Search or ask a question

Is there critic on case management in health care?

Systematic review

Integrated care

Emergency department

Best insight from top research papers

Critics on case management in health care have been noted in various studies. While some evidence suggests positive impacts on health care utilization outcomes, including reduced hospital readmissions and emergency department visits , there are mixed results indicating the need for further evaluation . Case management's success relies on patient involvement, collaborative practice teams, critical pathways, and multidisciplinary action plans . Additionally, the necessity of experienced and well-trained case managers with strong interpersonal skills to optimize case management programs has been emphasized for improved patient outcomes and proactive care . These findings highlight the importance of ongoing assessment and refinement of case management strategies in healthcare to ensure effectiveness and positive patient experiences.

Answers from top 4 papers

PDF

Open Access

More filters

Papers (4)	Insight
Open access•Journal Article•DOI Case Management Programs for Improving Integrated Care for Frequent Users of Healthcare Services: An Implementation Analysis Catherine Hudon, Maud-Christine Chouinard, Mathieu Bisson, Astrid Brousselle, Mireille Lambert, Alya Danish, Charo Rodríguez, Véronique Sabourin - Show less +7 more 11 Feb 2022-International Journal of Integrated Care 2 Citations	Case management in healthcare is critiqued for needing experienced, skilled case managers to optimize patient care, improve outcomes, and enhance integrated care for frequent users of healthcare services.
Book Chapter•DOI Case Management: Interprofessionelle Fachlichkeit in der fallbezogenen Versorgungssteuerung Wolf Rainer Wendt 01 Jan 2018 1 Citations	The paper discusses the positioning of case management in successful interprofessional collaboration in healthcare, without explicitly mentioning criticism on case management in health care.
Open access N nu ur rs si ing c ca as se e ma an na ag ge emen nt t: id de enti ify yi ing g, coordin na at tin ng g an nd D Monit 01 Jan 2012	Yes, there is criticism on case management in healthcare, particularly regarding concerns about standardization, potential negative impact on patient outcomes, and resistance from physicians towards critical pathways.
Journal Article•DOI Case Management Effectiveness on Health Care Utilization Outcomes: A Systematic Review of Reviews: Jee Young Joo, Diane L. Huber - Show less +1 more 01 Jan 2019-Western Journal of Nursing Research 34 Citations	Yes, the paper critically evaluates the effectiveness of case management on health care utilization outcomes for chronic illnesses, providing valuable insights for practitioners, researchers, and policymakers.

My columns

Related Questions

Case study methodology criticisms?5 answersCase study methodology faces criticisms primarily regarding issues of generalizability, methodological weaknesses, and rigour inadequacies. Despite these criticisms, case studies are gaining popularity among qualitative researchers, with a call for improved reporting to enhance the methodology's credibility. The lack of case studies in modern psychotherapy publications is noted, with suggestions for systematic case study development and ethical considerations highlighted. Criticisms also include concerns about generalizability, subjectivity, and different styles of conducting case studies, such as exploratory, explanatory, and descriptive cases. Opponents argue that case studies lack rigour and reliability, emphasizing the importance of experiential learning and critical thinking in addressing real-world issues.

What is the role of health care workers on the disease management?5 answersHealthcare workers play a crucial role in disease management by providing care, support, and education to patients. They are at the forefront of combating diseases like COVID-19, risking their health to care for patients. Health workers are essential in implementing preventive measures, promoting self-management interventions, and ensuring patient safety. During the COVID-19 pandemic, they faced increased risks of infection, psychological stress, and violence. Despite these challenges, healthcare workers continue to fulfill their responsibilities in diagnosing, treating, and responding to diseases, including supporting vaccination campaigns. Their involvement in research, treatment development, and patient education is vital for effective disease management and public health response.

How to conduct reviews of surgical cases?4 answersTo conduct reviews of surgical cases, it is essential to follow specific guidelines and methodologies. Systematic reviews in surgery should involve searching databases like MEDLINE, Web of Science, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, with critical appraisal being crucial in evaluating blinding, industry involvement, and standardization of surgical techniques. Additionally, the methodological and reporting quality of surgical case series needs improvement, as evidenced by deficiencies such as failure to use standardized definitions, missing data, incomplete reporting, and lack of consideration for alternative study designs. Developing reporting guidelines for case series is crucial to enhance the quality of reporting and ensure comprehensive documentation of key data in surgical literature.

What is Clinical Case Management?4 answersClinical case management involves the combination of practice-based evidence with management and documentation tasks in the delivery of clinical psychological services. It is a service provided in university counseling centers to support students who require referrals for further assistance. The role of a clinical case manager is to ensure continuous improvement in the quality of services and maintain high professional standards. Case management aims to optimize patients' self-care, provide continuous quality care, decrease hospitalization rates, and promote cost-effective use of resources. It is a managerial approach that improves the quality of healthcare organizations by focusing on process improvement, patient safety, and reducing costs and risks. In summary, clinical case management is a comprehensive and coordinated approach that integrates clinical, managerial, and financial skills to ensure the delivery of high-quality care and improve patient outcomes.

What is a healthcare management?2 answersHealthcare management is the process of effectively managing and improving the quality of healthcare services in a complex healthcare system. It involves understanding the requirements and needs of patients and employees, analyzing the latest trends in healthcare management, and finding ways to apply management principles to the core business of healthcare institutions. An integrated management system is a comprehensive tool that integrates all elements of the business system into a single system, including healthcare management. It aims to meet the requirements of stakeholders and achieve business goals by managing processes in the organization. Healthcare management also involves the use of data and technology to provide efficient and high-quality healthcare services. It includes generating output information related to healthcare values, providing healthcare decision support, and analyzing healthcare information and expenditure to assess efficiency and cost-effectiveness. Overall, healthcare management plays a crucial role in ensuring the smooth functioning and success of healthcare institutions by improving patient satisfaction, employee satisfaction, and overall business performance.

How much do healthcare case managers make?7 answers

See what other people are reading

What is the importance of learning communication skills as a student pursuing social work?

Learning communication skills is crucial for social work students as it enhances their ability to develop constructive relationships and improve outcomes for clients. Effective communication is at the core of social work practice, enabling professionals to connect with clients, express empathy, and conduct interviews skillfully. Inclusive education emphasizes the importance of communication in integrating individuals with disabilities into educational environments, highlighting the need for social workers to possess strong communicative competence. Communication skills enable social workers to pass information effectively, understand clients' needs, and establish rapport, ultimately aiding in providing better support and assistance. Therefore, mastering communication skills not only benefits social work students in their academic pursuits but also equips them with essential tools for successful professional practice.What does transformation mean in NHS healthcare?

Transformation in NHS healthcare refers to significant changes aimed at improving services and outcomes. This includes implementing new clinical models, altering processes, digitizing healthcare, and designing new care models to address systemic issues. Sustainability and evaluation are crucial in ensuring that these changes endure over time and have a positive impact. The NHS is under pressure to do more with limited resources, leading to initiatives like local sustainability and transformation plans that aim to deliver care more efficiently and effectively. Despite challenges and unrealistic expectations, early signs suggest promise in the implementation of new care models, emphasizing the need for a deep understanding of the multilevel context in healthcare transformation.Is benefit finding an emotion regulation?

Benefit finding is not explicitly mentioned as an emotion regulation strategy in the provided contexts. However, emotion regulation encompasses various methods individuals use to manage and control their emotions, such as cognitive reappraisal, expressive suppression, and mindfulness practices. Emotion regulation plays a crucial role in stress management, enabling individuals to respond adaptively to emotional stimuli and situations, leading to enhanced psychological health. Additionally, studies have shown that emotion regulation can impact learning outcomes, as seen in the relationship between emotion regulation processes and self-regulated learning (SRL) among professional musicians. While benefit finding may not be directly classified as an emotion regulation strategy in the contexts provided, it aligns with the broader concept of managing emotions effectively to promote well-being and adaptive responses to stress.Are health concious people more likely to take part in research trails?

Health-conscious individuals may indeed be more inclined to participate in research trials, as indicated by various studies. Research suggests that individuals interested in volunteering for mental health research tend to have more severe illness and longer treatment histories, possibly indicating a greater genetic predisposition for mental health issues. Furthermore, healthy volunteers in research projects are expected to have minimal risks involved, and ethical guidelines emphasize the importance of balancing risks to volunteers with collective benefits to the community. In the context of stroke research, participants differed from non-participants in terms of demographic and clinical profiles, highlighting potential biases in research findings due to participant selection. These findings collectively suggest that health-conscious individuals may indeed be more likely to engage in research trials, potentially impacting the generalizability of study results.In what ways do personal and planetary well-being intersect for millennials and Generation Z?

Personal and planetary well-being intersect for millennials and Generation Z through various avenues. The concept of planetary health emphasizes the interconnectedness between individual health, community vitality, and Earth's natural systems, highlighting the impact of environmental changes on human health. Integrative medicine plays a crucial role in advocating for the health of individuals, communities, and the planet, emphasizing the importance of safeguarding health at all scales. Additionally, ecologically sustainable behavior (ESB) and mindfulness meditation (MM) have been linked to subjective well-being (SWB), suggesting a relationship between personal and planetary well-being, especially for spiritually inclined individuals. Ultimately, promoting plant-based diets, incorporating environmental impact in dietary guidelines, and enhancing plant-based nutrition training in medical schools can further bridge the gap between personal health and environmental sustainability.What are the current trends and challenges in the privatization of healthcare in Canada?

The current trends and challenges in the privatization of healthcare in Canada reflect a complex landscape. While there have been shifts towards private involvement in healthcare delivery and financing, particularly in sectors like long-term care and core medical services, the country's universal healthcare system, known as "Medicare," remains a cornerstone. The debate around allowing private payments for faster access to care has resurfaced due to growing surgical backlogs during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite some initiatives suggesting privatization, the overall trend towards full privatization seems unlikely in the near future, with the public-private mix remaining a key feature of the Canadian healthcare system. Challenges persist in ensuring quality and equity, especially in services like dental care, prescription drugs, and long-term care, which are not universally covered, leading to access issues for lower-income Canadians.Didactic physical activity technology

Didactic physical activity technology encompasses the integration of information and communication technology (ICT) in various educational settings, including physical education courses at higher educational institutions. This integration is crucial for fostering 21st-century teaching and learning practices, as highlighted in studies exploring the use of mobile devices and apps in physical education classes. Additionally, the use of fitness wearables and mobile health trackers has been identified as a catalyst for lifestyle behavior change and a valuable tool for healthcare providers to prescribe physical activity as an evidence-based intervention to combat the negative health consequences of physical inactivity. Furthermore, virtual reality (VR) exercise interventions have shown promise in improving physical function and health-related quality of life in various patient populations, including hemodialysis patients.Mengapa tahap 3 dan 4 menjadi pembeda antara Action Research Tradisional dengan Action Research Based Soft system Methodology?

The distinction between stages 3 and 4 in Traditional Action Research (TAR) and Action Research based on Soft Systems Methodology (SSM) primarily revolves around the philosophical underpinnings and methodological approaches that each embodies. Traditional Action Research is deeply rooted in participatory approaches, emphasizing collaboration and iterative cycles of planning, acting, observing, and reflecting to improve practice or solve problems within specific contexts. This approach is characterized by its direct engagement with the problem context and the active participation of stakeholders in the research process, aiming for practical outcomes and improvements. On the other hand, Action Research based on Soft Systems Methodology introduces a more structured and systemic thinking approach to dealing with complex, ill-structured problems where there are multiple perceptions of reality. SSM is a process of inquiry that uses conceptual models to explore and structure complex problems, facilitating a learning process among participants to understand different viewpoints and derive consensus-based, actionable solutions. It is not just about solving a problem but understanding the different perceptions of the problem itself. Stage 3 in TAR typically involves the implementation of actions derived from the collaborative planning process, while in SSM-based Action Research, this stage is more about exploring and modeling the problem situation through rich pictures and conceptual models to understand the system and its issues deeply. Stage 4 in TAR focuses on observing and reflecting on the outcomes of the action taken, aiming for immediate practical improvements. In contrast, SSM-based Action Research at this stage emphasizes critically evaluating the situation through the lens of the conceptual models, identifying feasible and desirable changes, and then agreeing on actions that accommodate different viewpoints and interests. Therefore, the key distinction lies in SSM-based Action Research's emphasis on systemic thinking, understanding multiple realities, and conceptual modeling before moving towards action, contrasting with TAR's more direct and immediate problem-solving focus. This difference reflects a broader philosophical shift from a focus on practical action to a more reflective and interpretive understanding of complex social systems.What are the dangers of misdiagnosis mental health?

Misdiagnosis in mental health poses significant risks, including potential violation of civil rights, forced treatment, and inappropriate commitment under the guise of psychiatric care. This issue is exacerbated by the challenge of distinguishing genuine disorders from traits associated with high IQ, leading to diagnostic errors by mental health practitioners. Adolescents with acute psychiatric disorders, especially those who are isolated and foreign, are at risk of misdiagnosis, potentially receiving excessive diagnoses of psychotic disorders instead of conditions like depression or post-traumatic syndrome. Furthermore, the separation of medical and mental health services can result in neglect of patients with unexplained symptoms, emphasizing the need for integrated care approaches to prevent such neglect.What is privatization of healthcare in canada?

Privatization of healthcare in Canada involves a gradual shift towards private funding and delivery of medical services alongside the existing public system. Over the years, there has been an increase in private financing of medical expenses, with a notable growth in private provision of core medical services since a pivotal Supreme Court ruling in 2005. Private payment-only clinics offering a wide range of services have emerged, potentially impacting patient access to care. Additionally, public-private partnerships (PPPs) are being explored as a mechanism to reduce costs and enhance healthcare capacity in Canada. Canadian urologists anticipate a growing influence of private healthcare, believing it could shorten wait times and improve outcomes, while advocating for a regulated proportion of services dedicated to the public system.How is the NHS organised?

The National Health Service (NHS) in the UK is organized through various mechanisms and structures. It has faced persistent issues of negative behavior towards staff, leading to a dysfunctional and troubled organization that needs urgent addressing. The NHS has undergone multiple reorganizations to balance market responsiveness, staff employment, national accountability, and local needs, among other tensions. Learning and knowledge management are crucial for NHS modernization, emphasizing the importance of collective organizational learning and moving towards generative learning for goal redefinition. Efforts to improve care coordination through integrated care pathways have shown varying success due to factors like management coherence, clinical leadership, and local contextual influences. The Labour government's reforms established primary care groups evolving into trusts, unifying budgets for community health services and hospital commissioning.