With the increasing role that unmanned aerial systems (UAS) are playing in data collection for environmental studies, two key challenges relate to harmonizing and providing standardized guidance for data collection, and also establishing protocols that are applicable across a broad range of environments and conditions. In this context, a network of scientists are cooperating within the framework of the Harmonious Project to develop and promote harmonized mapping strategies and disseminate operational guidance to ensure best practice for data collection and interpretation. The culmination of these efforts is summarized in the present manuscript. Through this synthesis study, we identify the many interdependencies of each step in the collection and processing chain, and outline approaches to formalize and ensure a successful workflow and product development. Given the number of environmental conditions, constraints, and variables that could possibly be explored from UAS platforms, it is impractical to provide protocols that can be applied universally under all scenarios. However, it is possible to collate and systematically order the fragmented knowledge on UAS collection and analysis to identify the best practices that can best ensure the streamlined and rigorous development of scientific products.

Current Practices in UAS-based Environmental Monitoring

This study aims to produce accurate geospatial 3D data from unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) images. An image of a ≈ 0.05 km2 area of the Najran University campus in Najran, Saudi Arabia, was captured using a DJI Mavic Pro Platinum drone. Agisoft Metashape and Pix4dmapper programs were used to generate the solution. The horizontal and vertical accuracies of the obtained UAV solution were computed by comparing the coordinates of 21 ground control points (GCPs) with coordinates measured using the RTK GPS method. The accuracy of the four different GCP configurations was evaluated using both software packages. The root mean square error (RMSE) was calculated for some checkpoints. The generated model achieved the 2015 ASPRS accuracy standards for digital geospatial data, while horizontal RMSE values were 4–6 cm and vertical accuracy was 5–6 cm. The horizontal and vertical RMSE values were twice and three times the GSD, respectively.

Accuracy Assessment of Low-Cost Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Photogrammetry

Unmanned aircraft system (UAS) is a particularly powerful tool for plant phenotyping, due to reasonable cost of procurement and deployment, ease and flexibility for control and operation, ability to reconfigure sensor payloads to diversify sensing, and the ability to seamlessly fit into a larger connected phenotyping network. These advantages have expanded the use of UAS-based plant phenotyping approach in research and breeding applications. This paper reviews the state of the art in the deployment, collection, curation, storage, and analysis of data from UAS-based phenotyping platforms. We discuss pressing technical challenges, identify future trends in UAS-based phenotyping that the plant research community should be aware of, and pinpoint key plant science and agronomic questions that can be resolved with the next generation of UAS-based imaging modalities and associated data analysis pipelines. This review provides a broad account of the state of the art in UAS-based phenotyping to reduce the barrier to entry to plant science practitioners interested in deploying this imaging modality for phenotyping in plant breeding and research areas.

/pdf/uas-based-plant-phenotyping-for-research-and-breeding-g941lxbuz4.pdf

UAS-Based Plant Phenotyping for Research and Breeding Applications.

Currently, products that are obtained by Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) image processing based on structure-from-motion photogrammetry (SfM) are being investigated for use in high precision projects. Independent of the georeferencing process being done directly or indirectly, Ground Control Points (GCPs) are needed to increase the accuracy of the obtained products. A minimum of three GCPs is required to bring the results into a desired coordinate system through the indirect georeferencing process, but it is well known that increasing the number of GCPs will lead to a higher accuracy of the final results. The aim of this study is to find the suitable number of GCPs to derive high precision results and what is the effect of GCPs systematic or stratified random distribution on the accuracy of the georeferencing process and the final products, respectively. The case study involves an urban area of about 1 ha that was photographed with a low-cost UAS, namely, the DJI Phantom 3 Standard, at 28 m above ground. The camera was oriented in a nadiral position and 300 points were measured using a total station in a local coordinate system. The UAS images were processed using the 3DF Zephyr software performing a full BBA with a variable number of GCPs i.e., from four up to 150, while the number and the spatial location of check points (ChPs) was kept constant i.e., 150 for each independent distribution. In addition, the systematic and stratified random distribution of GCPs and ChPs spatial positions was analysed. Furthermore, the point clouds and the mesh surfaces that were automatically derived were compared with a terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) point cloud while also considering three test areas: two inside the area defined by GCPs and one outside the area. The results expressed a clear overview of the number of GCPs needed for the indirect georeferencing process with minimum influence on the final results. The RMSE can be reduced down to 50% when switching from four to 20 GCPs, whereas a higher number of GCPs only slightly improves the results.

Determining the Suitable Number of Ground Control Points for UAS Images Georeferencing by Varying Number and Spatial Distribution

The so-called Real Time Kinematic (RTK) option, which allows one to determine with cm-level accuracy the Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) camera position at shooting time, is also being made available on medium- or low-cost drones. It can be foreseen that a sizeable amount of UAV surveys will be soon performed (almost) without Ground Control Points (GCP). However, obstacles to Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) signal at the optimal flight altitude might prevent accurate retrieval of camera station positions, e.g., in narrow gorges. In such cases, the master block can be georeferenced by tying it to an (auxiliary) block flown at higher altitude, where the GNSS signal is not impeded. To prove the point in a worst case scenario, but under controlled conditions, an experiment was devised. A single strip about 700 m long, surveyed by a multi-copter at 30 m relative flight height, was referenced with cm-level accuracy by joint adjustment with a block flown at 100 m relative flight height, acquired by a fixed-wing UAV provided with RTK option. The joint block orientation was repeated with or without GCP and with pre-calibrated or self-calibrated camera parameters. Accuracy on ground was assessed on a fair number of Check Points (CP). The results show that, even without GCP, the precision is effectively transferred from the auxiliary block projection centres to the object point horizontal coordinates and, with a pre-calibrated camera, also to the elevations.

Indirect UAV Strip Georeferencing by On-Board GNSS Data under Poor Satellite Coverage

Ground control points (GCPs) are used in the process of indirectly georeferencing Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) images. A minimum of three ground control points (GCPs) is required but increasing the number of GCPs will lead to higher accuracy of the final results. The aim of this study is to provide the answer to the question of how many ground control points are necessary in order to derive high precision results. To obtain the results, an area of about 1 ha was photographed with a low-cost UAS, namely, the DJI Phantom 3 Standard at two different heights, 28 m and 35 m above ground, the camera being oriented in a nadiral position, and 50 ground control points were measured using a total station. In the first and the second scenario, the UAS images were processed using the Pix4D Mapper Pro software and 3DF Zephyr, respectively, by performing a full bundle adjustment process with the number being gradually increased from three GCPs to 40. The third test was made with 3DF Zephyr Pro software using a free-network approach in the bundle adjustment. Also, the point clouds and the mesh surfaces derived automatically after using the minimum and the optimum number of GCPs, respectively, were compared with a terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) point cloud. The results expressed a clear overview of the number of GCPs needed for the indirect georeferencing process with minimum influence on the final results.

https://www.mdpi.com/2504-3900/2/7/352/pdf

Determining the Optimum Number of Ground Control Points for Obtaining High Precision Results Based on UAS Images

Due to the large number of technological developments in recent years, UAS systems are now used for monitoring purposes and in projects with high precision demand, such as 3D model-based creation of dams, reservoirs, historical monuments etc. These unmanned systems are usually equipped with an automatic pilot device and a digital camera (photo/video, multispectral, Near Infrared etc.), of which the lens has distortions; but this can be determined in a calibration process. Currently, a method of “self-calibration” is used for the calibration of the digital cameras mounted on UASs, but, by using the method of calibration based on a 3D calibration object, the accuracy is improved in comparison with other methods. Thus, this paper has the objective of establishing a 3D calibration field for the digital cameras mounted on UASs in terms of accuracy and robustness, being the largest reported publication to date. In order to test the proposed calibration field, a digital camera mounted on a low-cost UAS was calibrated at three different heights: 23 m, 28 m, and 35 m, using two configurations for image acquisition. Then, a comparison was made between the residuals obtained for a number of 100 Check Points (CPs) using self-calibration and test-field calibration, while the number of Ground Control Points (GCPs) variedand the heights were interchanged. Additionally, the parameters where tested on an oblique flight done 2 years before calibration, in manual mode at a medium altitude of 28 m height. For all tests done in the case of the double grid nadiral flight, the parameters calculated with the proposed 3D field improved the results by more than 50% when using the optimum and a large number of GCPs, and in all analyzed cases with 75% to 95% when using a minimum of 3 GCP. In this context, it is necessary to conduct accurate calibration in order to increase the accuracy of the UAS projects, and also to reduce field measurements.

3D Calibration Test-Field for Digital Cameras Mounted on Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS)

3D modelling of urban areas is an attractive and active research topic, as 3D digital models of cities are becoming increasingly common for urban management as a consequence of the constantly growing number of people living in cities. Viewed as a digital representation of the Earth’s surface, an urban area modeled in 3D includes objects such as buildings, trees, vegetation and other anthropogenic structures, highlighting the buildings as the most prominent category. A city’s 3D model can be created based on different data sources, especially LiDAR or photogrammetric point clouds. This paper’s aim is to provide an end-to-end pipeline for 3D building modeling based on oblique UAS images only, the result being a parametrized 3D model with the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) CityGML standard, Level of Detail 2 (LOD2). For this purpose, a flight over an urban area of about 20.6 ha has been taken with a low-cost UAS, i.e., a DJI Phantom 4 Pro Professional (P4P), at 100 m height. The resulting UAS point cloud with the best scenario, i.e., 45 Ground Control Points (GCP), has been processed as follows: filtering to extract the ground points using two algorithms, CSF and terrain-mark; classification, using two methods, based on attributes only and a random forest machine learning algorithm; segmentation using local homogeneity implemented into Opals software; plane creation based on a region-growing algorithm; and plane editing and 3D model reconstruction based on piece-wise intersection of planar faces. The classification performed with ~35% training data and 31 attributes showed that the Visible-band difference vegetation index (VDVI) is a key attribute and 77% of the data was classified using only five attributes. The global accuracy for each modeled building through the workflow proposed in this study was around 0.15 m, so it can be concluded that the proposed pipeline is reliable.

/pdf/3d-modeling-of-urban-area-based-on-oblique-uas-images-an-end-1q3990dd.pdf

3D Modeling of Urban Area Based on Oblique UAS Images - An End-to-End Pipeline

Three-dimensional city models play an important role for a large number of applications in urban environments, and thus it is of high interest to create them automatically, accurately and in a cost-effective manner. This paper presents a new methodology for point cloud accuracy improvement to generate terrain topographic models and 3D building modeling with the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) CityGML standard, level of detail 1 (LOD1), using very high-resolution (VHR) satellite images. In that context, a number of steps are given attention (which are often (in the literature) not considered in detail), including the local geoid and the role of the digital terrain model (DTM) in the dense image matching process. The quality of the resulting models is analyzed thoroughly. For this objective, two stereo Pléiades 1 satellite images over Iasi city were acquired in September 2016, and 142 points were measured in situ by global navigation satellite system real-time kinematic positioning (GNSS-RTK) technology. First, the quasigeoid surface resulting from EGG2008 regional gravimetric model was corrected based on data from GNSS and leveling measurements using a four-parameter transformation, and the ellipsoidal heights of the 142 GNSS-RTK points were corrected based on the local quasigeoid surface. The DTM of the study area was created based on low-resolution airborne laser scanner (LR ALS) point clouds that have been filtered using the robust filter algorithm and a mask for buildings, and the ellipsoidal heights were also corrected with the local quasigeoid surface, resulting in a standard deviation of 37.3 cm for 50 levelling points and 28.1 cm for the 142 GNSS-RTK points. For the point cloud generation, two scenarios were considered: (1) no DTM and ground control points (GCPs) with uncorrected ellipsoidal heights resulting in an RMS difference (Z) for the 64 GCPs and 78 ChPs of 69.8 cm and (2) with LR ALS-DTM and GCPs with corrected ellipsoidal height values resulting in an RMS difference (Z) of 60.9 cm. The LOD1 models of 1550 buildings from the Iasi city center were created based on Pléiades-DSM point clouds (corrected and not corrected) and existing building sub-footprints, with four methods for the derivation of the building roof elevations, resulting in a standard deviation of 1.6 m against high-resolution (HR) ALS point cloud in the case of the best scenario. The proposed method for height extraction and reconstruction of the city structure performed the best compared with other studies on multiple satellite stereo imagery.

/pdf/proposed-methodology-for-accuracy-improvement-of-lod1-3d-1i0m5b6n.pdf

Valeria-Ersilia Oniga

Papers

Determining the Optimum Number of Ground Control Points for Obtaining High Precision Results Based on UAS Images

Determining the Suitable Number of Ground Control Points for UAS Images Georeferencing by Varying Number and Spatial Distribution

3D Calibration Test-Field for Digital Cameras Mounted on Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS)

3D Modeling of Urban Area Based on Oblique UAS Images - An End-to-End Pipeline

Proposed Methodology for Accuracy Improvement of LOD1 3D Building Models Created Based on Stereo Pléiades Satellite Imagery