Targeted mutation of the DNA methyltransferase gene results in embryonic lethality.

Since its discovery in 1983, the epigenetics of human cancer has been in the shadows of human cancer genetics. But this area has become increasingly visible with a growing understanding of specific epigenetic mechanisms and their role in cancer, including hypomethylation, hypermethylation, loss of imprinting and chromatin modification. This timeline traces the field from its conception to the present day. It also addresses the genetic basis of epigenetic changes — an emerging area that promises to unite cancer genetics and epigenetics, and might serve as a model for understanding the epigenetic basis of human disease more generally.

The history of cancer epigenetics.

Genomic imprinting affects several dozen mammalian genes and results in the expression of those genes from only one of the two parental chromosomes. This is brought about by epigenetic instructions--imprints--that are laid down in the parental germ cells. Imprinting is a particularly important genetic mechanism in mammals, and is thought to influence the transfer of nutrients to the fetus and the newborn from the mother. Consistent with this view is the fact that imprinted genes tend to affect growth in the womb and behaviour after birth. Aberrant imprinting disturbs development and is the cause of various disease syndromes. The study of imprinting also provides new insights into epigenetic gene modification during development.

/pdf/genomic-imprinting-parental-influence-on-the-genome-3ft04w0kfl.pdf

Genomic imprinting: parental influence on the genome

The paternal and maternal genomes are not equivalent and both are required for mammalian development. The difference between the parental genomes is believed to be due to gamete-specific differential modification, a process known as genomic imprinting. The study of transgene methylation has shown that methylation patterns can be inherited in a parent-of-origin-specific manner, suggesting that DNA methylation may play a role in genomic imprinting. The functional significance of DNA methylation in genomic imprinting was strengthened by the recent finding that CpG islands (or sites) in three imprinted genes, H19, insulin-like growth factor 2 (Igf-2), and Igf-2 receptor (Igf-2r), are differentially methylated depending on their parental origin. We have examined the expression of these three imprinted genes in mutant mice that are deficient in DNA methyltransferase activity. We report here that expression of all three genes was affected in mutant embryos: the normally silent paternal allele of the H19 gene was activated, whereas the normally active paternal allele of the Igf-2 gene and the active maternal allele of the Igf-2r gene were repressed. Our results demonstrate that a normal level of DNA methylation is required for controlling differential expression of the paternal and maternal alleles of imprinted genes.

Role for DNA methylation in genomic imprinting

The developmental programme of embryogenesis is controlled by both genetic and epigenetic mechanisms. An emerging theme from recent studies is that the regulation of higher-order chromatin structures by DNA methylation and histone modification is crucial for genome reprogramming during early embryogenesis and gametogenesis, and for tissue-specific gene expression and global gene silencing. Disruptions to chromatin modification can lead to the dysregulation of developmental processes, such as X-chromosome inactivation and genomic imprinting, and to various diseases. Understanding the process of epigenetic reprogramming in development is important for studies of cloning and the clinical application of stem-cell therapy.

Chromatin modification and epigenetic reprogramming in mammalian development

It has been suggested that the failure of parthenogenetic mouse embryos to develop to term is primarily due to their aberrant cytoplasm and homozygosity leading to the expression of recessive lethal genes. The reported birth of homozygous gynogenetic (male pronucleus removed from egg after fertilization) mice and of animals following transplantation of nuclei from parthenogenetic embryos to enucleated fertilized eggs, is indicative of abnormal cytoplasm and not an abnormal genotype of the activated eggs. However, we and others have been unable to obtain such homozygous mice. We investigated this problem further by using reconstituted heterozygous eggs, with haploid parthenogenetic eggs as recipients for a male or female pronucleus. We report here that the eggs which receive a male pronucleus develop to term but those with two female pronuclei develop only poorly after implantation. Therefore, the cytoplasm of activated eggs is fully competent to support development to term but not if the genome is entirely of maternal origin. We propose that specific imprinting of the genome occurs during gametogenesis so that the presence of both a male and a female pronucleus is essential in an egg for full-term development. The paternal imprinting of the genome appears necessary for the normal development of the extraembryonic membranes and the trophoblast.

Development of reconstituted mouse eggs suggests imprinting of the genome during gametogenesis

There has been much speculation on whether mammalian eggs with two male pronuclei can develop normally. Eggs with two female pronuclei can sometimes develop as far as the 25-somite stage1–3 but with only very meagre extraembryonic tissues2,3. We suggested that the genome undergoes specific imprinting during gametogenesis3 and that some paternal genes may be necessary for normal development of the extraembryonic tissues3,4, in which only the maternal X chromosome remains active5–9. However, the need for the maternal genome for development to term is not yet unequivocally established. The detailed study described here demonstrates that while between 40 and 50% of heterozygous reconstituted eggs with a male and a female pronucleus develop to term, none of the eggs with two male pronuclei does so. Furthermore, embryos in the latter case are very retarded, even though the trophoblast develops relatively well compared with embryos having two female pronuclei1–3. Our combined results indicate that while the paternal genome is essential for the normal development of extraembryonic tissues, the maternal genome may be essential for some stages of embryogenesis.

Role of paternal and maternal genomes in mouse development

A detailed analysis of the developmental potential of parthenogenetic embryonic stem cells (PGES) was made in vivo and in vitro, and a comparison was made with the development of cells from parthenogenetic embryos (PG). In vivo, in chimeras with normal host cells (N), PGES cells showed a restricted tissue distribution consistent with that of PG cells, suggesting faithful imprinting in PGES cells with respect to genes involved in lineage allocation and differentiation. Restricted developmental potential was also observed in teratomas formed by ectopic transfer under the kidney capsule. In contrast, the classic phenotype of growth retardation normally observed in PG N chimeras was not seen, suggesting aberrant regulation in PGES cells of genes involved in growth regulation. We also analysed the expression of known imprinted genes after ES cell differentiation. Igf2, H19 and Igf2r were all appropriately expressed in the PGES derived cells following induction of differentiation in vitro with all-trans retinoic acid or DMSO, when compared with control (D3) and androgenetic ES cells (AGES). Interestingly, H19 was found to be expressed at high levels following differentiation of the AGES cells. Due to the unexpected normal growth regulation of PGES N chimeras we also examined Igf2 expression in PGES derived cells differentiated in vivo and found that this gene was still repressed. Our studies show that PGES cells provide a valuable in vitro model system to study the effects of imprinting on cell differentiation and they also provide invaluable material for extensive molecular studies on imprinted genes. In addition, the aberrant growth phenotype observed in chimeras has implications for mechanisms that regulate the somatic establishment and maintenance of some imprints. This is of particular interest as aberrant imprinting has recently been invoked in the etiology of some human diseases.

A functional analysis of imprinting in parthenogenetic embryonic stem cells

SUMMARY The developmental potential of inner cell mass (ICM) and trophectoderm (TE) derived from parthenogenetic or biparental gynogenetic embryos was examined in reconstituted blastocysts with normal TE or ICM, respectively. The results demonstrate that when a normal ICM was introduced inside a trophectoderm vesicle derived from parthenogenetic or gynogenetic blastocysts, postimplantation development was characterized by the almost complete failure of trophoblast proliferation and without compensating cellular contribution from the normal ICM to the outer trophoblast lineage. Consequently, the normal ICMs also failed to develop adequately and only a few retarded embryos were detected on day 11-12 of pregnancy. In most respects, development of these reconstituted blastocysts resembled that obtained with unoperated gynogenetic and a parthenogenetic blastocyst. By contrast, an ICM from a parthenogenetic or gynogenetic embryo introduced inside a normal trophectoderm vesicle induced substantial proliferation of the trophoblast but again without a detectable cellular contribution from the ICM to the outer trophoblast lineage. However, with the improved development of the trophoblast, both the parthenogenetic and gynogenetic ICMs developed substantially better and without a detectable cellular contribution from the TE to the embryo. Almost all the embryos developed at least up to the 25-somite stage and many of them reached the 30- to 40-somite stage. Some of the most advanced day-11 and -12 gynogenones and parthenogenones yet seen have now been obtained in this way. Nevertheless, all the embryos were still smaller than the equivalent control embryos and showed signs of some tissue degeneration. The yolk sac was also suboptimal with poor blood supply and may need to be improved to obtain further improvement in the development of the embryos. The combined results demonstrate that the trophoblast proliferates very poorly even in the presence of a normal ICM, if the TE tissue lacks a paternal genome. However, ICM tissues which lack a paternal genome can develop to an advanced embryonic stage if they are introduced inside a normal trophectoderm vesicle. The results give further insight into the differential roles of maternal and paternal genomes during development of the embryo and extraembryonic tissues in the mouse.

Development of gynogenetic and parthenogenetic inner cell mass and trophectoderm tissues in reconstituted blastocysts in the mouse.

The fate of parthenogenetic cells was investigated during development of fetal and early postnatal chimeras. On day 13 of embryonic development, considerable contribution of parthenogenetic cells was observed in all tissues of chimeric embryos, although selection against parthenogenetic cells seemed to start before day 13. Between days 13 and 15 of development, parthenogenetic cells came under severe selective pressure, which was most striking in tongue. The disappearance of parthenogenetic cells from tongue coincided with the beginning of myoblast fusion in this tissue. Severe selection against parthenogenetic cells was also observed in pancreas and liver, although in the latter, parthenogenetic cells were eliminated later than in skeletal muscle or pancreas. In other tissues, parthenogenetic cells may persist and participate to a considerable extent throughout the gestation period and beyond, although a significant decrease was observed in all tissues. Parthenogenetic in equilibrium fertilized chimeras were significantly smaller than their non-chimeric littermates at all developmental stages. These results suggest that the absence of paternal chromosomes is largely incompatible with the maintenance of specific differentiated cell types. Furthermore, paternally derived genes seem to be involved in the regulation of proliferation of all cell types, as indicated by the drastic growth decceleration of parthenogenetic in equilibrium fertilized chimeras and the overall decrease of parthenogenetic cells during fetal development. Chromosomal imprinting may have a role in maintaining a balance between cell growth and differentiation during embryonic development. The major exception to the selective elimination of parthenogenetic cells appear to be the germ cells; viable offspring derived from parthenogenetic oocytes were detected, sometimes at a high frequency in litters of female parthenogenetic in equilibrium fertilized chimeras.

M. L. Norris

Papers

Development of reconstituted mouse eggs suggests imprinting of the genome during gametogenesis

Role of paternal and maternal genomes in mouse development

A functional analysis of imprinting in parthenogenetic embryonic stem cells

Development of gynogenetic and parthenogenetic inner cell mass and trophectoderm tissues in reconstituted blastocysts in the mouse.

Temporal and spatial selection against parthenogenetic cells during development of fetal chimeras.