How does Schermerhorn's approach to management differ from traditional management theories?
Best insight from top research papers
Schermerhorn's approach to management differs from traditional management theories by incorporating an ethical and ecological perspective into economic analysis, emphasizing the societal responsibility for the destruction of natural resources . In contrast, traditional management theories often focus on rational and mechanistic views of organizations, neglecting the human and environmental impacts of managerial decisions . Schermerhorn advocates for sustainable business practices and new models of prosperity, challenging the overreliance on free market self-regulation and the externalization of environmental costs . This contrasts with traditional management approaches that view individuals within organizations as mere productivity tools and often overlook cultural differences and individual needs . Schermerhorn's emphasis on ethical evaluations and communication strategies aligns with a more holistic and socially responsible approach to management, diverging from the conventional profit-driven mindset of traditional theories.
Answers from top 5 papers
More filters
| Papers (5) | Insight |
|---|---|
Open access 07 Jun 2017 3 Citations | Not addressed in the paper. |
| Schermerhorn's approach focuses on individual needs and cultural differences, contrasting with traditional management theories that prioritize organizational efficiency and view individuals as productivity tools. | |
| Schermerhorn's approach emphasizes participatory, benevolent, empathetic, change, and project management, contrasting with traditional vertical, controlling methods lacking empathy, and facing resistance during change. | |
05 Dec 2017 | Schermerhorn's approach integrates culture and art, emphasizing the irrational aspect alongside rationality, providing a holistic view for adequate managerial actions, unlike traditional purely rational management theories. |
01 Jan 2021 1 Citations | Scherhorn's approach emphasizes sustainable development over capitalism, integrating ethical and ecological evaluations, challenging reliance on free market self-regulation, and advocating for responsible resource use and internalizing environmental costs. |
Related Questions
What role does the theory of scientific management play in explaining the functions of management?5 answersThe theory of scientific management, pioneered by Frederick Winslow Taylor, plays a crucial role in explaining the functions of management by focusing on improving labor productivity. Taylor's approach involved scientific experiments and calculations to determine the most efficient ways of performing tasks, emphasizing factors like work norms, specialized management functions, and the division of labor between management and workers. Scientific management principles, aimed at increasing productivity by working smarter, not harder, have been widely adopted beyond industry, benefiting both organizations and employees. This theory underscores the importance of applying scientific methods to optimize processes, enhance efficiency, and achieve maximum prosperity for both employers and employees.
How does the author's definition of management practices differ from traditional approaches?5 answersThe author's definition of management practices, as depicted in the provided contexts, diverges from traditional approaches by emphasizing the importance of understanding management as a supportive practice rooted in intrinsic values specific to each domain. This modern perspective contrasts with traditional top-down management structures, advocating for self-management and delegation of decision-making to involve employees in corporate governance. Additionally, the author's view aligns with the practice approach, which focuses on real-time accomplishments of ordinary activities as central to understanding organizational and social phenomena. In contrast, classical approaches like Taylorism and Fayolism emphasized work planning, formal structures, and rational behavior, often neglecting human elements and the need for innovation and worker participation. This shift towards a more inclusive and value-driven management practice marks a departure from the rigidity of traditional management theories.
What is the traditional management approach?5 answersThe traditional management approach is a hierarchical and command-and-control structure that focuses on maintaining the present structure and following written rules and regulations. It originated in the late 19th century and emphasizes work planning, technical requirements, principles of management, formal structure, and rational and logical behavior. Traditional management approaches often treat organizations as closed systems and overlook the importance of human beings. This approach has been criticized for its lack of flexibility and failure to adapt to current business trends. In contrast, modern approaches such as process management emphasize a shift towards a horizontal, team-oriented structure that focuses on improving core processes and achieving strategic goals.
What are the different theories of management?3 answersManagement theories have evolved over time and can be categorized into different schools of thought. The classical management theory emphasizes scientific methods, administrative approaches, and bureaucratic structures for managerial practices, focusing on task efficiency. The neo-classical management theory considers individual needs, work relations, behavioral aspects, and motivations for effectiveness. The modern management theory recognizes the dynamic environment and adopts systems and contingent approaches, along with organizational humanism and management science as core concepts. Additionally, the latest work of Foucault and Bourdieu is used to explain the modernity of management. Other influential management theorists include Deming, Drucker, Maslow, McGregor, Schein, Senge, Taylor, and Weber, each contributing to the development of management theories. The concept of management itself is less than 150 years old, with Henri Fayol and F.W. Taylor being early contributors. Classical management theories such as scientific, administrative, and bureaucratic approaches are still practiced in various parts of the world.
What are some of the key concepts of classical management theory?5 answersClassical management theory is characterized by key concepts such as division of labor, control, structure, hierarchy, and maximum efficiency. The principles of division of labor and specialization are emphasized in classical management theory as means to achieve efficiency. However, criticisms have been raised regarding the rationality of division of labor, as it can lead to alienation from work, oneself, and society. The theories of Frederick Taylor, Max Weber, and Henri Fayol are foundational to classical management theory. These theories view management as a profession and provide principles and techniques to guide managers. Classical management theories have had a significant impact on organizational design and communication practices. The concepts of chain of command, autocratic management style, and predicted behavior are common features of classical management theories.
What are the strengths of the behavioral management theory?3 answersThe strengths of the behavioral management theory include its emphasis on understanding and explaining managerial decision-making based on personal preferences, limited rationality, and lack of information. It recognizes the importance of the human potential inside a manager and highlights the role of individual managers in organizations. The theory also contributes to the integration of the field of organizational studies by incorporating behavioral reasoning across different research traditions. It provides insights into the proactive behavior of managers in response to the business environment, demonstrating their exceptional flexibility in counteracting external shortcomings. Additionally, the theory emphasizes the importance of behavioral management programs in enhancing the welfare of animal subjects in research, leading to ethical research projects with valid and reliable results. Overall, the behavioral management theory offers a comprehensive understanding of managerial behavior and its impact on organizational outcomes, making it valuable for both theory and practice.