Homothetic separability and consumer budgeting

TLDR: In this article, the authors proposed a method of deriving the category expenditure functions, which requires stronger constraints on the utility function than does the mere existence of the functions, and showed that the necessary and sufficient condition for this procedure to be consistent is that the utility functions be separable into homothetic parts.

Abstract: Gorman [2] has derived necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of category expenditure functions which yield the optimal allocation of a consumer unit's income to each of a number of groups of commodities as functions of total income and group price indices. These conditions take the form of certain restrictions on the structure of the utility function. Gorman, however, did not address the problem of how these functions are derived. In this paper, we construct an algorithm (a budgeting procedure) for deriving the category expenditure functions and show that the necessary and sufficient condition for this procedure to be consistent is that the utility function be separable into homothetic parts. CASUAL OBSERVATION REVEALS that many consumers budget; that is, they first allocate their total expenditure among broad commodity categories and then decide upon the precise allocation of category expenditure to each of the commodities within the group. This type of consumer behavior is especially interesting if it is possible to carry out the broad category allocation with reference only to price indices for each of the budgeting categories, and then decide upon the intracategory allocation with reference only to commodity prices within that group. R. H. Strotz [4, 5] and W. M. Gorman [2] have examined the relationship between this type of consumer behavior and the form of the consumer unit's utility function. More precisely, they have shown that the necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of group price indices (which depend only upon commodity prices within the group), such that category expenditures are functions only of these price indices and total expenditure, are that the utility function be (a) homothetically separable2 or (b) strongly (additively) separable (with a certain restriction on the polar form of the utility function).3 Strotz and Gorman do not address the issue of how these functions could be derived. This paper discusses a method of deriving the category expenditure functions-a budgeting procedure-which requires stronger constraints on the utility function than does the mere existence of the functions. Price indices are first derived for each budgeting category. Then the