What factors contribute to constitutional erosion in democratic societies?
Best insight from top research papers
Constitutional erosion in democratic societies can be attributed to several factors. One factor is the structural changes in the socio-economic environment and geopolitical shifts, which can lead to democratic backsliding . Another factor is gerrymandering, where politicians manipulate district lines to favor their own party and expand their political power . The accession of former socialist countries to the European Union has also had a counterproductive effect on democracy and the rule of law in these countries . Additionally, the disobedience of imposed rules and the lack of social identification with the constitution can contribute to the erosion of constitutional authority and the failure of the rule of law . Finally, the role of courts in polities undergoing democratic erosion is crucial, as independent courts can serve as guardrails of democracy, but once captured by anti-system parties, they can become agents of democratic erosion .
Answers from top 4 papers
More filters
| Papers (4) | Insight |
|---|---|
| The paper does not directly address the factors that contribute to constitutional erosion in democratic societies. | |
| The paper does not explicitly mention the factors that contribute to constitutional erosion in democratic societies. | |
46 Citations | The paper discusses two threats to democratic stability: authoritarian reversion and constitutional retrogression. It argues that constitutional retrogression, which involves the erosion of democratic institutions, may pose a more pressing challenge. |
| The provided paper does not directly address the factors that contribute to constitutional erosion in democratic societies. The paper focuses specifically on gerrymandering in the United States and its impact on democracy. |
Related Questions
What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of implementing constitutional reforms in a state?5 answersImplementing constitutional reforms in a state can have both benefits and drawbacks. Benefits include the establishment of a more efficient and cohesive governmental structure, improvement of the system of checks and balances, and development of social and cultural policies. However, drawbacks may arise from challenges such as the crisis of national identity, leaders prolonging power through constitutional amendments, social exclusion, income inequality, and vulnerability to economic and environmental risks. Additionally, concerns about the partial improvement of judicial independence and the creation of hidden channels for political influence can hinder the advancement of the rule of law in a country. Overall, while constitutional reforms aim to enhance governance, they must navigate complex issues to achieve their intended goals.
What factors contribute to the consolidation or erosion of democracy in different countries?4 answersFactors that contribute to the consolidation or erosion of democracy in different countries include voting, fairness, equity, deliberation, economic resources, political instability, centrifugal processes within the elite, erosion of democratic institutions, popular and economically solvent heads of government, institutional strength, individual freedom, compassionate responsibility, totalitarianism, unresponsiveness of the political system, captured media, wealth inequality, corrupt justice system, extractive institutions, political and economic reforms, checks and balances, rule of law, corruption, property rights, regime legitimacy, trust, economic growth, business environment, distribution of political power, institutional learning, cultural patterns, and cumulative effects of extractive political and economic institutions.
How Democracies Die?4 answersDemocracies can die through a coup d'etat or through a slow erosion of political norms and democratic institutions. This erosion occurs when elected leaders from within the system undermine these institutions over time. Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt argue that contemporary democracies are at risk of dying due to this gradual erosion, rather than external attacks. They highlight the importance of maintaining independent judiciaries and a free press as fundamental democratic institutions. Their book, "How Democracies Die," draws on historical and comparative analysis to assess the similarities and differences between democratic breakdowns in different regions, including Europe, Latin America, and the United States. They warn that American democracy is currently in danger and offer suggestions for saving it.
Why do totalitarian societies tend to collapse?5 answersTotalitarian societies tend to collapse due to several factors. One of the main reasons is the deprivation of national cultures and educational institutions, which leads to the destruction of culture and ultimately the destruction of the society itself. Additionally, the increase in complexity and the lack of marginal returns for efforts to solve societal problems contribute to collapse. Furthermore, a preoccupation with resilience rather than transformability can also lead to collapse, as societies fail to adapt to changing circumstances. Totalitarianism, particularly communism, can be seen as a form of nihilism that undermines trust in civil society and devalues the highest values. Finally, the collapse of societies can be explained by self-organized criticality, a nonlinear process that produces sudden shifts and patterns in historical time series.
Why did the chile constitutional referendum fail?5 answersThe Chilean constitutional referendum failed due to several reasons. Firstly, the proposed constitution was radical and out of sync with the majority of Chileans, leading to opposition and lack of support. Secondly, the amateurish membership of the convention made mistakes and failed to course-correct, further eroding trust in the process. Additionally, the declining popularity of President Gabriel Boric, a prominent figure in the pro-reform camp, negatively impacted the fate of the proposal. Furthermore, the intrusion of everyday politics into the process contributed to the defeat of the progressive new constitution, potentially leading to a narrower vision of democracy in the future. The failure of the proposal highlights the importance of consensus building and the need to address social confrontation through constitutional processes.
What are the different factors that have contributed to democratic backsliding in EU member states?5 answersDemocratic backsliding in EU member states has been influenced by several factors. One factor is the emergence of competitive (semi-)authoritarian regimes with illiberal governing ideologies, leading to a regression of democratic quality. Another factor is the erosion of legal integration within the EU, which has weakened the Union's strength and relevance. Constitutional pluralism and differentiated integration have also been criticized for potentially legitimizing democratic backsliding, but they challenge the legitimacy of strong assertions of federal authority to tackle it. Additionally, the responses of EU institutions to member states that have violated European values have been ineffective in bringing them back in line. These factors highlight the need for effective measures to address democratic backsliding, including strengthening the legal authority of the Court of Justice of the European Union and implementing penalties such as exclusion from EU funding and voting rights.