In this paper, our current understanding and recent advances in the study of ionospheric storms is reviewed, with emphasis on the F2-region. Ionospheric storms represent an extreme form of space weather with important effects on ground- and space-based technological systems. These phenomena are driven by highly variable solar and magnetospheric energy inputs to the Earth's upper atmosphere, which continue to provide a major difficulty for attempts now being made to simulate the detailed storm response of the coupled neutral and ionized upper atmospheric constituents using increasingly sophisticated global first principle physical models. Several major programs for coordinated theoretical and experimental study of these storms are now underway. These are beginning to bear fruit in the form of improved physical understanding and prediction of ionospheric storm effects at high, middle, and low latitude.

Ionospheric Storms — A Review

[1] Ionospheric scintillations are one of the earliest known effects of space weather. Caused by ionization density irregularities, scintillating signals change phase unexpectedly and vary rapidly in amplitude. GPS signals are vulnerable to ionospheric irregularities and scintillate with amplitude variations exceeding 20 dB. GPS is a weak signal system and scintillations can interrupt or degrade GPS receiver operation. For individual signals, interruption is caused by fading of the in-phase and quadrature signals, making the determination of phase by a tracking loop impossible. Degradation occurs when phase scintillations introduce ranging errors or when loss of tracking and failure to acquire signals increases the dilution of precision. GPS scintillations occur most often near the magnetic equator during solar maximum, but they can occur anywhere on Earth during any phase of the solar cycle. In this article we review the subject of GPS and ionospheric scintillations for scientists interested in space weather and engineers interested in the impact of scintillations on GPS receiver design and use.

/pdf/gps-and-ionospheric-scintillations-2xz209z6xl.pdf

GPS and ionospheric scintillations

The most intense, F region irregularities in the high-latitude ionosphere appear to be produced by convective plasma processes and in particular, by the fluid (gradient drift) interchange instability. Such irregularities are produced by convectively mixing plasma across a mean plasma density gradient with the transport of higher-density plasma into regions of lower-density plasma (and vice versa) leading to the development of an irregularity spectrum that extends in scale from about 10 km down to the ion gyroradius. The mean plasma density gradient that must be present to allow irregularity production by this interchange process appears to be associated with larger-scale (>10 km) plasma structure produced by other means. Because much of the recent progress on this research topic stems from this recognition, a significant portion of this review is dedicated to a description of the characteristics and processes of 10-km plasma structure and their relationships to those of smaller-scale irregularities. From this review, we synthesize a descriptive model of plasma structures in the high-latitude F layer that unifies most of the diverse and independent observations. For the large-scale plasma processes, the model includes (1) the formation of 1000-km-scale “patches” in the polar cap from solar-produced plasma that is transported poleward from lower latitudes; (2) the reconfiguration of patches as they convect into the auroral region and become the latitudinally confined, but longitudinally extended, plasma density enhancements near the equatorward auroral boundary; and (3) the production of localized enhancements and depletions along the poleward auroral boundary by soft-particle precipitation and large but localized electric fields. In the model, the most intense, smaller-scale irregularities are in spatial proximity to these large-scale plasma features, the implication being that the presence of the latter allows formation of the former. The irregularity characteristics are consistent with production by the instability and a morphology controlled by (1) a “slip” velocity (i.e., plasma drift relative to the neutral gas) that is moderately small except in regions of nonuniform plasma convection or under time-varying conditions (e.g., substorms, pulsation events) and (2) a highly conducting auroral E layer that damps irregularity growth and enhances decay. The final irregularity spectrum appears to be produced by (1) global convective processes acting on solar-produced plasma at the largest scales (>50 km), (2) particle precipitation at scales greater than 10 km, (3) perhaps some form of wave activity around 10 km, and (4) the instability at the smaller scales (<10 km).

High-Latitude F-Region Irregularities: A Review and Synthesis

Associated with the large-scale enhancement of the ionospheric convection electric field during disturbed geomagnetic conditions, solar-produced F region plasma is transported to and through the noontime cleft from a source region at middle and low latitudes in the afternoon sector. As a result of the offset between the geomagnetic and geographic poles, the afternoon sector region of strong sunward convection is shifted to increasingly lower geographic latitude throughout the interval between 12 UT and 24 UT. A snowplow effect occurs in which the convection cell continually encounters fresh corotating ionospheric plasma along its equatorward edge, producing a latitudinally narrow region of storm-enhanced plasma density (SED) and increased total electron content which is advected toward higher latitudes in the noon sector. The Millstone Hill incoherent scatter radar regularly observes SED as a spatially continuous, large-scale feature spanning local times between noon and midnight and at latitudes between the polar cap and its mid- or low-latitude source region. For local times away from noon, the latitude of most probable SED occurrence moves equatorward by 6° for an increase of 2 in the Kp index. During strong disturbances the topside SED is observed to be convecting sunward at ∼750 m s−1 with a flux of 1014 m−2 s−1. This feature accounts for the pronounced enhancement of ionospheric density near dusk at middle latitudes observed during the early stages of magnetic storms (called the dusk effect) and constitutes a source for the enhanced F region plasma observed in the polar cap during disturbed conditions.

Storm time plasma transport at middle and high latitudes

Ground-based optical and digital ionosonde measurements were conducted at Thule, Greenland to measure ionospheric structure and dynamics in the nighttime polar cap F layer. These observations showed the existence of large-scale (800-1000 km) plasma patches drifting in the antisunward direction during a moderately disturbed (Kp greater than or equal to 4) period. Simultaneous Dynamics Explorer (DE-B) low-altitude plasma instrument (LAPI) measurements show that these patches with peak densities of about 10 to the 6th el per cu cm are not locally produced by structured particle precipitation. The LAPI measurements show a uniform precipitation of polar rain electrons over the polar cap. The combined measurements provide a comprehensive description of patch structure and dynamics. They are produced near or equatorward of the dayside auroral zone and convect across the polar cap in the antisunward direction. Gradients within the large scale, drifting patches are subject to structuring by convective instabilities. UHF scintillation and spaced receiver measurements are used to map the resulting irregularity distribution within the patches.

F layer ionization patches in the polar cap

F-layer ionization patches in the polar cap

Coordinated measurements of F region plasma patches were conducted on February 3/4, 1984, from Thule and Sondrestrom, Greenland. Optical, ionosonde, amplitude scintillation, total electron content (TEC), and incoherent scatter radar measurements were combined to reveal several new aspects of the structure and transport of these localized regions of enhanced F region ionization. For the first time these patches were directly tracked flowing in the antisunward direction over distances of 3000 km from the center of the polar cap to the poleward edge of the auroral oval. Quantitative measurements of TEC show increases of 10--15 TEC units within the patches, above a background polar cap value of 5 TEC units. Amplitude scintillation measurements show the presence of ionospheric irregularities through the entire patch, with a weak indication of stronger scintillation on the trailing (or E x B unstable) edge.

Polar cap F layer patches: Structure and dynamics

All-sky imaging photometer measurements and ionospheric soundings taken at Thule, Greenland (86° corrected geomagnetic latitude), in December 1979 and January 1982 reveal the large-scale organization of the winter polar cap ionosphere. Three groups of forms have been identified: (1) The most predominant features are sun-aligned, generally unstructured, subvisual, F region arcs, extending for more than 1000 km (limit of all-sky field of view) across the polar cap. In general, these arcs drift from dawn to dusk at speeds between 100 and 250 m s−1; however, stagnation of arc drift and drift reversals have been observed. The arcs are produced by soft particle precipitation. (2) During a magnetically disturbed period the arcs disappeared, and large patches of enhanced F region ionization drifted at speeds of 250 to 700 m s−1 across the field of view in the antisunward direction. Although arcs are produced by soft particle precipitation, preliminary results from the Dynamics Explorer satellite do not indicate any localized soft electron precipitation into the patches. (3) On a few occasions both forms were observed simultaneously. Between F region sun-aligned arcs, which were drifting from dawn to dusk, small patches of ionization were observed moving at much higher speed in the antisunward direction. Both the arcs and the patches appear as strong localized irregularities in the ionospheric soundings. The Doppler information provided by the aircraft's Digisonde 128PS was used to relate backscatter traces to individual arcs or patches and to track individual features over more than 1500 km. For a large number of observations the time variation of measured Doppler velocities suggests specular reflection from electron density enhancements associated with the optical forms, rather than scatter from field-aligned irregularities imbedded in the arcs or patches. A simple velocity filter applied to the ionogram data permitted the generation of range-time characteristics for selected ionization drift velocities. A tendency for high velocities to occur during magnetically active periods was found. The ionospheric soundings showed that the F region arcs are bands of enhanced ionization, imbedded in a background ionosphere with a base height (h′F) of approximately 250 km and a critical frequency of approximately 4 MHz (∼2 × 105 el cm−3). The virtual heights in the ionograms did not change during transit of the arcs through the zenith. During the active periods, when the antisunward moving patches were observed, the background ionization dropped to less than 3 MHz (105 el cm−3) while the base height (h′F) moved up to heights above 400 km. The strongly ionized patches (f0 F2 > 8 MHz), however, were observed to reach a minimum virtual range of ∼250 km during the zenith transit, leading during their passage through the zenith to rapid h′F fluctuations of the order of 200 km within minutes.

Structure and dynamics of the winter polar cap F region

An investigation of the polar cap ionosphere near the peak of the last solar cycle identified polar cap F layer arcs and ionization patches as unique features of the polar cap ionosphere, and as sources of severe scintillations observed on 250-MHz satellite beacon signals. The continuing investigations in January and December 1983 and January 1984 have shown that arcs and patches persist as the dominant features of the winter polar cap ionosphere during periods of low sunspot numbers. Improved ionospheric soundings made at Thule, Greenland (86°CGL), showed a clear diurnal variation for the occurrence of the patch-type ionization. Discussion of various possible mechanisms producing the observed ionization patches leads to the conclusion that the solar produced ionosphere equatorward of the dayside cusp is the source region of the ionization patches. Polar plasma convection transports this ionization across the cusp and the central polar cap. The local time dependence of the occurrence of the patches at Thule is shown to be a manifestation of the well-known universal time control of the polar cap F region. A strong positive solar cycle dependence of the scintillations was measured during three extended campaigns and confirms earlier measurements. The diurnal variation of scintillations is almost flat at solar maximum and has a local time variation very similar to that of the patch type ionization at solar minimum. Both arcs and patches contribute to substantial scintillations around solar maximum, while only the patches are responsible for the considerably weaker scintillations during solar minimum.

E. J. Weber

Papers

F layer ionization patches in the polar cap

F-layer ionization patches in the polar cap

Polar cap F layer patches: Structure and dynamics

Structure and dynamics of the winter polar cap F region

Ionospheric structures in the polar cap: Their origin and relation to 250‐MHz scintillation