Journal ArticleDOI
Crime Control as Drama
TLDR
In this article, the authors suggest five criteria for what they would tentatively classify as "great pieces for literature" within the tradition of western art, based on the theory of natural law.Abstract:
First things first: let us establish some criteria for this critique. I will suggest five criteria, for what I would tentatively classify as "great pieces for literature" within the tradition of western art. To keep inside this tradition is clearly an ethnocentric limitation. A Hindu tradition might find other criteria useful. And even within a western tradition there is little agreement on criteria for evaluation of art. Some would deny the possibility of establishing any such criteria. Some would tie it to popular opinions expressed through sales figures or counts of published reviews. But some would say there were some basic rules to be used, a platform of"natural law" within the literary critique. There are striking similarities between the discussions carried out within the theory of literature and the theory of law in the search for a basis for evaluation of drama as well as crime. For an interesting Danish attempt to create order out of anarchy in the critique, see Sven Moller Kristensen.2 An English classic is by Wellek and Warren.3 My position is close to a natural law positionat least within the theory of literature.read more
Citations
More filters
DissertationDOI
Dompter le futur au 21e siècle : discours politiques canadiens sur la gouvernance de la sécurité publique
TL;DR: In this article, the authors conduct a qualitative comparative analysis using as their data sources transcripts of discussions, political debates and legislation related documents leading up to the enactment of four separate federal bills.
Journal ArticleDOI
An abolitionist view of restorative justice
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors discuss the critique of professionalism and their emphasis on community conflict regulation in the context of restorative justice, highlighting their critique of professionalism and their focus on community conflicts.
Journal ArticleDOI
Sex offender punishment and the persistence of penal harm in the U.S.
TL;DR: The need to return to differentiation among sex offenders is reinforced, but differentiation based on science and on the experience-based, guided discretion of experts in law enforcement, corrections, and treatment is reinforced.
Journal ArticleDOI
Philosophy of Punishment: Normative Models and Construction Principles of Legal Systems
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors examine a philosophy of punishment in the normative perspective and to penetrate the structure of the fundamental premises and theses of retributivism, and discuss the notion of prima facie duty.
References
More filters