Pandemic influenza preparedness: an ethical framework to guide decision-making.
TLDR
An ethical framework for pandemic influenza planning was developed with expertise from clinical, organisational and public health ethics and validated through a stakeholder engagement process and will require re-evaluation and refinement.Abstract:
Planning for the next pandemic influenza outbreak is underway in hospitals across the world. The global SARS experience has taught us that ethical frameworks to guide decision-making may help to reduce collateral damage and increase trust and solidarity within and between health care organisations. Good pandemic planning requires reflection on values because science alone cannot tell us how to prepare for a public health crisis. In this paper, we present an ethical framework for pandemic influenza planning. The ethical framework was developed with expertise from clinical, organisational and public health ethics and validated through a stakeholder engagement process. The ethical framework includes both substantive and procedural elements for ethical pandemic influenza planning. The incorporation of ethics into pandemic planning can be helped by senior hospital administrators sponsoring its use, by having stakeholders vet the framework, and by designing or identifying decision review processes. We discuss the merits and limits of an applied ethical framework for hospital decision-making, as well as the robustness of the framework. The need for reflection on the ethical issues raised by the spectre of a pandemic influenza outbreak is great. Our efforts to address the normative aspects of pandemic planning in hospitals have generated interest from other hospitals and from the governmental sector. The framework will require re-evaluation and refinement and we hope that this paper will generate feedback on how to make it even more robust.read more
Citations
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
The 2019-2020 novel coronavirus (severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2) pandemic: A joint american college of academic international medicine-world academic council of emergency medicine multidisciplinary COVID-19 working group consensus paper
Stanislaw P Stawicki,Rebecca Jeanmonod,Andrew C. Miller,Lorenzo Paladino,David F. Gaieski,Anna Q Yaffee,Annelies De Wulf,Joydeep Grover,Thomas J Papadimos,Christina Bloem,Sagar Galwankar,Vivek Chauhan,Michael S. Firstenberg,Salvatore Di Somma,Donald Jeanmonod,Sona M Garg,Veronica Tucci,Harry L. Anderson,Lateef Fatimah,Tamara J. Worlton,Siddharth P. Dubhashi,Krystal S Glaze,Sagar Sinha,Ijeoma Nnodim Opara,Vikas Yellapu,Dhanashree S. Kelkar,Ayman El-Menyar,Vimal Krishnan,S Venkataramanaiah,Yan Leyfman,Hassan Al Thani,Prabath W. B. Nanayakkara,Sudip Nanda,Eric Cioè-Peña,Indrani Sardesai,Shruti Chandra,Aruna Munasinghe,Vibha Dutta,Silvana Teixeira Dal Ponte,Ricardo Izurieta,Juan A. Asensio,Manish Garg +41 more
TL;DR: Current state-of-science, mitigation strategies, possible therapies, ethical considerations for healthcare workers and policymakers, as well as lessons learned for this evolving global threat and the eventual return to a “new normal” are discussed.
Journal ArticleDOI
Recommendations for intensive care unit and hospital preparations for an influenza epidemic or mass disaster: Summary report of the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine's Task Force for intensive care unit triage during an influenza epidemic or mass disaster
Charles L. Sprung,Janice L. Zimmerman,Michael D. Christian,Gavin M. Joynt,John L. Hick,Bruce Taylor,Guy A. Richards,Christian Sandrock,Robert Cohen,Bruria Adini +9 more
TL;DR: Mortality, although inevitable during a severe influenza outbreak or disaster, can be reduced by adequate preparation, and key recommendations include increasing ICU beds to the maximal extent and expanding ICUs into other areas.
Journal ArticleDOI
Emergency department triage: an ethical analysis
TL;DR: An integrated clinically and ethically based framework of emergency department triage planning, as seen from a comprehensive ethics perspective that incorporates both the principles-based and care-oriented approach is proposed.
Journal ArticleDOI
Understanding the school community’s response to school closures during the H1N1 2009 influenza pandemic
Annette J Braunack-Mayer,Rebecca Tooher,Joanne Collins,Joanne Collins,Jackie M Street,Helen Marshall,Helen Marshall +6 more
TL;DR: It is concluded that school closures during an influenza pandemic represent both a challenge for public health officials and a litmus test for the level of trust in public officials, government and the school as institution.
Journal ArticleDOI
Public health emergency preparedness: a framework to promote resilience
Yasmin Khan,Yasmin Khan,Tracey O’Sullivan,Adalsteinn D. Brown,Shannon Tracey,Jennifer L. Gibson,Mélissa Généreux,Mélissa Généreux,Bonnie Henry,Brian Schwartz +9 more
TL;DR: This applied public health framework for local/regional public health agencies is empirically-derived and theoretically-informed and represents a complex adaptive systems approach to upstream readiness for PHEP.
References
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
Preparing for the next pandemic
TL;DR: The fragile and limited production capacity of the authors' 1950s egg-based technology for producing influenza vaccine and the lack of a national commitment to universal annual influenza vaccination mean that influenza epidemics will continue to present a substantial public health challenge.
Journal ArticleDOI
Accountability for reasonableness : Establishing a fair process for priority setting is easier than agreeing on principles
TL;DR: The study found that transparency was important to participants in the decisions, though it did not state whether the rationales for decisions were then made transparent to all affected by them, and an ethical approach to fair process must build on their findings.
Journal ArticleDOI
Psychosocial effects of SARS on hospital staff: survey of a large tertiary care institution
Leslie A. Nickell,Eric J. Crighton,C. Shawn Tracy,Hadi Al-Enazy,Yemisi Bolaji,Sagina Hanjrah,Ayesha Hussain,Samia Makhlouf,Ross E.G. Upshur +8 more
TL;DR: The findings indicate that the SARS outbreak had significant psychosocial effects on hospital staff, which differed with respect to occupation and risk perception.
Journal ArticleDOI
Ethics and Public Health: Forging a Strong Relationship
Daniel Callahan,Bruce Jennings +1 more
TL;DR: The time has come to more fully integrate the ethical problems of public health into the field of public Health and, at the same time, into theField of bioethics.