Search or ask a question

How do subaltern study give new perspective to existing scholarship?

Subaltern Studies

Best insight from top research papers

Subaltern Studies offer a fresh lens to existing scholarship by challenging traditional historical narratives. This initiative reevaluates Indian history, emphasizing the role of marginalized groups in shaping events. It critiques the limitations of previous frameworks, highlighting the exclusion of caste dynamics in historical analyses. Furthermore, Subaltern Studies advocate for a decentralized view of urbanization, focusing on smaller settlements and local agency. By integrating emotions and critiquing Western legal theories, this approach connects colonialism, human rights, and suffering, contributing to a more inclusive understanding of historical and legal discourses. Overall, Subaltern Studies provide a platform for reinterpreting history, amplifying the voices of the oppressed, and fostering a more comprehensive and nuanced approach to scholarship.

Answers from top 5 papers

PDF

Open Access

More filters

Papers (5)	Insight
Book Chapter•DOI Subaltern Studies as a History of Social Movements in India Rochona Majumdar 13 Mar 2015-South Asia-journal of South Asian Studies 4 Citations	Subaltern Studies offers a unique focus on the marginalized classes' politics during British colonial rule, providing a fresh perspective on social movements in India.
Open access Power and Autonomy: Subaltern Studies and the History of the Subaltern Groups Serhan Afacan 21 Jun 2020 1 Citations	Subaltern Studies offer a fresh outlook by focusing on marginalized groups' agency in historical events, challenging traditional frameworks and enriching historical scholarship with diverse perspectives.
Open access•Journal Article•DOI Human Rights and emotions from the perspective of the colonised: Anthropofagi, legal surrealism and subaltern studies José-Manuel Barreto 21 Nov 2013-Revista de Estudos Constitucionais, Hermenêutica e Teoria do Direito 4 Citations	Subaltern Studies offer insights linking colonialism, human rights, and suffering, critiquing Western legal theories. They provide a fresh approach integrating emotions into human rights discourse.
Journal Article•DOI Subaltern Urbanization: Indian Insights for Urban Theory Partha Mukhopadhyay, Marie-Hélène Zérah, Eric Denis - Show less +2 more 01 Jul 2020-International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 26 Citations	Subaltern urbanization challenges traditional urban theories by emphasizing smaller settlements' agency, diverse flows, and autonomous engagement, offering a fresh perspective on settlement hierarchies and innovation processes.
Journal Article•DOI Subaltern Studies and the Transition in Indian History Writing Umesh Bagade 01 Jan 2023-Critical Philosophy of Race	Subaltern Studies critiqued existing Indian history frameworks by highlighting their caste blindness, emphasizing the need to include caste and patriarchy in historical interpretations for a more comprehensive perspective.

My columns

Related Questions

How are subaltern approaches to contemporary migration applied?5 answersSubaltern approaches to contemporary migration are applied by highlighting migrants as speaking subjects utilizing digital platforms to connect with their communities and western audiences, challenging symbolic borders and binaries of inside/outside. These approaches view migrants not as silent figures but as individuals with agency, capable of telling their own stories of suffering, defiance, and civic engagement. Additionally, the concept of subalternity, as discussed in Gramscian theory, emphasizes the potential for migrants to emerge from subordination and pursue emancipation. The complexity of labor force migration is acknowledged, with its economic, social, and political implications requiring appropriate management at various levels for all countries involved. Overall, subaltern approaches empower migrants to reclaim their narratives and challenge dominant discourses surrounding migration in the contemporary global landscape.

What research has been done on subalterns in the Indian diaspora?5 answersResearch on subalterns in the Indian diaspora has explored various aspects. Studies have delved into the historical representations of subaltern masses, critiqued the caste blindness within Subaltern Studies projects, analyzed autobiographies of Dalit and African American women to highlight similarities in subaltern experiences, and examined the cultural experiences of subaltern migrants from Kerala to the Middle East. These research endeavors have focused on issues of oppression, exploitation, and marginalization faced by subaltern groups, shedding light on their struggles within patriarchal and hierarchical structures. The studies have utilized frameworks like Antonio Gramsci's subaltern theory and Gayatri Spivak's developments to understand and highlight the visibility of exclusion faced by subaltern individuals in various societal contexts.

What paper talk about subaltern knowledge?4 answersSubaltern knowledge is discussed in multiple papers. Masiero explores the potential of subaltern theory to voice systematically silenced and marginalized perspectives in critical IS research. Lavanya and Rashila highlight how the notion of subaltern encompasses marginalized and exploited groups based on social, cultural, and biased grounds. Olazabal et al. argue for the incorporation of subaltern knowledge in climate adaptation science and practice to enhance the effectiveness and social legitimacy of actions. Moyo presents subaltern urbanism as a way of life in contemporary Zimbabwe, emphasizing its role in redefining post-colonial urbanity.

What is subaltern in folklore?3 answersThe term "subaltern" in folklore refers to socially constructed categories of vulnerable populations with limited discursive power. It is a concept that highlights the lack of voice and representation of marginalized groups in society. Subaltern narratives are born out of lived experiences and folk wisdom, capturing the essence of the struggles and aspirations of these communities. The term "subaltern" originated from Antonio Gramsci's writings and refers to subordinate individuals based on class, gender, race, and culture. In the context of South Asian history, subaltern studies emerged as a way to explore the history of silenced and neglected masses, who were often marginalized and misrepresented in larger historical narratives. The study of subalterns in folklore aims to understand the historical representations of these marginalized groups and the processes through which they are produced and marginalized in the first place.

What is subaltern?5 answersThe term 'subaltern' refers to the lower classes and marginalized social groups in a society. It encompasses those who have limited or no access to cultural imperialism and are at the margins of society. The concept of subalternity has been explored in post-colonial theories and social sciences. In the Indian context, the concept has been applied to understand the marginalization and exclusion of Dalits in various aspects of life. Mahasweta Devi's story, Draupadi, portrays a figure of resistance to multilayered subalternity through the rejection of gender performative acts. The character, Dopdi Mejhen, challenges phallocentric representation and colonial domination, liberating herself from subalternity through non-cooperative resistance. The theory of subalternity by Ranajit Guha and Chakravorty Spivak, along with Judith Butler's theory of gender performativity, is applied to evaluate the resistance to subalternity. The concept of subalternity is a complex term that encompasses the tragedy of human relationships and is a lived reality for many marginalized communities worldwide.

Can the Subaltern Speak 1998?1 answersThe essay "Can the Subaltern Speak?" by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak explores the representation of marginalized voices and the challenges they face in being heard. Spivak's work is analyzed and critiqued by various scholars, who provide different perspectives on the topic. The historical context in which Spivak wrote her essay is also examined, particularly in relation to the debates between Michel Foucault and Jacques Derrida. The concept of the subaltern speaking is discussed, with some arguing that the subaltern can only speak if there is a collective audience and agency in the public sphere. Others suggest that the subaltern speaks indirectly through traces within elite discourses. Overall, the papers highlight the complexities and nuances of the subaltern's ability to speak and be heard in different contexts.

See what other people are reading

Is kokana tribe genetically Hindu?

The Kokana tribe's genetic affiliation with Hinduism cannot be definitively determined based on the provided research contexts. However, studies on other tribal populations like the Kharia, Koya, Kota, and Korkus shed light on genetic diversity and social interactions within tribal communities in India. These studies highlight genetic variations in hemoglobinopathies, G6PD deficiency, and blood groups among different tribal sects, such as the Dhelki and Dudh Kharia. Additionally, the Koya tribe's demographic characteristics and potential cultural assimilation into Hindu society are discussed, emphasizing the impact of social transformations on tribal identities. The Kota tribe's genetic load and inbreeding practices are also explored, showcasing unique genetic traits and low mortality rates within this isolated population.How does OAS function during cold war?

During the Cold War, the Organization of American States (OAS) played a relatively minor role in Latin America, often being unpopular. However, changes in US foreign policy and Latin American politics have allowed for a stronger and more effective OAS. The OAS aimed to strengthen peace and security, promote human rights, consolidate democracy, and address shared issues like poverty and terrorism. Initially sidelined by friction and military rule in the region, the OAS experienced a resurgence in influence post the Panama crisis in 1989. The OAS also coordinated international efforts to remove landmines and support member states in trade expansion and economic integration. Despite its historical challenges, the OAS emerged as a pivotal player in promoting democracy and resolving conflicts in Latin America during the Cold War era.What are the current trends in urban sustainability practices aimed at mitigating water scarcity in cities worldwide?

Current trends in urban sustainability practices to address water scarcity globally include integrating water management into city planning, enhancing groundwater levels and utilizing runoff water, focusing on transformative learning in urban sustainability efforts, adapting built infrastructure and natural systems to combat climate change impacts, and emphasizing effective water management through modern technologies and continuous improvement. Cities are repurposing urban spaces for sustainable development, promoting equitable distribution of amenities, and implementing participatory planning to enhance water sustainability. The key elements for future cities to avoid water collapse involve strategic management, trust-building, awareness, and long-term planning to ensure water resource sustainability amidst challenges like pollution, climate change, and population growth.What are urban villages in the context of Asia and other developing countires, write an 800 word essay?

Urban villages in Asia and other developing countries represent unique socio-spatial entities that blend urban and rural characteristics. These areas face the challenge of reconciling traditional sociocultural norms with modern urban lifestyles, highlighting the complexities of urban planning in rapidly growing cities. The phenomenon of "village in the city" is particularly prevalent in China, where rapid urbanization has led to the emergence of these hybrid spaces that straddle the urban-rural divide. Despite expectations of their gradual disappearance, urban villages demonstrate resilience by adapting to changing economic landscapes and providing new employment opportunities through informal economies. The interactions between urban and rural areas, as well as the coexistence of modern and traditional elements within cities, underscore the need for inclusive planning approaches that go beyond Western paradigms.How many money did government profit from one child policy?

The economic implications of China's One-Child Policy were multifaceted. The policy involved economic incentives and sanctions to control population growth. Research suggests that the policy induced higher human capital accumulation, leading to a 5.01% annual gain in GDP per worker decades after its implementation. However, unintended consequences included a welfare loss of around 4.9% of yearly household income, with marriage distortion contributing 17% to this loss. Despite these losses, the policy's impact on educational investment and intergenerational transfers resulted in a potential 4% higher output in 2025 compared to scenarios without the policy, emphasizing its growth-enhancing role through human capital formation. Therefore, while the exact monetary profit directly gained by the government from the One-Child Policy is not explicitly stated in the provided contexts, the policy had significant economic implications and trade-offs.How has the cultivation and use of paragis grass changed over time in Filipino communities?

The cultivation and use of Paragis grass in Filipino communities have evolved over time. Initially, Paragis grass gained popularity as an herbal medicine claimed to cure various medical conditions when processed into a concoction. As part of the changing agricultural landscape, practices in upland communities like Calminoe have shifted from subsistence root cropping to more permanent mixed annual-perennial cash cropping, reflecting the development of tailored knowledge based on local conditions. The broader transition in the Philippines from an agrarian sociometabolic regime to an industrial regime has influenced land-use patterns, with a shift towards intensification in agriculture to meet the growing food supply demands of a densely populated nation. In urban fringe areas like Metro Manila, there has been a noticeable decrease in agricultural land use, with some areas transitioning rapidly to urban landscapes.Why duration of study does not matter in determining school readiness?

The duration of study does not significantly impact school readiness as longer periods of school preparation may lead to lower levels of school motivation in children entering school. Children with varying hours of learning per week, whether 900 minutes or more, were mostly well-prepared for school, indicating that the length of study did not affect their readiness. Additionally, the focus on early childhood development and the support received from the child's environment since birth plays a crucial role in determining school readiness, emphasizing the importance of factors beyond just the duration of formal education. Therefore, while the duration of study may have some influence, it is not the sole determinant of school readiness, with other factors like early childhood experiences and support playing significant roles.What are the role of state actors?

State actors play crucial roles in various domains such as agriculture policy, human rights promotion, economic development, cybersecurity, and cyber warfare. They are key players in addressing pressing issues like unhealthy diets, climate change, promoting and implementing human rights, intervening in the economy for development, and ensuring cybersecurity across borders. In cyberspace, state actors face challenges due to the absence of clear attribution and the offense-dominant nature of cyber warfare. Additionally, non-state actors can also influence state actions by transferring resources and knowledge, albeit with risks of agency slacking. State actors need to identify policy spaces, set clear priorities, and adopt holistic approaches to effectively address contemporary challenges and drive positive change.How do age-specific net migration patterns vary across countries and regions?

Age-specific net migration patterns exhibit variations across countries and regions. Research in Russia highlights that young individuals predominantly migrate between peripheral areas and regional centers, with peak migration observed among 15-19 year-olds pursuing higher education. In South Korea, a novel analytical method utilizing dyadic matrices and PCA reveals age-specific migration patterns, capturing different life cycle stages. European Union studies emphasize the importance of migration dynamics in interpreting age structures, with variations linked to urbanization levels and territorial characteristics. Portugal's peripheral regions experience human desertification and aging, with migration models indicating different age groups responding to economic and demographic factors. These diverse findings underscore the significance of age-specific net migration patterns in shaping population dynamics globally.What are the function and effectiveness of Labour act 2006 in Bangladesh?

The Bangladesh Labor Act 2006 plays a crucial role in regulating labor practices within the country. It covers various aspects such as employment conditions, occupational health, safety standards, and international code of conducts, impacting industrial growth and private sector workforce management. However, challenges persist in the implementation of labor laws, particularly in industries like the Readymade Garment (RMG) sector, where issues like inadequate wage payments lead to unrest. The Act's effectiveness is assessed based on the principles of 'decent work' outlined by the International Labour Organization (ILO), emphasizing the need for a solid legislative framework to ensure labor rights and a conducive work environment. Additionally, the Act aligns with Islamic principles that emphasize the rights and protection of workers, reflecting the cultural and religious influences on labor laws in Bangladesh.For what era is Hagmatane hill of Hamadan?

Hagmatane Hill in Hamadan is associated with various historical eras, including the Median, Achaemenid, and Parthian periods. The hill's significance lies in being the remains of imperial palaces from ancient Hamadan, particularly flourishing during the Achaemenid era. Additionally, Hamadan's traditional neighborhoods from the Qajar era have evolved over time, with structures like mosques, baths, and caravanserais shaping the city's urbanization. Analyzing the urban system of Hamadan province from 1335-1390 reveals an additive process in the prime urban index, indicating the city's development over time. Overall, Hagmatane Hill's historical importance spans multiple ancient eras, reflecting the rich cultural heritage of Hamadan.