What are the potential benefits and challenges of implementing multi-centric governance in various settings?
Best insight from top research papers
Implementing multi-centric governance offers various benefits and challenges across different settings. The benefits include the ability to bring together diverse actors for the provision of collective goods , enhance city center development by focusing on local community needs and balancing public and private sector responsibilities , and achieve effective policy implementation through a central coordinating authority in multilevel governance systems . However, challenges arise in the form of substantive problem-solving, collaborative process, and multi-relational accountability challenges, which require a 'both/and' mindset to transcend and make progress in collaborative efforts . Additionally, in the context of transitioning to Smart Mobility, managing multi-level governance systems becomes complex due to the need for policy alignment between different governing tiers and entities .
Answers from top 5 papers
More filters
| Papers (5) | Insight |
|---|---|
| Multi-agency collaborations face challenges like substantive problem-solving, collaborative process, and accountability issues. Overcoming these through a 'both/and' mindset can lead to effective governance. | |
| Multi-centric governance can benefit from a central coordinating authority enforcing compliance, mobilizing actors, and providing resources, but challenges may arise in balancing power dynamics and ensuring effective coordination. | |
13 Aug 2020 5 Citations | Multi-level governance (MLG) offers advantages like policy innovation and de-risking, but challenges include aligning priorities and mandates across different governing tiers, crucial for implementing new policy instruments effectively. |
| Implementing multi-centric governance can enhance city centre development by bringing local needs to the forefront. Challenges include coordination complexities, but benefits include improved stakeholder engagement and project selection. | |
| Potential benefits of multi-centric governance include enhanced accountability and effectiveness, while challenges may involve issues of coherence and legitimacy, as well as overlooking un-institutionalized politics. |
Related Questions
What are the challenges and potential solutions in designing and implementing effective multidisciplinary health residency programs?5 answersDesigning and implementing effective multidisciplinary health residency programs face challenges such as disparate definitions and educational approaches, limited understanding of interactions between trainees, programs, and health systems, lack of multidisciplinary work, and extensive workloads. To address these challenges, a multilevel systems approach integrating health system and educational performance data is proposed, emphasizing the need for collaboration to produce integrated datasets linking health systems and GME-sponsoring institutions. Additionally, promoting interprofessional education and collaborative practices within residency programs can enhance holistic awareness, complementarity among professionals, and contribute to the integrality of care, thus potentially overcoming operationalization challenges.
What are the potential benefits and challenges of implementing a multidisciplinary approach in trauma care settings?4 answersImplementing a multidisciplinary approach in trauma care settings has the potential to bring several benefits. It allows for comprehensive and evidence-based approaches to optimize patient outcomes. Collaborative efforts between different specialties, such as ophthalmology, plastic surgery, and otorhinolaryngology, are crucial in managing injuries that pose a risk to vision. Addressing mental health needs and integrating early psychological support into patient care plans can help in managing the significant prevalence of psychological distress among trauma patients. Hemostatic procedures, such as laparotomy and angioembolization, have been associated with improved survival in solid organ injury patients requiring blood transfusion. However, implementing a multidisciplinary approach also comes with challenges. The wide spectrum and distinct lesions resulting from traumatic brain injury make the process of post-TBI rehabilitation challenging. Additionally, there may be challenges in de-implementing low-value clinical practices in trauma care, which require multifaceted interventions and careful consideration of unintended consequences.
What are the potential benefits and challenges of integrating AI into participatory governance processes?5 answersIntegrating AI into participatory governance processes has the potential to bring both benefits and challenges. On the benefits side, AI can contribute to social good by transforming individual lives, business operations, and public services. It can also help in achieving gold-standard societal values such as fairness, freedom, and long-term sustainability in AI regulation. Additionally, AI can improve anticipation and identification of impacts, facilitate better communication with policy and governance experts, and strengthen the norms around responsible research. On the other hand, there are challenges to consider. These include a lack of recognized best practices and procedural transparency, researcher opportunity costs, institutional and social pressures, cognitive biases, and the difficulty of the task itself. It is important to address these challenges by increasing transparency, improving guidance, creating incentives for engagement, and facilitating public deliberation. Overall, integrating AI into participatory governance processes can lead to significant benefits but requires careful consideration of the associated challenges.
What is the challenges and issue that confronting governance?5 answersGovernance faces several challenges and issues. One major challenge is the institutionalization of democratic governance systems, particularly in Bangladesh. Another challenge is the eradication of corruption, which has become pervasive in all aspects of life in Bangladesh. Additionally, the politicization of public services for personal and political interests is a key challenge in governance in Bangladesh. In the realm of cyberspace governance, accountability structures are often decentralized, posing challenges such as the problem of many hands and the hybridity of institutional arrangements. The governance model also faces difficulties associated with multi-level decision-making, a decline in public trust, and dysfunctional institutional legacies. Furthermore, governance raises constitutional issues and challenges in relation to state-sponsored network steering, network accountability, and equality of access to decision-making. These challenges and issues require conscious reframing and discursive construction of accountability relationships.
What are some of the challenges and opportunities associated with multidisciplinary technological approaches?5 answersMultidisciplinary technological approaches present both challenges and opportunities. On the one hand, the complexity of modern problems requires expertise from multiple disciplines to effectively address them. This need for collaboration arises from the realization that certain issues, such as climate change, cannot be adequately understood or solved by a single field of study. Additionally, investigating systems or phenomena from different perspectives and levels of organization can provide a more comprehensive understanding. On the other hand, the integration of different disciplines can be challenging, as it requires researchers to bridge gaps in knowledge and methodologies. Furthermore, there may be difficulties in coordinating efforts and ensuring effective communication among team members from diverse backgrounds. However, the convergence of technologies and the availability of advanced tools and resources offer exciting opportunities for multidisciplinary approaches to drive innovation and develop new solutions. These approaches have the potential to address complex problems more effectively and lead to transformative advancements in various fields.
How can multi-level governance be improved in the European Union?4 answersMulti-level governance in the European Union can be improved by promoting the principles of efficiency, democracy, and accountability in local government. The principle of multi-level governance, which distributes authority across governance levels and increases participation of governmental and non-state actors, contributes to the democratic legitimacy of EU decisions. Additionally, greater institutionalization of coordination between control subsystems can help optimize the complexity of multi-level financial management systems. Furthermore, understanding the heterogeneity of the EU in terms of administrative configurations and spatial governance and planning systems is crucial for successful regional development governance. By identifying the regional level as the ideal spatial scale for resources' redistribution, the EU can enhance economic, social, and territorial cohesion.