How to assess the impact of social design?
Best insight from top research papers
Assessing the impact of social design involves considering social, environmental, and economic factors. Design-led innovation can support the evaluation of community-led projects, leading to policy changes that endorse cultural and creative regeneration strategies . Social life cycle assessment (SLCA) can be used to assess the potential positive and negative social impacts of products and services, including those related to computer-aided design (CAD) software . The Product Social Impact Assessment method can be applied to assess social impacts in the automotive sector, providing insights for the design phase . Human-centered design approaches and design thinking can be used to consider the human aspect of urban spaces, but it is important to also measure and assess the social impact of projects during and after implementation . Evaluating the value of social design research can be challenging due to bureaucratic structures and the need to demonstrate impact. Two-stage social design research can help address this issue by assembling research issues, methods, and data, and then stabilizing the research to assess its value .
Answers from top 4 papers
More filters
| Papers (4) | Insight |
|---|---|
| The paper discusses the challenges of assessing the value of social design research and proposes a two-stage social design research approach to address this issue. However, it does not provide a specific method for assessing the impact of social design. | |
| The paper suggests using social impact evaluation tools to assess the impact of social design in urban environments. | |
| The paper discusses the development of a design-led toolkit for evaluating the impact of social innovation interventions. It suggests using Participatory Action Research (PAR) methodology and workshops to gather insights and inform policy changes. | |
01 Jan 2020 2 Citations | The paper discusses the use of the Product Social Impact Assessment method to assess the social impact of automotive component design. |
Related Questions
What are the most effective ways to evaluate the social impact of infrastructure projects?4 answersThe most effective ways to evaluate the social impact of infrastructure projects include engaging with users during the operation phase using big data from social media, evaluating the socio-economic development and opportunities for economic productivity using exploratory factor analysis, investing in stakeholder engagement to understand and identify social value, and conducting social impact assessments to assess the effects on communities and their environment. Additionally, Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) is presented as an alternative evaluation method that can enhance learning from infrastructure projects.
How is the impact of social science research evaluated?5 answersThe impact of social science research is evaluated through various approaches. One approach focuses on the characteristics of knowledge that researchers can control, such as content salience, effective communication, quality, and attending to parameters of use. Another approach involves examining the conceptions of social impact from the perspectives of policy authors and academics, which can result in uncertainty about the conceptualization and operationalization of impact. Additionally, there is a proposal for a Social Impact ex-post Evaluation Protocol (SIEP) that aims to gather and measure the social impact of research using qualitative methods. Furthermore, there is a growing emphasis on citizen participation in the evaluation of the social impact of research, which involves dialogic interactions and the integration of citizens' voices. Overall, the evaluation of the impact of social science research requires considering multiple factors, including researcher efforts, policy perspectives, societal impact, and citizen participation.
What attributes to a good social research design?5 answersA good social research design should have several key attributes. Firstly, it should be able to provide accurate and unbiased research insights. This means that the design should be neutral, reliable, and valid, and should also have the ability for generalization. Secondly, the design should involve critical decisions about concepts, hypotheses, indicators, case selection, measurement, and tests for association. Thirdly, the design should be a deliberate and well-organized technique that keeps the research endeavor together. Fourthly, the design should consider and explicate both philosophical and practical elements, such as ontological and epistemological assumptions, theoretical perspective, purpose, aims, and research questions. Finally, the design should enable well-founded and meaningful conclusions, enhancing the credibility of the research project.
Are interview and surveys the most used method for social impact assessment?5 answersInterviews and surveys are commonly used methods for social impact assessment. Interviews allow researchers to gather knowledge, views, and experiences that help in understanding social realities. They provide an opportunity for interaction and communication, enabling researchers to uncover information that may be concealed in written responses. However, interviews are subjective and can be influenced by bias. Surveys, particularly household surveys, are also widely used in social monitoring programs and impact assessments. They provide qualitative and quantitative data, offering a reliable view of change from the community perspective. Surveys need to be carefully designed to capture variations in the local economy and can be time-consuming. Therefore, while interviews and surveys are commonly used, researchers should consider the strengths and limitations of each method when conducting social impact assessments.
How to measure social impact in social enterprise?5 answersMeasuring social impact in social enterprises can be done through various methods. One approach is the use of a measuring framework that offers utility for inclusive stakeholder collaboration and the incorporation of diverse developmental theories. Another method is the use of indicators such as the balanced scorecard (BSC), social return on investment (SROI), and cost-benefit analysis (CBA). Additionally, a holistic view of social impact can be achieved by considering factors such as influence on the field, development of capabilities, and transformation of individuals' habitus. The uptake of social impact measurement in the social enterprise sector can be influenced by context, the nature of the impact, and stakeholders' involvement. Various measurement methods have been proposed in the literature, including Prove and Improve, Social Audit (SA), Social Return on Investment (SROI), Local Multiplier (LM3), Balanced Scorecard (BSC), and ESometr.
What are core value of social impact assessment?2 answersSocial impact assessment (SIA) is a tool used to evaluate the potential social consequences of projects and inform decision-making. The core values of SIA include promoting sustainability and equity in both the biophysical and human environment. Equity considerations should be fundamental in SIA and development planning. SIA aims to optimize operations to account for potential social impacts and improve the quality of decision-making. It is a risk management tool that helps identify and mitigate negative impacts on communities. SIA also benefits communities by engaging them in the decision-making process and ensuring their concerns are addressed. The methods used in SIA involve predicting future impacts and assessing baseline conditions without project actions. It is important to ensure the quality of methods and data used in SIA and provide opportunities for critical review.