachment frequency decreases. For helium-rich gases, the current converges at the workpiece with a “ring” shape which produces non-Gaussian-like distributions of arc pressure and temperature along the workpiece surface. Detailed explanations to the physics of the very complex but interesting transport phenomena are given.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, a systematic study of the effects of activating flux in the weld morphology, arc profile, and angular distortion and microstructure of two different arc welding processes, namely, Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) and plasma arc welding (PAW), was carried out.
Abstract: A systematic study of the effects of activating flux in the weld morphology, arc profile, and angular distortion and microstructure of two different arc welding processes, namely, Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) and Plasma Arc Welding (PAW), was carried out. The results showed that the activating fluxes affected the penetration capability of arc welding on stainless steel. An increase in energy density resulting from the arc constriction and anode spot reduction enhanced the penetration capability. The Depth/Width (D/W) ratio of the weld played a major role in causing angular distortion of the weldment. Also, changes in the cooling rate, due to different heat source characteristics, influenced the microstructure from the fusion line to the centre of the weld.

Journal ArticleDOI
K. Yamazaki1, Eri Yamamoto1, Keiichi Suzuki1, Fusaki Koshiishi1, S. Tashiro1, M. Tanaka1, K. Nakata1 
TL;DR: In this paper, two colour pyrometry was conducted to obtain the surface temperature of weld pools, in which the weld pool was photographed by a high speed camera during arc welding.
Abstract: In this research, two colour pyrometry was conducted to obtain the surface temperature of weld pools, in which the weld pool was photographed by a high speed camera during arc welding. Two wavelengths (950 and 980 nm) of light in the infrared range were selected from the thermal radiation light emitted from the weld pool at the instant when the arc was extinguished, using an imaging spectroscope. Consequently, in gas tungsten arc welding, it was shown that the surface temperature distribution of a weld pool is affected by the sulphur content in the base metal. It is thought that this temperature distribution is determined by the balance between the driving forces of viscous drag from the cathode jet of plasma and Marangoni surface tension. In gas metal arc welding, it was seen that the surface temperature distribution becomes uniform and the temperature is 1715–1845 K, which is obviously lower than that of the metal droplet.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, laser welding of AISI 904 L super austenitic stainless steel using a diffusion cooled slab 3.5kW CO2 laser and employing two different shielding gases, namely argon and helium, was carried out.
Abstract: Laser welding of AISI 904 L super austenitic stainless steel using a diffusion cooled slab 3.5 kW CO2 laser and employing two different shielding gases, namely argon and helium, was carried out. The laser weld bead profile depends on various parameters such as beam power (BP), travel speed (TS) and focal position (FP) of the laser spot. These parameters have to be selected suitably to obtain the desirable output. The cross sectioned area of the bead profiles measured using an optical microscope to determine the bead width and depth of penetration. X-ray diffraction used for phase identification confirmed that the weld structure was fully austenitic and dendritic. Hardness was observed to increase in the weld bead with respect to the parent metal and it was related to the microstructural refinement induced by a rapid cooling of the weld zone.

Patent
Reiichi Suzuki1
15 Oct 2010
TL;DR: In this paper, a flux-cored wire is adopted to hardfacing MIG-arc welding using a pure argon gas as a shielding gas, and the wire is a flux cored wire prepared through drawing a steel hoop or steel pipe as a sheath in which a flux is filled.
Abstract: A wire is adopted to hardfacing MIG-arc welding using a pure argon gas as a shielding gas. The wire is a flux-cored wire prepared through drawing a steel hoop or steel pipe as a sheath in which a flux is filled. The flux contains, based on the total mass of the wire, C: 0.12 to 5.00 percent by mass, Si: 0.50 to 3.00 percent by mass, Mn: 0.30 to 20.00 percent by mass, P: 0.050 percent by mass or less, S: 0.050 percent by mass or less, and at least one of TiO 2 , ZrO 2 , and Al 2 O 3 (TiO 2 +ZrO 2 +Al 2 O 3 ) in a total content of 0.10 to 1.20 percent by mass and has a total content of silicon and manganese (Si+Mn) of 1.20 percent by mass or more. The wire has a ratio of the total mass of the flux to the mass of the wire of 5 to 30 percent by mass.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, a disc laser of 16 kW in maximum power was used to weld thin plates of AZ31B and AZ61A alloys, and sound welded joints could be obtained for Alloy Alloy with similar mechanical properties as that of the base material.
Abstract: To confirm the process potential and limitations of laser welding of magnesium alloys, a newly developed disc laser of 16 kW in maximum power was used to weld thin plates of AZ31B and AZ61A alloys. Melting characteristics and weld metal properties were studied under different process parameters. The very high power density of the applied beam caused the keyhole and the molten pool to be unstable. Underfill was the main welding defect limiting the process window and its formation was closely related to the keyhole instability. A process diagram indicating areas of sound and defected welds could be constructed. Sound welded joints could be obtained for AZ31B alloy with similar mechanical properties as that of the base material. The brittle intermetallics network present along the grain boundaries in AZ61A weld metals required a higher energy input to alleviate its detrimental effect on the mechanical properties of the welded joints.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, an activating flux combining argon and hydrogen was used for gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) to improve penetration capability. But, the welding morphology, the arc profile, the retained delta ferrite content, the angular distortion, and the microstructures were examined.
Abstract: Using activating flux for gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) to improve penetration capability is a well-established technique. Argon is an inert gas and the one most widely used as a shielding gas for GTAW. For the most austenitic stainless steels, pure argon does not provide adequate weld penetration. Argon–hydrogen mixtures give a more even heat input to the workpiece, increasing the arc voltage, which tends to increase the volume of molten material in the weld pool as well as the weld depth-to-width ratio. Great interest has been shown in the interaction between activating flux and the hydrogen concentration in an argon-based shielding gas. In this study, the weld morphology, the arc profile, the retained delta ferrite content, the angular distortion, and the microstructures were examined. The application of an activating flux combining argon and hydrogen for GTAW is important in the industry. The results of this study are presented here.

Journal ArticleDOI
04 Mar 2010-Vacuum
TL;DR: In this paper, a composite source model was developed for magnesium alloy welding, which was composed of Gaussian surface source and conical heat source, and the varying of focus conditions in model were realized by the power coefficient of composite welding heat source.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the welding properties for the components of an aluminum-alloy ultra-high vacuum chamber and beam position monitor (BPM) were discussed, and the welding parameters include the modes of laser output (pulsed wave and continuous wave), welding speed, shield gas flow, welding bead structure, and focusing distance.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the effects of shielding gas types and flow rates on CO2 laser weldability of DP600/TRIP700 steel sheets were studied in the presence of various shielding gases, including helium (He), argon (Ar), and different mixtures of He and Ar.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the effect of nitrogen oxide addition to the shielding gas composition on the amount of welding fumes and gaseous emissions produced during welding was analyzed, using the standard procedures contained in EN ISO 15011-2.
Abstract: New environmental, health and safety legislation, both in the EU and in the USA, is driving the need for the study of new welding processes, and the selection of the operational procedures that will reduce fume emissions and will promote a healthier, safer and more productive work environment. Actually, there are a significant number of publications related with gas metal arc welding hazards. However, for the new gas metal arc welding hazards variants, especially cold metal transfer, there is no data available concerning fumes and gases emissions. This paper attempts to point out ways of reducing the harmful effects of gas metal arc welding processes using different filler materials, different shielding gases, different operational welding procedures and three welding processes: gas metal arc welding process and two variants, pulsed gas metal arc welding and cold metal transfer. The effect of nitrogen oxide addition to the shielding gas composition on the amount of welding fumes and gaseous emissions produced during welding is also analysed. The amount of fume and gases generated during welding was measured over a range of current intensity and arc voltages, using the standard procedures contained in EN ISO 15011-2 [1]. The data presented give a summary of the different gas metal arc welding variants and their relations to fume generation rates and gases emitted. The results obtained give indications on measures to be taken in order to reduce fume and gas emissions. In general, the minimisation of fume formation rate can be achieved by using lower energy gas metal arc welding variants, gas shielding with low CO2 and O2 contents and “green” wires.

01 Jan 2010
TL;DR: In this article, a bead on plate welding of super austenitic stainless steel sheets using laser welding was performed on two different shielding gases like argon and helium, and the optimal welding conditions were identified in order to increase the productivity and minimize the total operating cost.
Abstract: This study focused on the bead on plate welding of super austenitic stainless steel sheets using laser welding. Taguchi Technique is applied to plan and conduct the experiments. The output variables such as Bead Width (BW), Depth of Penetration (DP) and Aspect Ratio (AR) were measured from the bead on plate weld. These output variables were determined according to beam power, travel speed and focal position. The bead on plate welding was performed on two different shielding gases like argon and helium. The shielding gas affects the weld bead characteristics such as shape, penetrationwelding efficiency etc. It is appropriate to apply Taguchi’s technique to a complex system like welding process. Therefore, this study is made to determine the near optimal welding process parameters (beam power, travel speed and focal position) using grey relational analysis by simultaneously considering multiple output parameters (bead width, depth of penetration and aspect ratio). Taguchi experimental design for determining welding parameters was successful. The gray relational grade helped to quantify the integrated performance of bead on plate welding of laser beam welding process. Confirmation experiment has been conducted to validate the optimized parameters. The predicted and initial parameters have the better aspect ratio. The optimal welding conditions were identified in order to increase the productivity and minimize the total operating cost. The process input parameters effect was determined under the optimal welding combinations.