Search or ask a question

What are the local political (municipal) causes behind the Detroit water shutoffs?

Framing (construction)

Best insight from top research papers

The Detroit water shutoffs stem from historical government-sanctioned racial residential segregation policies that persist today, leading to a decrease in black homeownership and wealth, and diverting taxpayer funds away from essential services like water . Austerity-driven accounting practices are used to justify water disconnections, reflecting urban governance characterized by "rule by accountancy" . News coverage often frames the crisis as an economic burden on the city, attributing responsibility to the government while neglecting the human rights and health implications for affected residents . Invisible water insecurity in Detroit disproportionately affects Black households in impoverished areas due to structural disadvantages rooted in a legacy of racism and segregation . The municipal causes of the Detroit water shutoffs thus intertwine historical racial segregation, austerity measures, and inadequate government responses, exacerbating water insecurity in the city.

Answers from top 4 papers

PDF

Open Access

More filters

Papers (4)	Insight
Journal Article•DOI A bucket in the river: race and public discourse on water shutoffs in Detroit Jessi Quizar 21 May 2020-Social Identities 1 Citations	The paper does not directly address the specific local political (municipal) causes behind the Detroit water shutoffs.
Open access•Journal Article•DOI Government failure or irresponsible residents? Framing Detroit’s water shutoffs before and during the COVID-19 pandemic Kelsey Mesmer, Darryl Frazier, Scott Burgess - Show less +2 more 28 Feb 2022-Newspaper Research Journal	The Detroit water shutoffs were primarily framed as a government failure, attributing responsibility to the city's government for the ongoing crisis, as highlighted in local newspapers.
Journal Article•DOI Water Shutoffs During COVID-19 and Black Lives: Case Study Detroit 01 Oct 2022-Environmental Justice 2 Citations	The Detroit water shutoffs are influenced by historical racial segregation policies, diverting funds from public services to benefit elites, reflecting systemic racism and economic disparities in municipal governance.
Journal Article•DOI The politics of owing: Accounting, water disconnection, and austerity urbanism in Detroit Melissa Heil 25 Nov 2022-Environment And Planning C: Politics And Space	Accounting practices in Detroit justified water disconnections as part of austerity urbanism, reflecting political decisions to manage finances, impacting social relations and urban conditions.

My columns

Related Questions

How does urban politics affect Municipal solid waste management?5 answersUrban politics significantly influences Municipal Solid Waste Management (MSWM) practices. The Politics of Trash highlights how corruption, gender, and racial hierarchies historically shaped waste collection programs in American cities, showcasing the impact of political decisions on sanitation. In Yaoundé, Cameroon, socio-political practices of stakeholders affect household waste management, with blame games hindering efficient waste governance. The political economy of urbanization and waste management in developing countries emphasizes the need for effective systems and financial viability, requiring capacity development across society. In Ghana, the lack of attention to urbanites' roles in MSWM has led to poor waste management, with political influences in awarding contracts contributing to the problem. Similarly, in Kwekwe, Zimbabwe, inadequate funding, staffing, and resident cooperation impact solid waste management, necessitating a focus on environmental stewardship principles.

What are the political causes of global warming?5 answersThe political causes of global warming stem from the intense debates and conflicting interests among nations, politicians, and multinational corporations. The politicization of climate change is driven by economic, developmental, and strategic motives, leading to discord in international agreements and negotiations. While scientific evidence points to human-induced greenhouse gas emissions intensifying global warming, there is a strong opposition arguing for natural causes and minimal human contribution. This political struggle over climate change is further complicated by cultural influences that either deny the existence of global warming or recognize it as a severe threat, hindering effective mitigation efforts at both local and global levels. Ultimately, the politics surrounding global warming reflect a clash of interests and ideologies that impede unified action to address this pressing environmental challenge.

Why is there inequality in water in Detroit?4 answersIn Detroit, there is inequality in water access due to historical racial residential segregation policies that persist today. These policies have led to a decrease in black homeownership and wealth, as well as integration and democratically elected governance. The banking/housing industries, water access, and government policies are interconnected, resulting in taxpayer money being diverted away from affordable housing, home loans, and public services like water. This has created a system where the impoverished black population of Detroit is taxed and fined for water, while elites and the largely white suburban population receive free or reduced water rates. The relationship between water shut-offs and race and poverty is linked to structural disadvantage caused by a legacy of racism and segregation in the city. Industrial activity, often located in minority and low-income areas, has also contributed to water contamination and violations of drinking water standards. Historical redlining and housing trends have further exacerbated these inequalities.

Who cares about local politics?4 answersLocal politics is an important area of study that has been overlooked in political science. Understanding local politics can contribute to broader debates in political science and provide insights into unique aspects of cities. The study of local politics can help scholars better understand gender and politics, as well as authoritarian politics. Local government plays a significant role in suburbs and small towns, impacting various policy domains such as zoning, growth, integration, and public housing. Analyzing local politics within a polity-centered approach can provide valuable insights into major theoretical and empirical debates in American politics, such as the rise of conservative government. By studying local politics, researchers can gain a better understanding of political participation, cognition, and the factors influencing individuals' engagement in the local political process.

What are the factors that influence local government budget performance?5 answersFactors that influence local government budget performance include regional income, legislative size, regional government size, level of regional wealth, regional GDP, agriculture and industry volume, and the number of small business entities. The effect of these factors on budget performance varies. Regional income has a negative effect on financial performance. Legislative size, regional government size, and level of regional wealth have a positive and significant effect on financial performance. Regional GDP, agriculture and industry volume have a positive influence on local budget income, while the influence of the number of small business entities is not statistically significant. Additionally, budget planning is a significant driver of budget performance.

What can explain local policy failure?5 answersLocal policy failure can be explained by several factors. One factor is the inability of policymakers to plan for long-term population decline, which can be seen as a policy failure itself. Another factor is the perception of local failure by the central government, which influences the effectiveness of strategies aimed at recovering poor-performing local authorities. Additionally, failures in implementing intergovernmental programs can be attributed to the resistance of local actors to comply with federal goals and objectives. Furthermore, the effectiveness of local economic policies in creating employment is influenced by the circumstances and conditions in which they are implemented. Lastly, policy failure is a relational process that emerges from long-term interactions between political actors and governance institutions, and can have generative effects even after the failure occurs.

See what other people are reading

What is agenda setting theory?

Agenda Setting Theory is a communication theory that highlights the media's ability to influence public perception by emphasizing certain topics as important. It focuses on how the media's selection and presentation of news can shape what the public considers significant, ultimately impacting their opinions and priorities. Over the years, Agenda Setting Theory has evolved to encompass a wide range of subjects beyond traditional public affairs, including military, climate, and finance. Scholars from various disciplines such as media studies, political science, and public health have explored this theory, with a notable emphasis on issues like political advocacy, governance, and social activism. The theory's relevance persists in today's society, especially in addressing global challenges like waste, pollution, and climate change, by leveraging media platforms to raise awareness and influence public attitudes.How does message framing influence public perceptions and decision-making regarding vaccines?

Message framing plays a crucial role in shaping public perceptions and decision-making regarding vaccines. Studies have shown that different frames, such as egoism, altruism, and loss-framed information, can impact individuals' willingness to receive a COVID-19 vaccine. Additionally, communication strategies focusing on vaccine safety/efficacy with emotive imagery descriptions can enhance vaccine uptake, especially among hesitant individuals. The effectiveness of gain-framed and loss-framed narratives in changing health behaviors depends on factors like individuals' stages of change, perceived risk, vulnerability, and control. Moreover, the framing effect, a cognitive bias, can lead to significant changes in people's opinions on vaccination-related issues, potentially misrepresenting scientific findings and influencing decision-making processes.What is meant by a centralized decision making by an autocratic leader?

Centralized decision-making by an autocratic leader refers to the concentration of decision-making powers in the hands of a single authority figure, often for the sake of political survival and control. This approach is influenced by the leader's need to maintain power and authority. In non-democratic states, such as autocracies, leaders may centralize decision-making to ensure their political survival, with the specific concerns and methods varying based on the type of autocracy, be it single-party, military, or personalist. Centralization of decision-making processes can lead to a reduction in citizen participation and local variation, as seen in the case of Turkey post-2008 financial crisis, where urban financialization drove fast and centralized decision-making, weakening local institutions. This centralization can also impact the evolution of cultural systems, with centralized societies not necessarily having a single all-powerful ruler.Amanda knox case study

The Amanda Knox case, involving the murder of Meredith Kercher in Italy, highlighted issues of gendered portrayals and legal system representations. Knox was depicted as a malign sexual deviant, while Kercher was transformed into a virtuous victim, reinforcing gender stereotypes. The case also shed light on the Italian Criminal Justice System, where Knox faced two convictions and two acquittals, revealing procedural flaws and the prosecutorial strategies of figures like Mr. Mignini. Media representations and public interactions with news articles during the case demonstrated selective recontextualization and transformation of legal elements, influencing perceptions of guilt and innocence. Knox's online declaration of innocence through a tweet was analyzed in the context of crime, celebrity culture, and changing media landscapes, showing the performative nature of constructed identities in legal and media discourses.Types of sustainability messages ?

Different types of sustainability messages include emotional, normative, gain, sensual, and guilt appeals. These messages play a crucial role in promoting sustainable behavior among consumers and employees. Sustainability messages can be framed in various ways to influence individuals' emotions, beliefs, and intentions towards sustainable practices. For instance, gain framing emphasizing cost-saving information has been found to have a powerful impact on encouraging sustainable choices. Additionally, the source of the message, whether it is from the company itself or a social media influencer, can also impact the effectiveness of sustainability communication. Overall, utilizing different message framing types and sources can effectively persuade stakeholders to engage in sustainable activities and support corporate sustainability initiatives.What are the most popular mediums or channels used to disseminate information about sustainable water use?

The dissemination of information about sustainable water use commonly occurs through various channels. Social media platforms play a significant role in communicating sustainability practices, aiding in raising awareness, fostering engagement, and generating interactivity with audiences. Additionally, newspaper articles have been analyzed using natural language processing techniques to gain insights into human-nature interactions with water, highlighting dynamics in water-related dialogues across different regions in the United States. Moreover, communication strategies for promoting new sustainable technologies, such as self-cleaning fish screens, involve utilizing trusted sources, research-grounded information, hands-on experiences, and focusing on benefits for the target audience. Overall, a combination of social media, traditional media like newspapers, and targeted communication strategies are crucial in disseminating information about sustainable water use effectively.How do writing center multilingual tutors identities construct?

Writing center multilingual tutors construct their identities through a combination of literacy practices, empathy, and rhetorical attunement, influenced by their multilingual upbringing and training. These tutors engage in practical reasoning, shifting between directive and nondirective methods to create epistemic tutorial interactions. The study of first-year multilingual writers visiting writing centers highlights discrepancies between tutor and writer views of sessions, with tutors focusing on development and organization while writers emphasize sentence-level accuracy. Additionally, the writing center environment plays a crucial role in shaping tutor identities, with practices evolving over time through exposure to rhetorical education, training courses, and continual practice of tutoring. Ultimately, the complexities of tracing literacy practices and the impact of formal and informal education underscore the development of multilingual writing tutors' identities.Where the Blame Lies: Unpacking Groups Into Their Constituent Subgroups Shifts Judgments of Blame in Intergroup Conflict?

Unpacking groups into their constituent subgroups shifts judgments of blame in intergroup conflict by increasing perceived responsibility of the unpacked group for the conflict. This shift is influenced by the victim-perpetrator paradigm, where groups construct and maintain claims to victim status to differentiate themselves from perceived perpetrators. Group identification, particularly with subgroups, plays a crucial role in determining feelings of collective guilt, with high subgroup identifiers experiencing varying levels of guilt based on the presence of a third party. Social psychology highlights the importance of individual judgmental processes in understanding intergroup conflicts, despite conflicts primarily involving groups and institutions. Understanding these dynamics can aid in addressing and potentially resolving intergroup conflicts effectively.How can video games be used to help science and research teams?

Video games can be valuable tools for science and research teams in various ways. They can be used to measure the abilities of non-human animals, foster creative solutions in scientific software user interface design, attune citizen scientists to collective responsibilities in scientific research, and serve as academic games for generating, evaluating, or disseminating knowledge within academic institutions. Additionally, video games designed as research tools must meet scientific protocol requirements while providing an engaging gaming experience, requiring extensive planning and support for trans-disciplinary teams. These games can collect rich data to study fundamental research questions in fields like psychology and human-computer interaction, assessing and training cognitive and non-cognitive traits and abilities of players.What is the role of family in criminology?

The family plays a crucial role in criminology by being a significant factor in the formation and prevention of delinquent behavior. Family relationships are studied in the context of criminogenic factors, societal influences, and the impact on criminal behavior. Research has historically focused on the role of parents in understanding the causes of crime, emphasizing contemporary risk factor approaches. Government responses to riots have highlighted the importance of family dynamics, with programs like the 'Troubled Families' initiative aiming to address issues within crimogenic families. Family criminology is a complex field that recognizes the family as a fundamental social unit influencing individual socialization and behavior, making it a critical aspect of understanding and preventing criminal activities.What are the current trends and practices in mentoring pre-service teachers in Australian teacher education?

Current trends and practices in mentoring pre-service teachers in Australian teacher education involve a focus on high-quality mentoring, collaboration between schools and universities, and the importance of context in mentoring relationships. Schools like the New South Wales Department of Education's Hub Schools program emphasize constructive feedback and mentorship growth. Professional-experience coordinators play a key role in mentoring pre-service teachers, considering student diversity and values in their journey to becoming educators. The literature review highlights new mentoring models, tools for support, and the impact of context on mentorship work, calling for further research on mentor professional development and long-term mentoring studies. Effective mentoring implementation includes collaboration, coaching, and authentic learning situations, with mentor teachers acting as knowledge providers and facilitators.