scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

How do cultural differences in healthcare practices and communication styles affect the cross-cultural adaptation of IMGs in the UK? 


Best insight from top research papers

Cultural differences in healthcare practices and communication styles significantly impact the cross-cultural adaptation of International Medical Graduates (IMGs) in the UK, affecting their integration, performance, and the quality of patient care they provide. The adaptation challenges stem from various factors, including differences in medical education, professional values, and communication styles between IMGs and their UK-trained counterparts. Firstly, IMGs often come from educational backgrounds that favor didactic methods over simulation-based training, which is increasingly common in the UK. This discrepancy can lead to IMGs feeling less prepared for the practical, hands-on approach required in the NHS, as they have minimal exposure to simulation and human factors training. Additionally, the bioethical principle of social justice in healthcare, which emphasizes patient-centered care and cultural competence, may not be as pronounced in the training of IMGs. This can lead to challenges in ensuring that the human right to medical care and wellbeing is fully respected, especially for vulnerable populations such as immigrants and social minorities. Cultural and professional values also differ significantly, with IMGs often coming from cultures with higher power distance, which affects communication styles and expectations within the healthcare team. This difference can lead to misunderstandings and challenges in team dynamics, as IMGs may be more accustomed to hierarchical structures that are at odds with the more egalitarian approach in the UK. Communication challenges are further compounded by language subtleties and the need for IMGs to navigate a complex new culture while adapting to new pathways, policies, and frameworks. Efforts to bridge these gaps include dedicated induction programs, simulation courses tailored to the needs of IMGs, and virtual interview practice days to improve understanding and expectations. However, despite these initiatives, IMGs continue to face significant barriers to integration, including experiences of bullying, undermining, and feeling undervalued, which can impact their decision to remain in the UK. Moreover, the differential attainment observed in postgraduate medical examinations highlights the influence of culture and language on clinical communication skills, underscoring the need for targeted support to address these challenges. In conclusion, cultural differences in healthcare practices and communication styles pose significant challenges to the cross-cultural adaptation of IMGs in the UK. Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach that includes tailored educational programs, support systems, and a focus on cultural competence and patient-centered care.

Answers from top 10 papers

More filters
Papers (10)Insight
Cultural differences impact IMGs' adaptation in the UK by creating challenges in navigating new healthcare practices and communication styles, highlighting the need for tailored support and training initiatives.
Cultural differences impact immigrant medical graduates (IMGs) in the UK through barriers like language, socio-economic status, and literacy, highlighting the need for cultural competence and patient-centered care in healthcare settings.
Cultural differences impact IMGs' communication skills in UK exams due to varying power distance, uncertainty avoidance, and masculinity/femininity, affecting patient engagement and overall consultation performance.
Not addressed in the paper.
Cultural differences impact IMGs' adaptation in the UK by influencing communication skills and patient interactions, highlighting the need for language proficiency and cultural awareness for effective healthcare delivery.
Cultural differences impact IMGs in the UK, leading to challenges like bullying and relocation considerations. Support through mentoring, education, and well-being initiatives is crucial for successful adaptation.
Cultural differences impact IMGs' adaptation in the UK by influencing communication, diagnostic skills, and work-life balance, highlighting the need for mentorship and tailored support programs.
Open accessJournal ArticleDOI
Mina Farag, Idowu Olaogun 
01 Oct 2020-Cureus
1 Citations
Cultural differences impact IMGs in the UK, affecting communication and career progression. Digital platforms and local interventions aim to support IMGs in overcoming these challenges nationally.
Cultural differences impact IMGs' adaptation in the UK by influencing clinical practices, team dynamics, and communication. High-fidelity simulation aids inclusivity and confidence-building for smoother transitions.
Not addressed in the paper.

Related Questions

What are the primary drivers of migration among International Medical Graduates (IMGs) in the UK healthcare industry?4 answersThe primary drivers of migration among International Medical Graduates (IMGs) in the UK healthcare industry are multifaceted, encompassing a range of macro, meso, and micro-level factors. At the macro level, poor working conditions, employment opportunities, and the pursuit of better quality of life are significant drivers. These factors are not only pivotal in attracting IMGs to the UK but also in driving UK-trained doctors to seek opportunities abroad, highlighting a complex interplay of push and pull factors that influence medical migration to and from the UK. The historical reliance of the UK's National Health Service (NHS) on IMGs, particularly from countries like India and Pakistan, underscores the systemic dependency and the challenges of achieving medical 'self-sufficiency', further exacerbated by the international jobs market dynamics. Meso-level factors, including career prospects, a good working environment, and job satisfaction, play a crucial role. These elements are consistent across geographical regions, indicating a universal appeal for better professional opportunities and working conditions. Additionally, the integration experiences of IMGs, influenced by their source country experiences and the work environment in the UK, suggest that the extent of these drivers varies among different healthcare professions. At the micro level, personal factors such as the desire for higher education and training, better income, and improved family prospects are key motivators. However, IMGs face significant challenges, including psychosocial issues, cultural differences, and hurdles in career progression and passing exams. The ethical considerations of 'brain drain' and the rights of health workers to migrate versus the right to health in their home countries add another layer of complexity to the migration dynamics. The increasing number of IMGs playing central roles in health economies worldwide reflects the global nature of medical practice in the 21st century, emphasizing the importance of diversity and global collaboration. The ethical implications of relying on IMGs, who are trained at the expense of their home countries, further complicate the narrative, suggesting a need for a more equitable approach to healthcare access and migration. Lastly, the mobility of new university graduates, including those in the medical field, indicates a broader trend of geographical and inter-industry moves as responses to job mismatches, highlighting the complexity of migration drivers.
How does the united kingdom being a low-context culture affect communication?5 answersThe United Kingdom being a low-context culture affects communication in several ways. In low-context cultures, there is an emphasis on explicit verbal messages and less reliance on non-verbal cues. This means that communication in the UK tends to be more direct, linear, and focused on the words used to convey meaning. In low-context cultures like the UK, communication is often individualistic and assertive, with a preference for informal verbal styles. This can lead to potential misunderstandings when interacting with individuals from high-context cultures, who rely more on non-verbal communication and contextual cues. In healthcare settings, for example, clinicians in the UK may use low-context communication styles, while patients from high-context cultures may use high-context communication strategies, leading to miscommunication and misunderstandings. Overall, the low-context nature of communication in the United Kingdom influences the communication styles and expectations of individuals in various contexts.
How does culture influence healthcare?4 answersCulture has a significant influence on healthcare. It affects the quality of healthcare services, including patient care, safety, and satisfaction, as well as the working environment within healthcare organizations. Organizational culture in healthcare settings can impact member efficiency, motivation, morale, and quality of work, as well as stress, accident rates, burnout, and turnover. Cultural background also plays a role in healthcare providers' perceptions of self-care and how they adapt patient education and care based on cultural differences. Additionally, cultural factors can impact the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) in healthcare, with high uncertainty avoidance hindering acceptance of technology like AI. Understanding cultural contexts is crucial for healthcare professionals to work effectively, influence change, and avoid misunderstandings or causing offense.
How can culture influence different communication methods in a mental health care setting?5 answersCulture can influence different communication methods in a mental health care setting in several ways. Firstly, cultural beliefs and values shape the way individuals present their symptoms, which can lead to difficulties in diagnosis and treatment. Secondly, cultural norms and meanings regarding mental illness can affect how individuals express and communicate their distress. Thirdly, patients' perception of provider cultural competency can indirectly influence their health outcomes through the process of care, including the experience of respect, trust, and communication with the clinician. Additionally, in a multicultural hospital setting, diverse cultural and ethnic backgrounds of both staff and patients can create intergroup conflicts and miscommunication, highlighting the need for an intercultural lens in understanding and addressing these issues. Overall, culture plays a significant role in shaping communication methods in mental health care, impacting diagnosis, treatment, and patient outcomes.
How do cultural differences impact health outcomes?5 answersCultural differences impact health outcomes in several ways. Firstly, culture plays a significant role in how people perceive and experience health and illness, as well as how they access and engage with healthcare systems. Secondly, cultural assumptions underlying healthcare systems can influence health behaviors and outcomes for minority and low-SES populations. Thirdly, cultural factors affect communication and the provision of effective quality palliative care for patients and families from diverse backgrounds. Additionally, cultural variations need to be considered and controlled in health promotion research to ensure the reliability, validity, and generalizability of study findings. Overall, understanding and addressing cultural differences are crucial for achieving more equitable health outcomes for culturally diverse communities.
How do culture, beliefs, and values influence health care practices?3 answersBudaya, keyakinan, dan nilai-nilai memiliki pengaruh signifikan pada praktik perawatan kesehatan. Budaya yang berbeda memiliki keyakinan dan praktik unik mereka sendiri terkait dengan perawatan kesehatan dan rehabilitasi. Keyakinan dan pendekatan orang tua terhadap kesehatan anak mereka juga bervariasi dengan budaya. Di pedesaan Zambia, faktor budaya berperan dalam cara ibu mencari perawatan bayi baru lahir, dengan ritual bayi baru lahir tradisional dan protektif menjadi tema dominan. Keluarga di Brasil selatan mendasarkan perawatan mereka terhadap anak-anak yang dirawat di rumah sakit pada referensi budaya mereka, termasuk kepercayaan tentang makan, pakaian, kebersihan, dan praktik keagamaan. Profesional kesehatan dan pandangan pasien tentang perawatan dipengaruhi oleh budaya dan agama, menyoroti pentingnya kesadaran dan pemahaman latar belakang budaya dalam perawatan kesehatan. Temuan ini menekankan perlunya penyedia layanan kesehatan untuk mempertimbangkan keyakinan dan nilai-nilai budaya ketika memberikan perawatan, karena mereka membentuk praktik perawatan kesehatan individu dan proses pengambilan keputusan.]].

See what other people are reading

What negotiation style is used in international negotiations?
5 answers
International negotiations encompass a variety of negotiation styles influenced by cultural values, linguistic styles, trust-building, and leadership approaches. Negotiators may adopt styles favoring compromise, consensus-seeking, or even adversarial tactics, depending on the cultural context. Linguistic style analysis reveals that agreement in multilateral negotiations often involves a convergence of diplomats' linguistic styles, while disagreement is associated with divergence. Trust is crucial in facilitating the negotiation process, with ethical values playing a significant role in building trust early on in negotiations. Leadership, particularly MAGNUS leadership, is also essential in international negotiations, offering practical tips and recommendations for negotiators. Overall, international negotiations involve a dynamic interplay of negotiation styles, linguistic nuances, trust-building strategies, and credible leadership approaches.
Do size and material have an impact on purchase intention?
5 answers
Packaging size significantly influences purchase intention. For organic food, smaller packaging enhances consumer purchase intention, with green perceived value acting as an intermediary factor. Similarly, in the olive oil market, consumers prefer small packaging, which positively impacts purchase intentions. Moreover, factors like environmental knowledge, perceived value, and price influence the intention to purchase reusable shopping bags. These findings highlight the importance of considering packaging size and material in shaping consumer purchase intentions. Understanding consumer preferences for smaller packaging and environmentally friendly materials can lead to higher purchase intentions, emphasizing the need for businesses to align their packaging strategies with consumer values and preferences.
Why AI is crucial to be research?
5 answers
AI research is crucial due to its impact on various scientific fields and society. Understanding the evolving trends in AI through bibliometric analysis is essential to support researchers and organizations. AI has the potential to significantly enhance research productivity across different domains, contributing to economic and social value. Additionally, researchers face increasing pressure to secure funding, leading to fierce competition and complexity in proposal preparation. Utilizing transdisciplinary AI tools can help automate parts of the application process, alleviating discomfort and enhancing success rates. In summary, AI research is vital for fostering interdisciplinary knowledge, supporting research productivity, and addressing the challenges faced by researchers in securing funding, ultimately contributing to societal well-being and sustainability.
Who are the researchers who have developed theories about the impact of poverty on students?
5 answers
Researchers who have developed theories about the impact of poverty on students include Shashank Joshi, Aditya Agrawal, Yogendra Thapa, Pankaj Meel, and Nicole Brownfield, Monica Thielking, Glen W. Bates, Fiona Morrison. These researchers have explored various aspects of how poverty affects students' educational experiences, academic performance, and overall well-being. Their studies highlight that poverty can hinder class participation, academic success, and overall university experiences. Additionally, they emphasize the need for interventions to address the negative impacts of poverty on students' education and well-being. By examining the barriers faced by students living in poverty, these researchers aim to inform policies and practices that can support disadvantaged students in their pursuit of education.
What are the factors that influence the cost of absorption in various industries?
5 answers
The factors influencing the cost of absorption in various industries include variables such as wage, labor productivity, non-wage spending, output of production, level of education, population growth, and foreign direct investment (FDI). In the context of CO2 absorption technologies, factors affecting absorption costs and energy consumption are crucial considerations. Technologies like calcium looping and ammonia are highlighted as relatively suitable due to their cost-effectiveness and absorptivity. Additionally, the absorption process itself can be influenced by competition from other channels, impacting cross-section reduction and angular distribution. Understanding these diverse factors is essential for industries to make informed decisions on selecting appropriate absorption technologies with lower costs, reduced energy consumption, and higher efficiency.
What is the impact of job satisfaction in occupational health and well being of agricultural workers?
5 answers
Job satisfaction plays a crucial role in the occupational health and well-being of agricultural workers. Studies highlight that factors such as health satisfaction and the nature of the work significantly influence the job satisfaction of agricultural employees. Job satisfaction among rural health workers (RHWs) is also a key variable affecting their work status and turnover behavior, with publications emphasizing its negative predictive effect on job burnout and turnover intention. The agricultural industry, known for its high rates of injury and illness, particularly affects hired farmworkers, who face unjust risks due to structural disadvantages. Enhancing job satisfaction through addressing health concerns, work environment, and structural disparities is essential for promoting the overall occupational health and well-being of agricultural workers.
How does shyness impact academic performance in students who choose to specialize in humanities?
5 answers
Shyness has been found to have a negative impact on academic performance in students specializing in humanities. Research indicates that shyness is negatively correlated with academic performance, with a significant relationship observed between shyness and academic achievement. Additionally, the social-psychic environment of the classroom plays a crucial role in predicting academic performance, with a negative relationship identified between the classroom environment and students' academic success. Therefore, it is essential for educators to create a supportive and participative classroom atmosphere to enhance students' satisfaction, fulfillment, and ultimately improve their academic performance, especially in humanities disciplines.
What are the contributing factors to the precarization and disqualification of work?
5 answers
The precarization and disqualification of work stem from various factors observed in different contexts. Globalization and the capitalist economy model have led to the erosion of workers' rights, facilitating layoffs and unregistered employment. The gig economy, exemplified by platforms like Uber, normalizes precarious work conditions with long hours, low income, and lack of social protections. In specific settings like a Prison Primary Care Team in Brazil, work precariousness manifests through outsourced labor, inadequate work process management, and insufficient professional development opportunities. These factors collectively contribute to the creation of a precariat class, where workers internalize exploitation, face uncertainty, and struggle to maintain traditional middle-class aspirations.
Are values towards health diverse?
5 answers
Values towards health are indeed diverse, as highlighted in various research papers. Healthcare organizations face challenges due to the convergence of multiple value systems within their teams. The importance of diversity and inclusion in healthcare is emphasized, especially in the context of treating a diverse patient population. Different expectations towards healthcare based on diversity characteristics like disability, gender, age, or migration background exist, impacting patient satisfaction and outcomes. Indigenous cultures such as Ojibway, Xhosa, and Mayan have unique ethical values related to illness, healing, and healthcare choices, showcasing a different perspective compared to Western views. The increasing multicultural environments in healthcare settings due to demographic shifts pose ethical challenges, emphasizing the need for critical cultural competence to navigate cross-cultural interactions effectively.
What are the implications of incorporating Lakein's principles into organizational policies and procedures for promoting a healthier work-life balance?
5 answers
Incorporating Lakein's principles into organizational policies and procedures can have significant implications for promoting a healthier work-life balance. Lakein's principles emphasize effective time management and prioritization. By integrating these principles, organizations can help employees better manage their workloads during challenging times like COVID-19. This approach can lead to reduced work-related stress and mental pressure, ultimately contributing to improved work-life balance. Additionally, offering work-life balance practices such as flexi-time schedules and telecommuting can further support employees in balancing their personal and professional lives. Ensuring fairness in addressing employees' needs, especially in cultures where family responsibilities predominantly fall on women, is crucial for promoting well-being and motivation at work. Overall, aligning organizational policies with Lakein's principles can enhance employee satisfaction, productivity, and overall health outcomes.
Why do people with degrees have a higher salary?
5 answers
People with degrees tend to have higher salaries due to various factors. One significant reason is the rising earning inequality, attributed not only to skill-biased technological changes but also to increased market power in certain sectors, offsetting the increased supply of degree holders. The earnings gap between different educational levels has been widening, with post-graduate degree holders experiencing a growing gap compared to those with only a college degree, reflecting labor market polarization. Studies in Albania show that university degree holders enjoy a 17.22% earnings premium and a 40.13% higher monthly wage compared to high school diploma holders, emphasizing the financial benefits of higher education. Additionally, data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics confirms that higher education leads to increased earnings and guards against unemployment, with bachelor's degree holders earning significantly more than those with lower educational qualifications.