Search or ask a question

What are the most effective tools and instruments for evaluating evidence-based teaching and learning practices in classrooms?

Generalizability theory

Psychological intervention

Best insight from top research papers

Various tools and instruments have been developed to evaluate evidence-based teaching and learning practices in classrooms. The Practical Observation Rubric to Assess Active Learning (PORTAAL) is a validated tool that measures the presence, intensity, and duration of evidence-based teaching practices, showing positive correlations with student exam performance . Additionally, the KACE assessment tool assesses EBP learning outcomes, focusing on knowledge, attitudes, familiarity with evidence sources, and critical appraisal skills, demonstrating positive results in dental students . A systematic review identified 12 tools for assessing EBM competencies in medical education, with six tools of reasonable validity available for evaluating most steps of EBM and some domains of EBM learning . However, no single teaching modality has been identified as superior in increasing learner competency in evidence-based practice .

Answers from top 4 papers

PDF

Open Access

More filters

Papers (4)	Insight
Open access•Journal Article•DOI Evidence-based teaching practices correlate with increased exam performance in biology. Sungmin Moon, Mallory A. Jackson, Jennifer H. Doherty, Mary Pat Wenderoth - Show less +3 more 30 Nov 2021-PLOS ONE 4 Citations	The Practical Observation Rubric to Assess Active Learning (PORTAAL) is an effective tool for evaluating evidence-based teaching practices in classrooms, correlating with increased exam performance in biology.
Open access•Journal Article•DOI A systematic review and taxonomy of tools for evaluating evidence-based medicine teaching in medical education Bharathy Kumaravel, Jasmine Heath Hearn, Leila Jahangiri, Rachel Pollard, Claire J. Stocker, David Nunan - Show less +5 more 24 Apr 2020-Systematic Reviews 21 Citations	Six high-quality tools are available for evaluating most steps of evidence-based medicine (EBM) teaching, focusing on knowledge gain and skills in medical education. Further tool development is recommended.
Open access•Journal Article•DOI Evidence Based Practice: Assessing the educational outcome 29 Aug 2022	The KACE assessment tool is effective for evaluating evidence-based teaching outcomes in dental education, measuring knowledge, attitudes, familiarity with evidence sources, and critical appraisal skills.
Open access•Journal Article•DOI Methods of teaching evidence-based practice: a systematic review Bethany Howard, Basia Diug, Dragan Ilic - Show less +2 more 26 Oct 2022-BMC Medical Education 4 Citations	Not addressed in the paper.

My columns

Related Questions

Https://typeset.io/search?q= What methods do educators use to assess student learning in the classroom?5 answersEducators utilize various methods to assess student learning in the classroom. These methods include classroom assessment, standardized tests, teacher evaluations, formative assessments, summative assessments, and online assessment. Classroom assessment involves gathering evidence of student performance to guide instruction and grading, emphasizing the importance of creating the right assessment environment. Standardized tests and teacher evaluations inform stakeholders about student progress, guiding study efforts and course choices, while also influencing school effectiveness and student sorting. Formative assessments aid in guiding student learning, while summative assessments measure course outcomes and provide feedback for curriculum enhancement. Online assessment is crucial in digital classrooms, requiring a balance of technology, pedagogy, and learning outcomes to comprehensively evaluate student learning.

What are the tools of educational technology?5 answersEducational technology encompasses various tools that enhance teaching and learning processes. Some prominent tools include FORVO, YouGlish, and OALD 8th ed. for improving speaking performance. Additionally, Big Data plays a crucial role in education, facilitating Technology Enabled Learning (TEL) and Outcome Based Education (OBE) through AI-based Ed-Tech tools. Digital educational resources like learning management programs, online quizzes, interactive worksheets, and video lessons are also essential tools for creating engaging learning experiences. Furthermore, free digital tools such as learning management systems, collaboration tools, search engines, content creation tools, and content sharing tools are beneficial for educators in traditional and online course delivery. Overall, the integration of various educational technology tools is vital for enhancing the quality and effectiveness of teaching and learning processes.

How is research evidence used in education?4 answersResearch evidence is used in education to inform decision-making and improve educational practices. Graduates from EdD programs combine research use for decision-making and persuasion purposes. Quality use of research evidence in education involves appropriate research evidence, thoughtful engagement and implementation, and enabling components such as skillsets, mindsets, relationships, leadership, culture, and infrastructure. Teachers value evidence that is relevant, approachable, accessible, and practical, and they rely more on experiences of educational practices rather than theoretical knowledge. In the UK Parliament, evidence is sometimes avoided in debates, and moral sidestepping is used to support claims without empirical evidence. However, there is still limited knowledge about how to effectively get research evidence into use in education, and more research is needed to understand the best approaches.

What are the most effective ways to evaluate educational technology?5 answersEffective ways to evaluate educational technology include using frameworks and tools that focus on addressing student learning needs and driving learning improvement. One such tool is the Education Technology Value Evaluation Tool, which provides a structured approach to defining metrics for success and establishing criteria for ongoing evaluation. Another approach is the use of a tailored realist evaluation framework, which helps gather evidence about wider influences and theories of potential future impact. Additionally, a holistic framework based on four distinct dimensions can be used to set up evaluation activities, with the focus on the mutual dependence between evaluation dimensions and procedures. It is also important to adopt evaluation strategies from the social science community, such as realist evaluation, which explores context-driven and evidence-based techniques.

Artificial intelligence tools to evaluate students?5 answersArtificial intelligence (AI) tools have been developed extensively for evaluating student learning outcomes. These tools provide a brand-new learning environment, free from the constraints of traditional teaching time and space, and offer a wealth of learning resources and tools. By analyzing student data, AI-based evaluation methods can predict whether students will successfully complete a course and identify learning problems in real-time. This enables teachers to provide personalized guidance and interventions for at-risk students, improving teaching strategies and outcomes. AI techniques, such as concept mapping and natural language processing, are used to assess a student's understanding of a particular topic and evaluate their knowledge. These tools have been successfully tested in various undergraduate courses, particularly in the areas of mathematics and concept mapping. Additionally, big data analysis combined with AI can be used to study student evaluations of teaching, providing valuable insights for educational institutions.

What are the tools in technology to use in educational teaching?5 answers

See what other people are reading

What is the rate of tobacco usage among adolescent in Bangladesh?

The rate of tobacco usage among adolescents in Bangladesh is a significant public health concern. Studies indicate that the prevalence of smoking among adolescent males in selected communities is 25.0%. Additionally, data from the Global Adult Tobacco Survey (GATS) in Bangladesh shows that 40.0% of males and 25.2% of females use tobacco, with 36.2% of males and 0.8% of females engaging in smoking tobacco. Furthermore, the analysis of GATS data reveals that around 89% of current tobacco users initiated tobacco use before the age of 18 years, emphasizing the early onset of tobacco use among youth in Bangladesh. Efforts to reduce tobacco use through community interventions have shown promising results, with a decline observed from 58.8% in 2006 to 43.4% in 2014 in rural areas. Addressing tobacco use among adolescents in Bangladesh requires targeted interventions and policy measures to curb this concerning trend.What is the current situation of mental health among adolescent in South asia?

The current situation of adolescent mental health in South Asia is concerning. South Asian countries face challenges such as high prevalence of mental illnesses, limited mental health professionals, inadequate resources, and stigma towards mental health. Studies show that adolescents in South Asia are exposed to significant mental health risks, with limited access to mental health services and underdeveloped policies for prevention and treatment. Research gaps exist in understanding the prevalence, risk factors, and interventions for adolescent girls and young women's mental health during pregnancy and postpartum in low- and middle-income countries, including South Asia. The COVID-19 pandemic has further exacerbated mental health concerns among the general population in South Asia, highlighting the need for interventions and mental health counseling.What are the specific psychological benefits of using Uno cards in therapy sessions?

The use of OH Cards in therapy sessions has shown significant psychological benefits in various studies. OH Cards have been found to increase posttraumatic growth scores, improve coping styles, reduce stress disorders, decrease depression, enhance psychological states, increase knowledge about fractures, and promote recovery in children with fractures. Additionally, group therapy based on Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) with flashcards has been effective in reducing violent behavior in schizophrenic patients, showing a 66.6% effectiveness rate. Moreover, CBT with flashcards has been successful in reducing low self-esteem in schizophrenia patients by 65.6%, leading to increased self-esteem and adaptive behavior. Therefore, the utilization of card-based interventions like OH Cards and flashcards in therapy sessions can offer valuable psychological benefits for individuals undergoing treatment.How does deployment impact military wives' mental health?

Deployment can significantly impact military wives' mental health. Research has shown that military spouses may experience psychological distress due to various factors related to deployment and military life. Problems from service-related moves have been found to be associated with increased psychological stress among partners, even when considering the service members' PTSD symptoms and deployment separation. Additionally, bidirectional associations between marital distress and symptoms of anxiety and depression have been observed during specific periods after deployment, highlighting the complex interplay between marital relationships and mental health outcomes in military families. These findings underscore the importance of addressing the unique challenges faced by military spouses during and after their partners' deployments to safeguard their mental well-being.How does resilience in health care worker can be enhanced?

Resilience in healthcare workers can be enhanced through various strategies. One effective method is through interprofessional education (IPE) programs that focus on developing adaptability and resilience skills. Additionally, web-based interventions have shown promise in improving resilience among healthcare professionals, with studies indicating positive outcomes in enhancing resilience levels following the implementation of such interventions. It is crucial to empower healthcare professionals by providing them with resilience-promoting strategies that address both intra- and interpersonal dimensions of control, coherence, and connectedness. Furthermore, fostering a culture of wellness within healthcare organizations can contribute to enhancing both personal and organizational resilience, ultimately leading to improved quality of healthcare delivery and workforce wellbeing. By incorporating these approaches, healthcare workers can better navigate the challenges they face and maintain their mental health and well-being.What grade level do students morelikely to wear uniform?

Middle and high school students, particularly in grades 7 and 8, are more likely to wear uniforms. A study involving 604 middle school students revealed that students in these grades perceived various benefits of wearing school uniforms, such as increased safety, confidence, and self-esteem. Additionally, a survey conducted with 907 middle and high school students found that most students wore uniforms, indicating a prevalent uniform-wearing culture among these age groups. Furthermore, a study focusing on attitudes towards uniform modification among middle and high school girls showed that a significant portion of students expressed a willingness to modify their uniforms to align with fashion trends and personal expression, highlighting an active engagement with uniform-related choices in these grade levels.What are the most effective massage techniques for relieving symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome?

Manual therapy techniques, including nerve mobilization and myofascial release, have shown effectiveness in relieving symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). Nerve mobilization involves moving and stretching the nerve tissue to alleviate discomfort and pain associated with CTS. On the other hand, myofascial release focuses on massage techniques and stretching instructions to relieve pain, increase range of motion, and balance the body. Research indicates that both nerve mobilization and myofascial release can significantly reduce pain in CTS patients. Therefore, a combination of these techniques, particularly soft tissue mobilization and neurodynamic therapy, may provide the best results for improving symptoms of mild to moderate CTS.What are the strategies to manage social media body dissatisfaction?

Adolescents employ various strategies to manage social media-induced body dissatisfaction. These include avoiding negative content, selecting positive content, critically evaluating body-related content, psychologically distancing from challenging content, and positively reframing such content. Boys tend to exhibit more positive agency over their bodies and social media use, utilizing active coping styles more frequently than girls. Additionally, research suggests that exposure to fitspiration on social media can lead to increased body dissatisfaction, especially among women. To combat this, promoting media literacy education is crucial to help individuals interpret social media content correctly and develop critical analytical skills. Implementing such educational initiatives, especially targeting adolescents, can help mitigate the negative effects of social media on body image perceptions.What are the emotional challenges faced by military wives during deployment?

Military wives face various emotional challenges during their spouses' deployment. Research indicates that problems related to frequent relocations significantly contribute to increased psychological distress in partners, surpassing the impact of deployment separation and service members' PTSD symptoms. Additionally, the pre-deployment phase involves preparing children for the absence of the military parent and intensifying intimacy between the couple before separation, while during deployment, challenges include increased parental responsibilities, insecurity about the marital relationship, and concerns for the deployed partner's well-being. Furthermore, the post-deployment phase requires the reintegration of the military member, leading to the need for reorganizing parental roles and responsibilities and reestablishing intimacy within the couple. These emotional challenges highlight the complex dynamics military wives navigate throughout the deployment cycle.What are the current guidelines for screen time recommendations for adolescents based on research and expert opinions?

Current guidelines for screen time recommendations for adolescents emphasize the importance of reducing screen time and promoting physical activity to prevent cardiometabolic diseases in adulthood. Studies have shown that high screen time is significantly associated with reduced physical activity, gender differences, and unhealthy dietary patterns among urban adolescents. Excessive screen time has been linked to negative outcomes in cognitive, social, emotional, and physical development in children, highlighting the need for limited and monitored screen exposure. Furthermore, research indicates a positive association between increased screen time and the risk of overweight/obesity among adolescents, emphasizing the detrimental effects of prolonged screen exposure on health. Excessive screen time has also been associated with mental health problems in adolescents, particularly affecting mental well-being and increasing the risk of depression, underscoring the importance of regulating screen time for overall well-being.What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of using digital tools in the treatment of psychological disorders?

The integration of digital tools in the treatment of psychological disorders presents a multifaceted landscape of potential benefits and drawbacks. On the benefits side, digital interventions offer accessibility and scalability, extending the reach of psychological therapies to those who might not otherwise seek treatment due to attitudinal barriers such as a lack of motivation or stigma associated with mental health issues. These tools, including mobile applications and virtual reality (VR), have shown effectiveness in treating conditions like psychosis, with cognitive VR therapy reducing delusions and distress. Digital health tools also promise more accurate and comprehensive measures of patient behavior, potentially improving treatment outcomes in depression. Moreover, the use of information and communication technology in mental health care can improve access to specialized care, reduce care delays, and diminish stigma. However, the drawbacks of digital interventions cannot be overlooked. The rapid development of digital technologies has outpaced the evaluation of their efficacy, leading to a lagging infrastructure and skill base, which limits their application in mental health care. There are also concerns about the safety, effectiveness, and equity of digital mental health tools, with many not backed by evidence of their efficacy. Additionally, while digital tools can enhance engagement and learning, challenges such as accessibility issues and limited content can hinder their effectiveness. The integration of digital therapeutics into clinical care faces challenges in uptake and engagement, with no clear models for their integration and significant underutilization by service users. Furthermore, apprehensions towards technology exist among both patients and professionals, highlighting the need for patient empowerment and trust in technology. In summary, while digital tools in psychological treatment offer promising avenues for expanding access and improving outcomes, their implementation is fraught with challenges related to efficacy, infrastructure, and acceptance among users and providers.