Remediation of heavy metal(loid)s contaminated soils - To mobilize or to immobilize?

Much as Rachel Carson's \"Silent Spring\" was a call to action against the pesticides that were devastating bird populations, Charles S. Elton's classic \"The Ecology of Invasions by Animals and Plants\" sounded an early warning about an environmental catastrophe that has become all too familiar today-the invasion of nonnative species. From kudzu to zebra mussels to Asian long-horned beetles, nonnative species are colonizing new habitats around the world at an alarming rate thanks to accidental and intentional human intervention. One of the leading causes of extinctions of native animals and plants, invasive species also wreak severe economic havoc, causing $79 billion worth of damage in the United States alone. Elton explains the devastating effects that invasive species can have on local ecosystems in clear, concise language and with numerous examples. The first book on invasion biology, and still the most cited, Elton's masterpiece provides an accessible, engaging introduction to one of the most important environmental crises of our time. Charles S. Elton was one of the founders of ecology, who also established and led Oxford University's Bureau of Animal Population. His work has influenced generations of ecologists and zoologists, and his publications remain central to the literature in modern biology. \"History has caught up with Charles Elton's foresight, and \"The Ecology of Invasions\" can now be seen as one of the central scientific books of our century.\"-David Quammen, from the Foreword to \"Killer Algae: The True Tale of a Biological Invasion\

The Ecology of Invasions by Animals and Plants

▪ Abstract In the search to identify factors that make some plant species troublesome invaders, many studies have compared various measures of native and alien invasive plant performance. These comparative studies provide insights into the more general question “Do alien invasive plants usually outperform co-occurring native species, and to what degree does the answer depend on growing conditions?” Based on 79 independent native-invasive plant comparisons, the alien invaders were not statistically more likely to have higher growth rates, competitive ability, or fecundity. Rather, the relative performance of invaders and co-occurring natives often depended on growing conditions. In 94% of 55 comparisons involving more than one growing condition, the native's performance was equal or superior to that of the invader, at least for some key performance measures in some growing conditions. Most commonly, these conditions involved reduced resources (nutrients, light, water) and/or specific disturbance regimes. I...

https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdfplus/30033774.pdf

PERFORMANCE COMPARISONS OF Co-OCCURRING NATIVE AND ALIEN INVASIVE PLANTS: Implications for Conservation and Restoration

Effects of biochar and greenwaste compost amendments on mobility, bioavailability and toxicity of inorganic and organic contaminants in a multi-element polluted soil.

Invasion ecology, the study of how organisms spread in habitats to which they are not native, asks both about the invasiveness of species and the invasibility of habitats: Which species are most likely to become invasive? Which habitats are most susceptible to invasion? To set the stage for considering these questions with regard to plants, we offer a two-way classification of nativeness and invasiveness that distinguishes natives, non-invasive non-natives and invasive non-natives. We then consider the current state of knowledge about invasiveness and invasibility. Despite much investigation, it has proven difficult to identify traits that consistently predict invasiveness. This may be largely because different traits favour invasiveness in different habitats. It has proven easier to identify types of habitats that are relatively invasible, such as islands and riverbanks. Factors thought to render habitats invasible include low intensities of competition, altered disturbance regimes and low levels of environmental stress, especially high resource availability. These factors probably often interact; the combination of altered disturbance with high resource availability may particularly promote invasibility. When biotic factors control invasibility, non-natives that are unlike native species may prove more invasive; the converse may also be true. We end with a simple conceptual model for cases in which high levels of environmental stress should and should not reduce invasibility. In some cases, it may be possible to manipulate stress to control biological invasions by plants.

/pdf/invasiveness-invasibility-and-the-role-of-environmental-301e5j7b9y.pdf

Invasiveness, invasibility and the role of environmental stress in the spread of non-native plants

Reestablishing native perennial plants and reducing invasive species are pivotal for many ecological restoration projects. The interactions among plant species, arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, and soil P availability may be critical determinants of the success of native and non-native plants in restoration and species invasions. Here we assessed mycorrhizal responsiveness for three late-successional and three early-successional plant species native to Rocky Mountain National Park and for the non-native Downy brome, cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum L.) using field soil and commercial inoculum. Factorial greenhouse experiments were conducted to compare biomass of plant species with and without field soil and commercial inoculum treatments along a phosphorus (P) gradient, which ranged from ambient field levels to 12% of field levels, using dilutions of native soils. The two field soil inoculum treatments resulted in significant biomass differences for all species studied. Late-successional species responded positively to field inoculum, whereas early-successional species responded negatively. The two commercial inocula had low colonization rates (14 of 166 inoculated plants). The commercial inocula substrates had significant treatment effects on five of seven species included in the study in the apparent absence of mycorrhizal symbiosis. Soil P levels influenced mycorrhizal responsiveness in only one species, Smooth blue aster (Aster laevis L.). Our results show that, at least for the species studied here, locally collected field inoculum is the best choice for reestablishment of late-successional native plant species.

Comparisons of Mycorrhizal Responsiveness with Field Soil and Commercial Inoculum for Six Native Montane Species and Bromus tectorum

During construction of roads, entire hillsides can be cut away, dramatically disturbing the ecosystem. Microbial communities play important, but poorly understood roles in revegetating roadcuts because of the many functions they perform in nutrient cycling, plant symbioses, decomposition, and other ecosystem processes. Our objective was to determine relationships among microbial community composition, soil chemistry, and disturbance on a serpentine soil disturbed by a roadcut and then partially revegetated. We hypothesized that the adjacent undisturbed serpentine soil would have a different microbial community composition from barren and revegetated sections of the roadcut and that undisturbed soils would have the greatest microbial biomass and diversity. We measured phospholipid fatty acids (PLFA) and soil nutrient concentrations on barren and revegetated sections of the roadcut and on adjacent undisturbed serpentine and nonserpentine soils. Most roadcut samples had soil chemistry similar to the serpentine reference soil. The microbial biomass and diversity of barren sites was lower than that of revegetated or the serpentine reference site. The nonserpentine reference site had significantly (P≤0.05) greater microbial biomass than serpentine or disturbed sites but significantly lower relative proportions of actinomycetes, and slow growth biomarkers. The Barren site had the lowest microbial biomass and a significantly (P≤0.05) greater proportion of that biomass was fungi. Barren, revegetated, and serpentine sites all had dissimilar microbial community composition. The composition of the revegetated communities, however, was intermediate between the serpentine reference and barren soils, suggesting that community composition of revegetated soils is approaching that of an undisturbed site with similar soil chemistry.

Microbial community composition on native and drastically disturbed serpentine soils

Compost amendment of Cu-Zn minespoil reduces toxic bioavailable heavy metal concentrations and promotes establishment and biomass production of Bromus carinatus (Hook and Arn.).

The low water-holding capacity and low nutrient levels of roadcuts in northern California cause many of these disturbed areas to remain chronically barren. Yard waste compost was incorporated into four nonvegetated substrates found along roadcuts (decomposed granite [DG], lahar, serpentine, and sandstone) in order to regenerate topsoil infiltration, water-holding capacity, and nutrient availability. Soil physical and chemical properties, as well as the vegetative response of a native perennial grass, were compared between treatments (non-tilled, tilled, and tilled with compost amendment). Tillage and compost addition decreased soil bulk density compared to the non-tilled treatment, and the compost treatment increased the soil carbon and nitrogen contents compared to the non-tilled and tilled treatments. Tillage alone resulted in an increase in saturated hydraulic conductivity in soils that did not contain a large amount of coarse fragments. Tillage also reduced sediment loss in all soils except the DG. Foliar C13 content did not predict water stress consistently between treatments. The incorporation of yard waste compost increased plant available water in coarse but not in fine-textured soils, and aboveground plant biomass was significantly greater in the compost treatment than in either of the other treatments. Although the incorporation of yard waste compost generated the greatest revegetation success, tillage alone may be a sufficient treatment if residual soils have adequate nutrient levels.

Regenerating Topsoil Functionality in Four Drastically Disturbed Soil Types by Compost Incorporation

Construction activity typically results in the removal of existing topsoil, exposing unconsolidated parent material that is often difficult to revegetate. In areas with serpentine mineralogy, revegetation is even more difficult because of low nutrient concentrations, heavy metal toxicity, and a low Ca:Mg ratio. Because serpentine-tolerant plants typically display xeric morphology, we hypothesized that water stress was a main factor limiting revegetation on serpentine roadcuts and that compost incorporation would increase plant available water (PAW). Four treatments were evaluated for their ability to increase PAW on a large serpentine roadcut: nontilled (ambient), tilled, and two rates of incorporated compost (270 and 540 Mg/ha or 12 and 24% by volume). Soil water release curves and moisture depletion were measured in situ using time domain transmissometry and soil psychrometers from early spring through the dry summer months. Compost incorporation (24% by volume) resulted in greater than a 2-fold increase in PAW and generated more than 4 times more vegetative biomass compared with the nontilled control. In contrast to the in situ method, by the conventional pressure plate method showed significantly less PAW in the 24% compost treatment compared with the nontilled treatment. In situ measurements of PAW agreed well with biomass data, indicating that for this atypical soil, in situ measurements were more accurate. Compost incorporation into a drastically disturbed serpentine soil is a successful revegetation technique that will increase PAW as well as the ability of the plants to access this water resource through greater root proliferation.

Victor P. Claassen

Papers

Comparisons of Mycorrhizal Responsiveness with Field Soil and Commercial Inoculum for Six Native Montane Species and Bromus tectorum

Microbial community composition on native and drastically disturbed serpentine soils

Compost amendment of Cu-Zn minespoil reduces toxic bioavailable heavy metal concentrations and promotes establishment and biomass production of Bromus carinatus (Hook and Arn.).

Regenerating Topsoil Functionality in Four Drastically Disturbed Soil Types by Compost Incorporation

Compost incorporation increases plant available water in a drastically disturbed serpentine soil