Policy design,, whether conceptualized as a verb referring to the process of formulating policy ideas,, or as a noun describing the logic through which policy intends to achieve its objectives,, remains relatively uncharted territory.. This paper reviews what we know about how policy designs emerge,, and identifies the kinds of biases and weaknesses that are introduced into designs by the decision heuristics employed.. Theories of policy invention and expert decision--mmaking suggest that individuals search through large amounts of relevant information stored in memory,, reason by analogies,, make comparisons,, and either copy or simulate patterns of information.. Policy scholars may contribute to improved policy design by making more explicit the biases introduced through reliance on decision heuristics,, and by suggesting a more formal,, self conscious search and selection process that enables designers to be more discriminating when they pinch policy ideas from other contexts.. To perform this task,, comparative policy analysis is needed in which common elements that exist in virtually all policies are identified and the underlying structural logic of the policies is made explicit.. In this paperwe set forth generic elements found in policies,, describe and compare some of the more common design patterns,, and discuss the circumstances where these may be inappropriately copied or borrowed,, thereby thwarting the effectiveness of the policy.

/pdf/systematically-pinching-ideas-a-comparative-approach-to-4gvv54ymht.pdf

Systematically Pinching Ideas: A Comparative Approach to Policy Design

This article examines the use of integrative propositional analysis (IPA) to assess the internal logic structures of policy, to complement policy analysis and evaluation for improved implementation...

Model for Overcoming Policy Analysis Limitation and Implementation Challenges: Integrative Propositional Analysis of South African National Mental Health Policy Framework and Strategic Plan 2013-2020

Although infrastructure public-private partnerships (PPPs) have become increasingly popular globally, they face their own institutional challenges in transition economies. This paper highlights som...

The institutional challenges of public-private partnerships (PPPs) in transition economies: lessons from Kosovo

Delivering transport infrastructure using state-owned enterprises (SOEs): A business history of Vietnam Expressway Corporation between 2004 and 2016

Calibrating Lenders’ Concerns and Performance Issues in Road Infrastructure Projects under Public Private Partnership

Although learning is the foundation of improved policymaking, little is known about policy learning in transportation programs. To address this knowledge gap, this article explores how two structur...

Julián D. Parra

Papers

Structural Impediments to Policy Learning: Lessons from Colombia’s Road Concession Programs