What are the limitations and challenges associated with using CDOM absorption for predicting water pollution?
The use of Chromophoric Dissolved Organic Matter (CDOM) absorption as a predictor for water pollution faces several limitations and challenges, as highlighted by recent research. One primary challenge is the difficulty in accurately measuring in situ CDOM absorption coefficients due to the necessity of prefiltration of water samples, which can be cumbersome and time-consuming. Additionally, the complex optical conditions in inland waters, such as those found in eutrophic lakes, can significantly challenge the remote sensing estimates of CDOM, thereby affecting the accuracy of water pollution predictions. Moreover, the spectral characteristics of CDOM can vary significantly with the water quality and spectral parameters, especially in highly polluted waters, making it difficult to develop universally applicable bio-optical models. The variability in CDOM properties across different regions and trophic states further complicates the use of CDOM absorption for predicting water pollution, as the relationship between CDOM and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) can vary, affecting the applicability of remote sensing monitoring. The seasonal characteristics of CDOM also introduce variability, with different fluorescent CDOM components showing seasonal variations that can influence the quantity and quality of CDOM in water samples. This seasonal variability, along with the spatial discrepancy in CDOM optical properties, necessitates the development of region-specific algorithms and models. Furthermore, the emerging technology of UV-visible imaging spectroscopy, while promising for improving the remote sensing of CDOM in optically complex waters, has yet to be fully evaluated for its potential advantages in monitoring CDOM-related water quality. The fluorescence characteristics of CDOM, which can be indicative of pollution levels, also vary spatially and with pollution levels, requiring sophisticated analysis methods like EEM-PARAFAC to interpret. Lastly, the influence of anthropogenic disturbances on CDOM characteristics, as observed in the Liaohe River Delta, underscores the need for tools that can trace the sources and characteristics of CDOM to effectively monitor riverine water quality. These challenges highlight the need for continued research and development of more robust, efficient, and region-specific methods for using CDOM absorption as a predictor for water pollution.
Answers from top 10 papers
Papers (10) | Insight |
---|---|
Not addressed in the paper. | |
16 Oct 2013 | Limitations include uncertainties in CDOM retrieval at shallow depths (<1.5m) and weak correlation between modeled and measured absorption coefficients, impacting accurate water pollution prediction. |
23 Citations | The challenges include potential inaccuracies in algorithms due to solutes and suspended matter in inland waters, affecting CDOM absorption predictions for water pollution assessment. |
12 Citations | Limitations include the need for sample filtration to measure CDOM absorption accurately, which the field-portable laser fluorometer overcomes by providing rapid, high-resolution fluorescence measurements on unfiltered samples. |
21 Citations | CDOM absorption can vary spatially but not temporally, limiting its predictive value for water pollution. Challenges include the need for complementary methods to trace pollution sources effectively. |
9 Citations | CDOM absorption varies by region and trophic state, affecting its relationship with DOC. CDOM may not be a universal proxy for DOC estimation due to regional variability. |
Limitations include weak correlations between CDOM absorption and pollutants like DOC, TN, NH4-N, and CODMn. Challenges involve accurately predicting water pollution solely based on CDOM absorption coefficients. | |
9 Citations | Limitations include CDOM absorption not solely indicative of effluent, challenges in distinguishing sources due to similar spectral shapes, and reliance on fluorescence-based indicators for differentiation. |
29 Citations | The limitations of using CDOM absorption for predicting water pollution include the influence of terrigenous inputs, variations in seasonal values, and the presence of UDOM from human sources. |
7 Citations | Challenges include low CDOM optical signal and complex optical conditions in inland waters, impacting accurate CDOM absorption coefficient estimation for water pollution prediction. |