Showing papers on "Naturalness published in 1992"

Problems of naturalness: Some lessons from string theory

Abstract: We consider some questions of naturalness which arise when one considers conventional field theories in the presence of gravitation: the problem of global symmetries, the strong CP problem, and the cosmological constant problem. Using string theory as a model, we argue that it is reasonable to postulate weakly broken global discrete symmetries. We review the arguments that gravity is likely to spoil the Peccei-Quinn solution of the strong CP problem, and update earlier analyses showing that discrete symmetries can lead to axions with suitable properties. Even if there are not suitable axions, we note that string theory is a theory in which CP is spontaneously broken and $\theta$ in principle calculable. $\theta$ thus might turn out to be small along lines suggested some time ago by Nelson and by Barr.

Looking for Those Natural Numbers: Dimensionless Constants and the Idea of Natural Measurement

Abstract: Many find it “notoriously difficult to see how societal context can affect in any essential way how someone solves a mathematical problem or makes a measurement.” That may be because it has been a habit of western scientists to assert their numerical schemes were untainted by any hint of anthropomorphism. Nevertheless, that Platonist penchant has always encountered obstacles in practice, primarily because the stability of any applied numerical scheme requires some alien or external warrant.This paper surveys the history of measurement standards, physical dimensions and dimensionless constants as one instance of the quest to purge all anthropomorphic taint first in the metric system, then in the dimensions provided by the atom, then in physical constants intelligible to extraterrestrials, only then to end up back at overt anthropomorphism in the late 20th century. This suggests that the “naturalness” of natural numbers has always been conceptualized in locally contingent cultural terms.

Problems of Naturalness: Some Lessons from String Theory

Abstract: We consider some questions of naturalness which arise when one considers conventional field theories in the presence of gravitation: the problem of global symmetries, the strong CP problem, and the cosmological constant problem. Using string theory as a model, we argue that it is reasonable to postulate weakly broken global discrete symmetries. We review the arguments that gravity is likely to spoil the Peccei-Quinn solution of the strong CP problem, and update earlier analyses showing that discrete symmetries can lead to axions with suitable properties. Even if there are not suitable axions, we note that string theory is a theory in which CP is spontaneously broken and $\theta$ in principle calculable. $\theta$ thus might turn out to be small along lines suggested some time ago by Nelson and by Barr.

The effect of accentuation and word duration on the naturalness of speech.

Abstract: In this study the effect of appropriate word duration and correct (pitch) accentuation on the naturalness of speech was investigated. In the stimulus material, the information value of the target word determined the correctness of accentuation ([new, +accent] and [old, −accent] were defined as correct). Appropriate word duration was defined as either ‘‘in agreement with accentuation’’ ([long, +accent] and [short, −accent]) or ‘‘in agreement with information value’’ ([long, new] and [short, old]). Listeners were asked to give naturalness judgments along a scale from 1 (very unnatural) to 10 (very natural) on fragments consisting of two sentences. Duration and accentuation of the target word, which always occurred in the second sentence, were manipulated separately and in combinations. Judgments show that accentuation that is not in agreement with information value causes a significant decrease of naturalness. When accentuation is in agreement with information value but duration is inappropriate for both factors, the perceived naturalness decreases significantly. However, listeners were unable to give consistent naturalness judgments on the manipulated word durations in fragments with incorrect accent distributions. Based on these results and the findings of an earlier production study [W. Eefting, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 89, 412–424 (1991)], which showed that duration is not involved in the realization of pitch accent, the following is suggested. Speakers adapt both accentuation and word duration in order to indicate that a word contains relevant information. Presence of an accent distinguishes the word from its (less relevant) environment. A longer duration provides the listener with the extra time that is needed in order to process the word’s content adequately.

Causal Thinking and Its Anthropological Misrepresentation

Abstract: The study of causal inferences is an essential part of the study of other cultures. It is therefore crucial to describe the cognitive mechanisms whereby subjects are led to find specific causal explanations plausible and "natural." In the anthropological literature, specific causal connections are described as the result produced by applying a general "conception of causation" or some general "theories" to specific events; the essay aims to show that these answers are either trivial or false. The "naturalness" of explanations must be examined in the context of concept acquisition and belief-fixation. On the basis of an ethnographic example, it is possible to show how certain presumptions (e.g., about the use of certain categories as natural kind terms) can be involved in the processes whereby certain explanations are made cognitively salient.