Resource Description and Access (RDA): mapeamento sistemático de literatura
27 Jan 2020-Vol. 16, pp 1-19
TL;DR: In this paper, a survey of a cientifica sobre o Resource Description and Access (RDA) is presented, with a focus on the desenvolvimento of the RDA.
Abstract: Desenvolvido para ser o sucessor da edicao revisada do Codigo Anglo-Americano de Catalogacao, 2. edicao, (AACR2), o Resource Description and Access (RDA) tem sido objeto de testes, treinamentos, implementacao e de estudos cientificos. Identificar a producao cientifica sobre o RDA, com criterios adotados nos processos de mapeamento sistematico de literatura, mostra a dimensao e a diversidade de pesquisas que tem sido desenvolvidas sobre o padrao RDA. Ao considerar esse contexto, questiona-se sobre a contribuicao cientifica nas discussoes sobre o RDA. Como objetivo geral busca-se analisar a producao cientifica sobre o RDA e consideram-se, como objetivos especificos que orientam o desenvolvimento deste trabalho: [1] definir as bases de dados a serem analisadas sobre a tematica da pesquisa; [2] definir o protocolo de mapeamento sistematico de literatura; [3] analisar a evolucao temporal, os autores, os periodicos e os temas abordados; [4] avaliar a producao cientifica sobre o RDA. Os procedimentos metodologicos adotados para o desenvolvimento desta pesquisa, de natureza aplicada, caracterizam-se pela abordagem mista, com procedimentos de pesquisa bibliografica, e o incremento da analise de resultados a partir dos dados identificados. Tais resultados foram alcancados com uso de bases de dados cientificas e softwares como StArt e Excel, e a apresentacao dos resultados em esquemas e graficos e da analise de conteudo.
Citations
More filters
[...]
TL;DR: It is found that the instructions of RDA are much more in compliance with the scientific principles of Ranganathan than the RDA principles recorded at the beginning of the code.
Abstract: Unlike its predecessor Anglo-American Cataloguing Rules, Second Edition (AACR2), Resource Description and Access (RDA) has incorporated principles and objectives at the beginning of the code. This article is an attempt to make a comparative study between the practical applications of the principles of RDA with that of the Normative Principles of cataloging of S. R. Ranganathan. It is found that the instructions of RDA are much more in compliance with the scientific principles of Ranganathan than the RDA principles recorded at the beginning of the code. The outcome of the study is presented in two different ways. Tabular presentation of the same is made at the beginning followed by analytical studies.
1 citations
References
More filters
[...]
TL;DR: A thorough and critical review of the emerging RDA literature published from 2005 to 2011 concerns key areas of difference between RDA and AACR2, the relationship of the new cataloging code to metadata standards, the impact on encoding standards such as Machine-Readable Cataloging (MARC), end user considerations, and practitioners' views on RDA implementation and training.
Abstract: Resource Description & Access (RDA) is intended to provide a flexible and extensible framework that can accommodate all types of content and media within rapidly evolving digital environments while also maintaining compatibility with the Anglo-American Cataloguing Rules, 2nd edition (AACR2). The cataloging community is grappling with practical issues in navigating the transition from AACR2 to RDA; there is a definite need to evaluate major subject areas and broader themes in information organization under the new RDA paradigm. This article aims to accomplish this task through a thorough and critical review of the emerging RDA literature published from 2005 to 2011. The review mostly concerns key areas of difference between RDA and AACR2, the relationship of the new cataloging code to metadata standards, the impact on encoding standards such as Machine-Readable Cataloging (MARC), end user considerations, and practitioners' views on RDA implementation and training. Future research will require more in-depth studies of RDA's expected benefits and the manner in which the new cataloging code will improve resource retrieval and bibliographic control for users and catalogers alike over AACR2. The question as to how the cataloging community can best move forward to the post-AACR2/MARC environment must be addressed carefully so as to chart the future of bibliographic control in the evolving environment of information production, management, and use.
31 citations
[...]
TL;DR: Prominent themes have included cataloging codes and the influence of authors such as Julia Pettee, Andrew Osborn, and Seymour Lubetzky; costs and other practicalities; technology, information science, and Cranfield; subject access, including subject headings, thesauri, and classification schemes; and historical, international, and research perspectives.
Abstract: This article reports the results of a quantitative and thematic content analysis of the organization of information literature in the Library Quarterly (LQ) between its inception in 1931 and 2004. The majority of articles in this category were published in the first half of LQ’s run. Prominent themes have included cataloging codes and the influence of authors such as Julia Pettee, Andrew Osborn, and Seymour Lubetzky; costs and other practicalities; technology, information science, and Cranfield; subject access, including subject headings, thesauri, and classification schemes; and historical, international, and research perspectives. Future volumes of LQ can fruitfully build on these themes to address contemporary issues in the organization of information such as the future of catalog code development of “RDA: Resource Description and Access” to replace AACR2 and the Functional Requirements for Bibliographic Records (FRBR); concerns in digital library development, including metadata; and other innovative m...
20 citations
[...]
TL;DR: The study demonstrates that as far as cataloging is concerned authorship is the role that is represented rather than any true intellectual responsibility.
Abstract: The major concern of this paper is the cultural ramification of the bibliographic conception of "authorship." Beginning with Foucault's question "what is an author" and his notion of an author as a cultural phenomenon, the paper proceeds to examine the treatment of authorship in cataloging practices of two ancient cultures, the Greek and the Chinese, as well as in the modern Anglo-American cataloging standards from Panizzi's 91 rules to the draft of Resource Description and Access (RDA). An author, as the study shows, is constructed as part of the recognition of "a work" as an essential communicative social entity. All cataloging practices and standards examined, east or west, ancient or modern, exhibit a similar obsessive attitude toward the imposition of an author, be it only a name or a culturally identified entity responsible for the work. In fact, the study demonstrates that as far as cataloging is concerned authorship is the role that is represented rather than any true intellectual responsibility.
14 citations
[...]
TL;DR: This article aims to present an overview of current changes, potential convergences, developments, and weak points from Ranganathan's point of view.
Abstract: Since the end of the last century, catalogs have been changing more and more quickly. This change is following a recognizable course, beginning with the publication of Functional Requirements for Bibliographic Records, passing through the reorganization of international cataloging principles, the revision of international standards of the International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions (International Standard for Bibliographic Description), and the foundation of new cataloging codes, such as Resource Description and Access. While principles, models, and rules are well established, bibliographic formats seem to be a bottleneck and users seem far from libraries. This article aims to present an overview of current changes, potential convergences, developments, and weak points from Ranganathan's point of view.
9 citations
[...]
TL;DR: The paper aims to highlight many consequences deriving from RDA being a content standard, and in particular the change from record management to data management, differences among the two functions realizing by RDA and functions realized by other standard such as MARC21 and ISB.
Abstract: RDA Resource Description and Access are guidelines for description and access to resources designed for digital environment and released, in its first version, in 2010. RDA is based on FRBR and its derived models, that focus on users’ needs and on resources of any kind of content, medium and carrier. The paper discusses relevance of main features of RDA for the future role of libraries in the context of semantic web and metadata creation and exchange. The paper aims to highlight many consequences deriving from RDA being a content standard, and in particular the change from record management to data management, differences among the two functions realized by RDA (to identify and to relate entities) and functions realized by other standard such as MARC21 (to archive data) and ISB (to visualize data) and show how, as all these functions are necessary for the catalog, RDA needs to be integrated by other rules and standard and that these tools allow the fulfilment of the variation principle defined by S.R. Ranganathan.
6 citations