This article traces research on floral symmetry back to its beginnings. It brings together recent advances from different fields that converge in floral symmetry and new unpublished material on diversity and development of floral symmetry. During floral development, symmetry may change: monosymmetric flowers may have a polysymmetric early phase; polysymmetric flowers may have a monosymmetric or even asymmetric early phase; more than one symmetry change is also possible. In Lamiales s.l. (comprising the model plant Antirrhinum, where the cycloidea gene produces monosymmetric flowers with the adaxial side of the androecium reduced), taxa also occur in which the androecium is reduced on both sides, adaxial and abaxial. As a trend in asymmetric flowers, enantiomorphy (with two mirror-image morphs) at the level of individuals seems to occur only in groups in which the flowers are predominantly of a relatively simple construction. In contrast, one morph is fixed at the level of species or higher taxa in groups with more complicated flowers. This is indicated by the apparent lack of enantiomorphy in corolla contortion in asterids but its predominance in rosids with contort flowers, or by the apparent lack of enantiomorphy in the pollination organs of asymmetric flowers in Faboideae but its presence in asymmetric flowers in Caesalpinioideae. To study the evolution of the diverse symmetry patterns, a concerted approach from different fields including molecular developmental genetics, pollination biology, and comparative diversity research is necessary.

http://molbiol.ru/forums/index.php?act=Attach&type=post&id=8685

Symmetry in Flowers: Diversity and Evolution

Acanthaceae (Asteridae; Lamiales) include ∼4000 species and encompass a range of morphological diversity, habitats, and biogeographic patterns. Although they are important components of tropical and subtropical habitats worldwide, inadequate knowledge of the family's phylogenetic framework has impeded comparative research. In this study, we sampled all known lineages of Acanthaceae including Andrographideae. Also included were eight of 13 genera whose relationships remain enigmatic. We used sequence data from nrITS and four chloroplast noncoding regions, and parsimony and Bayesian methods of analysis. Results strongly support most aspects of relationships including inclusion of Avicennia in Acanthaceae. Excepting Neuracanthus, newly sampled taxa are placed with strong support; Kudoacanthus is in Justicieae, Tetramerium lineage, and the remaining enigmatic genera are in Whitfieldieae or Barlerieae, and Andrographideae are sister to Barlerieae. This last result is unanticipated, but placement of Andrographideae based on structural characters has been elusive. Neuracanthus is monophyletic but placement relative to (Whitfieldieae (Andrographideae + Barlerieae)) is weakly supported. Many clades have clear morphological synapomorphies, but nonmolecular evidence for some remains elusive. Results suggest an Old World origin with multiple dispersal events to the New World. This study informs future work by clarifying sampling strategy and identifying aspects of relationships that require further study.

https://bsapubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.3732/ajb.0800096

Toward a comprehensive understanding of phylogenetic relationships among lineages of Acanthaceae s.l. (Lamiales).

We used sequence data from the intron and spacer of the trnL-trnF chloroplast region to study phylogenetic relationships among Acanthaceae. This region is more variable than other chloroplast loci that have been sequenced for members of Acanthaceae (rbcL and ndhF), is more prone to length mutations, and is less homoplasious than these genes. Our results indicate that this region is likely to be useful in addressing phylogenetic questions among but not within genera in these and related plants. In terms of phylogenetic relationships, Elytraria (representing Nelsonioideae) is more distantly related to Acanthaceae sensu stricto (s.s.) than Thunbergia and Mendoncia. These last two genera are strongly supported as sister taxa. Molecular evidence does not support monophyly of Acanthaceae s.s., although there is strong morphological evidence for this relationship. There is strong support for monophyly of four major lineages within Acanthaceae s.s.: the Acanthus, Barleria, Ruellia, and Justicia lineages as here defined. The last three of these comprise a strongly supported monophyletic group, and there is weaker evidence linking the Ruellia and Justicia lineages as closest relatives. Within the Acanthus lineage, our results confirm the existence of monophyletic lineages representing Aphelandreae and Acantheae. Lastly, within the Justicia lineage, we develop initial hypotheses regarding the definition of sublineages; some of these correspond to earlier ideas, whereas others do not. All of these hypotheses need to be tested against more data. Acanthaceae are a large family (.4000 species; Mabberley, 1987), the members of which present a rich diversity of morphological and ecological characteristics. The family is part of Lamiales s.l. (sensu lato) (i.e., sensu Olmstead et al., 1993). Unlike a number of family-level taxa in Lamiales (e.g., Lamiaceae, Verbenaceae, Scrophulariaceae), there seems little doubt that Acanthaceae s.s. (sensu stricto, see below) are monophyletic. This hypothesis is supported by the shared presence of a fruit type that is unique among angiosperms: a few-seeded, explosively dehiscent capsule within which the seeds are borne on retinacula (the lignified derivatives of funiculae). The precise delimitation of the family, however, has been controversial due to three small lineages that do not 1

Phylogenetic relationships among Acanthaceae: evidence from noncoding trnL-trnF chloroplast DNA sequences.

Parsimony analyses of ndhF chloroplast gene sequences were undertaken for 15 species of Acanthaceae and nine representative outgroup species. In addition, parsimony analyses of rbcL sequences were undertaken for 12 species of Acanthaceae and the same nine outgroup species as for ndhF. The results indicate that ndhF provides more informative characters and greater systematic resolution at this hierarchical level than rbcL. The ndhF analyses demonstrate that Elytraria and Thunbergia are successive sister taxa to all Acanthaceae taxa that have retinacula and explosive fruits. These data also demonstrate that taxa with both retinacula and explosive fruits can be subdivided further into two monophyletic groups that correspond to taxa with and without cystoliths. Within the group with cystoliths three putatively monophyletic groups correspond to taxa possessing quincuncial, left contort, and ascending-cochlear corolla aestivation patterns. The results of the rbcL analysis provide less systematic resolution than ndhF but do contain several congruent arrangements of taxa within Acanthaceae. The Acanthaceae are a large pan-tropical family of herbs and shrubs. Estimates of the number of species in the family range from 2,500-2,600 (Long, 1970; Willis, 1980) to 4,300 (Mabberley, 1990). These include several species that are grown as omamentals (e.g., Thunbergia alata, Strobilanthes dyeriana, Justicia brandegeeana, Hypoestes phyllostachya), and although the family is not noted for its economic importance, 103 species of West Tropical Africa were listed as "useful plants" by Burkill (1985). Acanthaceae are a substantial floristic element in many regions: "As regards Southern India, I suspect species of the Acanthaceae are almost as numerous as those of Com

Higher-level systematics of acanthaceae determined by chloroplast dna sequences

Phylogenetic relationships among species of the large genus Ruellia (Acanthaceae) have never been studied. Ruellia, with approximately 300 species, is geographically widespread and morphologically diverse. Molecular data for 196 specimens from the nuclear ribosomal ITS region and the chloroplast trnG-trnR region were used to test monophyly of the genus against closely related genera in Ruellieae, to reconstruct phylogenetic relationships among species of Ruellia on a global scale, to re-evaluate previous morphology-based classifications, and to examine the utility of morphological characters, especially corolla morphology, for future sectional delimitation. Bayesian and parsimony analyses indicate four genera are evolutionarily allied to Ruellia. Acanthopale is sister to Ruellia s. l. with strong support. Blechum, Eusiphon, and Polylychnis are nested within Ruellia s. l., and species in Eusiphon and Polylychnis are here formally transferred to Ruellia resulting in the new combinations Ruellia gea...

https://bioone.org/journals/Systematic-Botany/volume-32/issue-3/036364407782250625/Evolutionary-Relationships-Within-the-Species-Rich-Genus-Ruellia-Acanthaceae/10.1600/036364407782250625.pdf

Timothy J. Lawrence

Papers

Corolla ontogeny and aestivation in the Acanthaceae

Regular ArticleCorolla ontogeny and aestivation in the Acanthaceae