What are the disadvantages of dual reservation of women?
Best insight from top research papers
Dual reservation of women has been a topic of debate in India. The proposed bill for reservation of seats in the union and state legislatures to facilitate women's entry into high-level decision-making institutions has faced opposition and stalled its passage . The lack of will to restructure democratic representation by including women has been indicated . The women's movement has opposed any dilution of the demand for one-third reservation, as it may ultimately target the panchayat raj provision, which is a priority for the movement .
Answers from top 5 papers
More filters
| Papers (5) | Insight |
|---|---|
Open access•Journal Article 7 Citations | The paper does not mention any disadvantages of dual reservation of women. The paper discusses the uncertain future of the 81st constitutional amendment bill and the commitment of political parties to 33% reservation for women in state assemblies and the Lok Sabha. |
| The provided paper does not mention the disadvantages of dual reservation of women. The paper is about women and reservation in India. | |
3 Citations | The provided paper does not discuss the disadvantages of dual reservation of women. The paper is about a multi-channel MAC protocol for ad hoc networks. |
| The provided paper does not mention anything about dual reservation of women. | |
3 Citations | The paper does not mention any disadvantages of dual reservation of women. |
Related Questions
What are the potential consequences for India's political landscape if the Women's Reservation Bill is not fully implemented?5 answersThe non-implementation of the Women's Reservation Bill in India could have significant repercussions on the political landscape. Despite efforts to enhance women's representation, Indian women remain vastly underrepresented in parliament. Gender quotas may inadvertently reduce the representation of traditionally disadvantaged ethnic groups, as constituencies reserved for women are less likely to elect members from these groups, potentially favoring candidates from Hindu upper castes. The existing reservation system for women has brought about some changes in Indian politics, but women's representation and decision-making power are still limited. The complex intersectionality dynamics in political participation, including caste, class, and gender inequities, further emphasize the need for comprehensive analysis to ensure equitable political participation for women.
What are the main factors that contribute to gender discrimination?4 answersGender discrimination is influenced by various factors. In the architecture industry in Nigeria, gender discrimination is predicted by cultural and religious factors, including sociocultural norms, values, and religious elements. In Isfahan city, gender disparity exists in the economic and cultural spheres, and it is not correlated with gender stereotypes, adherence to patriarchal ideology, or societal norms. Patriarchal culture and gender ideology contribute to gender inequality, particularly in the occupational domain, where men dominate the workforce. These factors result in women's marginalization, subordination, and lower education levels, leading to discrimination and limited work opportunities. Overall, gender discrimination is influenced by cultural, religious, and societal factors, as well as gender stereotypes and patriarchal ideologies.
What are the main factors that prevent society from granting equal opportunities?5 answersSociety faces several factors that prevent the granting of equal opportunities. These factors include the inequality of efforts and circumstances beyond one's control, such as family background and economic status. Additionally, social factors like economic power, cultural capital, and social policy also contribute to the reproduction of inequalities in education. The concept of Pareto optimality poses a challenge to equalizing opportunities, as any attempt to favor one individual or group may harm others. Furthermore, the lack of large and widespread business benefits associated with equal opportunities policies may hinder their implementation in society. These factors, along with the moral dilemma of balancing justice for the privileged and underprivileged, make it difficult to achieve equal opportunities in society.
Why polygyny is disadvantageous for women?3 answersPolygyny is disadvantageous for women because it is associated with reduced fertility. Women in polygynous unions often suffer from financial, emotional, and physical burdens. Affluent polygyny in South Africa, for example, can lead to women entering these arrangements due to socio-economic issues and high rates of unemployment. In polygynous marriages, women may experience competition and jealousy among co-wives, unequal health or fertility, biased emotional and material support from husbands, and accusations of wrong-doing and witchcraft. Furthermore, polygyny is linked to a range of negative consequences for women, including discrepancies in gender equality, higher birth rates, lower rates of education, higher rates of HIV infection, and higher rates of domestic violence.
What are the pros and cons of dual reservation of women?5 answersDual reservation of women has several pros and cons. On the positive side, it can address the under-representation of women in elected and decision-making bodies, promote equality of opportunity, and bring about a change in development priorities and perspectives. However, there are also potential drawbacks. Some argue that dual reservation may lead to reverse discrimination or create a perception of tokenism, where women are seen as placeholders rather than being valued for their qualifications and abilities. Additionally, there may be concerns about the effectiveness and efficiency of dual reservation policies, as well as the potential for backlash from those who feel disadvantaged by such measures. It is important to carefully consider these pros and cons when evaluating the implementation of dual reservation of women in any context.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of using dual currency?5 answersUsing a dual currency system has both advantages and disadvantages. One advantage is that in a dual currency circulation economy, the money type with a higher rate of growth circulates more widely than the money type with a lower rate of growth. Another advantage is that a dual currency system can be used as a solution to balance of payments problems, allowing certain selected transactions to take place at a fixed official exchange rate while remaining transactions are effected at a more depreciated rate determined by market forces. However, there are also disadvantages. One disadvantage is that using a sovereign currency as the world currency can lead to unfairness and instability in the international monetary system. Another disadvantage is that reintroducing a national currency in a dual currency system can lead to legal, political, and economic problems, especially if it involves leaving the Economic and Monetary Union.