scispace - formally typeset
Journal ArticleDOI

Abuse of Rights

H. C. Gutterridge
- 01 Mar 1933 - 
- Vol. 5, Iss: 01, pp 22-45
Reads0
Chats0
TLDR
Our law has not hesitated to place the seal of its approval upon a theory of the extent of individual rights which can only be described as the consecration of the spirit of unrestricted egoism as discussed by the authors.
Abstract
The theory of the abuse of rights is one which has been rejected by our law, with the result that the ancient brocard ‘ dura lex sed lex ’ finds its most vivid illustration in the present-day decisions of the Anglo-American Courts. The absolutist view of rights which is a feature of the Common Law was summed up by Lord Macnaghten in trenchant language when he said in Mayor of Bradford v. Pickles that although Mr. Pickles's conduct in wilfully depriving his fellow townsmen of part of their water supply might be ‘shocking to a moral philosopher’ there was nothing in the law of England which could stop him from being as ‘churlish, selfish and grasping’ as it was possible for a man to be. In other words our law has not hesitated to place the seal of its approval upon a theory of the extent of individual rights which can only be described as the consecration of the spirit of unrestricted egoism.

read more

Citations
More filters
Book

Provisional Measures before International Courts and Tribunals

TL;DR: In this article, a comparative analysis of provisional measures jurisprudence in a range of significant international courts and tribunals is presented to compare investor-state arbitration with more traditional inter-state courts.
Book

The Prevention Principle in International Environmental Law

TL;DR: Duvic-Paoli et al. as mentioned in this paper provided a systematic, comprehensive assessment of the rationale, content, and scope of the prevention principle while also placing it in a wider legal context.
Dissertation

Law in a law-governed union (Recht in einer Rechtsunion) : the Court of Justice of the European Union and the free law doctrine

Patrick Kelly
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors argue that societal legal norms could be provided with an appropriate position consistent with the principle of legal certainty by making the validity of a societal legal norm contingent on its material lawfulness.
Journal Article

Revisiting privatization, foreign investment, international arbitration and water

TL;DR: In this article, the effect of international trade and investment agreements may have on national capacities to manage natural resources and to regulate public services is discussed. But the authors do not consider the effects of international investment agreements on the economic, social and environmental sustainability and efficiency of natural resources utilization and provision of public services.
Book

Property and Practical Reason

TL;DR: In this article, the authors discuss the possibility of private property from the inside, the nature of property rights, and the contours of the property rights in law, and how to enforce them.